ŷ

Lisa's Reviews > Children of the Alley

Children of the Alley by Naguib Mahfouz
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites, nobels

Oh, the banality of human beliefs!

Some years back, when I introduced Mahfouz to my eager son, who quickly made him one of his favourite authors, I told him that this parable on the development of human beliefs, societies and rituals is a quite simple, yet true tale. After he had read it, he agreed, and claimed other works by this versatile author his preferred reading.

Thinking back though, I am convinced that it is precisely the banality of the cyclical need for revolution, followed by the institution of new authorities and then a slow development of authoritarian attitudes in the new leadership that makes it a timeless reading experience.

There are no complicated theological or sociological mysteries to be found anywhere - simply because we are quite simpleminded as a species. We want to worship, and we want to enrich ourselves, we want to be feeling superior and we want to dictate our worldview to others. We want to be famous and revered and to leave a legacy. We want to get rid of rivals and overthrow whatever order is against our personal prosperity and success. That's all there is to religion or ideology.

The house of the king is empty, no matter what we choose to call him and how we choose to show our respect and allegiance.

The power lies in the elusive character of the leader. The less he (for it is a patriarch to be sure!) is defined, the more followers can identify with him. Beware of intellectually challenging statements, if you want to rule the world. Sadly, I think I have grown to believe this simple tale out of experience, as my intellectual idealism of earlier years turned out to be a quite naive illusion. We are not capable of anything more demanding than Mahfouz' parable. And we are willing to kill and steal and lie to protect our own specific brand of banality.

So I am giving it five stars for seeing where we have always been heading: from one silly delusion to the next!
117 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Children of the Alley.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
June 26, 2014 – Shelved
June 26, 2014 – Shelved as: favorites
June 26, 2014 – Shelved as: nobels

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dolors (new)

Dolors What an asset you gave your son by introducing him to Mahfouz's writing, Lisa. Midaq Alley still remains one of my favorite novels of all times and I must have read it at the same age as your son...


message 2: by Ray (new)

Ray I know of this author but have not read any books by him. Are you able to recommend one to start with?


message 3: by Julie (new)

Julie Thank you, Lisa, for introducing me an author whom I wouldn't have picked up in a month-of-Sundays: and yet you make this book sound so interesting!


Lisa Dolors wrote: "What an asset you gave your son by introducing him to Mahfouz's writing, Lisa. Midaq Alley still remains one of my favorite novels of all times and I must have read it at the same age a..."
I think I will reread MidaqAlley. I hardly remember it...


Lisa Ray wrote: "I know of this author but have not read any books by him. Are you able to recommend one to start with?"

My son loves the Cairo trilogy, which I haven't read yet. I read a couple of shorter novels, Midaq Alley, which Dolors recommends, and Miramar, which I liked a lot a long time ago. This one stayed most vividly in my mind because I couldn't figure out what on Earth made fundamentalists react so strongly against it.


message 6: by Kalliope (new)

Kalliope I have been sorting through my books recently, and have made piles, some to give away straight away and some to reread and then think about what to do with them.

In the second pile I have the Cairo trilogy. I read it just before visiting Egypt..

It is wonderful that your son liked it so much.

I have not read this parable, however... so oriental, to use fiction for parables... always something to learn.


Lisa Julie wrote: "Thank you, Lisa, for introducing me an author whom I wouldn't have picked up in a month-of-Sundays: and yet you make this book sound so interesting!"

That's our job as GR friends - to tempt each other to add to our book castles!


message 8: by Lyn (new)

Lyn Elliott Lisa, your son is fortunate indeed to have you lead him into reading and thinking like this. I confess I read the first of the Cairo trilogy and was so depressed by the repression of the mother that I haven’t read any Mahfouz since.


Marwan Hamed I'm Egyptian. I recommend Cairo trilogy and mirrors for you. I am happy cause you like his book.


message 10: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Kalliope wrote: "I have been sorting through my books recently, and have made piles, some to give away straight away and some to reread and then think about what to do with them.

In the second pile I have the Cair..."


I have the Cairo trilogy on the growing pile of books my kids recommend to me as a quid pro quo for all the books I force down their throats ;-)


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Lyn wrote: "Lisa, your son is fortunate indeed to have you lead him into reading and thinking like this. I confess I read the first of the Cairo trilogy and was so depressed by the repression of the mother tha..."

Then I am curious to see what I will make of it - after reading several other Mahfouz novels. I react strongly to repression of women as well at the moment, so I might wait for better times to get started.


message 12: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Marwan wrote: "I'm Egyptian. I recommend Cairo trilogy and mirrors for you. I am happy cause you like his book."

I am very pleased to hear you recommend them, Marwan! Thank you kindly!


message 13: by Eleanor (new)

Eleanor A wonderful review Lisa.


message 14: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Eleanor wrote: "A wonderful review Lisa."

Thank you, Eleanor!


message 15: by Fran (new)

Fran Lisa.. .yes...."we are willing to kill and steal and lie to protect our own specific brand of banality". You words say it all! Thank you for an excellent review!


message 16: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Fran wrote: "Lisa.. .yes...."we are willing to kill and steal and lie to protect our own specific brand of banality". You words say it all! Thank you for an excellent review!"

Thanks, Fran!


message 17: by Najma (new) - added it

Najma Bone hermoso


message 18: by Judi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Judi You are spot on. I just finished it...the 1981 translation...and your comments are so relevant no matter what era as I'm writing in August 2022! Also read the Cairo Trilogy years ago, loved it. Amazing man, amazing writer...


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Judi wrote: "You are spot on. I just finished it...the 1981 translation...and your comments are so relevant no matter what era as I'm writing in August 2022! Also read the Cairo Trilogy years ago, loved it. Ama..."

Thank you, Judi!


back to top