ŷ

Noel’s Reviews > Letters to Milena > Status Update

Noel
Noel is 92% done
“You say, Milena, that you don’t understand it. Try to understand it by calling it illness. It’s one of the many manifestations of illness which psychoanalysis believes it has uncovered. I don’t call it illness and I consider the therapeutic part of psychoanalysis to be a hopeless error. All these so-called illnesses, sad as they may appear, are matters of faith,�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 15, 2024 12:35PM
Letters to Milena

2 likes ·  flag

Noel’s Previous Updates

Noel
Noel is 98% done
“[L]iving authors have a living connection with their books. With their very existence they fight for or against them. The real independent life of the book begins only after the death of the writer, or, more correctly, some time after his death, for these eager men still go on fighting awhile for their book beyond their death. Then, however, it is alone and can rely only on the strength of its own heartbeat.�
Oct 15, 2024 06:33PM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 92% done
“[A]ll the time I’m trying to convey something unconveyable, to explain something inexplicable, to tell of something which I have in my bones and which can be experienced only in these bones. Fundamentally it’s perhaps nothing but that fear of which we have already talked so often, but fear extended to everything, fear of the greatest as of the smallest—�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 15, 2024 12:51PM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 91% done
“Yes, torturing is extremely important to me, I’m preoccupied with nothing but being tortured and torturing. � The stupidity inherent in this (realization of stupidity doesn’t help) I once expressed as follows: “The animal wrenches the whip from the master and whips itself so as to become master, and doesn’t realize…�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 15, 2024 12:15PM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 89% done
“I’ve spent all afternoon in the streets, wallowing in the Jew-baiting. “Prasivé plemeno”—“filthy rabble� I heard someone call the Jews the other day. Isn’t it the natural thing to leave the place where one is hated so much? (For this, Zionism or national feeling is not needed.) The heroism which consists of staying on in spite of it all is that of cockroaches…�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 15, 2024 11:55AM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 89% done
“I’m reading a Chinese book, “bubácká kniha�. I mention it because it’s concerned exclusively with death. A man lies on his death-bed and in the independence given him by the proximity of death, he says: “I’ve spent my life trying to fight lust and to put an end to it.� Then a pupil mocks his teacher who speaks of nothing but death:�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 15, 2024 11:42AM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 85% done
“Lonely imperfection has to be endured through every moment, imperfection shared by two does not have to be endured. Hasn’t one got eyes to tear them out and a heart for the same purpose? And yet it isn’t so bad, it’s all an exaggeration and a lie, everything is an exaggeration, only the longing is true, this cannot be exaggerated.�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 14, 2024 09:37PM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 78% done
“I’m dirty, Milena, infinitely dirty, which is why I make so much fuss about purity. No people sing with such pure voices as those who live in deepest hell; what we take for the song of angels is their song.�
Oct 14, 2024 07:35PM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 66% done
I can’t help wondering what Kafka’s feelings would be on Zionism today. I guess simply being able to understand the question would completely change his life�

“I won’t meddle in the fight between you and Max [Brod, always an active Zionist]. I stand aside, see each one’s point of view, and am safe. You are undoubtedly right in what you say, but now we are changing places.�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 13, 2024 08:45PM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 48% done
“Once as a very small boy I was given a Sechserl [a ten-Kreuzer piece during the Austro-Hungarian monarchy] and felt a great urge to hand it to an old beggar woman who sat between the Grosse and the Kleine Ring. But the sum seemed to me enormous, a sum which probably never before and been given to a beggar, so I was ashamed in front of the beggar woman to do something so unheard-of…�

ڰDzԳ’d
Oct 11, 2024 09:25PM
Letters to Milena


Noel
Noel is 45% done
“I’m tired, can’t think of anything and want only to lay my face in your lap, feel your hand on my head and remain like that through all eternity.

ճ󾱲Ա�
Oct 11, 2024 08:47PM
Letters to Milena


Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Noel “efforts of souls in distress to find moorings in some maternal soil; thus psychoanalysis also considers the origin of religions to be nothing but what (in its opinion) causes the “illnesses� of the individual. Nowadays, of course, we generally lack a sense of religious community; the sects are countless and confined to single individuals—though perhaps it only appears so to the eye coloured by the present.

Such moorings, however, which really take hold of solid ground, are after all not an isolated, interchangeable property of man, rather they are pre-existing in his nature and continue to form his nature (as well as his body) in this direction. And it’s here they hope to cure?

In my case one should imagine three circles, an innermost one A, then B, then C. The centre A explains to B why this man has to torture and to distrust himself, why he has to renounce (it’s no renunciation, that would be very difficult, it’s only a having-to-renounce), why he may not live. (Wasn’t Diogenes, for instance, severely ill in this sense? Who of us would not have been happy if at last Alexander’s eye had shone down on us? But Diogenes begged him, desperate, to let him have the sun—this terrible, Greek, interminably burning, mad-driving sun. That tub was full of ghosts.) To C, the acting person, nothing is any longer explained, it only takes orders from B. C acts under most severe pressure, in cold sweat of fear (is there any other sweat that breaks out on the forehead, cheek, temple, scalp—in short, all round the whole skull? This is what it’s like for C.) Thus C acts more from fear than from understanding; he trusts, he believes that A has explained everything to B and that B has understood and handed on everything correctly.�


back to top