ŷ

Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > Great Expectations

Great Expectations by Charles Dickens
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3427339
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: victorian

”I saw that the bride within the bridal dress had withered like the dress, and like the flowers, and had no brightness left but the brightness of her sunken eyes. I saw that the dress had been put upon the rounded figure of a young woman, and that the figure upon which it now hung loose had shrunk to skin and bone.�


How do you do Miss Havisham? She makes many lists of the twenty greatest characters from Dicken’s novels.

I hadn’t ever met Miss Havisham officially, although I knew of her. I have heard of her circumstances, discussed her in English Literature classes, and even referenced her in a paper. She is a tragic figure tinged with true insanity; and yet, someone in complete control of her faculties when it comes to talking about HER money. She was jilted at the altar and like a figure from mythology she is suspended in time. She wears her tattered wedding dress every day and sits among the decaying ruins of her wedding feast.

We meet our hero Pip when in an act of charity born more of fear than goodwill he provides assistance to a self-liberated convict named Abel Magwitch. It was a rather imprudent thing to do similar to one of us picking up a hitchhiker in an orange jumpsuit just after passing a sign that says Hitchhikers in this area may be escaped inmates. Little does he know, but this act of kindness will have a long term impact on his life.


Pip and the Convict.

Pip is being raised by his sister, an unhappy woman who expresses her misery with harsh words and vigorous smacks. ”Tickler was a wax-ended piece of cane, worn smooth by collision with my tickled frame.� She also browbeats her burly blacksmith husband Joe into submission. Mr Pumblechook, Joe’s Uncle, is always praising the sister for doing her proper duty by Pip. "Boy, be forever grateful to all friends, but especially unto them which brought you up by hand!� In other words she didn’t spare the rod or the child. Mr. Pumblechook is one of those annoying people who is always trying to gain credit for anyone’s good fortune. He intimates that he was the puppet master pulling the strings that allowed that good fortune to find a proper home. Later when Pip finds himself elevated to gentleman’s status Pumblechook is quick to try and garner credit for brokering the deal.

Things become interesting for Pip when is asked to be a play companion of Miss Havisham’s adopted daughter Estella. The girl is being trained to be the architect of Miss Havisham’s revenge...on all men. She is the brutal combination of spoiled, beautiful, and heartless. She wants Pip to fall in love with her to provide a training ground for exactly how to keep a man in love with her and at the same time treat him with the proper amount of disdain.

As Pip becomes more ensnared in Estella’s beauty Miss Havisham is spurring him on.

"Love her, love her, love her! If she favors you, love her. If she wounds you, love her. If she tears your heart to pieces,� and as it gets older and stronger it will tear deeper,� love her, love her, love her!" Never had I seen such passionate.


Estella, the weapon of man’s destruction, walking with Pip.

Pip is fully aware of the dangers of falling in love with Estella, but it is almost impossible to control the heart when it begins to beat faster. ”Her contempt for me was so strong, that it became infectious, and I caught it.� His hopes, almost completely dashed that he will ever have a legitimate opportunity to woo Estella properly are buoyed by the knowledge of a benefactor willing to finance his rise to gentleman status. No chance suddenly becomes a slim chance.

Pip is not to know where these great expectations are coming from, but he assumes it is Miss Havisham as part of her demented plans for exacting revenge by using Estella to break his heart. He is willing to be the patsy for her plans because some part of him believes he can turn the tide of Estella’s heart if he can find one beating in her chest.

"You must know," said Estella, condescending to me as a brilliant and beautiful woman might, "that I have no heart,� if that has anything to do with my memory."

The book is of course filled with Dickensonian descriptions of the bleaker side of Victorian society.

”We entered this haven through a wicket-gate, and were disgorged by an introductory passage into a melancholy little square that looked to me like a flat burying-ground. I thought it had the most dismal trees in it, and the most dismal sparrows, and the most dismal cats, and the most dismal houses ( in number half a dozen or so), that I had ever seen.�

As I was reading the book it felt like the plot suddenly sped up from a leisurely world building pace that permeates most Dickens novels to the final laps of an Indy 500 race. I was not surprised to discover that Dickens had intended this novel to be twice as long, but due to contractual obligations with the serialization of the novel Dickens found himself in a quandary. He had a much larger story percolating in his head, but simply out of room to print it. Nothing drives a reader crazier than knowing that this larger concept was realized, but never committed to paper.


The rest of Great Expectations exists only in the lost dreams of Dickens.

Pip is a willing victim; and therefore, not a victim because he fully realized that Miss Havisham was barking mad, and that Estella had been brainwashed into being a sword of vengeance. He was willing to risk having his heart wrenched from his body and dashed into the sea for a chance that Estella would recognize that happiness could be obtained if she would only forsake her training.

Pip like most young men of means spent more than his stipend allowed and as debts mount he is more and more anxious to learn of his benefactor’s intentions. It will not be what he expects and provides a nice twist to the novel. There are blackguards, adventures, near death experiences, swindlers, agitations both real and imagined, and descriptions that make the reader savor the immersion in the black soot and blacker hearts of Victorian society. Better late than never, but I now have more than a nodding acquaintance with Miss Havisham, Pip, and the supporting cast. They will continue to live in my imagination for the rest of my life.

If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:
366 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Great Expectations.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
May 3, 2014 – Shelved
May 3, 2014 – Finished Reading
May 4, 2016 – Shelved as: victorian

Comments Showing 1-50 of 61 (61 new)


Lada Great expectation beautiful


Dawn Jeffrey- this is one of my up, Top All Time Favorites of Dickens!!!! I read this very young and this book continued as a book to push my life along its way!!! Yes, we all have such Great Expectations along the way that sometimes we do forget to appreciate and notice what is most important around us until we are older and not so inexperienced. This book taught me so very much about people. It was the beginning of my love affair with the books of Dickens because of his emotional and sentimental writing about the historical times and also the characters that would become timeless in any setting. Dawn


message 3: by Diane (new)

Diane Barnes I re-read this 3 years ago, after a first read as a high school Junior. To my surprise, I remembered some passages verbatim. I guess that's why it's called a classic. And yes, I was a nerd.


Garrett Cash Still one of my top five favorite books. Every word was more delicious than bacon.


Dawn Garrett- never thought about delicious as "bacon" !!! But that is a guy taste thing or well guess not , but I could say CHOCOLATE !!! Dawn


B the BookAddict ”We entered this haven through a wicket-gate, and were disgorged by an introductory passage into a melancholy little square that looked to me like a flat burying-ground. I thought it had the most dismal trees in it, and the most dismal sparrows, and the most dismal cats, and the most dismal houses ( in number half a dozen or so), that I had ever seen.�

I think the beauty of Dickens is that he will make even a reader with the most lazy imagination see the scenes he is setting. Great review!


message 7: by Alejandro (new) - added it

Alejandro I had great expectations of your review! ;) And gladly I can say that you didn't disappoint me! :)

Great review indeed!


Jeffrey Keeten Lada wrote: "Great expectation beautiful"

Yes indeed!


Jeffrey Keeten Dawn wrote: "Jeffrey- this is one of my up, Top All Time Favorites of Dickens!!!! I read this very young and this book continued as a book to push my life along its way!!! Yes, we all have such Great Expectatio..."

Sometimes only a Dicken's novel will do. I'm not sure how these things happen that I reach such a mature age before reading such an important book, but finally, at last, I've been formally introduced to Miss Havisham.


Jeffrey Keeten Diane wrote: "I re-read this 3 years ago, after a first read as a high school Junior. To my surprise, I remembered some passages verbatim. I guess that's why it's called a classic. And yes, I was a nerd."

I read David Copperfield forever ago. I bet I will have a similar experience. It does not surprise me you were a nerd Diane. Weren't we all!


Jeffrey Keeten Garrett wrote: "Still one of my top five favorite books. Every word was more delicious than bacon."

Bacon is food of THE GODS!


Jeffrey Keeten Bette BookAddict wrote: "”We entered this haven through a wicket-gate, and were disgorged by an introductory passage into a melancholy little square that looked to me like a flat burying-ground. I thought it had the most d..."

You know that is a really good point. He can inspire even the lazy of imagination what a wonderful tribute to a great writer. Thank you Bette!


Jeffrey Keeten Alejandro wrote: "I had great expectations of your review! ;) And gladly I can say that you didn't disappoint me! :)

Great review indeed!"


Thank you Alejandro! I didn't check to see how many reviews have been written of this book or I probably wouldn't have bothered writing one, but still whether there are 20, 20,000 or 20,000,000 reviews we all have a unique perspective that is worth sharing.


Jeffrey Keeten Elham wrote: "Great review for "Great Expectations"! Thank you Jeffrey!"

Thank you Elham! I always have to achieve some distance from one of my reviews before I can decide if it is any good, but your encouragement has given me hope that I didn't muck this one up. :-)


message 15: by Alejandro (new) - added it

Alejandro Jeffrey wrote: "Alejandro wrote: "I had great expectations of your review! ;) And gladly I can say that you didn't disappoint me! :)

Great review indeed!"

Thank you Alejandro! I didn't check to see how many revi..."


Oh, I never mind to check that to make my own review about any novel that I read. Not matter if it's a book been read by 20,000,000 people, only you will be able to make a review about the book from your own particular point of view.

No two people read the same book. Any review counts.


Jeffrey Keeten Alejandro wrote: "Jeffrey wrote: "Alejandro wrote: "I had great expectations of your review! ;) And gladly I can say that you didn't disappoint me! :)

Great review indeed!"

Thank you Alejandro! I didn't check to s..."


I just checked 8,404 pshaw barely a drop in the bucket. :-)


message 17: by Alejandro (new) - added it

Alejandro Jeffrey wrote: "Alejandro wrote: "Jeffrey wrote: "Alejandro wrote: "I had great expectations of your review! ;) And gladly I can say that you didn't disappoint me! :)

Great review indeed!"

Thank you Alejandro! I..."


Hahaha ;) See? There aren't many yet! ;) Hehehe


message 18: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl I tried not to read your review because I'm reading this one soon, Jeffrey. But I couldn't help it. Great review--I love how you write about the foreshadowing of the downfall of Pip's and Estella's relationship.


message 19: by Gary (new)

Gary  the Bookworm Jeffrey, I liked reading your review so much more than I liked reading the book. This was taught to me in 9th grade and I avoided Dickens for decades. It wasn't until last year, when I read Bleak House, that I regretted my decision. Perhaps I should revisit it because I do love the David Lean film.


Samadrita I read this a long time ago in my teens but a re-read is on the cards. Your review is a timely reminder that I need to hurry up with the re-read already.
Excellent analysis, Jeffrey.


Dolors Superbly nuanced analysis of the masculine and feminine psyches hidden behind the masks of these stellar characters, Jeffrey. I wonder what Freud would have to say about Mrs. Havisham's deranged need for vengeance, Estella's steely manipulation and Pip's self-deceptive nature. Absolutely spot-on visual stimulation for such a classic. Sensational review.


Jeffrey Keeten Cheryl wrote: "I tried not to read your review because I'm reading this one soon, Jeffrey. But I couldn't help it. Great review--I love how you write about the foreshadowing of the downfall of Pip's and Estella's..."

Thank you Cheryl! I don't think I revealed anything that will take away your enjoyment of first discovery.


Jeffrey Keeten Gary wrote: "Jeffrey, I liked reading your review so much more than I liked reading the book. This was taught to me in 9th grade and I avoided Dickens for decades. It wasn't until last year, when I read [book:B..."

I've got the David Lean film on my list to watch soon. I've avoided watched the many Great Expectations movies and mini-series because I've always intended to read the book. Although really I knew the plot very intimately without having read the book from discussions in college. I'm so glad you enjoyed the review. It is always hard reviewing such a well known classic.


Jeffrey Keeten Samadrita wrote: "I read this a long time ago in my teens but a re-read is on the cards. Your review is a timely reminder that I need to hurry up with the re-read already.
Excellent analysis, Jeffrey."


I think you will like it much better this go around Samadrita. I'm probably at about 4.5, but bumped to five. I bet your rating will come up a star at least. Thanks Samadrita!


Jeffrey Keeten Dolors wrote: "Superbly nuanced analysis of the masculine and feminine psyches hidden behind the masks of these stellar characters, Jeffrey. I wonder what Freud would have to say about Mrs. Havisham's deranged ne..."

I especially was pleased to find the sketch of Miss Havisham that I opened the review with. It catches the drama of her condition so well. Freud would have bundled Miss Havisham up and wrapped her in cellophane and propped her up in a corner of his office. If you ever decide to go mad Dolors, and I dearly hope you don't, do so majestically. You must provide the center piece character for some writer's novel. :-) Thank you as always. You are the Queen of elegant comments adding sparkle to any review thread.


message 26: by Gary (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gary The bastard sure writes good reviews, doesn't he? Damn him....lol..... I had Great Expectations for this book,and I wasn't disappointed...... See the PBS movie version with Gillian Anderson....it's great!



I have not seen the one with Helena Bonham Carter.


message 27: by Hanneke (new)

Hanneke Thanks for the great review, Jeffrey. I had already the intention of rereading it, but your review made that a definite and soon too!


Jeffrey Keeten Gary wrote: "The bastard sure writes good reviews, doesn't he? Damn him....lol..... I had Great Expectations for this book,and I wasn't disappointed...... See the PBS movie version with Gillian Anderson....it's..."

I always have X-FILES flashbacks whenever I see Gillian Anderson in anything. She'll always be Scully. :-)

I've always had an odd crush on Helena Bonham Carter part of my inherent weakness for crazy females. Maybe as Miss Havisham I can fully put behind me any thoughts of ravishing her.

Thanks Gary!


Jeffrey Keeten Hanneke wrote: "Thanks for the great review, Jeffrey. I had already the intention of rereading it, but your review made that a definite and soon too!"

Thanks Hanneke! It actually reads very fast. Not much meandering in this one. You can reacquaint yourself with Miss Havisham and shudder at the damage a warped mind can do.


message 30: by Hanneke (last edited May 08, 2014 07:36AM) (new)

Hanneke Aaah, I am looking forward to it. I still think of her as an apparition with dust floating around her.


Jeff Well done, Jeffrey!

One thing about Miss Havisham that should have clued Pip in about her insanity would have been (for me) the smell. Between Miss Havisham (how long had she been wearing that dress? )and the petrified wedding cake. Ughh


Jeffrey Keeten Jeff wrote: "Well done, Jeffrey!

One thing about Miss Havisham that should have clued Pip in about her insanity would have been (for me) the smell. Between Miss Havisham (how long had she been wearing that ..."


Thanks Nine Feet of Jeff! Yeah the only hope is that everything except her has passed the smelly stage and turned to dust.


Renato Great review, Jeffrey! Loved the images you linked! :-)


Jeffrey Keeten Renato wrote: "Great review, Jeffrey! Loved the images you linked! :-)"

Thanks Renato!


Jeffrey Keeten Greg wrote: "Great review. Reading Great Expectations now and enjoying it much more than expected."

I was worried about reading it because I was so familiar with the story, but it was still so good. I hope you continue to like it Greg. Thanks!


Nicole Great expectations he always been my favorite classic novel.😂


Jeffrey Keeten Nicole wrote: "Great expectations he always been my favorite classic novel.😂"

Awesome!


message 38: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey He had a much larger story percolating in his head, but simply out of room to print it. Nothing drives a reader crazier than knowing that this larger concept was realized, but never committed to paper. The rest of Great Expectations exists only in the lost dreams of Dickens

No way! You know, before I thought that writers had it way better than scenarists of TV shows, because the latter they need to make changes constantly, because the actors decide to give up all the time. But I thought that a writer of books could let his/her imagination run wild, do whatever he/she wants, acts completely according to his/her heart’s desire. It’s so unfortunate and frustrating when this happens! It reminds me of Forever Amber. It was REALLY reduced. What we have today is only a fifth of its original size. I don’t like it at all, but that still doesn’t make what it was done it right. Writers should not be limited this way. I wonder for the reasons. If publishers think that something is too large for it to turn into a single novel, they can publish it as a series. This happens all the time. Look at all those massive, epic fantasy series. What’s the problem?

Jeffrey, this was an amazing review. It tempts me to give this book another try. I love you <3


Jeffrey Keeten Vessey wrote: "He had a much larger story percolating in his head, but simply out of room to print it. Nothing drives a reader crazier than knowing that this larger concept was realized, but never committed to pa..."

Well Dickens is equally at fault because he signed a contract for so many words. I would have thought as popular as he was that they would have loved to have had more from him, but alas not the case. He had to wrap it up. Thanks Vessey!


Jeffrey Keeten AniPoghosyan*ExtremeTalkerReaderCommenter* wrote: "I have read this, and your review is perfect for the book."

Thank you! Much appreciated!


message 41: by Lars (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lars Jerlach Excellent once again....!


Jeffrey Keeten Nikhil Dhume wrote: "nice"

Thanks Nikhil!


Jeffrey Keeten Lars wrote: "Excellent once again....!"

Aww shucks Lars! Thanks!


Blanca Ruiz I am reading Great Expectations right now, and came across your review. I loved it Thank you. I saw you have read many interesting books and written great reviews. I hope you don't mind if I follow you here in GR to get some book ideas.


Jeffrey Keeten Blanca wrote: "I am reading Great Expectations right now, and came across your review. I loved it Thank you. I saw you have read many interesting books and written great reviews. I hope you don't mind if I follow..."

I'm glad my review was helpful! Thanks Blanca! I just accepted your friend request.


Blanca Ruiz I am on chapter 50 of 59. I will be finishing the book in the next day or two. Charles Dickens sure created amazing, original, brilliant characters. I love Miss Havisham!


Jeffrey Keeten Blanca wrote: "I am on chapter 50 of 59. I will be finishing the book in the next day or two. Charles Dickens sure created amazing, original, brilliant characters. I love Miss Havisham!"

Absolutely! I'm so glad you are enjoying Dicken's genius.


James Brilliant review covering so much. One of my fave books.


Jeffrey Keeten Thanks James! Brilliant book!


Brian Thank you for this review! Wonderful. Reading your review makes my eyes wet. What a powerhouse of a writer. I've narrowed down the writers i want to read before I die. I'm working Tolkien now, then Kafka, then Dickens. Can't wait to read this in a couple years. Genres have no relevance to me, but the expression of special gifts to humanity in flesh, bone and blood.


« previous 1
back to top