ŷ

James Thane's Reviews > Killing Floor

Killing Floor by Lee Child
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3483907
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: crime-fiction, suspense
Read 3 times. Last read August 6, 2024.

This is the book that introduced Lee Child's popular character, Jack Reacher in 1997. Reacher is a former military cop who's been made redundant by the end of the cold war. After spending his entire life in the military (Reacher grew up in a military family), he's now completely on his own, footloose and fancy-free. After spending much of his life abroad, he's wandering about the country, getting to know the U.S. up close and personal. As will continue to be the case, Reacher travels light, with nothing more than the clothes on his back, paying cash, traveling by bus and staying off the grid.

On a whim, Reacher has a bus driver drop him off at the interchange for tiny Margrave, Georgia. Reacher has heard a story about an ancient Blues man who once spent time in the town, and decides to check it out. He walks fourteen miles into town, orders a cup of coffee in a diner, and is promptly arrested for murder.

Reacher knows that he hasn't killed anyone, at least not in Margrave and not for some time, so he's obviously mystified. He soon discovers that there are a lot of weird things going on in this tiny, pristine town where the townfolk, or at least a good number of them, are harboring some strange secrets. Reacher couldn't care less. He just wants to get clear of the murder charges, get back on the bus, and resume his wandering life. But he quickly develops a personal stake in the murder case, which is decidedly bad news for the evildoers.

Before long, the bodies are piling up left and right, and Reacher is contributing more than his fair share to the carnage. This is a cleverly-plotted book, although it does depend on a coincidence that's almost too huge to swallow. Still, it's a fun read that sets the template for the future books in the series. This is essentially "Shane" brought forward into the Twentieth (and now the Twenty-first) century. Jack Reacher is the mysterious stranger with something approaching mystical powers, who rides into a troubled town, albeit on a Greyhound rather than a horse. He cleans up the town, disposes of the bad guys, dallies briefly with a beautiful, sexy woman that he will have to abandon in the end, and then, once his job is done, he rides off into the sunset.

What's not to like? The formula has worked very well through sixteen books now, and Jack Reacher has become an international favorite. Those who have somehow missed him would do well to start with Killing Floor.
120 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Killing Floor.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 23, 2010 – Shelved
November 1, 2011 – Started Reading
November 3, 2011 – Shelved as: crime-fiction
November 3, 2011 – Shelved as: suspense
November 3, 2011 – Finished Reading
Started Reading
April 16, 2019 – Finished Reading
Started Reading
August 6, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Kemper This is a rare one that you and I totally disagree on.


James Thane Just reread your review which, I confess, I had forgotten. You had me laughing out loud again. I understand where you're coming from on this one, and I think you make some legitimate points. Reacher is clearly much more like a cartoon super-hero than someone like a Lucas Davenport. I think this is one of those concepts that you either buy into or you don't. In this case, I can suspend my disbelief and enjoy the read, but I can also easily understand that others might not.


message 3: by Randy (new)

Randy I read this one and enjoyed it, but never felt like trying another one. I don't know whether that says something about me or the book.


message 4: by Jerold (new)

Jerold Last I've read several of the "Reacher" books and find them entertaining. I might wish for a 3.5 star option for this series...more than like, but less than "like it a lot". Another valid comparison for this series is John D. MacDonald's Travis McGee series of half a century or so ago. A lot of social commentary by the hero, who tries to live off the grid, comic book aspects to the hero and especially the bad guys, but well plotted and a good read that makes you want to return for more.


James Thane I think that the McGee comparison is a good one, although Reacher has a much healthier, or maybe just more contemporary, view of women.


message 6: by Jerold (new)

Jerold Last My guess is contemporary. John D. MacDonald's background was growing up in upstate New York during the first part of the 20th century.


Jamie Good analogy with the old Westerns.


Marty Fried Great review, James. Makes me want to go back and read the few I never got to. I read a lot of them, but got a bit burned out after a while, but your review makes me think maybe I could read a couple more.


James Thane Marty wrote: "Great review, James. Makes me want to go back and read the few I never got to. I read a lot of them, but got a bit burned out after a while, but your review makes me think maybe I could read a coup..."

Thanks, Marty. I'm embarking on a project to reread the series in order. I think it will be fun.


debra Wonderful review, James. I read this soooooo long ago and still have some scenes in my "mind movies". ; ))


message 11: by Nan (new)

Nan Williams I always enjoy your reviews, but this one was even better than usual! I loved the comparison to Shane. I don't remember having read this book, but doubtless did since I think I've read all of the series. You've made me want to go back and re-read it! Thanks so much for such a delightful way to start my day!


Bernadette I can still see Margrave, GA, and Reacher prowling the streets there after reading this book several years ago. Child's ability to create details of a setting and have them contribute to the plot are uncanny. I agree that Reacher is a reincarnation of our western heros/outlaws/free spirits that are so much a part of the American psyche. Maybe that's why the series is so popular. Thanks for taking me back to Margrave. Great review.


James Thane debra wrote: "Wonderful review, James. I read this soooooo long ago and still have some scenes in my "mind movies". ; ))"

Thanks, Debra. I read it so long ago that I decided it was time to read it again. Enjoyed it at least as much this time around.


James Thane Nan wrote: "I always enjoy your reviews, but this one was even better than usual! I loved the comparison to Shane. I don't remember having read this book, but doubtless did since I think I've read all of the s..."

Thanks, Nan. Glad you liked it. "Shane" remains both my favorite western novel and movie, and when I began reading the Reacher series, that's the thought that immediately came to mind.


James Thane Bernadette wrote: "I can still see Margrave, GA, and Reacher prowling the streets there after reading this book several years ago. Child's ability to create details of a setting and have them contribute to the plot a..."

Thanks, Bernadette. And you're right--he does do a great job with the setting in this book.


message 16: by K (new) - added it

K Spot on, James. Shane is an apt metaphor� I love a good western, so small wonder that Reacher appeals as a guilty pleasure. Great review.


message 17: by Pat (new)

Pat Ha ha James for once I am ahead of you. I love the Reacher series and have already re-read the books. I might do it again when I'm an old crone. I hope you enjoy the experience.


Hobart nailed it


message 19: by James (last edited Apr 17, 2019 11:13PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

James Thane K wrote: "Spot on, James. Shane is an apt metaphor� I love a good western, so small wonder that Reacher appeals as a guilty pleasure. Great review."

Thanks, K.


James Thane Hobart wrote: "nailed it"

Thanks, Hobart.


James Thane Pat wrote: "Ha ha James for once I am ahead of you. I love the Reacher series and have already re-read the books. I might do it again when I'm an old crone. I hope you enjoy the experience."

I'm sure I will!


message 22: by Barbara (new)

Barbara I like Reacher precisely BECAUSE he's like a comic book superhero. I need someone in this world to give the bad buys what for (even if it's a fictional person). 😃🌺🍂


James Thane Barbara wrote: "I like Reacher precisely BECAUSE he's like a comic book superhero. I need someone in this world to give the bad buys what for (even if it's a fictional person). 😃🌺🍂"

Agreed!


message 24: by Rich (new) - rated it 4 stars

Rich I read this and found it interesting. One of the reasons was I read his foreword where he said reading John D. MacDonald's the Lonely Silver Rain--the final book in his Travis Mcgee series--inspired him to write what has become the Jack Reacher series.

I liked it and found many things interesting. But I've never read any other books in the series.


James Thane Rich wrote: "I read this and found it interesting. One of the reasons was I read his foreword where he said reading John D. MacDonald's the Lonely Silver Rain--the final book in his Travis Mcgee series--inspire..."

I've read and enjoyed all of them, Rich. Inevitably, there are some that are not as good as the others, but that's generally the way it is with a series this long.


message 26: by L (new) - rated it 4 stars

L Ok, I've read one book in the series, based on my sister's insistence. I did not like it. I did not like the character. But reading your review, and your explanation of Reacher, perhaps I should give this another try--at the beginning, rather than in the middle.


James Thane L wrote: "Ok, I've read one book in the series, based on my sister's insistence. I did not like it. I did not like the character. But reading your review, and your explanation of Reacher, perhaps I should gi..."

I think that the earlier books are better, but if you do give this one aa try, let me know what you think of it.


message 28: by L (new) - rated it 4 stars

L Oh, I will. And as often happens, reading your review cost me some $$. It's on my Kindle and I suspect it will be read before my next book-club book. I do love your reviews, as you know.


James Thane L wrote: "Oh, I will. And as often happens, reading your review cost me some $$. It's on my Kindle and I suspect it will be read before my next book-club book. I do love your reviews, as you know."

Thanks; I'm flattered!


message 30: by L (new) - rated it 4 stars

L You're welcome! I'm enjoying Killing Floor and liking Reacher. He's an interesting character. One of the comments on your review referred to him as a super-hero, and I'm getting that.


back to top