Joyzi's Reviews > Gone
Gone (Gone, #1)
by
by

Joyzi's review
bookshelves: e-book, ya-books, book-series, dystopia, disappointing-books, contemporary-fiction
Mar 25, 2010
bookshelves: e-book, ya-books, book-series, dystopia, disappointing-books, contemporary-fiction
Gone is like a mix of Lord of the Flies, Under the Dome, Animal Farm, Lost, Kid Nation, Heroes, X-Men and that Simpsons Movie...
This book I think is popular and also has quite number of fans but I haven't read it immediately because the book was very thick and I just find that I'm too lazy to follow a series like this. However I changed my mind and finally decided to read the first book.
At first my opinion about this book is, it is a very easy read. The sentences and the dialogues are kept simple. There are many times that I find it too simple but I think it made sense because the target of this book are young adults and I think even a nine year old can follow the words and sentences used in this one.
Also what I like about this book is that, it is really scary. There are moments that I just find myself having goosebumps and it was just really creepy.
Also I like that there are many characters in this book and my favorite character ironically is one of the bad guys which is Dianna. She has the power to know someone's power level by merely touching his or her hand. I jst find her really interesting.
What I don't like about this one is that it is you know something that is not that "original" because you can see that the idea of it was already seen from other books, TV series, movie etc.
I also don't like the fact that there are many times wherein I found the kids unrealistically acting like adults. These kids are 14 years old and below however they can use the fire hydrant, fire hose, the oxygen tank and the oxygen mask, some of them can drive and can measure a city's radius, hack a computer, use a machine gun etc. Those kind of things wherein you'll just say, "Blimey, smart kids."
I also find the answer to the mystery of the "poof" and how you can not "poof" cheesy.
And there's this moment wherein I just can't understand the logic why do these kids wanted to kill other kids. I find the logic of Battle Royale and Hunger Games somewhat realistic because they only kill other children because their lives are at stake and it is the Society that dictates to kill.
But here it's a matter of free will more similar to Lord of the Flies. It comes from their own savage mind and I just find myself having a hard time to buy that idea.
This book I think is popular and also has quite number of fans but I haven't read it immediately because the book was very thick and I just find that I'm too lazy to follow a series like this. However I changed my mind and finally decided to read the first book.
At first my opinion about this book is, it is a very easy read. The sentences and the dialogues are kept simple. There are many times that I find it too simple but I think it made sense because the target of this book are young adults and I think even a nine year old can follow the words and sentences used in this one.
Also what I like about this book is that, it is really scary. There are moments that I just find myself having goosebumps and it was just really creepy.
Also I like that there are many characters in this book and my favorite character ironically is one of the bad guys which is Dianna. She has the power to know someone's power level by merely touching his or her hand. I jst find her really interesting.
What I don't like about this one is that it is you know something that is not that "original" because you can see that the idea of it was already seen from other books, TV series, movie etc.
I also don't like the fact that there are many times wherein I found the kids unrealistically acting like adults. These kids are 14 years old and below however they can use the fire hydrant, fire hose, the oxygen tank and the oxygen mask, some of them can drive and can measure a city's radius, hack a computer, use a machine gun etc. Those kind of things wherein you'll just say, "Blimey, smart kids."
I also find the answer to the mystery of the "poof" and how you can not "poof" cheesy.
And there's this moment wherein I just can't understand the logic why do these kids wanted to kill other kids. I find the logic of Battle Royale and Hunger Games somewhat realistic because they only kill other children because their lives are at stake and it is the Society that dictates to kill.
But here it's a matter of free will more similar to Lord of the Flies. It comes from their own savage mind and I just find myself having a hard time to buy that idea.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Gone.
Sign In ?
Reading Progress
March 25, 2010
– Shelved
September 5, 2010
– Shelved as:
e-book
September 5, 2010
– Shelved as:
ya-books
February 4, 2011
–
Started Reading
February 4, 2011
– Shelved as:
book-series
April 6, 2011
– Shelved as:
dystopia
April 9, 2011
–
30.0%
"Yes this book is addicting, but a small part of me says that I should pretend that I'm dumb to enjoy this. Gosh the characters are unrealistically smart and skilled. They are all under 15 years of age right? Okay I'm dumb, dumb, dumb, gee just eat this stuff"
April 18, 2011
–
Finished Reading
April 19, 2011
– Shelved as:
disappointing-books
October 26, 2011
– Shelved as:
contemporary-fiction
Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Rollie
(new)
Feb 04, 2011 06:46AM

reply
|
flag
I hope you're enjoying this one. I did, but I found it really action-packed and gory, with a crazy action sci-fi plot, which isn't always for me.

![Diane ? [ Lestrange ]](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1628026870p1/3442094.jpg)
haha me too. :D


@Polina, the book does not provide answer yet, a goodreads friend told me it will be explained I think in the 4th book which is Plague, for now no answers

A part of where the grownups went is in the book 3 LIES.

I didn't really like this book ... Like you pointed out, it wasn't very original at all. The whole "isolated kids all start killing each other" thing has been done a million times before (but better). Also there were too many characters, and none of them had distinct enough personalities. Then there was the writing, which I couldn't stand. And I thought the plot wandered all over the place ... by the end I was like, "All right, I'm sick of this. Please just explain what's going on!" only to find that it's part of a series and that nothing was resolved in the end. *headdesk* I didn't even bother trying the following books. I mean, you have to wait 4 BOOKS for an explanation? Ugh! I don't think so!

@Kwesi "poof" means in the blink of an eye a person who just turned 15 years old will be gone, the characters have used the term "poof" for that (as I've said that the words used here are simple words) - Joyzi the poofy geek girl.


And I do agree that the writing was not that great and a lot of stuff was not explained like, where do the powers come from, why are the animals can think and speak all of a sudden, and why are the kids can use a gun all of a sudden or use an oxygen mask perhaps, did they learn that in school?


@Kwesi "poof" means in the blink of an eye a person who just turned 15 years old will be gone, the characters have used the term "poof" for that (as I've said that the words used here a..."
copy paste.

Rollie, I know.

@Kwesi tiningnan ko yung next books mukhang interesting naman, babasahin ko na din


