Erica's Reviews > Tomboy: A Graphic Memoir
Tomboy: A Graphic Memoir
by
by

Erica's review
bookshelves: bffs, biographical, girlfriend-power, graphic-novel, growing-up, inside-vs-outside, judging-the-book-by-its-cover, life-in-school, love-and-romance, mothers-and-their-kids, non-fiction, women-and-girls, ya, sex-n-gender
Dec 02, 2014
bookshelves: bffs, biographical, girlfriend-power, graphic-novel, growing-up, inside-vs-outside, judging-the-book-by-its-cover, life-in-school, love-and-romance, mothers-and-their-kids, non-fiction, women-and-girls, ya, sex-n-gender
Because I recently read An Age of License: A Travelogue and In Real Life, Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ has been hinting that I would probably like Tomboy.
Fate conspired to test that theory when this book came across my desk today.
Because Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ doesn't quite understand the content in reviews, it didn't understand that maybe I wouldn't like Tomboy based upon what I said about those other two books.
In this case, I am happy that GR doesn't have artificial intelligence yet because it was right - I enjoyed this book.
I think this story will strike a chord with anyone who doesn't/didn't fit in during elementary through secondary school years (that's pretty much everyone, right? Because even those who did fit in didn't feel like they really fit in but more that they were just faking it for making it, right?)
I identified strongly with Ms. Prince's plight to establish herself as a girl without the frilly trappings of effeminance. I felt especially sad for her having to go through her early struggle in the middle of the '80's when the girl/boy separatism exploded as marketing groups realized they could make ten billion more dollars if they aimed clothing, toys, books, movies, cereal, etc at individual genders and not at kids, in general. I'm sure it was very difficult to stand in the face of consumerism and shout, "I will NOT wear your flower-patterned leggings with a matching dress!"
It was easier ten years earlier. There were girl things and boy things but there were a larger amount of just kid things. A girl could wear a red, green, and brown striped shirt with orange corduroys, just like a boy. A boy could play with a Raggedy Andy doll just like a girl. The '80's changed that landscape and the kids who had to navigate the extreme gender conformity are going to be jacked-up forever, I'm sure. I'm basing this opinion on nothing whatsoever and am basically making random, unsupported statements, just so you know.
So this story winds up being less about gender identity, despite what it says on the back cover as well as the Library of Congress subject heading, and more about inculturated gender norms in American society. I say this because while Liz wishes she were a boy, she wants the power of privilege, not necessarily the penis. She is a girl, she knows she's a girl, she's fine being a girl, she just doesn't want to have to adhere to the Rules of Girls, i.e. makeup, pink everything, cattiness, kittens, glitter, dresses, etc. She wants to be comfortable as a girl of her choosing and if she can't do that, then she wants to be a boy because they get more choices.
I thought she illustrated (literally and figuratively) this point well, realizing, with the help of those who have some wisdom, that it's not her gender she questions, but the insidious, pervasive beliefs surrounding the identity of her gender, if that makes sense.
I'm glad she eventually found her tribe. It's something we all strive to do else we end up as loners and while some of us thrive on our own, most of us need at least one other human with whom to share the burdens and joys of life.
Rock your jeans and t-shirts, Liz. You can be a kick-ass girl without being girly. You can also be girly and be kick-ass. There really are no rules, especially after you realize that the rules were all fake in the first place.
Fate conspired to test that theory when this book came across my desk today.
Because Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ doesn't quite understand the content in reviews, it didn't understand that maybe I wouldn't like Tomboy based upon what I said about those other two books.
In this case, I am happy that GR doesn't have artificial intelligence yet because it was right - I enjoyed this book.
I think this story will strike a chord with anyone who doesn't/didn't fit in during elementary through secondary school years (that's pretty much everyone, right? Because even those who did fit in didn't feel like they really fit in but more that they were just faking it for making it, right?)
I identified strongly with Ms. Prince's plight to establish herself as a girl without the frilly trappings of effeminance. I felt especially sad for her having to go through her early struggle in the middle of the '80's when the girl/boy separatism exploded as marketing groups realized they could make ten billion more dollars if they aimed clothing, toys, books, movies, cereal, etc at individual genders and not at kids, in general. I'm sure it was very difficult to stand in the face of consumerism and shout, "I will NOT wear your flower-patterned leggings with a matching dress!"
It was easier ten years earlier. There were girl things and boy things but there were a larger amount of just kid things. A girl could wear a red, green, and brown striped shirt with orange corduroys, just like a boy. A boy could play with a Raggedy Andy doll just like a girl. The '80's changed that landscape and the kids who had to navigate the extreme gender conformity are going to be jacked-up forever, I'm sure. I'm basing this opinion on nothing whatsoever and am basically making random, unsupported statements, just so you know.
So this story winds up being less about gender identity, despite what it says on the back cover as well as the Library of Congress subject heading, and more about inculturated gender norms in American society. I say this because while Liz wishes she were a boy, she wants the power of privilege, not necessarily the penis. She is a girl, she knows she's a girl, she's fine being a girl, she just doesn't want to have to adhere to the Rules of Girls, i.e. makeup, pink everything, cattiness, kittens, glitter, dresses, etc. She wants to be comfortable as a girl of her choosing and if she can't do that, then she wants to be a boy because they get more choices.
I thought she illustrated (literally and figuratively) this point well, realizing, with the help of those who have some wisdom, that it's not her gender she questions, but the insidious, pervasive beliefs surrounding the identity of her gender, if that makes sense.
I'm glad she eventually found her tribe. It's something we all strive to do else we end up as loners and while some of us thrive on our own, most of us need at least one other human with whom to share the burdens and joys of life.
Rock your jeans and t-shirts, Liz. You can be a kick-ass girl without being girly. You can also be girly and be kick-ass. There really are no rules, especially after you realize that the rules were all fake in the first place.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Tomboy.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 2, 2014
–
Started Reading
December 2, 2014
– Shelved
December 2, 2014
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Debbie "DJ"
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Dec 03, 2014 08:36AM

reply
|
flag

But don't worry! This one goes quickly; it has pictures.


That's what I keep getting told. Guess I should stop arguing about it ; )

Sadly my house is filled with penis. I don't even have a female animal : (


I know I wouldn't be able to teach anyone to do that because...well...I just cant. See?

Disadvantage of military school: not free, and requires several years of cleaning up after the kids while they're too young to attend.

