Martine's Reviews > The Gathering Storm
The Gathering Storm (Wheel of Time, #12; A Memory of Light, #1)
by
by

Wow. Was this ever a pleasant surprise.
I got into Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time series about eight years ago. Despite protestations from friends that I should steer clear of it because it went completely off the rails after about five books and probably wouldn't ever be finished, I gave it a shot, and like so many other readers I got hooked. This was unfortunate, because as I discovered halfway through the series, my friends were right. The Wheel of Time did go off the rails, and badly, with Robert Jordan losing himself in so many insignificant subplots and failing so utterly to bring the story closer to its conclusion that it seemed doubtful that it would ever be finished. Nevertheless I soldiered on, reading each new instalment despite my mounting frustration with them, because hey, I was hooked. So much so that I actually joined a Wheel of Time newsgroup at one point, where I spent many hours discussing theories about characters' double identities and where the series might be headed. That newsgroup probably did more for my love of fantasy literature than The Lord of Rings (my introduction to the genre, which I still love to death) ever did. I miss it quite a bit -- it was fabulous.
And then Robert Jordan did something incredible. Something his fans had joked about for years but had never considered a serious possibility. He passed away before he could finish the series, rendering the massive investment his fans had made in it (we are talking about eleven books of about nine hundred pages each) virtually useless, because after all that theorising, after all those looooooooong hours spent discussing the minutiae of the books, no one would ever find out how the story ended.
Enter Brandon Sanderson, a lesser-known fantasy author of whom I had never heard before, although with hindsight I probably should have. He was hired by Jordan's wife to finish the series, using her husband's extensive notes, unfinished passages and instructions for support. Like many others, I was sceptical about the enterprise, and not sure I wanted to read the result.
But then the prologue to Sanderson's sequel was posted on line, about a month before the book's release date, and to my infinite surprise it was good. And about a week later the first chapter of the sequel was leaked on line, and to my mounting surprise that was good, too -- more focussed than anything Jordan himself had written in a while, except perhaps New Spring, the much-maligned prequel to the series. In just two short chapters, Sanderson had got rid of several characters and plotlines which had irked myself and other fans for ages. It actually looked like he was getting the plot to move forwards, which was such a pleasant surprise that I suddenly found myself really, really looking forward to seeing what else he had done to Jordan's universe. So I bought the book the day it was released, ready to lose myself in Randland once more.
So what has Sanderson done to Randland? In a word, he has revived the series. The Gathering Storm is by far the best instalment in the Wheel of Time saga of the last ten years. An action-packed romp which actually takes the story forwards several weeks (gasp), it's a return to the form of the earliest books, before Jordan started introducing every single Aes Sedai in existence, expecting us to care about their minor squabbles. In marked contrast to Jordan's later books, The Gathering Storm actually focuses on the main characters (you know, the original heroes of the series, who got us interested in it in the first place), allowing them to achieve goals which had eluded them for quite some time. It eliminates unnecessary side plots like the Prophet and the Shaido, often swiftly so. It is largely free of padding (although a very critical reader might ask what exactly Mat's storyline is meant to accomplish, other than getting him on his way to the Tower of Ghenjei and showing that the Dark One is touching the world). And best of all, it is faithful to the style of the early Jordan, which is to say without endless descriptions of clothes and characters taking baths, yanking their braids, tapping their feet, etc. Nynaeve actually overcomes her urge to yank her braid every time she gets mad at the beginning of the book, which I'm sure is a development welcomed by any reader of the series. In other words, Sanderson has managed to channel Jordan without all the latter's infuriating obsessions, following Jordan's style without copying its bad aspects. I wouldn't say the transition is seamless (Sanderson's style, featuring many short sentences, is punchier than Jordan's), but it certainly isn't jarring, either. While there is the odd moment where you'll find yourself thinking, 'Hmmm, that didn't sound entirely Jordanesque,' these moments are more than made up for by Sanderson's ability to focus on essentials, in my opinion. It's refreshing, reading Randland stories without all the padding.
So what actually happens in The Gathering Storm? (WARNING: MASSIVE SPOILERS AHEAD) Well, the Prophet finally dies (about time). Tuon (one of my favourite characters, though less so here than before) finally becomes Empress of Seanchan. The Seanchan finally attack the White Tower, which Egwene has been prophesying for ages. Egwene herself finally becomes Amyrlin Seat, in quite an impressive manner. Rand, who seemed to be going increasingly mad in the last few books, finally finds himself again, in a way which holds promise for the future. Perrin finally accepts his wolf self, while Mat and his cronies finally set out for the Tower of Ghenjei, a subplot anyone with a brain has seen coming for the last seven books or so. For her part, Aviendha is finally accepted as a Wise One, in a manner befitting those strange Aiel customs. Gawyn, who was fighting on the wrong side, finally sees the light (ha!) and joins the rebel Aes Sedai. Siuan Sanche and Gareth Bryne finally become an item, though rather chastely so. Two more Forsaken are taken care of (presumably). And in two of the more brilliant plot twists, a mysterious character from the beginning of the series is revealed to be Black Ajah (a jaw-dropping chapter, very well written and conceived), while Elaida is deposed in a way which had me chuckling out loud. I'm not sure who came up with the idea for Elaida's demise, Jordan or Sanderson, but whoever it was, he has a rich sense of poetic justice. It's just too, too good.
Of course, many storylines still remain unresolved, and Sanderson now believes he will need two books to tie them up, not one, as previously planned. I have faith in him, though. I know that these two books of his will really be two books, not seven (as with Jordan). And I have no doubt that they will be good books. Books in which we will finally see Moiraine make a reappearance. Books in which all the prophecies and viewings which have been bandied around for the last twelve books will finally be fulfilled (or not, as the case may be). In which Perrin, Lan, Logain, Mazrim Taim, Slayer, Elayne, Galad, Thom, Birgitte, Olver, the Sea Folk and the Kin will probably get to see more action than they did in The Gathering Storm, and in which the stage is well and truly set for Tarmon Gai’don, the final battle. And I also know that thanks to Sanderson, I am excited about this series again. I will probably spend more time than I care for at Wheel of Time websites over the next few months, looking up old prophecies and comparing theories about where the story is heading. And when it's all over, two books from now, I will in all likelihood look back on the Wheel of Time series with fondness, rather than the bitterness Jordan was increasingly inspiring in me.
Thanks for that, Brandon. After all the time I have invested in this series, I need to love it again, rather than despair of it. It now looks like I may, which is great.
I got into Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time series about eight years ago. Despite protestations from friends that I should steer clear of it because it went completely off the rails after about five books and probably wouldn't ever be finished, I gave it a shot, and like so many other readers I got hooked. This was unfortunate, because as I discovered halfway through the series, my friends were right. The Wheel of Time did go off the rails, and badly, with Robert Jordan losing himself in so many insignificant subplots and failing so utterly to bring the story closer to its conclusion that it seemed doubtful that it would ever be finished. Nevertheless I soldiered on, reading each new instalment despite my mounting frustration with them, because hey, I was hooked. So much so that I actually joined a Wheel of Time newsgroup at one point, where I spent many hours discussing theories about characters' double identities and where the series might be headed. That newsgroup probably did more for my love of fantasy literature than The Lord of Rings (my introduction to the genre, which I still love to death) ever did. I miss it quite a bit -- it was fabulous.
And then Robert Jordan did something incredible. Something his fans had joked about for years but had never considered a serious possibility. He passed away before he could finish the series, rendering the massive investment his fans had made in it (we are talking about eleven books of about nine hundred pages each) virtually useless, because after all that theorising, after all those looooooooong hours spent discussing the minutiae of the books, no one would ever find out how the story ended.
Enter Brandon Sanderson, a lesser-known fantasy author of whom I had never heard before, although with hindsight I probably should have. He was hired by Jordan's wife to finish the series, using her husband's extensive notes, unfinished passages and instructions for support. Like many others, I was sceptical about the enterprise, and not sure I wanted to read the result.
But then the prologue to Sanderson's sequel was posted on line, about a month before the book's release date, and to my infinite surprise it was good. And about a week later the first chapter of the sequel was leaked on line, and to my mounting surprise that was good, too -- more focussed than anything Jordan himself had written in a while, except perhaps New Spring, the much-maligned prequel to the series. In just two short chapters, Sanderson had got rid of several characters and plotlines which had irked myself and other fans for ages. It actually looked like he was getting the plot to move forwards, which was such a pleasant surprise that I suddenly found myself really, really looking forward to seeing what else he had done to Jordan's universe. So I bought the book the day it was released, ready to lose myself in Randland once more.
So what has Sanderson done to Randland? In a word, he has revived the series. The Gathering Storm is by far the best instalment in the Wheel of Time saga of the last ten years. An action-packed romp which actually takes the story forwards several weeks (gasp), it's a return to the form of the earliest books, before Jordan started introducing every single Aes Sedai in existence, expecting us to care about their minor squabbles. In marked contrast to Jordan's later books, The Gathering Storm actually focuses on the main characters (you know, the original heroes of the series, who got us interested in it in the first place), allowing them to achieve goals which had eluded them for quite some time. It eliminates unnecessary side plots like the Prophet and the Shaido, often swiftly so. It is largely free of padding (although a very critical reader might ask what exactly Mat's storyline is meant to accomplish, other than getting him on his way to the Tower of Ghenjei and showing that the Dark One is touching the world). And best of all, it is faithful to the style of the early Jordan, which is to say without endless descriptions of clothes and characters taking baths, yanking their braids, tapping their feet, etc. Nynaeve actually overcomes her urge to yank her braid every time she gets mad at the beginning of the book, which I'm sure is a development welcomed by any reader of the series. In other words, Sanderson has managed to channel Jordan without all the latter's infuriating obsessions, following Jordan's style without copying its bad aspects. I wouldn't say the transition is seamless (Sanderson's style, featuring many short sentences, is punchier than Jordan's), but it certainly isn't jarring, either. While there is the odd moment where you'll find yourself thinking, 'Hmmm, that didn't sound entirely Jordanesque,' these moments are more than made up for by Sanderson's ability to focus on essentials, in my opinion. It's refreshing, reading Randland stories without all the padding.
So what actually happens in The Gathering Storm? (WARNING: MASSIVE SPOILERS AHEAD) Well, the Prophet finally dies (about time). Tuon (one of my favourite characters, though less so here than before) finally becomes Empress of Seanchan. The Seanchan finally attack the White Tower, which Egwene has been prophesying for ages. Egwene herself finally becomes Amyrlin Seat, in quite an impressive manner. Rand, who seemed to be going increasingly mad in the last few books, finally finds himself again, in a way which holds promise for the future. Perrin finally accepts his wolf self, while Mat and his cronies finally set out for the Tower of Ghenjei, a subplot anyone with a brain has seen coming for the last seven books or so. For her part, Aviendha is finally accepted as a Wise One, in a manner befitting those strange Aiel customs. Gawyn, who was fighting on the wrong side, finally sees the light (ha!) and joins the rebel Aes Sedai. Siuan Sanche and Gareth Bryne finally become an item, though rather chastely so. Two more Forsaken are taken care of (presumably). And in two of the more brilliant plot twists, a mysterious character from the beginning of the series is revealed to be Black Ajah (a jaw-dropping chapter, very well written and conceived), while Elaida is deposed in a way which had me chuckling out loud. I'm not sure who came up with the idea for Elaida's demise, Jordan or Sanderson, but whoever it was, he has a rich sense of poetic justice. It's just too, too good.
Of course, many storylines still remain unresolved, and Sanderson now believes he will need two books to tie them up, not one, as previously planned. I have faith in him, though. I know that these two books of his will really be two books, not seven (as with Jordan). And I have no doubt that they will be good books. Books in which we will finally see Moiraine make a reappearance. Books in which all the prophecies and viewings which have been bandied around for the last twelve books will finally be fulfilled (or not, as the case may be). In which Perrin, Lan, Logain, Mazrim Taim, Slayer, Elayne, Galad, Thom, Birgitte, Olver, the Sea Folk and the Kin will probably get to see more action than they did in The Gathering Storm, and in which the stage is well and truly set for Tarmon Gai’don, the final battle. And I also know that thanks to Sanderson, I am excited about this series again. I will probably spend more time than I care for at Wheel of Time websites over the next few months, looking up old prophecies and comparing theories about where the story is heading. And when it's all over, two books from now, I will in all likelihood look back on the Wheel of Time series with fondness, rather than the bitterness Jordan was increasingly inspiring in me.
Thanks for that, Brandon. After all the time I have invested in this series, I need to love it again, rather than despair of it. It now looks like I may, which is great.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Gathering Storm.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
November 1, 2009
–
Finished Reading
January 7, 2010
– Shelved
January 7, 2010
– Shelved as:
fantasy
January 7, 2010
– Shelved as:
modern-fiction
January 7, 2010
– Shelved as:
north-american
Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)
date
newest »



I lost faith after book 4, gave up after book 8 or 9, but your review has single-...reviewedly renewed my excitement, drats. All those teasers you dropped.

A lot of people are complaining that Sanderson got Mat wrong, and that he turned him into a cheap comic relief boy. I didn't really get that. I agree Mat's voice sounded a little 'off' at times, but I didn't really mind what Sanderson had done to him. Nor did I mind the dark, dark, dark place to which he took Rand. It was hard to read sometimes, but it was well done, in my opinion. I'm glad to see Rand has made it through that phase, though. I hope he will get to spend some quality time with Tam, Hurin and Min in the next book, because, well, damn. I seriously believed he was going to kill Tam, which was pretty shocking, even though I always suspected Tam would be brought back for something like this.
I have only two complaints about this book: Perrin and Mat hardly do anything in it (although I suspect both will be given plenty to do in the next book, especially Mat), and Graendal's off-screen death seemed a little lazy. I do hope she is indeed dead. I wouldn't be surprised to see her back in the next book, though, chuckling at how easy it was to fool the Al'Thor boy.
I'll be interested to see where the True Power storyline is going. There are some interesting theories about that one, some of which sound very likely to me.
And on that note I should probably force myself to stop writing about all this, lest I start sounding like the complete junkie I am.
Any other junkies out there?


I want to be sure, absolutely sure, that THIS time, the series is going to end before recommitting to reading these massive fantasy novels.

I do think Mat was a bit off. Usually I'm charmed and amused by his sections, this time not so much. He is a difficult character, I'll admit. But Jordan had a lot of fun with him, don't think Sanderson nailed him. Yet.
Yes, I was also thrilled to finally know who Morodin was, it's about time. And it does seem like all the Forsaken do come back, altho Rand did use that um um, you know I read this waaaay back in December so I've already forgotten what that special fire is. *blush*
I hate to also admit I don't remember much about the Tower of Ghenjei, but I've been pining for Moiraine ever since she was "killed" in the beginning of this series.
Martine, I am totally back on board with this, and a complete fangirl again. I spent a good week wondering over "the 3 into one" for Callonder to become an all-powerful weapon, thinking it's Rand, Lews and Ileanor or whatever her name was? Cause it ends with the reveal that she could also come back. And maybe Morgaine is her, same as Lews is Rand - I don't think Lews was cognizant when Rand was with her. Altho that was 15 years ago, so who can remember.
I think the biggest compliment to Sanderson is that no rereads were required at all. He's brought it all back to the characters we know and crucial to the plot. He introduced so many characters in the later books, that not only was I lost, I didn't even care I was lost and hadn't the slightest urge to investigate who they were. All those Aes Sedai, as you said! Especially the red ones.
The Verin reveal was shocking. Shockingly good.
Egwene kicked ass. I knew for quite awhile what Aviendha had to do, no surprise when she finally realized it. Perrin and Mat will most definitely be back, as will Tuon. I really like Tuon and am most curious about her further development. And we didn't see Elayne (sp?) at all, I look forward to seeing her again too.
AND please do tell what you have discovered from your various site perusals.
Jackie, I said I wasn't going to read this until it was all done, but after great reviews when I saw it at Costco I snatched it up with a big silly grin on my face!


As for the revelations of The Gathering Storm, are you seriously telling me you hadn't guessed who Moridin was prior to this book? There were some pretty unambiguous clues to his identity in the previous books. I guess you must have skipped those parts, and quite frankly I can't blame you. Some of those books were pretty unreadable.
The Tower of Ghenjei is a tower without entrance in Andor. Mat, Rand and Thom caught a glimpse of it from afar when they were hitching a ride with Bayle Domon all the way back in book 1. It is supposed to be the place where the Aelfinn and Eelfinn (the scary fox- and snakelike creatures Rand and Mat met in one of the earlier books, who answered important questions and gave Mat his ancient memories) live. It is believed the Finns are holding Moiraine, as the doorway through which Moiraine disappeared when she fell was a portal to their world. It is my pet theory (based mostly on a few descriptions in New Spring) that the Finns are also holding all the women who failed their Accepted and Aes Sedai tests -- those poor souls who got lost in the testing ter'angreal and were never heard from again. So Mat, Thom and Olver (I'm absolutely convinced the latter will be involved in the operation) may end up saving not just Moiraine from the tower, but a vast army of women who can channel. Not that that matters now that everybody and their grandmother seems to be able to channel, but still... I believe there may also be a tenuous link between the tower and Slayer, who has been missing in action for the last few books, so I'm guessing we'll see a bit of him, as well. Nice.
Moiraine = Ilyena? Now that's an interesting theory. I don't think it's true, but I suppose it could be. Although I personally believe that if anyone is Ilyena reborn, it is Elayne.
Most people seem to agree that the three-become-one theory regarding Callandor seems to point to Rand, Elayne and Aviendha wielding the sword together, or alternatively Rand, Nynaeve and Alivia. However, I've come across two other interesting theories. One is that the three to be merged are Rand, Lews Therin and Moridin, who are obviously all linked and may well be the same person now. Another is that the three things which must become one are saidin, saidar and the True Power, and I like that theory a lot. I suppose it is possible that we will see Rand channeling the True Power, with an Ashaman (Logain? Narishma?) channeling saidin and an Aes Sedai (probably Nynaeve) channeling saidar. Or alternatively, Rand could use not the True Power, but a fourth, as yet unused power -- the Creator's power. We'll see...
Another interesting theory I've come across is that Verin's instructions to Mat concern the location of the Horn of Valere, which makes an awful lot of sense, given how involved Verin was with that plotline. I predict a plot twist involving Mat, the Horn and Padan Fain.
Other scenes I'm really looking forward to:
-- Rand and Egwene discovering that Mat is married to Tuon. Mat, Rand and Tuon all in one room, with or without Egwene there as a furious fourth party. I'm salivating at the thought.
-- Elayne and Gawyn being reunited with their mother.
-- Aviendha in Rhuidean. Something tells me Aviendha is going to see something important in those pillars. Either that or she is going to find the mighty sa'angreal Lanfear once mentioned, the one that was supposedly stronger than Callandor and the Choedan Kal.
-- A massive battle in Caemlyn. The stage is set for something quite horrific there. White Tower, Black Tower, Borderland army, Seanchan... vast potential for something quite spectacular there.
-- Lan in the Borderlands. There wasn't nearly enough Lan in this book. I do hope he is not going to die, as Min's viewing seems to suggest; neither he nor Nynaeve deserves that.
-- Someone (Thom?) finding the Tinker song, which we know is important.
More theories (ranging from the frankly insane to the remarkably probable) can be found in the link provided above.

Ah yes, I like the theory of Morodin being part of the 3 to 1. Yes I must skipped or forgotten the previous parts of Morodin reveals. I knew he was black, but wasn't sure he was one of the Forsaken, come back with a different name. I love the development with him and Rand being linked and the hints of their former relationship being close when Rand was Lews.
When Moiraine comes back, doncha think Lanfear will as well?
Martine, there's another epic fantasy that I'm completely obsessed with, The Malazen Book of the Fallen. The first book, Gardens of the Moon is hard to get into at first as the author throws us not only into an extremely complex set of characters and established alternative world but also a battle, so you feel a bit lost. But it all starts coming together towards the 2nd half. The series is quite dark almost nihilistic yet filled with small acts of beauty of humanity. Chaos abounds - but that's the whole point, raising this series into the realm of deeper philosophical questions. The last book (#10) is being released this coming August in England. I'm so obsessed in fact that I purchased 9 from England, couldn't wait for the American release!

The thing about Lanfear/Cyndane is that she was resurrected by the Dark One, which means she had to be dead in the first place. Some people have taken this to mean that Moiraine is also dead, since neither of them should have survived the fall through that portal. Alternatively, Moiraine may have killed Lanfear during or after the fall, and survived the experience herself. Personally, I believe Moiraine is alive, but it will be interesting to see how her stay with the Finns has affected her. At the very least, she should have gained some vital new information.
I'll check out the Malazen Book of the Fallen. You do make it sound good, and I've heard other good things about the series. My problem with Erikson (based on a very quick browse of one of his books) is that I truly abhor the names he comes up with for his characters and places. All those consonants and apostrophes... ugh. But I guess I'll have to overcome that particular pet peeve and make an effort to focus on the world he has created instead...
At any rate, thanks for the recommendation; I'll give the series a try!

Moiraine is most definitely still alive!
The Malazen series has captured my fangirl obsession even more than Wheel of Time. It's superb. Of course, the advantage is that I was able to read all the books one right after another, until the last, and even that was only about an 8 month lapse. And not one failed me in any way, as opposed to Jordan's latter ones where nothing happened except more and more people I lost track of having the power! The Malazan is beautifully written, but very dense, not an easy read, which WoT basically is. It makes me think. Hard.
Anyhow, I'm sure both yourself and your husband have enough books on your to-read piles as it is, but really, you could do worse than read The Gathering Storm. It's a pretty damned good book; I came close to giving it five stars. I wouldn't be surprised if your husband, having got to book 5, were to find the plot of book 12 fairly easy to follow, given that very little of note actually happened in books 6 through 11. I'm pretty certain that someone who hadn't read the last six books would still understand most of the action in book 12, which says much about just how little Jordan accomplished in those last few books. I'd say, give it a go; if you get stuck, there are Wheel of Time websites where you can look things up. Although maybe you should wait until the series is actually finished, so that you can read the final three volumes all in one go...