Mr. Matt's Reviews > Dauntless
Dauntless (The Lost Fleet, #1)
by
by

Dauntless was just what the doctor ordered. The last couple of books that I read were slow, plodding things - all about immersion and realism. All of that was great, but sometimes I want a book to reach out of the cover and slap me in the face with bigger than life action. Rest assured, Dauntless delivered.
Black Jack Geary is picked up by a passing Alliance warships. Frozen for a hundred years in deep-freeze hibernation, he was lost and presumed dead. He awakes to find the Alliance still locked in a desperate struggle against the Syndicate and himself as a kind of iconic war hero archetype. Black Jack finds himself abruptly thrust into a leadership position and forced to deal with a severe case of hero worship. Fortunately, Black Jack is more than up to the challenge and he promptly whips his fleet into shape, first escaping the Syndicate trap and then defeating a pursuit force.
Dauntless does what it does very well. The action is quick and well crafted. I love the fact that these star fleet books are basically ships-of-the-line in space. I love big ship to ship battles where grapeshot fills the air along with smoke, guns and cutlasses. My college physics is a little rusty, but I felt like he did a good job of handling starship battles at relativistic speeds - yet the story kept the flavor of the ships-of-the-line. I also liked Black Jack's emphasis on the rule of law and playing by the rules of civilization - not barbarians. Good for all of us to ponder in this day and age.
A couple of odd things about the story. First, the religion felt very generic and sterilized. The alliance fleet pretty much exercised a form of ancestor worship. That combined with sayings like "the living stars" kind of fell flat with me. I felt like the author wanted to have some sort of belief system in the story but didn't want to show favoritism to anyone faith. Not a big deal, but it felt artificial to me. Next, some of the story line felt very formulaic. I can't say that I was surprised about anything that happened (expect for one revelation towards the end of the book). That predictable story line isn't all bad. The book is good enough on its own merits. It was a very fun read.
Four broadsides out of five.
Black Jack Geary is picked up by a passing Alliance warships. Frozen for a hundred years in deep-freeze hibernation, he was lost and presumed dead. He awakes to find the Alliance still locked in a desperate struggle against the Syndicate and himself as a kind of iconic war hero archetype. Black Jack finds himself abruptly thrust into a leadership position and forced to deal with a severe case of hero worship. Fortunately, Black Jack is more than up to the challenge and he promptly whips his fleet into shape, first escaping the Syndicate trap and then defeating a pursuit force.
Dauntless does what it does very well. The action is quick and well crafted. I love the fact that these star fleet books are basically ships-of-the-line in space. I love big ship to ship battles where grapeshot fills the air along with smoke, guns and cutlasses. My college physics is a little rusty, but I felt like he did a good job of handling starship battles at relativistic speeds - yet the story kept the flavor of the ships-of-the-line. I also liked Black Jack's emphasis on the rule of law and playing by the rules of civilization - not barbarians. Good for all of us to ponder in this day and age.
A couple of odd things about the story. First, the religion felt very generic and sterilized. The alliance fleet pretty much exercised a form of ancestor worship. That combined with sayings like "the living stars" kind of fell flat with me. I felt like the author wanted to have some sort of belief system in the story but didn't want to show favoritism to anyone faith. Not a big deal, but it felt artificial to me. Next, some of the story line felt very formulaic. I can't say that I was surprised about anything that happened (expect for one revelation towards the end of the book). That predictable story line isn't all bad. The book is good enough on its own merits. It was a very fun read.
Four broadsides out of five.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Dauntless.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 21, 2014
– Shelved as:
to-read
January 21, 2014
– Shelved
August 7, 2014
–
Started Reading
August 11, 2014
– Shelved as:
2014
August 11, 2014
– Shelved as:
sci-fi
August 11, 2014
– Shelved as:
ships-of-the-line
August 11, 2014
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Conor
(new)
-
added it
Aug 11, 2014 05:30PM

reply
|
flag

Thanks. Yep. I read his review after finishing my own. I was a bit surprised. I thought it was a fun book, but to each their own, I guess. Bottom line is that these books are really about the space battles. On that front I thought the author delivered.

I think the coolest part is that a lot of the book is directly based on history and legends from our own world. For instance the concept of a fleet lost behind enemy lines was based on The Persian Expedition, and Geary himself was actually intended to be a sci-fi version of George Washington.

I think the coolest part is that a lot of the book is directly based ..."
Yeah. I can see that. It's a fun read.
Hmm...interesting review. The starship battles sound awesome, but I'm one of those readers that has to connect with the characters for enjoyment, so what's Black Jack like? Is he a take charge guy? Is he sarcastic or humorous in any way?

The characters in this series are, to be brutally honest, a bit stiff and cardboard. I'm enjoying them, but I'm kind of in the mood for a very quick read at the moment. If you want character development and ships-of-the-line action, I recommend reading the Horatio Hornblower series by C.S. Forester. Despite the snicker-inducing name, those books are pretty darn good.
You got me there, that names was just, wow. I'll look it up, thanks for the honesty :D



Sounds good. I like the books for the more military/fleet action. It's when the author starts the whole space opera angle that I start to cringe.
