Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Chrissie's Reviews > A Woman in Berlin: Eight Weeks in the Conquered City: A Diary

A Woman in Berlin by Anonymous
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
632247
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: germany, history, bio, favorites

I think everybody should read this book. When I began it I warned others that it is about rape in wartime. And that is true. Any subject in a good author’s hands can be worth reading. It is the ability of the author to make that subject comprehensible to readers that distinguishes a good author. We know now who the anonymous writer of these diaries was. Her name is Marta Hillers. The German writer Kurt Marek was responsible for the initial publication of the book in 1954, in the United States. The author was anonymous. Only later was it published in Germany. Only after her death in 2003 was it revealed who the writer was.

The book is based on the author’s diary accounts from the 20th of April to the 22nd of June 1945. It gives us a personal account of one woman’s experiences when the Red army occupied Berlin. Her story lets us understand what she and those around her experienced. What they lived through.

When I read this book I thought: I am being shown a world that I could never, ever imagine. It was beyond belief. The horror of it! Fear. Hunger. Being alone, completely alone. And it is hard to imagine that people can act as they do. It is important to read this book. We must acknowledge how people can behave. Yes, you and I can behave so deplorably too.

So then you will think, why should I read this? Why should I put myself through this? We must understand in our gut what has happened. A book like this makes us aware both in our head and in our stomach, both with clear thoughts and powerful emotions what another human being has experienced. And why is this important? It is important since it teaches us to not judge others. Before judging another you must put yourself in their shoes. This author has let us walk in her shoes. And the writing shows us how we human beings behave.

Yes, this book is about rape, but it is also about survival. It is about hunger too. The book begins with hunger and ends with hunger. How many of us reading this book has any real comprehension of being HUNGRY? Can we come to understand what we might do, what choices we might make if we were hungry as she was? You will understand her choices when you read this book. I will say it outright: in an effort to survive this woman realized that she needed to find a Russian that would provide her with food and safety. One’s chances of not being raped were minimal. If you are going to be raped anyway, why not make sure you get food in the bargain? By aligning yourself with a Russian of higher rank you could perhaps have him protect you from indiscriminate raping. But to understand the world she was living in you must read her words. When this book came out it was the women who were accused of bad behavior. The author was a survivor. I respect this woman. She was a journalist. She was well educated. She had traveled through Europe. She knew Russian. All of this is evident in her diary writing. She used her head and she survived. How can you look down on such a person? How can you criticize her if you have no idea what she has experienced?

You can only understand her choices by following her diary writings.

And the ending�. When her boyfriend comes back he doesn’t understand her actions. He too thinks she has degraded herself. We do not know if eventually they can bridge this incomprehension of what each has experienced in the war. I was so happy before her boyfriend came back. She had survived. I was so dam proud of her. I was crushed by his incomprehension. If he had read the book, he would maybe understand what she had gone through. If you read the book you will understand what she went through. If you read the book you will not judge others too quickly. I don’t think this book is terribly sad or depressing. I am so happy she survived. Dam, she is some strong woman, this author, Marta Hillers. She has let us see what happened to her. I admire her for surviving. I am so very glad she shared her experiences with us. I thoroughly understand her wish that the book have an anonymous author while she lived.

One does not read this book to find out if her boyfriend comes back. For this reason I do not think my telling you this is a “spoiler�. Only those of you wanting to understand another human being should bother to read this book. You have to want to get into their being. You have to want to become them in an effort to understand them and what they lived through.

There is a little boy at the end of the book who sees an old horse pulling a cart. He turns to his mother and says, “Mutti, can we eat the horse?� Earlier in the book another horse was still moving when he was cut into by hungry Berliners. Have you ever been that hungry? Do you have any idea how their world was? Do you want to understand their world? Read the book.

Be very careful before you judge another human being’s behavior.

I must add this. Although the subject matter is not light, the way the author expresses herself will make you smile. She calls herself the “automatic walking machine�, as she trudges to work�.. This author can write. I wish I could copy parts of the book to show you, but I cannot use both Vocatex and Zoomtex at the same time. I need Vocatex to read the book and Zoomtex to write my review. When I am writing the review, I cannot read the book � so no quotes! This is so annoying to me.
35 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read A Woman in Berlin.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 20, 2010 – Shelved
January 20, 2010 – Shelved as: germany
January 20, 2010 – Shelved as: history
January 20, 2010 – Shelved as: bio
March 20, 2012 – Started Reading
March 24, 2012 – Shelved as: favorites
March 24, 2012 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tom (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tom Interesting, I didn't know the author had been identified. I wonder if she went public voluntarily or was "outed" by someone? Is she still alive? I guess a little research in order here.


message 2: by Chrissie (last edited Mar 24, 2012 10:30AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chrissie Tom, she died in 2003. She did not want the book to be printed with her name while she lived. I am glad I am reading the book finally. You can tell that she was a journalist. Her writing is gripping. What happens to her is horrendous. She is extremely honest about her own actions.

This book is so different from the writing in the book I just completed. Each piece is dated. There is no question in my mind that these are accurate, on-the-spot experiences. She is simply trying to survive. Nothing is glossed over.


Denise I loved this book. Have you seen the movie? It is very good, too.


message 4: by Manybooks (new) - added it

Manybooks I will add this as well, any book you rate five stars, is worth checking (even though the subject matter is a bit wow).


Chrissie Gundula, I was going to recommend this one to you.

Denise, I have not seen the movie. There are so many things that could be discussed in this book. Why did the Russians behave as they did? Did Stalin want them to behave in this manner because it made others scared of them? And liquor..... if a country wants to protect its women, the first thing that should be done is remove the liquor. Every bottle should be broken before the enemy enters the city. But neither were the German men anything to rely on. Was their inability to defend their women just their way of surviving too? What will people do to survive? Everybody stole. I guess I would too. You realize when you read this book that none of us are above acting despicably, that we too would probably do horrid things if we are simply trying to survive. But it is not all horrid, she survives. When she was washing and singing. When they recited poetry you felt the beauty of it. This book really moves the reader. People should read this book to get a better understanding of how the human species is.


Chrissie Gundula, I was actually going to recommend this to you.

Denise, what a book! It isn't all horrid. Remember when the women are washing and singing?! She values life, she realizes that life is worth living. THAT is not depressing.


message 7: by Manybooks (last edited Mar 24, 2012 11:01AM) (new) - added it

Manybooks Chrissie wrote: "Gundula, I was going to recommend this one to you.

Denise, I have not seen the movie. There are so many things that could be discussed in this book. Why did the Russians behave as they did? Did S..."


One of the theories regarding why some members of the Red Army behaved the way they did is that the German army had previously behaved in a very similar fashion on their push into Russia (so for some, it was payback, it was revenge). I don't think that is the complete story, but I think that the above theory does have some merit. And not all members of the Red Army behaved viciously, just like on the German push to the East, not all soldiers acted like monsters (on the other hand, the German army did seem to have actual orders from Hitler, Goering et al to terrorise, to kill, to destroy civilians, I don't know wether the Red Army had similar orders from Stalin)


Chrissie It is stated in the book that the Russians were NOT told to behave as they did. It was not an order from above. But was such behavior punished? The abundance of liquor is shown as a prime cause of their behavior. Nobody acted as one would normally. Her world was so different. To understand her world you have to read her words. It is also stated that the Russians were taking revenge, as you point out, for what they had experienced. But why through rape? Where is the connection? On the other hand this is not the sole example of rape in wartime.


message 9: by Tom (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tom Thanks for the bio background, Chrissie, and for the compelling review. I've had this on my shelf for some time, and hope to get to it soon.


Chrissie Tom, grab it soon. You will not be disappointed. Extremely engaging. Now my husband is going to read it, he says.


Chrissie I haven't read All But My Life: A Memoir, but I gave "A woman in Berlin" five stars. It is brutal reading though.


Wendy I really enjoyed this book too! Have you also read Resistance: A French Woman's Journal of the War. It's from a different perspective, but I thought it was excellent.


Wendy Anna wrote: "Wendy wrote: "I really enjoyed this book too! Have you also read Resistance: A French Woman's Journal of the War. It's from a different perspective, but I thought it was excellent."

Wendy, thank..."


I hope you enjoy it Anna. I found the author's ability to recall details and eperiences to be very impressive. And she just seemed like an amazing person with an indomitable spirit (not sure if I spelled indomitable right????).


Chrissie Wendy, I have Resistance: A French Woman's Journal of the War on the shelf next to my desk. This makes me so happy to hear. I am determined to read all the books I have purchased before I buy more paper books. Some of the books I have I really do not know why I bought them!Why, why, why have I bought Forever Amber? Maybe because it covers the plague and the fire in London.... Thank you for telling me that Résistance is good!

Anna, so you know Wendy? Lovely! Anna, I admire your ability to read that whole book in one night! It is rather a tough read, don't you think? But a very good book. I will check out your review.


Wendy Oh Chrissie - I read Forever Amber too! It is pretty much historical fiction smutty style. Not sure it is your cup of tea, but I did learn about the restoration period which was interesting.


message 16: by Chrissie (last edited Dec 07, 2012 06:49AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chrissie Wendy, I do not know what got into me when I bought Amber! It is good to know that some of the paper books I have left on my shelves will not be a waste of time. That is why I was so very happy that you mentioned Resistance: A Frenchwoman's Journal of the War was good!


Wendy Anna -- I'm not gonna lie, Forever Amber is a fun, raunchy read, and there is a lot of history crammed into it as well. It wasn't miserable reading, but it's probably on par (or perhaps a notch below)a Phillipa Gregory book. They made it into a movie some time ago, so you could always opt for the video version and only have to sink 2 hours into it as opposed to slogging through all 900+ pages. Does that help?


Wendy I have a copy of the movie somewhere, but haven't watched it, so I don't know how good/bad it is.


Chrissie Wendy, I will at least try Forever Amber. To dump a book I already have is stupid. Maybe the history will save it. ;0)


Wendy Try to read it w/ a sense of humour :-)


Chrissie You have me laughing already..... I am not going to jump and read it first.


message 22: by Mark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark Super review, Chrissie, and a challenging but compelling read. Seldom will you encounter such brutal honesty in an autobiography and her depth of self-knowledge is incredible. I guess she was her own therapist for those appalling eight weeks in Berlin, and as she says she ‘never surrendered herself.�


Chrissie Thank you, Mark. I'm an honest reviewer, I say exactly what I think! Some get annoyed. Others appreciate my honesty.


back to top