Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Jibran's Reviews > In the Name of Identity: Violence and the Need to Belong

In the Name of Identity by Amin Maalouf
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5407952
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: history-politics

A thoughtful exposition on the clash engendered by modern ideas of nationhood between a person's many identities and allegiances. He argues for a new approach that doesn't box people into exclusive, singular identity based either on nationality, or ethnicity, or language, which, according to him, is the main source of so much violence of the last century.

The argument is that in the age of globalisation it is no longer tenable to have homogeneous countries with single or dominant ethnicity, language or even culture. Therefore, there is a need to accommodate a person's many different identities for the sake of tolerance and peace. Maalouf gives his own example. He's Lebanese, native Arabic speaker, a Christian and a French national. He asks if he's not French because he has Arab origins? Is he not Arab because he's a Christian? Arabic in his mother tongue yet he writes in French and drinks France's water. Who is to deny him what part of his identity to fit him 'properly' into one country?

A very useful read and in a way an eye-opener for the Western societies that still seem to be hanging on to the pre-World War II conception of nationhood. Maalouf argues that our failure to adjust ourselves to new realities will end up in lots of unrest and bloodshed. Two decades onwards, we're seeing his prescient analysis beginning to come true in the European countries where leaders increasingly taking on the view that multiculturalism and diversity have 'failed'. If Maalouf were to hear this, he might have said, "it is not diversity that has failed; it's you who have failed your vision of the future.'
14 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read In the Name of Identity.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
January 1, 2014 – Finished Reading
March 6, 2014 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Cristina One of my favorite ones, no doubt about that!! Happy you like it too :)


message 2: by Jibran (last edited Apr 03, 2015 12:11PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jibran Maalouf is so eloquent and prophetic with his vision. I feel I have not done justice to his impeccable prose in my ramblings!

Thanks you so much, Cristina, for stopping by to read and comment :)


Rowena Glad you enjoyed this one, Jibran! Maalouf made a lot of great points about diversity, definitely a lot I could relate to.


Jibran Rowena wrote: "Glad you enjoyed this one, Jibran! Maalouf made a lot of great points about diversity, definitely a lot I could relate to."

Indeed he made a lot of good points. Given, the turn things are taking in the West I think everyone will do well to heed Maalouf's subdued warnings found in the book before it's too late!


message 5: by Mehwish (new) - added it

Mehwish A great review as always Jibran! You make it easy for me to choose whether I want to read it or not :)


Jibran Mehwish wrote: "A great review as always Jibran! You make it easy for me to choose whether I want to read it or not :)"

Hi Mehwish, thank you for the word. I could certainly do better with distilling Maalouf's thought. I wrote this in a hurry and haven't been able to revisit. But it's good to know you found it useful. It's a good book and very relevant to our times now that what Maalouf feared is apparent than ever before. God have mercy on "us" and "them" mentality...


Jibran ^^ and apologies for the late reply. I am not on GR these days, not much anyway.


message 8: by Mehwish (new) - added it

Mehwish Jibran wrote: "Mehwish wrote: "A great review as always Jibran! You make it easy for me to choose whether I want to read it or not :)"

Hi Mehwish, thank you for the word. I could certainly do better with distill..."


"us" and "them" - breaks my heart! Sad times


message 9: by Mehwish (new) - added it

Mehwish Jibran wrote: "^^ and apologies for the late reply. I am not on GR these days, not much anyway."

:)


ReemK10 (Paper Pills) I am glad to see that you read this as well. Enjoyed reading your review Jibran but can't "like" your review over the phone.


Jibran ReemK10 (Paper Pills) wrote: "I am glad to see that you read this as well. Enjoyed reading your review Jibran but can't "like" your review over the phone."

Thank you, Reem. I believe Maalouf's message has taken a new urgency seeing what's happening around the world esp in developed countries which were supposed to be more inclusive.
And I hope you've been well. It's been a long time we communicated :)


ReemK10 (Paper Pills) You're so right. We truly need to live in a society where no one is excluded from the conversation.I've been well. Spending my time on twitter and google+. We mustn't lose touch.


ReemK10 (Paper Pills) Hello Jibran, was just reading this and wanted to share it with you :



Jibran In a study of readers' attitudes they found that reading literature breeds empathy and understanding. I think this is just one benefit. The article convincingly lays out why dialogue and interaction in the best language possible is necessary for diversity and peaceful coexistence. Great article, thank you very much for linking me to it, Reem!


Jibran Sabah wrote: "A wonderful review, Jibran! I agree with a great deal of what has been said. I also think that many immigrants face this very same problem, and have been doing so for decades now. I think the globa..."

You have summed up the problem succinctly and eloquently, Sabah. In addition to the great and sudden rise in migrant numbers since the onset of globalosation, I also think the host communities didn't properly conceive what they came to call multiculturalism. The whole concept was poorly defined and romanticised to begin with. Now that the novelty has worn off it's becoming harder to redefine it on the basis of more inclusive and integrated community model. The nature of single-nation state nationalism that has given Europe, and indeed the rest of the world, its shape is ill-suited to absorb diversity, despite all the lip service one might pay it, and this I believe is the biggest challenge of in a globalised world. We will see more diversity not less as time passes. So I think it's in everyone's best interest to come to terms to it. There are great dangers if it fails. Scapegoating has been a great problem in modern history and with some Holocaust survivors still living, it would be a shame if things begin to appear to go down that road in the West, or elsewhere anyplace in the world. I think Maalouf's warning has been prescient.

Apologies for the delayed response. I missed the notification, perhaps didn't get it, and saw it only in my gmail. Thank you so much for reading and gracing this space with your insightful comment, Sabah :)


back to top