欧宝娱乐

Shannon 's Reviews > Breaking Dawn

Breaking Dawn by Stephenie Meyer
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
395599
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: paranormal, vampires, ya, shape-shifters, 2008, urban-fantasy, romance

** spoiler alert ** I'll preface by saying that I did enjoy this book - I love the story overall, and the characters, and the premise and all of that. I don't have a problem with Bella, and it was funny seeing her through Jacob's biased eyes - on the contrary, I like Bella. I wouldn't be able to read these books if I didn't. What really bothers me most about this series are the obsessive fans.

This is one of those series where the obsessive fans take the story away from the author, writing their own versions, coming up with their own theories and all the rest of it. I don't begrudge them that, but what really annoys me is when they say that Meyer has it all wrong, that that's not what vampires are like, and on and on. I came across a few discussions over what would happen in this book, which I tried to avoid, but people were coming up with all sorts of things: about babies, about what Bella's special gift would be, about the wedding and so on.

I would have thought that this book would have completely satisfied people, but from the glimpses I've caught (much to my annoyance), a lot of fans seem almost scornful of how things panned out. Maybe it's because there was too much of a build-up, like with the last Harry Potter book, and it creates an anti-climax. I'd like to pat myself on the back for avoiding that feeling, by steering clear of all the online discussions - though it's hard on 欧宝娱乐, because people's comments pop up on your updates page. Grrr.

The pregnancy took me by surprise, but I loved it. It was plausible, it was scary, and by switching Point-of-View to Jacob in the middle there (an ingenious device), we not only get a more fleshed-out perspective of that period, a wise move, but it makes Bella's life more fragile, precarious, uncertain. For a while there I was extremely worried that she wouldn't survive. Edward's pain was so very real, and really got to me.

The baby device is quite common in fantasy - the baby that will save the world or the baby that will unite people and so on. Here it was much more personal though, and I appreciated that. Renesmee was a little too perfect, but her bizarre nature balanced it enough that she wasn't too sickly sweet. I wasn't surprised at Jacob imprinting with her - and it was certainly an effective way of handling that pesky problem! I wonder, though, was Bella less interesting when she no longer had to worry herself over two men?

As for the other characters, apart from Bella and Jacob, they're very much in the background, which was rather disappointing. Playing their typical support roles, it felt a little rushed at times, almost like Meyer's heart wasn't really in it - as I understand it she wrote this book because her publisher wanted her to, like with the previous two; Twilight was meant to be a stand-alone novel in the beginning. [I've since learnt from a friend who saw her interviewed that she had this planned out from the beginning and had to convince her publishers to let her do it in four books. But it still felt a bit rushed and half-hearted in places.]

Is it just me or is Jacob Meyer's favourite? He gets an awful lot of airtime here, which gives us a chance to feel really comfortable with him, and he has a nice irreverent tone, but it still leaves many of the other characters thinly sketched. Even Edward, I never really feel like we break through his mystery and outward charisma to the person beneath. Bella sees him as a kind of idol, and as such, he's almost inhuman (ha ha). His emotions come across, but not so much his reasoning, or motivations. I'm not sure, maybe that's not it exactly, but I always want more Edward and want I'm given just doesn't satisfy me.

Now, it was always going to be tricky, writing Bella as a vampire. All her main quirks as a human are gone - the clumsiness, the blushing, the sweetness - which Meyer always used to define her character, so I was really pleased at how she managed to make Bella a convincing vampire while still retaining enough to make her familiar. Her voice doesn't really change, but her actions have. She's much less vulnerable, and that's bound to change anyone. But her body language has been altered, and her confidence too. It worked well. Edward, too, no longer treated her like a fragile human but effortlessly shifted his perspective and treated her as more of a partner, less as an eccentric pet.

The climax was less climactic than the other books, but the fact that it didn't end on violence like the previous book gave the end of the series the right kind of ending, a peaceful one. Bella's special ability made sense, and while it's not visibly impressive, it's certainly very useful and fits her character: always trying to protect others.

Is it just me or do all the books start with Bella in a car? I can't remember how the others started and I didn't get a chance to have a look, but it seemed like they do. If they do, it's an interesting comfort zone.

I love Meyer's version of the vampiric species - it's original and very well fleshed out, and differs at important points from the more generic, Anne Rice version, making them much more attractive, less vulnerable creatures.

This is an addictive series, with as many detractors as fans, and with as much hoo-ha as Harry Potter. They're not as well written as the Harry Potter books, but they're nothing to cringe over either - you don't read them for the prose, but for the story, which is emotionally intense and very, very addictive. It's a classic love story, it's just that the circumstances are a little different.

So, I guess the long and the short of it is, I loved the book, yet it wasn't wholly satisfying, like there was something missing, some part of character development maybe, or maybe I'm just wishing Edward was more fleshed out, now that Bella's like him and he's no longer an alien species. I can't quite put my finger on it. But there were lots of surprises, and the plot was well-structured in three parts, three distinct stages, with all the emotional gut-punching I've come to expect from Meyer. Truly, she puts me through the wringer like Diana Gabaldon - and for this alone I will always love these books (yes, I like the feeling of being put through the proverbial emotional wringer!). It's also a great romance, though too much time was spent telling us of the bond between Bella and Edward, and not enough time showing us. Perhaps that was what bugged me?
98 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Breaking Dawn.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

November 1, 2007 – Shelved
November 1, 2007 – Shelved as: paranormal
November 1, 2007 – Shelved as: vampires
February 16, 2008 – Shelved as: ya
February 28, 2008 – Shelved as: shape-shifters
Started Reading
August 7, 2008 – Finished Reading
August 8, 2008 – Shelved as: 2008
January 1, 2009 – Shelved as: urban-fantasy
February 23, 2009 – Shelved as: romance

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Maria Elmvang Yes, yes, yes and yes! :-)


Shannon Even the not-so-glowing bits? Doesn't stop me from really enjoying it though! I'm sure you feel the same :)


Maria Elmvang Yes, even the not-so-glowing bits :) I'm not the type of person why has to love everything about a book in order to enjoy it. Just like in the people I love the most, I can see a book's faults and love it regardless.


Shannon I'm just the same, especially with these books! I'm usually quite picky but it's so nice to just enjoy a book for what it is!


Theresa Great review, Shannon!


message 6: by Claire (new)

Claire Exactly what i'm thinking...great review...and i can't understand why some poeple want to burn their book just because it's not what they wanted to read...and i thought I was a weirdo...


Tina Yes, i agree whole heartedly.. especially about the addiction part, its freaking me out a bit. I also love the diana gabaldon books. Finally, a good, truthful review.


message 8: by Emily (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:16AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Emily Smith Good review! I just checked Eclipse. I think she had just gotten out of the car, but I know Breaking Dawn and Twilight start in a car. I'll try to get to you on New Moon, if I remember.:)Again, like the review!



Shannon *laughs*

Thanks for responding to my silly car question Emily!

I can't remember what I said in the review anymore but I'm glad to hear I'm not the only one who's not over-reacting to this book :)

And why am I not getting email notifications when people leave comments on reviews? I'd like to discuss but I no longer know when someone's left a comment on my or someone else's review. I've checked my settings... maybe this is one for Otis...


Emily Smith Yeah, no problem (about the car question)! ;)
I'm not sure why you're not getting email notifications, sorry bout that.


Shannon It's working now - if you ever get asked to verify your email address on your account, you also need to unblock it. I got help ;)


Jennifer Excellent review! You hit the nail on the head with this one. I really don't understand all the negative uproar over this book. I thought it was great, and about what I expected. Meyer threw us a few curve balls, but overall it was an enjoyable read.


Shannon Yes, I think part of the definition of being "blown away" by a book is to not have the expectation of being blown away in the first place ! I don't think you can be all that impressed if you expect it to be amazing, know what I mean? Twilight worked so well for me because it took me by surprise, the next two followed up on the same momentum. I didn't even give myself time to stop and start putting together a list of expectations.


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

wow, long review


Shannon Guess I had a lot to say :)


message 16: by Carolina (last edited Dec 24, 2010 07:46AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Carolina Well, it WAS a great review because... it explained the reasons I started to dislike the book!
I mean, it was a good thing to read, you could enjoy the characters but I don't think they were... real? I probably wouldn't consider them as my friends if I got to knew them and I think that was part of the problem.
Oh well, once again, great review!


Shannon Carol'ina wrote: "Well, it WAS a great review because... it explained the reasons I started to dislike the book!
I mean, it was a good thing to read, you could enjoy the characters but I don't think they were... re..."


*laughs* I wouldn't be friends with them either Carol'ina, I don't think we have anything in common! I find them much more melodramatic in the movies, which bothers me some, but in the context of the story it worked for me. :)


message 18: by Maye (new) - rated it 3 stars

Maye Even though I didn't feel the same as you, I still LOVE your reviews! I need to totally follow your reviews.


Shannon Maye wrote: "Even though I didn't feel the same as you, I still LOVE your reviews! I need to totally follow your reviews."

Thanks Maye. :)
I certainly enjoy discussing books with people who had different reading experiences.


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

I admire that you are a loyal fan to a series that has bee hated so many times. I don't agree with you about BD, but I admire your loyalty to the author. :)


Shannon Lael Nicole wrote: "I admire that you are a loyal fan to a series that has bee hated so many times. I don't agree with you about BD, but I admire your loyalty to the author. :)"

I don't think I'm loyal to the author so much as the story, but thanks, I appreciate your polite disagreement. If you want to share your thoughts I'm happy to discuss. :) I was at least fortunate to have read these books mostly before all the fuss about them started, which would no doubt have adversely affected me and I hate that!


message 22: by [deleted user] (new)

Shannon wrote: "Lael Nicole wrote: "I admire that you are a loyal fan to a series that has bee hated so many times. I don't agree with you about BD, but I admire your loyalty to the author. :)"

I don't think I'm ..."


I know what you mean. I hate it when people just go with what everyone else says about the book and you can't help but to hop in the bandwagon. I prefer to read a book before all the hype starts. That way I can form my own, personal, independent opinion. I started Twilight just before everyone started reading it. I liked it. It is addicting, I'll give it that. But to me, BD just ruined it in a whole lot of levels. That's just my opinion though.


message 23: by Emmma (new)

Emmma nice review!!!!!! i agree! :)


message 24: by pranya (new)

pranya I hate Twilight. Every bit of it. I've read the books, all of them. I've always wondered what girls love about it so much. Their reasons are a) OMG, Edward is lyk sooooo hawtt!! b) Taylor Lautner is da sexiest wolf evaaaa!! c) Alice is sooooo shweet!
You have given me reasons. You have made me nod in agreement. You have listed almost every reason I hate Twilight. Great job.


message 25: by Alexis (new)

Alexis Thompson The last book of the series would always be the best one? It hasn't been for the most part.There is a happy ending of course, Bella turns into a vampire. I knew this was going to happen from the first book. The book was very predictable to me but in some parts of the book it was very interesting. Like when she gave birth to Renesmee. When she did she died but Edward saves her by biting her then boom! Bella is a vampire.What disturbs me the most is when Jacob imprints on the baby. I really don't know why people liked the series it was really just another teen book to me. :(


message 26: by Rasheed Ahamed (new)

Rasheed Ahamed This book is amazing


message 27: by Lily (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lily I know this review didn't do this but I really don't understand whyyyy people hate on Bella and edward and this book is amazing and great review btw


back to top