Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

karen's Reviews > The Birds and Other Stories

The Birds and Other Stories by Daphne du Maurier
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
45618
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: hey-shorty, netgalley, oh-no-biiiiiiirds

in calculating my enjoyment of this collection, i might have made a mathematical error. there are six stories in this collection, and i only disliked one of them. granted, the one i disliked was the longest story, which gives it more negative weight, but my love of the last story was so great that i think i shall round this up to four stars.

there.

since there are only six stories, it is not a trial for me to review them separately.

The Birds

yeah, we've all seen the movie.



but du maurier's story is completely different, except for the central premise fact that birds are evil. hers is a much more pastoral story, where the action revolves around one family's attempts to keep the aggressive birds out of their house, but the attacks are of course much wider-reaching. it's terrifically tense with the window-pecking and chimney-invading, and the family's attempts to turn their small home into a fortress in the small windows of opportunity between massive bird-invasions. goddamn birds.

Monte Verita

this is the one i thought was barf. it starts out promising but it just goes on and on and then gets all weird and flaky with all that ineffable imagery that i find so tedious in authors like lovecraft. this story made me really grouchy.

The Apple Tree

this one is darkly comic with an unlikeable, unreliable narrator recently widowed and glad of it. finally he is free to do as he pleases, living like a bachelor without the pesky sighing martyrdom of his wife invading his relaxing space with her relentless housework and negative attitude. but there's this apple tree, see, and it is starting to remind him of her - dauntlessly clinging to life, keeping the other, younger, prettier trees in its shadow, producing fruit that everyone else finds pleasant but tastes rancid in his mouth. and he starts to HATE that tree. it starts to haunt his every waking moment and ruin his peace of mind. and he is going to have to do something about it. this is a great slow-burning character study of a man who is bitterly angry with limited self-awareness. man vs tree - who will win?

The Little Photographer

this is another great character study, with a fantastic shift in readerly loyalty. it concerns a beautiful, lonely marquise left to her own devices on holiday with her two young daughters while her husband tends to his business needs. she married an older man for the glamor of his title, but has found that it is not at all as rewarding as she had imagined, and is a very shallow existence of keeping up appearances and tedious public engagements. she envies her friends with their romantic dalliances and the freedom they have in their unscrutinized lives, and decides to take advantage of her unsupervised situation by having an affair with a young awestruck photographer whom she uses for the physical pleasures while treating him with indifference and lording her social superiority over him. but when he starts to get a little clingy, she has to protect herself, right?

Kiss Me Again, Stranger

a young man falls hard for an enigmatic beauty with some serious baggage. it has the feeling of a ghost story without any actual ghosts, and it a fantastic cautionary tale about finding out some details about a lady before you go getting all starry-eyed. pretty girls make graves and all.

The Old Man

oh, man. i am not going to say anything about this story except that du maurier blew my everlovin' mind with this one. COMPLETELY caught by surprise. i was reading it and going "blah blah blah - why do i care about this situation??" and the OUT OF NOWHERE she yanked the rug out from under me, and i fell in love with her. best way to end a story collection ever.

so, yes. four stars for the collection, no stars for that mountain-story, and one million stars for that last story.

this is math.

245 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Birds and Other Stories.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 17, 2014 – Started Reading
March 17, 2014 – Shelved
March 27, 2014 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Debbie "DJ" (new)

Debbie "DJ" You rock!! Shhhh!


karen haahha! you too, poetess!


message 3: by Cole Klotz (new)

Cole Klotz cine erviwe (its scrambled go easy on me am a noob at it oll)


karen ksntha


message 5: by Jonah (new)

Jonah Reilly i odnt nokw ywh uyo ysgu ear kaitnlg ikle isht ubt i wnan eb cluinedd!


message 6: by Jessica (new)

Jessica T. would you recommend it as a good introduction to her work?


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

I like the movie very,very much..I loved that movie!!


karen Jessica wrote: "would you recommend it as a good introduction to her work?"

i have only read this and Rebecca, and even though i just realized i only gave Rebecca 4 stars on here, my 2007-self surprises me, because i feel like i loved that book the most. all that to say - read Rebecca. it kicks ass.


message 9: by Trish (new)

Trish Like your math. It includes the concept of "compromise" which is excluded from "fuzzy math."


message 10: by Debbie "DJ" (new)

Debbie "DJ" Yes, thank you for your fine math skills, I never quite understood them before. Now, it all makes sense! I have learned so much from you already.:)


message 11: by Cole Klotz (new)

Cole Klotz atht asw ot asey


Lady Alexandrine hi, Karen :) thank you for your review. I read a lot of Daphne de Maurier stories and books. My favourite is Jamaica Inn :) I really liked two of the stories you described: The Apple Tree and Kiss Me Again, Stranger. I like the atmosphere of danger and mystery in her writing, just like the Hitchcock movies.


message 13: by Helen (new) - added it

Helen What a great review! Going on my TBR list.


karen yes! i definitely have to read more of her. mmmmm


message 15: by Tim (new)

Tim Martin Great review. I never knew the Birds was a short story. The Apple Tree sound very neat, just the sort of idea best explored in a short story. Nice!


karen yeah, she's a fantastic writer. just that one story....

but other people like it a lot, so it's my own failing there.


message 17: by Tim (new)

Tim Martin True, but I can't think of a single book, TV show, movie, or piece of music that EVERYONE I know likes. Sometimes people dislike things for very personal reasons or things they cannot even explain at a conscious level.

I do like reading your reviews, I think your format for short story reviews is spot on.


karen awww thank you!!!


message 19: by Erica (new)

Erica I've always enjoyed The Apple Tree. I should probably read more of her work, especially now that your review reminded me I like this woman's stories.


karen dooooooo it, internet twin!


message 21: by Erica (new)

Erica karen wrote: "dooooooo it, internet twin!"

I think I will. First, I think I will go through my compendiums and compilations to see what I already have and will read those. Thank goodness I'm a cataloger and have all the compilations and compendiums in one place on one bookshelf!


message 22: by Will (new)

Will Byrnes Boids, dirty, filthy, stinkin' boids!


Almeta I need not say more. Fully agree. I considered stopping after a couple stories, and didn't.

The last story was my reward for perseverance!


karen exactly! stay the course, people!


Carol Still can't believe the ending of The Old Man!


karen ugh, i know! it floored me!


Carol karen wrote: "ugh, i know! it floored me!"

Ditto Karen!


message 28: by [Name Redacted] (new)

[Name Redacted] I love Lovecraft, since I'm one bad day away from becoming either a protagonist or an antagonist in one of his stories. So consider me sold!

Though I am a bit weary of stories which try to make me sympathize with adulterers, so we shall see...


karen yeah, but that's just one story, silly! (which applies to both of your sentences. economy!)


message 30: by [Name Redacted] (new)

[Name Redacted] But if the second referenced story sets me off, I might start summoning things. Ineffable things!


karen hhmph. the review i'm posting today is a lovecrafty book of stories, so waaaiiiit fooooor it!


message 32: by Claire Duffer (new)

Claire Duffer YOU ROCK


Hester I think you'd like her short story The Doll, it's messed up. And Monte Verita was a real snooze.


message 34: by [Name Redacted] (new)

[Name Redacted] karen wrote: "hhmph. the review i'm posting today is a lovecrafty book of stories, so waaaiiiit fooooor it!"

WE HAVE WAITED MILLENNIA. WE WILL WAIT FOR YOUR REVIEW.


karen i will definitely read the doll, thanks!!

and sheeeeit radacto, the review went up days ago! you need a linky??


message 36: by [Name Redacted] (new)

[Name Redacted] karen wrote: "i will definitely read the doll, thanks!!

and sheeeeit radacto, the review went up days ago! you need a linky??"


ALL TIME IS AS ONE TO US.


message 37: by Ava McClure (new)

Ava McClure fantastic review karen iits going on my tbr list


Steve Egger Perfect review


message 39: by Zoeb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Zoeb Monte Verita does go on longer than it should but it was very, very suspenseful and also poignant and heartbreaking at the end. Sorry to disagree with you there. I think Du Maurier dissected the real price that one pays for paradise and bliss and how even paradise is not free from earthly disease and disappointment. It was quite stirring and also demonstrated Du Maurier's gift of perspective.


message 40: by Zoeb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Zoeb Nevertheless superb review and hope to finish the remaining three stories soon...


Stefanie I had to read the last story twice. I read it, was amazed by the end, and immediately reread the story. And this time it was a completely different story to the one I had just read. A million stars! 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟


karen oooh, yes! this makes me want to reread it right now!


William Thank you for the review!

However, my memory is still playing tricks. The short story I am looking for starts with a picnic in the woods, and one of the birds in the trees darts down and pecks the neck of the girl, drawing blood. Does that ring a bell with anyone?


message 44: by Bonnie (new)

Bonnie I too dislike Lovecraft. Love your spot on reviews


back to top