ŷ

Tadiana ✩Night Owl�'s Reviews > The Diamond Age: or, A Young Lady's Illustrated Primer

The Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
8734459
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: cyberpunk, science-fiction, victorian

3.5 stars. Review originally posted at .

Neal Stephenson’s The Diamond Age is set in a near future that is unrecognizable in some ways and disturbingly familiar in other ways. Nations have dissolved and people now tend to congregate in tribes or “phyles� based upon their culture, race, beliefs or skills. Nanotechnology has upended society, and even the poorest people have access to matter compilers that create clothing, food and other items from a feed of molecules. Still, the lack of education and opportunities for the underclass has created a wide division between them and a wealthy phyle like the Neo-Victorians, who have adopted the manners and society of the British Victorian age.

John Hackworth is a brilliant nanotechnologist who lives with and works for the neo-Victorians. He is approached by one of the leaders of the clan, Lord Finkle-McGraw, to secretly create an interactive smart book for Finkle-McGraw’s young granddaughter. Lord Finkle-McGraw fears that the neo-Victorian society is too hidebound and commissions Hackworth to use his skills to create a children’s book that will develop a more educated and inquiring mind. Hackworth develops this book, the “Young Lady’s Illustrated Primer,� but can’t resist the temptation to (illegally) create a copy of it for his own young daughter.

Unfortunately for Hackworth, Dr. X, the Chinese black market engineer whose compiler Hackworth used to create the copy of the Primer, wants a copy of the book for his own purposes as well. Hackworth is mugged on his way home with the Primer by a gang under Dr. X’s direction, but the young thug who grabs the book gives it to his 4-year-old sister Nell rather than to Dr. X. The education Nell gets from the interactive Primer ends up changing her life drastically. While Nell’s life is benefited immeasurably by the Primer, Hackworth runs into serious trouble, caught between the pressures exerted by both Lord Finkle-McGraw and Dr. X, both of whom are aware of his crime and both of whom are using Hackworth for their own interests and goals.

The first half of The Diamond Age was fascinating, alternating between Hackworth’s adventures and Nell’s, interspersed with stories told to Nell by the Primer that pull from Nell’s own life (her stuffed animals and toys play a major teaching role in the stories) and encourage her to think in new ways. Stephenson has created an intricate and marvelous future world, with both amazing achievements and alarming pitfalls. Stephenson’s writing doesn’t coddle the reader, but he writes so well that even when his future world is confusing, it’s still entrancing.

At about the halfway mark, the plot weakens as it digresses to some new, less appealing plot lines (the Drummers, who create a subconscious hive mind through sexual orgies) and abandons some interesting characters and plots, such as the humorous but ruthless Judge Fang and his assistants, and the mysterious, powerful CryptNet organization.

The ending of The Diamond Age was even weaker, as yet another group, the Chinese Fists of Righteous Harmony, takes center stage and reenacts the Boxer Rebellion, putting Nell and other characters in grave danger. Then the novel abruptly ends, answering a few questions but leaving most of the threads hanging and the fate of the characters unclear. It’s an inconclusive and disappointing ending.

Overall, despite its weaknesses, The Diamond Age is still a worthwhile read for those who appreciate brain-challenging science fiction.

5 stars for the first half. 2 to 2 1/2 stars for the second half. 3.5 stars overall.

Content notes: rape and near-rape. Some F-bombs and rough language. Brief but explicit description of an orgy.
100 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Diamond Age.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 12, 2015 – Shelved
January 12, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
June 5, 2015 – Started Reading
June 5, 2015 – Shelved as: cyberpunk
June 5, 2015 – Shelved as: science-fiction
June 5, 2015 –
page 9
1.98% "Most of the children had reached the age when they were no longer naturally endearing to anyone save their own parents; the size when their energy was more a menace than a wonder; and the level of intelligence when what would have been called innocence in a smaller child was infuriating rudeness.

--I'm in the mood for some brain-challenging SF. This looks like it will fit the bill."
June 18, 2015 –
page 95
20.88% "I can't remember the last time a SF book made my brain work so hard. Sometimes it's frustrating, but I'm loving it too."
July 3, 2015 –
page 146
32.09% "But Dr. X's whole affect seemed to deliver the message that if you were going to sign a Faustian bargain with an ancient and inscrutable Shanghainese organized-crime figure, you could hardly do better than the avuncular Dr. X, who was so generous that he would probably forget about it altogether, or perhaps just stow the favor away in a yellowed box in one of his warrens."
July 5, 2015 –
page 385
84.62%
July 5, 2015 – Finished Reading
July 13, 2015 – Shelved as: victorian

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Danielle (new) - added it

Danielle Just It's one of my favorite novels! I've got his newest (Seveneves) on my TBR list.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Danielle wrote: "It's one of my favorite novels! I've got his newest (Seveneves) on my TBR list."

I've temporarily put this one on hold while I try to quickly read a few books that are due back at the library before this one, but I've been impressed with what I've read so far.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ I'm back on track with this book now! And so far I'm totally loving it. Really excellent writing.


Melissa McShane I gave it five stars because I loved the beginning so much that the weak ending wasn't enough to overcome that for me. Still, Anathem is better. Having trouble with Seveneves.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Melissa wrote: "I gave it five stars because I loved the beginning so much that the weak ending wasn't enough to overcome that for me. Still, Anathem is better. Having trouble with Seveneves."

Yes, the first half was amazing. I can't figure out why an author who's obviously tremendously bright has such trouble with endings. I've read comments from other Stephenson fans that the issues with Diamond Age aren't isolated to this book.


Melissa McShane I don't know if I agree about his endings in general. Snow Crash, certainly, and Cryptonomicon doesn't end so much badly as peter out, but the Baroque Cycle is satisfying and Anathem is brilliant even if it does end in a place not suggested by the beginning. I don't recall Reamde ending badly either.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ I couldn't get into Snow Crash--the writing style was too chaotic--but I'm going to try Anathem sometime.


Andrea AKA Catsos Person This books blurb, your review and a couple of other reviews all seem as if this book is a unique idea, though not perfectly executed. I'm a little afraid of some scifi though.


Sparrow Knight I'm glad I'm not the only one disappointed in the plot switch & the dribble of an ending. I'm in total agreement w/the first part of the book being dynamite, an absolute great fun read, but once Nell leaves the Vicky phyle, things kinda go downhill. And the unsatisfying resolutions to the lives of Elizabeth & Fiona...just shoved off into the sidelines.

There's something going on w/the Drummers becoming a parallel neurology, creating a communal brain as it were, that I didn't quite get...wasn't interested enough to parse it out, I think. And the Fists? I guess Stephenson had to come up w/something big to create the conditions for Nell to become the leader of a new phyle. But felt really kludged in.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Sparrow Knight wrote: "I'm glad I'm not the only one disappointed in the plot switch & the dribble of an ending. I'm in total agreement w/the first part of the book being dynamite, an absolute great fun read, but once Ne..."

Yes, I totally agree with you. Stephenson completely changed direction at about the halfway point and it felt like he was trying to mush too many new (and weaker) ideas in. I wish he'd stuck with the characters and settings from the first part and developed them further.


carol. You nailed it. And don't forget (view spoiler) as content advisory. Unbelievable.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Carol. wrote: "You nailed it. And don't forget [spoilers removed] as content advisory. Unbelievable."

Good suggestion; I should have thought of that. Edited to add. With a few months' distance, I would now be harsher in my rating of the second half, and would drop my overall rating probably to 3.5 stars. It looks like I still liked this novel better than you did, though.


carol. I did like the beginning but a poor end leaves a bad taste. I thought your review was a great summary and well written, though!


Melissa McShane I don't know why this suddenly showed up in my feed again, but did reviews always have that line about who recommended the book at the top? And did I really recommend this to you? That surprises me.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ That's funny, I show it as being recommended to me by you too, but I don't remember that. Of course it was about 5 years ago so probably we've both forgotten. :) Time flies, doesn't it?


back to top