Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Joe's Reviews > East of Eden

East of Eden by John Steinbeck
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26876584
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: fiction-general, california

** spoiler alert ** East of Eden came into my life by virtue of a classics book club I belonged to seven years ago. Published in 1952, this is the best novel that group assigned. It remains my favorite novel. John Steinbeck's magnum opus tells the tale of two families in the Salinas Valley of California who at the turn of the 20th century, find their capacity for good opening the doors to prosperity, while their potential for evil threatens to hurtle some of them into darkness.

The novel is narrated by an author surrogate who is grandson to one Samuel Hamilton, an Irishman whose gifts for invention are weighted by his lack of business acumen. Samuel and his God fearing, indestructible wife Liza relocate their family from San Jose to the foothills east of King City in 1873. The only land Samuel can afford is useless for farming, but the family is fertile in love. They bear nine children, many of whom play small roles in the unfolding narrative.

Adam Trask's story begins in Connecticut. He's a kind hearted boy drilled into obedience by his father Cyrus, a hellraiser who returns from the Civil War with the clap. His first wife, Adam's mother, blames her social disease on her own sin and drowns herself, while Cyrus' second wife gives birth to Adam's half-brother Charles and ultimately succumbs to tuberculosis. Cyrus grossly inflates his war experience and as a result, gains prominence and fortune in Washington as a military adviser.

Charles is a manipulator who covets the love of his father. The boy is also given to a violence that disqualifies him from soldiering as far as his father is concerned. Cyrus' hopes fall onto Adam, who does not love his father and abhors military discipline. Charles attempts to buy his father's love by diligently saving to buy him a pocketknife. Cyrus never uses it, while a stray puppy that Adam carries home becomes the old man's loyal companion for life. Profoundly rejected, Charles beats and almost murders his brother.

Adam serves two tours in the Army, making every effort in the Indian Wars to not shoot an Indian. He rambles around the country, restless, until his father's death and a large inheritance reunite him with Charles. Sorely missed by his brother, now a miserly farmer, Adam co-exists on the farm with Charles for a time. He tries to sell his bachelor brother on coming with him to California, where the fields have no rocks and offer endless bounty to those willing to work hard.

If the story is already good, it gets even better.

Cathy Ames has been endowed with considerable physical gifts and charisma and no empathy for other human beings whatsoever. Having burned her parents up in a house fire, she's beaten to near death by her lover, a Boston pimp, and left to die when the Trasks find her. Adam nurses Cathy back to health and asks her to marry him. Penniless but plotting, she agrees. Charles recognizes in Cathy a devil even more manipulative than him. Adam ignores his brother's warning and head west with his bride.

In Salinas Valley, Adam Trask purchases fertile land, plans for the future and awaits the birth of his first child. Samuel Hamilton is hired to drill a well and is left unsettled by his encounter with Cathy. He delivers her twin boys and is bitten for his trouble. Cathy makes good on her promise to leave Adam and when he takes too long to get out of her way, she plugs him with a .44. The twins are raised by Adam's servant, a second generation Chinese named Lee, while Adam drifts through their lives until Samuel knocks sense into his despondent neighbor.

Cathy settles in Salinas, where she changes her name and rises to power in the criminal underworld as the madam of a whorehouse. Lee ultimately confides in Adam where Cathy can be found. After confronting his wife in her den of inequity, Adam elects to keep Cathy's sinister existence hidden from his boys, who Samuel and Lee have helped name Caleb (Cal) and Aaron (Aron). Seventeen years old when the Great War breaks out in 1917, Cal & Aron covet the acceptance of their father and their estranged mother, as good and evil duke it out in each of them.

The 1955 film version of East of Eden was directed by Elia Kazan and skimmed the source material, focusing on the Cain and Abel struggle between Cal and Aron. Paul Osborn's adaptation eliminated the Hamilton family history and left Adam and Cathy's lurid past to the imagination. James Dean starred as Cal Trask in the second of his three film roles. It's my favorite Dean performance because Steinbeck created a character in Cal with the richest past and the most to lose in the future.

Rich in history, psychology, sociology, criminology and folk wisdom, East of Eden is big (602 pages) but whenever Steinbeck threatens to become professorial and turn the book into a lecture, he slams the reader back into the life and death struggles of his characters with grandeur, urgency and wit. We remain in the hands of a master storyteller throughout. It's impossible to read this book and not come away with something about America, about farming, about family or about guilt.

This book has stayed within me and will continue to do so. Having a younger brother, I could relate to the competitiveness between Adam & Charles and Cal & Aron (my brother's name is Aaron) and the intense hurt you feel when you assume others are loved or given preferential treatment over you, which of course they are, but that love ebbs and flows, and if dwelled upon, can consume you. It's a masterful novel that achieves a perfection in its storytelling.
55 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read East of Eden.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 1, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
May 1, 2014 – Shelved
May 19, 2014 – Started Reading
May 19, 2014 –
page 38
6.31% "Liza had a finely developed sense of sin. Idleness was a sin, and card playing, which was a kind of idleness to her. She was suspicious of fun whether it involved dancing or singing or even laughter. She felt that people having a good time were wide open to the devil. And this was a shame, for Samuel was a laughing man, but I guess Samuel was wide open to the devil. His wife protected him whenever she could."
May 20, 2014 –
page 90
14.95% "There was a time when a girl like Cathy would have been called possessed by the devil. She would have been exorcised to cast out the evil spirit, and if after many trials that did not work, she would have been burned as a witch for the good of the community. The one thing that may not be forgiven a witch is her ability to distress people, to make them restless and uneasy and even envious."
May 22, 2014 –
page 147
24.42% ""You know what I think? I don't think I'm half as mean as you are under that nice skin. I think you're a devil.""
May 22, 2014 –
page 221
36.71% "The church and the whorehouse arrived in the Far West simultaneously. And each would have been horrified to think it was a different facet of the same thing. But surely they were both intended to accomplish the same thing: the singing, the devotion, the poetry of the churches took a man out of his bleakness for a time, and so did the brothels."
May 26, 2014 –
page 275
45.68% "Kate never hurried. If a barrier arose, she waited until it disappeared before continuing. She was capable of complete relaxation between the times for action. Also, she was mistress of a technique which is the basis of good wrestling--that of letting your opponent do the heavy work toward his own defeat, or of guiding his strength toward his weaknesses."
May 27, 2014 –
page 342
56.81% "I think perhaps Liza accepted the world as she accepted the Bible, with all its paradoxes and its reverses. She did not like death but she knew it existed, and when it came it did not surprise her. Samuel may have thought and played and philosophized about death, but he did not really believe in it. His world did not have death as a member. He, and all around him, were immortal."
May 28, 2014 –
page 413
68.6% "In uncertainty I am certain that underneath their topmost layers of frailty men want to be good and want to be loved. Indeed, most of their vices are attempted short cuts to love. When a man comes to die, no matters what his talents and influence and genius, if he dies unloved his life must be a failure to him and his dying a cold horror."
May 29, 2014 –
page 484
80.4% "Cal's discovery of this mother was more a verification than a new thing for him. For a long time he had known without details that the cloud was there. And his reaction was twofold. He had an almost pleasant sense of power in knowing, and he could evaluate actions and expressions, could interpret vague references, could even dip up and reorganize the past. But these did not compensate for the pain in his knowledge."
May 31, 2014 –
page 601
99.83% "Kate put her head down on the blotter between her crooked hands. She was cold and desolate, alone and desolate. Whatever she had done, she had been driven to do. She was different--she had something more than other people. She raised her head and made no move to wipe her steaming eyes. That was true. She was smarter and stronger than other people. She had something they lacked."
May 31, 2014 – Finished Reading
June 1, 2014 –
page 602
100.0% "When I said Cathy was a monster it seemed to me that it was so. Now I have bent close with a glass over the small print of her and reread the footnotes, I wonder if it was true. The trouble is that since I cannot know what she wanted, we will never know whether she got it. If rather than running toward something, she ran away from something, we can't know whether she escaped."
September 18, 2014 – Shelved as: fiction-general
June 27, 2021 – Shelved as: california

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Cher 'N Books This one is on my favorites shelf and that shelf is very sparse indeed. Enjoy!!


message 2: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe I agree you 100% here, Cher. Steinbeck is a master storyteller. I'm blown away by his ability to write about history and sociology in a deeply absorbing way at right before that stuff becomes a little too long in the tooth, he slams you back into the story with life or death circumstances for the characters. Cathy Ames is a sociopath for the ages. I haven't read any of Steinbeck's other work, but look forward to after I finish this one.


message 3: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Wonderful review, Joseph. :)


Caroline Glad you enjoyed this, Joe. I liked it too. Steinbeck is a favorite of mine. What others of his do you plan to read?


Licha Whew! I'm exhausted by this review...in a VERY good way. Thanks for summarizing the basic elements of this story. It helped me relive this wonderful book that I read so long ago when I had no business reading it (too young, but it was one I read by choice and made me feel like I was so mature by picking it--to my delight I loved it then). It reminds me how good Steinbeck is. Stories just don't get any better than this. You're making me want to read this again. Great, great review Joe.


message 6: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Carmen wrote: "Wonderful review, Joseph. :)"

Thank you, Carmen.

Caroline wrote: "Glad you enjoyed this, Joe. I liked it too. Steinbeck is a favorite of mine. What others of his do you plan to read?"

Cannery Row is next. I might read three or four of Steinbeck's short novels before going to The Grapes of Wrath. I also have Travels With Charley to finish.

Licha wrote: "Thanks for summarizing the basic elements of this story. It helped me relive this wonderful book that I read so long ago when I had no business reading it"

I had to summarize the plot so that in three or four years, I'll remember what I read! A 5-star rating will do nothing to jog my memory, I'm afraid. Thanks for hanging in there, Licha. I agree that a teen would not really appreciate this book. Steinbeck wrote it for his sons, but perhaps sons who've gone out into the world and with their parents getting old, might never learn where they came from. I certainly got more out of it as a 40-year-old. Highly recommended!


Licha What I've come to realize is that reviews are also based on individual personalities and individual needs. I appreciate what you do. I have to agree that sometimes I look at my reviews and don't quite remember why I made have made a particular comment. Keep doing what you are doing. When I said I was exhausted by your review I meant that as a compliment, (although it may not have sounded as one.)


Caroline Steinbeck wrote this for his sons? Very interesting! I didn't know that. I want to read the The Grapes of Wrath. I've only read this one you just read, Of Mice and Men, and The Pearl. The last two were 5-stars for me, easily. I hope TGoW also will be a 5-star or a 3-star, at least.


Steve Superbly done, Joe. That was an excellent summary, and a great reminder of how engrossing this book can be.


Dolors "ich in history, psychology, sociology, criminology and folk wisdom, East of Eden is big (602 pages) but whenever Steinbeck threatens to become professorial and turn the book into a lecture, he slams the reader back into the life and death struggles of his characters with grandeur, urgency and wit. We remain in the hands of a master storyteller throughout."

Nicely put, Joe. I couldn't agree more with your well expressed statement about this classic American epic. The way Steinbeck shifts from storyline to more digressive philosophy and history is impressive and that he manages to give a moving cohesion to it all is a feat that puts him where he deserves to be, at the top of the list of best American writers.


message 11: by Andi (new)

Andi I have been intimidated by this book for too long, your review is excellent and I may finally attempt this in earnest!


back to top