ŷ

Robin (Bridge Four)'s Reviews > Daughter of the Forest

Daughter of the Forest by Juliet Marillier
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
14105531
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 4-5-stars, chick-i-want-to-hang-out-with, book-boyfriend-material, buddy-read, chocolate-pms-day-reads, fantastic-fantasy, quit-crying-robin
Reading for the 2nd time. Most recently started July 30, 2022.

Sale Alert 3/15/19: Daily Deal on Amazon for

It has taken me forever to get to this review because I was just not sure how I could possibly pack everything I felt during this book into coherent words stuck together that would even possibly do it justice. I still don’t think that I will be able to manage it but I’ll try.

Daughter of the Forest (DoF) takes an old Irish legend/fairy tale and breathes new life into it. I was not familiar at all with the original version of this story so I cannot comment on how closely it follows but I will say this is not a Disney version of a fairytale. It is dark, painful and horrifying at times but it is also balanced with extreme love, devotion and hope. So even though it breaks your heart DoF will do its best to patch it up again.
heart
This hurts, I know. But you have been strong before, and you will be now. What is burned can be replaced; what is destroyed can be made again. In time you will win back your voice. In time—in time, you will find your path back home

This is not a watered down version of a legend. DoF follows Sorcha over years first chronicling the time she spent growing up with her brothers to the events that led to the curse. It laid the foundation very well for how close Sorcha was to all of her brothers and the strife between the Irish and the English. I really believed how much she loved her brothers and why she would undertake such a large task in an attempt to save them.

Sorcha is not the normal kick-butt heroine that you see in a lot of new fantasy. She has a solid heart, kindness in abundance and a quite determination that she uses to complete her task. She also has a type of subdued magic, not in the sense that she makes spells and such but more natural from a time when people cared about the forest and treated it and the spirits within it with reverence. A time when the realm of Fae was just a wrong turn away and you could easily be caught up in one of their schemes and games.

The magic of the story isn’t overpowering it feels natural and like it is meant to be there instead of forced. I really enjoyed that and thought it fit well with the task that was given to Sorcha to save her brothers from the curse that turned them into swans.
swans
╰⊰✿Everything I Loved✿⊱�

There is so much that is really wonderful in this story. It is told entirely from Sorcha’s PoV and sometimes that doesn’t work for me in fantasy but it made this story feel all the more personal. I connected with Sorcha right away and saw how she grew from an innocent giving child who knew nothing about the true dangers of the world into a resilient young woman who sacrificed much of her childhood to save the brothers that she was so close to.

When Sorcha started her task she was but a child still and even though she knew a lot about healing, she really didn’t understand how long it would take her to complete her task or any of the other obstacles that would get in the way of that. The Fae had a plan set into motion for her and although not all of the pieces clicked together right away you could see how each obstacle set in her path shifted and changed her into the woman she was destined to become.

For part of the story she is completely isolated and the story was a little slower for me through this section as I felt all the loneliness that Sorcha was feeling. I liked the story much more once she found a companion and protector in Red.
“Take this to light your way, daughter of the forest,� she said. “You told me you were tired of being strong. Maybe you will not need to be so strong, now.� She placed a tiny around candle, herb scented, in my open hand. She turned to the Briton. “You hurt her with your unthinking words,� she said, and her eyes had lost any warmth they had once had. “Make sure she is not hurt again.� And before he could draw breath, she turned and was gone.

Red made this story for me. He is EVERYTHING I love in a good hero. He is the epitome of a quixotic character. He is noble, kind and stoic. He is a man that is strong and can be counted on in any situation and I ADORE HIM. When he found Sorcha she had been beaten down and broken possibly even close to giving up, but Red is patient and so respectful to her even though she is technically one of the enemy. Red never sits too close, he learns to listen to Sorcha’s body, face and eyes to learn about her. He takes the time to really get to know her and even though she cannot speak he learns to hear her. The story of their time together is beautiful, frustrating, hopeful and probably every other emotion in-between.
Here I am telling tales, and half believing them. For I think sometimes that you, too, will go back one day, hear the call of the sea and slide away under the water as Toby’s mermaid did. Or maybe one night, as I watch outside your window, I will see an owl fly out and vanish into the forest; and when I look for you, all that will be left is one small feather on your pillow.

Sorcha has many other dealing with people and those never go as smooth but she did find a few friends besides Red in a land of enemies and they were all wonderful. There are also quite a few people to despise and hate along the way for their cruelty and bias against Sorcha. The fact that she isn’t allowed to speak at all while completing her task made me even more frustrated for her.

There was so much TENSION that built and built and I really wasn’t sure how things would end up. I had a lot of hopes but I was left with so many doubts and I could just see things ending tragically. This is not a traditional HEA story which actually made me love it more in some ways. There are some areas that had true happiness and others that didn’t get the resolution that you might expect. I really liked that not everything was tied up with a nice bow at the end. It made everything in this seem so much more real.

There are a few things that really worked in the story but that I didn’t love due to the nature of them. I will discuss those below. Please note they may be spoilerish in details.
╰⊰✿Warnings and Cautions✿⊱�

There will be a few spoilers (the general ones are not marked because they are part of the warning)

Like I mentioned before This is not a Disney Version of a Fairytale meaning there are some extremely graphic scenes of violence and abuse. I completely understand why these are in the story and I think the author did a fantastic job with them and how they affected the character. They aren’t thrown in just to build drama they really did serve the story and really showed Sorcha’s dedication to her task and everything she had to go through to complete it.

I’m really sensitive to two things in books. The first is Rape and the second is animal deaths. This story had both of those and I’m not going to lie they were rough�.really really rough. But they served a really large part of the story. Those events changed who Sorcha was and really showed how strongly she was willing to fight to complete the task and save her brothers. The way she interacted with people and trusted was forever changed and it actually added to the love story the way that Red was so patient with Sorcha and how well he tamped down his own emotions and wants in an effort to never scare her and gain her trust. DID I MENTION I LOVE ❤RED�

I’m so glad that it was never swept under the rug. I think it showed a real account of how someone rebuilds her life after an event like that. My one and really only complaint is that while the rape scene was really graphic the very much later scene involving sex was not quite fade to black but pretty close. I would have liked to see a little more of that transition and how it was dealt with by the couple.

The other thing that was a little over the top for me was the villain Richard. He is aweful and does some absolutely horrendous things to Sorcha, but it is more mental abuse than physical. Still it was really difficult at times to read those parts, as intended but non-the-less he is very graphic in some of his mental abuse as well.
╰⊰✿You Should Still Read This✿⊱�

Even though there are some rough patches this is still a highly entertaining story that will tug at all your heart strings. I have thought about multiple sections of this story repeatedly over the last few weeks and have even gone back and reread some of my favorite sections. It is a truer story than most where not everything is handed to you, at the end there are still questions in my mind and I think about the characters and where their paths led them.

If you, like me, are a fan of Melina Marchetta, like stories with complicated paths or can be happy with a story that isn’t all rainbows and sunshine then this is probably something that you will enjoy.


description
87 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Daughter of the Forest.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 22, 2015 – Shelved
February 22, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
February 25, 2015 – Started Reading
February 26, 2015 –
page 2
0.36% "

This has 2 things I HATE in it but will Trust Jessica that I will love the story. Please be good."
February 26, 2015 –
4.0% "“My feet will tread soft as a deer in the forest,”said Conor, frowning with concentration. “My mind will be clear as water from the sacred well. My heart will be strong as a great oak. My spirit will spread an eagle’s wings, and fly forth. This is the way of truth.�

I'm liking the slight magical feel of the book so far."
February 26, 2015 –
12.0% "“Sorcha,”she said, and her voice was like a terrible music. “You have a long journey before you. There will be no time for weeping.�

O.o a fae woman from the forest. Interesting. Is it bad I want her to be abducted by the fae"
February 27, 2015 –
20.0% " This woman is dangerous; I don’t know why she is here, but she will destroy our family if we let her.



What is Oonagh?"
February 27, 2015 –
37.0% "

Don't mind me I'll just be crying in a corner for the rest of the day."
February 28, 2015 –
42.0% "There is no truth on the island of yours. Rather, there are as many truths as there are stars in the sky; every on of them different.


HELLO RED"
March 1, 2015 –
56.0% "“I promise I will take you back, no matter what happens. I promise I will see you safe home when it’s time. As soon as I learn the truth about my brother, I will take you there. I never break my promises, Jenny. I know it’s hard for you to trust me. If ever I find the man who did this to you, who made you so frightened, I’ll kill him with my bare hands. But you can trust me.�

*swoony sigh* Red is amazing"
March 2, 2015 –
71.0% "Here I am telling tales, and half believing them. For I think sometimes that you, too, will go back one day, hear the call of the sea and slide away under the water as Toby’s mermaid did. Or maybe one night, as I watch outside your window, I will see an owl fly out and vanish into the forest; and when I look for you, all that will be left is one small feather on your pillow.�

Heart hurts"
March 4, 2015 –
94.0% "“Wait!”I said urgently, as if one such as she would heed a mortal’s plea. “Please wait! I need you to tell me—I need you to explain…�
“What, child?”She arched her brows as if she found me amusing.


Oh the Fae and there tricks!"
March 4, 2015 – Shelved as: 4-5-stars
March 4, 2015 – Shelved as: chick-i-want-to-hang-out-with
March 4, 2015 – Shelved as: book-boyfriend-material
March 4, 2015 – Shelved as: chocolate-pms-day-reads
March 4, 2015 – Shelved as: buddy-read
March 4, 2015 – Shelved as: fantastic-fantasy
March 4, 2015 – Shelved as: quit-crying-robin
March 4, 2015 – Finished Reading
July 30, 2022 – Started Reading

Comments Showing 1-35 of 35 (35 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

mich yaaay! is that 4 stars or 4.5? What made it not 5? (view spoiler) LOL, ok, don't mind me, I can wait for your full review :)


message 2: by Sandra (new) - added it

Sandra OMG. Is there any way to know if I'm going to resist all that suffering without any spoilers? What is the percentage of hurting in here or something!?


Robin (Bridge Four) mich wrote: "yaaay! is that 4 stars or 4.5? What made it not 5? [spoilers removed] LOL, ok, don't mind me, I can wait for your full review :)"

It will be a 4.5 round down to 4 I believe for just a few reasons (view spoiler)
BUT RED IS EVERYTHING I LOVE IN A HERO!!!


Robin (Bridge Four) Sandra wrote: "OMG. Is there any way to know if I'm going to resist all that suffering without any spoilers? What is the percentage of hurting in here or something!?"

No, there isn't but I will give a heads up to a few things in my full review. I will probably spoiler tag a couple not sure how to write it yet.


NoNameLoves2Read But my heart still hurts a little..

Just finished and now I know what you meant by that. That book was such a roller coaster for me. There was one point where I wanted to quit because it was nearly too much. (view spoiler)


Robin (Bridge Four) Stacy wrote: "But my heart still hurts a little..

Just finished and now I know what you meant by that. That book was such a roller coaster for me. There was one point where I wanted to quit because it was nea..."


Yes exactly, that got a bit brutal too.


mich Robin wrote: "It will be a 4.5 round down to 4 I believe for just ..."

(view spoiler)

Oh, and I love Red, too! :)


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ I kind of bailed on you with this one. Sorry!!


Robin (Bridge Four) Tadiana wrote: "I kind of bailed on you with this one. Sorry!!"

No worries. I'm aren't starting the next one until next Wednesday next week. If you have time to catch up great but no worries either way.

I hope you like it and get to finish it soon. :)


message 10: by Tadiana ✩Night Owl� (last edited Mar 12, 2015 11:04AM) (new) - added it

Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ It's not terribly likely that I'll catch up with you at this point, but if I don't I'll stand on the sidelines and cheer for you!

So true confessions time: I read about 150 pages of this book and then started skimming, I don't know why, I just did. So now I pretty much know everything that happened, including the bad stuff, and I've lost most of my motivation to read it. I AM SO BAD!!! *hangs head in deep shame*

ETA: Maybe I should just jump into book 2 with you next week. Lol!


Robin (Bridge Four) Lol...yeah the bad part was rough. I started to really love it once Red took her to England though.

Jump in it will be fun :)


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Robin wrote: "Lol...yeah the bad part was rough. I started to really love it once Red took her to England though.

Jump in it will be fun :)"


All right--let me know when you want to start. :)


Robin (Bridge Four) K as soon as I hear from Jessica we will be set. We were planning on this Wednesday if her house guests are gone.


Teryna90 Oh this book made me smile, cry, laugh, dream, sigh, fall in love, scream, cry, get pissed off, smile! :)


Robin (Bridge Four) Teryna90 wrote: "Oh this book made me smile, cry, laugh, dream, sigh, fall in love, scream, cry, get pissed off, smile! :)"

Yep multiple times and in various orders.


Teryna90 Robin wrote: "Teryna90 wrote: "Oh this book made me smile, cry, laugh, dream, sigh, fall in love, scream, cry, get pissed off, smile! :)"

Yep multiple times and in various orders."


<3 RED!!!


message 17: by Tamara (new) - added it

Tamara This review really got me excited for this book! Awesome review Robin :) Thanks for the warning about graphic scenes. I'm really sensitive to subjects like rape and abuse so I'm probably going to wait for a right time to read this book. Again, I really really appreciate the warning!


Robin (Bridge Four) Tamara wrote: "This review really got me excited for this book! Awesome review Robin :) Thanks for the warning about graphic scenes. I'm really sensitive to subjects like rape and abuse so I'm probably going to w..."

Me too which is why I was glad I was forwarned as well. It is one of those things that if not done right it ruins the book for me


message 19: by Lizet (new) - added it

Lizet Wonderful review Robin!

I didn't know anything about this series, but when I read "Recommended for: Fans of Melina Marchetta", you immediately caught my attention because I love that author.

After reading your review I'm really excited to start it because I like when books make you feel all kind of emotions. So, I'm going to stalk your updates and reviews of the next books :D

And, btw, thanks for accepting my friend request :)


Robin (Bridge Four) Lizet wrote: "Wonderful review Robin!

I didn't know anything about this series, but when I read "Recommended for: Fans of Melina Marchetta", you immediately caught my attention because I love that author.

Aft..."


Thanks for asking. This has more of a fairytale feel than a Marchetta book but it is an emotion tale all based on family so I think a lot of it is similar in the way the wrench every emotion out of you.


Mayim de Vries Robin what a glorious review this is! Were I the author, it would be printed and framed in my office so I can look at it when writer's block hits. I liked the book too and yet I am struggling to write a review and now I'm asking myself if I should really bother when something THAT beautiful has been already written.


Robin (Bridge Four) Mayim wrote: "Robin what a glorious review this is! Were I the author, it would be printed and framed in my office so I can look at it when writer's block hits. I liked the book too and yet I am struggling to wr..."

*blushes* thank you. This was one review I remember I had the hardest time writing because the book is so emotional and gripping that I want people to read it and I really wanted to do it justice.

Thanks for the kind words.


Mayim de Vries It's lovely, just lovely, the best I read of yours.


Helen 2.0 This book is so emotionally draining! After I read a certain scene I was on the verge of tears for the rest of the day, then when Red entered the stage I was so giddy!
You know the book is good when it elicits such big reactions :)


Robin (Bridge Four) Helen 2.0 wrote: "This book is so emotionally draining! After I read a certain scene I was on the verge of tears for the rest of the day, then when Red entered the stage I was so giddy!
You know the book is good whe..."


Huge emotions for me in this one for sure. I know exactly the scene you are talking about and I knew it was coming and still struggled so much.

Glad you totally loved it too.


Karishma That's a beautiful review. I skipped past the spoilers. I hope to read this when I'm a bit more prepared for an emotionally draining book.


Robin (Bridge Four) Karishma wrote: "That's a beautiful review. I skipped past the spoilers. I hope to read this when I'm a bit more prepared for an emotionally draining book."

It is a beautiful tale but yes you should be emotionally prepared. I'll hold your hand when you get to it.


Karishma Robin wrote: "Karishma wrote: "That's a beautiful review. I skipped past the spoilers. I hope to read this when I'm a bit more prepared for an emotionally draining book."

It is a beautiful tale but yes you shou..."


Thanks for that Robin. I will look to you for support :))


Juliette Cross One of my favorite books/series ever. And you're so right about how the author handled the horrific event Sorcha endures as a catalyst for the character's growth, etc. Also, I LOVE RED, TOO! Great review.


Karishma I am reading this. Be prepared to hold my hand!


Robin (Bridge Four) Karishma wrote: "I am reading this. Be prepared to hold my hand!"

I'm totally ready for hand holding.

Just wait until you meet Red


Karishma Can you follow the MacHalo thread or should I post my comments on the BB&B thread also?

Which would be more convenient for you?


Robin (Bridge Four) Karishma wrote: "Can you follow the MacHalo thread or should I post my comments on the BB&B thread also?

Which would be more convenient for you?"


I'm a part of MacHalo's. I'll pop to the thread over there.


Karishma Robin wrote: "Karishma wrote: "Can you follow the MacHalo thread or should I post my comments on the BB&B thread also?

Which would be more convenient for you?"

I'm a part of MacHalo's. I'll pop to the thread o..."


Great! And I know you are!


Robin (Bridge Four) Karishma wrote: "Robin wrote: "Karishma wrote: "Can you follow the MacHalo thread or should I post my comments on the BB&B thread also?

Which would be more convenient for you?"

I'm a part of MacHalo's. I'll pop t..."


I'm the worst member ever. I hardly ever participate.


back to top