Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Lisa's Reviews > The Giver

The Giver by Lois Lowry
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: children, newbery-medal-and-honor

"What does 'release' mean in The Giver?", my daughter asked me this morning, when she had just started reading the novel on a strong recommendation from myself and both her older brothers.

"I can't tell you that, it will spoil the reading experience!" I answered. "What do you think of the book so far?"

"Well, the community has many rules."

"Is that good or bad, do you think?"

"I don't know, some rules are good, but some seem a bit too much. Like not being allowed to choose your profession."

We went on to talk about rules serving to protect human beings from chaos (like traffic rules, for example, or rules that protect the freedom and well-being of all people acting in a shared space), and rules serving to control thoughts and actions (like oppressive dogma).

Later, when I arrived at school, I changed an introductory lesson plan for my mentor class to include a discussion on the validity of certain rules (like school rules, for example), and the importance of distinguishing them from oppressive ones. Reading and talking about books with my children has a major effect on my professional choices.

In the evening, my daughter came back into my room, looking sad and bewildered. She had figured out what "release"stands for, and she was confused. This is her first encounter with dystopian fiction, and she was shocked by the power of euphemisms (without knowing the term itself). My middle son joined the discussion and reprimanded me for telling his sister what the word means.

"I figured it out myself!" she said, and he nodded approvingly.

"We spent several lessons discussing release in class", he added, and started talking about the ethical dilemma of the book: how much did the characters know of the sinister undercurrents of the community? Since they were deliberately held outside history and memory, and were taught limited facts, how much understanding could they possibly have gained?

"Jonas' dad was a nice man!" My kids insisted. And still he released the baby.

"Rosemary released herself, and I don't think she was a failure at all, she just couldn't bear all those feelings without anyone to share. It is horrible if you are alone!" My daughter is adamant.

I listened to my children, communicating their thoughts, reflecting on a society so scared of passionate emotions and painful memories that they have abolished them, and I felt grateful that we aren't there just yet. We still read books, talk about them, communicate our worries, reflect on the good and bad aspects of highly regulated societies, and we all see the different colours in the world. We may not like them, and we may be scared of both colours and sounds and emotions that we aren't familiar with, but we have not turned into complacent, numb non-thinkers like the people in the world of The Giver. We still care enough to have all those scary feelings: fear, anger, frustration, passionate love and longing.

Let us keep reading and talking and communicating with the next generation to prevent our world from becoming careless and resistant to human emotions. Let us practice the skill of giving and receiving knowledge of the world and help each other carry the pain it brings, so that joy is not lost along with sorrow.

The Giver is a perfect novel to introduce the great questions of our time to a young and curious audience!
124 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Giver.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 25, 2014 – Shelved
June 26, 2014 – Shelved as: children
June 26, 2014 – Shelved as: newbery-medal-and-honor
Started Reading
August 17, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Fer (new) - added it

Fer Prz Now I have to know


message 2: by Jaline (new)

Jaline Beautiful review, Lisa! I loved your discussions about this book with your children and the insights they derived for themselves. I also love that you utilized this as a tool for discussion with your mentor class. Our world needs more teachers like you!!


Candace I agree with Jaline. Discussing these books with the next generation is important. It expands both our worlds. I read this book in college. Awesome book! Great review, Lisa!


Lisa Fer wrote: "Now I have to know"

You'll have to read the book or between the lines of the review, Fer :-)


Lisa Jaline wrote: "Beautiful review, Lisa! I loved your discussions about this book with your children and the insights they derived for themselves. I also love that you utilized this as a tool for discussion with yo..."

Thank you, Jaline! I needed to read that comment now while having a meltdown over assessment schedules - to keep the priorities straight! It sounds easier than it actually is...


message 6: by Czarny (new)

Czarny Pies I read this book because my son was taking it in high school. A lot of the kids in his class really enjoyed it.


Lisa Candace wrote: "I agree with Jaline. Discussing these books with the next generation is important. It expands both our worlds. I read this book in college. Awesome book! Great review, Lisa!"

Thank you very much, Candace!


Lisa Czarny wrote: "I read this book because my son was taking it in high school. A lot of the kids in his class really enjoyed it."

I am happy to hear we share the habit of reading in conjunction with our kids' projects, Czarny! I find a special kind of pleasure in seeing the world with their eyes.


message 9: by Lucas (new) - added it

Lucas Sierra Great review. Love your relation with your children. Hope I can find the book soon, and give it a shoot.


message 10: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Lucas wrote: "Great review. Love your relation with your children. Hope I can find the book soon, and give it a shoot."

Thank you, Lucas! Hope you enjoy it as much as we did!


message 11: by Praveen (new) - added it

Praveen A beautiful enlightening conversation Lisa! The giver is in my list since long. I wish I reach to it fast now !


Marialyce My 100% favorite YA book. Not to be missed imho.


Fran Lisa...an excellent, thought provoking review.


message 14: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Praveen wrote: "A beautiful enlightening conversation Lisa! The giver is in my list since long. I wish I reach to it fast now !"

Thank you so much, Praveen!


message 15: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Marialyce wrote: "My 100% favorite YA book. Not to be missed imho."

I agree!


message 16: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Fran wrote: "Lisa...an excellent, thought provoking review."

Thank you, Fran!


message 17: by Frank (new)

Frank Thanks for sharing your experiences as an educator and parent.


message 18: by Frank (new)

Frank inspiring!


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Frank wrote: "inspiring!"

Thanks, Frank!


message 20: by Jaline (new)

Jaline Lisa wrote: "Thank you, Jaline! I needed to read that comment now while having a meltdown over assessment schedules - to keep the priorities straight! It sounds easier than it actually is..."

It doesn't sound easy at all - and my Mom went back to University and became a teacher when I was in junior high school. I remember her sitting for hours at her desk late into the evening planning, revising, planning some more. It's a hugely time-consuming job and I admire you so much for your dedication.


message 21: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Jaline wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Thank you, Jaline! I needed to read that comment now while having a meltdown over assessment schedules - to keep the priorities straight! It sounds easier than it actually is..."

It d..."


Thank you, Jaline! It is a strange calling for sure. But also a perfect way to stay a lifelong learner.


Cecily I love hearing about your bookish family!


message 23: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Cecily wrote: "I love hearing about your bookish family!"

Happy to hear that! I am desperately trying to keep up eith their class novels this year, thus moving a bit outside my comfort zone at times - which probably is a good thing.


message 24: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Like Cecily, I love hearing about your bookish family too, Lisa.
Thought-provoking and intelligent review!


message 25: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Kevin wrote: "Like Cecily, I love hearing about your bookish family too, Lisa.
Thought-provoking and intelligent review!"


Thank you very much, Kevin :-)


message 26: by Cecily (last edited Aug 30, 2017 12:13PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cecily Lisa wrote: "I am desperately trying to keep up eith their class novels this year, thus moving a bit outside my comfort zone..."

The older they get, the harder it will be to keep up, without sacrificing your own reading. But I'm sure you'll still compare thoughts and sometimes read the same books.


message 27: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Cecily wrote: "Lisa wrote: "I am desperately trying to keep up eith their class novels this year, thus moving a bit outside my comfort zone..."

The older they get, the harder it will be to keep up, without sacri..."


Yes, I agree! There's a balance to be found, and we don't necessarily have to read the same books to share.


message 28: by Cairo (new) - added it

Cairo Marques Your reviews always make me strongly interested in a book. Thank you!


back to top