ŷ

David's Reviews > Moby-Dick or, The Whale

Moby-Dick or, The Whale by Herman Melville
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3073544
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: pants-crapping-awesome

There once was a grouchy alpha whale named Moby Dick who -- rather than being agreeably shorn of his blubber and having lumpy sperm scooped out of his cranium like cottage cheese -- chose life. Unlike so many shiftless, layabout sea mammals of his generation, Moby Dick did not go gentle into that good night. This whale, in short, was not a back-of-the-bus rider. He assailed a shallow, consumerist society, which objectified him only as lamp oil or corset ribbing, with the persuasive argument of his thrashing tail, gaping maw, and herculean bulk.

In his seminal (in more ways than one) animal rights saga, Herman Melville conjures an aquatic, rascally Norma Rae out of an elephantine albino whale. Reasonably enough, Moby Dick (hereafter M.D., despite possible confusions with the profession) is irritable when people are chasing him, stabbing him with harpoons, and trying to kill him. Thus, in an act which would be protected by law as self defense in most enlightened nations, M.D. bites off part of the leg of one of his many hunters, the humorless Captain Ahab.

Gall alert! Gall alert! Ahab has the nerve to hold a fucking grudge against the whale for this entirely ethical dismemberment. (He also holds a grudge for some incidental damage incurred to Lil' Ahab as a very weak corollary of his lost limb, but I'm not even getting into that. Judge Wapner would've never stomached that half-baked reasoning, so neither will I.) Now mind you, M.D. doesn't, like, come ashore in Nantucket, rent a lowrider horse-drawn carriage, and try to put a cap in the ass of that one-legged old bitch-ass captain who wanted to decapitate him. So, I mean, who's really the petty one in this equation?

The novel Moby-Dick eschews a first-person whale narrator in favor of Ishmael, a bit of a rube who shows up in New Bedford with big dreams of a whaling career. (Whaling was the Hollywood of that era.) He meets this reformed cannibal harpooner named Queequeg who hails from the South Seas, has lots of tattoos, and moonlights as a decapitated-human-head salesman. So basically he's rough trade. Ishmael and Queequeg become fast-friends and do all kinds of jovial homoerotic things together, like cuddle in bed and curiously espy each other undressing -- despite their pronounced cultural differences. I think Ishmael acts as a keen ethnographer when he highlights the variances: Queequeg, the savage, idol-worshipping, hell-condemned, unenlightened, "oogah-boogah" heathen, and Ishmael, the... white guy. Yet their love endures. It's as if all the sexual currents in Neil Simon's Odd Couple were suddenly foregrounded.

Ishmael and Queequeg find employment on the whaler Pequod, helmed by none other than the killjoy Captain Ahab himself -- he of prosthetic whalebone leg, abbreviated schlong, and legendary grudge-holding. So the Pequod embarks upon a three or four year whaling adventure around the globe, ostensibly in search of valuable whale oil, but in fact -- as we later learn -- to bring about Ahab's vengeance against the Marxist whale M.D., who refuses to be expropriated by the Man.

Interestingly enough, as the journey goes on, Ishmael's character seems to evaporate. In other words, he gradually shifts from a compartmentalized first-person narrator to an omniscient third-person narrator. He seems almost to have rescinded his identity (or he only rarely invokes it) in the latter part of the novel, as if -- while we have been distracted by gloppy whale sperm and passing ships -- he morphed into the Star Child. This transformation is, of course, intentional and creates a sense of broadening perspective throughout the novel -- of transcending the menial and specific to embrace a grand, universal tragedy.

Here's the bottom line. Moby-Dick is an American classic that sounds as though it would be absolutely torturous to read. A six-hundred-page nineteenth-century novel about the pursuit of a whale? You've got to be kidding. Did I mention that there are chapters after chapters that merely detail the processes and (often gory) procedures of whaling? I know. Try to control yourself before you run out to the bookstore or library, right? Wrong. Wrong. Wrong.

This novel is magnificent. It proves what I have held true ever since I started writing myself -- that any subject at all, from whittling to colonoscopies to Riverdance to bagpipe playing, can be enthralling in the hands of a competent writer -- a writer like Melville, who simultaneously locates the universal in this seemingly very particular narrative and makes even the occasionally perplexing rituals of whaling seem fascinating.

Also, it's a captivating historical document chronicling M.D.'s groundbreaking role in the nascent Whale Power movement. Eat tailfin, honkies!
225 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Moby-Dick or, The Whale.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
January 18, 2010 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Where are the five pants-crapping stars?


karen this is going to make me sleepy.


David Oops.

(...up inside your head. Oops up inside your head. Say oops up.)


message 4: by Joshua Nomen-Mutatio (last edited Jan 18, 2010 12:05PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Ahhhh, there we go. Now I can sleep tight tonight. Balance is restored to the universe.

(...up inside your head. Oops up inside your head. Say oops up.)

I have no idea what this is about, but I bet dollars to donuts that it's funny!


message 5: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! I think he's talking to himself about the once missing stars. Either that or pants were crapped and need changing.


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio I was hoping against hope that it'd be something involving some hottt traxxx.


message 8: by Cathy (new)

Cathy This is by far the most magnificent book review I have ever read. I, personally, love Moby Dick -- but I love your review of it even mroe than I love the actual book!


The Crimson Fucker I voted for this review cuz david asked me to vote for all of his reviews!


Edward Creter May I suggest you read Ahab's Wife by Sara Naslund? It's allegedly the Moby Dick prequel rto end ALL prequels. I've a copy at home I've yet to read and I need a second opinion. Readable or no?


Robin P Ahab's wife is excellent, mabye a bit wishful thinking as to what a more feminist 19th century could have been. It does have some seafaring based on a true incident and some cameos by famous New Englanders, as well as one of the more dramatic opening scenes I've ever read.


Robin P I was referred to this review by the current Big Moby Dick Group Read on ŷ, I am in a live book group reading it right now as well and I will share this fabulous review with them.


Sandra I am reading this now... I LOVED your review! So funny, so astute. I shall follow you!


kashiichan This is the best M.D. review I've ever read.


message 15: by Nancy (last edited Nov 21, 2014 10:32AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nancy I'm not writing a review of this book since you have done it for me, much better than I could myself! Humorous, intelligent, perceptive! Yes!!


message 16: by Kyle (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kyle Minton nailed it David.


Summer Rain This is good and correct.


message 18: by Paul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Yes, it is magnificent. Magnificently so.


message 19: by Joel (new)

Joel Larson Nothing has ever made me want to read Moby Dick more than this review


message 20: by TT (new)

TT Girl “Lump of cottage cheese� PLS I’M SCREAMING


back to top