ŷ

Melanie's Reviews > A Court of Mist and Fury

A Court of Mist and Fury by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3030788
's review

liked it
bookshelves: fae, fantasy, read-in-2016, retellings, romance, signed, new-adult, magic, read-in-2023, audiobook
Read 2 times. Last read July 24, 2023 to August 3, 2023.

1.) A Court of Thorns and Roses ★★★★

[2023 reread] ★★�
for years and years, i have said this was sjm’s best book and the only book of hers that i had given five stars to >.< !! i fully thought i would give this five stars again upon reread, but here we are with a three star rating and a lot of feelings. but i had a lot of fun with this, and i truly do think this book is doing and talking about a lot of important things and i never want to lessen that! but as far as enjoyment goes, i just didn’t have as good of a time rereading this, which shocked me extra, because i had such a good time rereading acotar last month!

i loved seeing the inner circle for the first time once again, and truly i love those characters so much. amren, morrigan, azriel, cassian, it was just great being back with them in velaris (iykyk - this was the biggest reason i wanted to reread this series), and i adored every scene with nesta and elain. but honestly, i think for me the side characters just all really outshined feyre and rhysand and their romance - i can’t believe i typed that, but it is true. sjm’s books are always too long, but jesus did this one feel extra long sometimes. ahhhhh, i still think the end of this book is five star worthy. i remember losing my mind finishing that last chapter seven years ago lol. and i know mor and nesta are five star worthy on their own! and i just really love exploring all the new courts and places in this world, too! i am obviously a little disappointed, but i am still very excited to reread acowar... hopefully soon!

trigger + content warnings: ptsd depictions, trauma, murder, death, blood, vomit, nightmares, captivity, panic attacks, slavery, talk of weight loss, heavy war themes and talk of war, abuse and domestic abuse, invasion of mind magically, mentions and talk of rape in past, depression depiction, suicidal thoughts, torture, heavy child abuse in past, drugging, less of parents in past

[2016 first read] ★★★★�




| | | | |
438 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Court of Mist and Fury.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 12, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
May 12, 2015 – Shelved
April 21, 2016 – Shelved as: fae
April 21, 2016 – Shelved as: fantasy
April 21, 2016 – Shelved as: read-in-2016
April 21, 2016 – Shelved as: retellings
May 2, 2016 – Started Reading
May 2, 2016 – Shelved as: romance
May 2, 2016 – Shelved as: signed
May 5, 2016 – Finished Reading
May 15, 2016 – Shelved as: new-adult
May 3, 2017 – Shelved as: magic
July 24, 2023 – Started Reading
July 24, 2023 – Shelved as: read-in-2023
July 29, 2023 – Shelved as: audiobook
August 3, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ Wonderful review! I agree with everything - Chapter 54 oh my <3 i hated book 1 (except for Rhys) so this one made me so freaking happy!


Melanie Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Wonderful review! I agree with everything - Chapter 54 oh my <3 i hated book 1 (except for Rhys) so this one made me so freaking happy!"

Thank you so very much! I went into this with such low hopes and expectations, and I was just blindsided by the happiness I felt when I saw it was actually going "my way", haha! I can't wait to read your review, Alienor! <3


Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ Melanie wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Wonderful review! I agree with everything - Chapter 54 oh my

Thank you so very much! I went into this with such low hopes and expectations..."


SAME! Everything I wanted and even more :D


Olya Wow fantastic review as always! I loved Rhysand from the start as well. This has given me hope!


Melanie Olya wrote: "Wow fantastic review as always! I loved Rhysand from the start as well. This has given me hope!"

Sammmmme, therefore, I think you will absolutely love this, Olya! YOU MUST WRITE TO ME AFTER CHAPTER 54 SO WE CAN FANGIRL TOGETHER <3333. It's been 24 hours and I'm STILL not over it! Ahhhhh! >^.^<


Olya Ok I'm making this book a top priority now and then I'll write so wait for me ;)


SueBee★bring me an alpha!★ Wonderful review Melanie! = DD


Marianne I'm guessing that Elain will be Snow White. According to Feyre, her skin is the color of ivory and "the fairest of them all" i.e. the sisters.) Guess that means she will have a run-in with one of the mortal bitch queens...


Melanie Marianne wrote: "I'm guessing that Elain will be Snow White. According to Feyre, her skin is the color of ivory and "the fairest of them all" i.e. the sisters.) Guess that means she will have a run-in with one of t..."

Oh my gosh, Marianne! You're a genius!


Melanie SueBee★bring me an alpha!� wrote: "Wonderful review Melanie! = DD"

Thank you, sweetheart <3 xx


Melanie Candy wrote: "Beautiful review ..... (¯`v´¯)�"

Thank you so much, Candy <3. xx


message 12: by Mary (new) - rated it 4 stars

Mary Agreed! I loved this book and was so happy because I wasn't too excited with ACOTAR. I just wonder how she'll expand what was supposed to be a trilogy into a series of 8 books...


Melanie Mary wrote: "Agreed! I loved this book and was so happy because I wasn't too excited with ACOTAR. I just wonder how she'll expand what was supposed to be a trilogy into a series of 8 books..."

I am very curious, too! I'll be honest, I was sad when I heard she is adding on to both series, but maybe she will surprise me! <3


Candace Fabulous review, Melanie! :)


Melanie Candace wrote: "Fabulous review, Melanie! :)"

Thank you, Candace! <3 xx


Melanie Stephanie wrote: "Wonderful review! Can't wait to read this series."

Thank you so much, Stephanie! Same, I am so excited! <3 xo


message 17: by Karen (new) - added it

Karen Fab review Melanie. I still don't know how I feel after this one. The ending left me reeling in emotions.


Melanie Karen wrote: "Fab review Melanie. I still don't know how I feel after this one. The ending left me reeling in emotions."

I feel you completely! So many emotions! ;___;


BAM doesn’t answer to her real name I think I need to give this series another try. Everyone loves it, it won the ŷ award, and I'm over here falling asleep. What's wrong with this picture???


Melanie BAM wrote: "I think I need to give this series another try. Everyone loves it, it won the ŷ award, and I'm over here falling asleep. What's wrong with this picture???"

Hahaha, I'm sorry, love! I do think the second book (this one) is much better than the first one! But hopefully you have an amazing read soon! Happy New Year! <3 xo


Stacy The first sentence of your review made me laugh!! :) It's so true, and, to me, was perhaps most apparent in Empire of Storms.


Melissa ♥ Dog/Wolf Lover ♥ Martin I love this book so much I could fall out in the floor and lay there like an idiot! :-D xo


message 23: by Natalie (new)

Natalie  ~ The Biblioholic Incredible review, Melanie! I haven't started this series yet, but I'm definitely intrigued!! xx


Alex is The Romance Fox Fab review Melanie :)


message 25: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace good review!!


Melanie Stacy wrote: "The first sentence of your review made me laugh!! :) It's so true, and, to me, was perhaps most apparent in Empire of Storms."

I swear, I end up writing that sentence in EVERY one of her books. I need to just accept it at this point, haha. <3 xo


Melanie Melissa � Dog Lover � wrote: "I love this book so much I could fall out in the floor and lay there like an idiot! :-D xo"

This is me. I honestly turn into a huge pile of goo just thinking about Rhy! <333 xo


Melanie Natalie wrote: "Incredible review, Melanie! I haven't started this series yet, but I'm definitely intrigued!! xx"

I think you'd REALLY like it, Natalie! But book two is WAY better than book one! <3 xo


Melanie Alex is The Romance Fox wrote: "Fab review Melanie :)"

Thank you, Alex! <3 xo


Melanie Diana wrote: "good review!!"

Thank you so much, Diana! <3 xo


message 31: by Coco.V (new)

Coco.V Terrific review, Melanie! You did a wonderful job to summarize such a long book. :) xo


Melanie Coco.V wrote: "Terrific review, Melanie! You did a wonderful job to summarize such a long book. :) xo"

Thank you so much, Coco! It means so very much to me! <3 xx


Sophia Triad Great review Melanie �


Darcy (Daydreamingofbookdragons) Just that last little bit 😂😂 not gonna lie, I love the idea of Rhys as Snow White.


ℓуηη_σƒνєℳűяιѕ I absolutely LOVE your review. I have been a fan of Rhysand since ACOTAR, and was so thrilled when Feyre moved on from pansy Rankin to badass Rhys. After reading your review I feel like rereading the books. When I finished ACOMAF the first time I almost threw the book at the wall I was so emotional after that ending!!! The ending was so good.


Melanie Sophia wrote: "Great review Melanie �"

Thank you so much, Sophia! 💖xo


Melanie Darcy wrote: "Just that last little bit 😂😂 not gonna lie, I love the idea of Rhys as Snow White."

Hahaha! Me too! We shall find out tomorrow! Ahhhh! 💖xx


Melanie ℓуη�, ℓσкιѕℓутнєя¢ℓα� wrote: "I absolutely LOVE your review. I have been a fan of Rhysand since ACOTAR, and was so thrilled when Feyre moved on from pansy Rankin to badass Rhys. After reading your review I feel like rereading t..."

Thank you so much, Lynn! Yeah, I'm not sure I'm emotionally prepared for starting ACOWAR tonight at midnight! 💖 xo


Darcy (Daydreamingofbookdragons) Well I'm lucky enough that it's already been released her so I am currently finding out!


Maria Your review is very close to how I experienced this novel. I really felt like the end of ACOTR foreshadowed Rhysand's further involvement, but I was blown away by the slow burn romance Feyre developed for him. So glad there was life and beauty in the Night Court-- not all darkness evil. And I was relieved that this particular fantasy trope was overturned.
Very strong side characters as you describe well. Thank you.


Melanie Darcy wrote: "Well I'm lucky enough that it's already been released her so I am currently finding out!"

Oh my gosh, how crazy is it that ACOFAS is coming out now, a year later? Hehe! 💖xx


Melanie Zenki the Hermit wrote: "CHAPTER 54 YES! I read it and reread it and reread it and cried over and over again. It was so, so beautiful I am so glad Maas pulled it off!"

Ahhh, Yes, Zenki! I must reread chapter 54 AT LEAST before ACOFAS next week! 💖xx


Melanie Maria wrote: "Your review is very close to how I experienced this novel. I really felt like the end of ACOTR foreshadowed Rhysand's further involvement, but I was blown away by the slow burn romance Feyre develo..."

Awh, Maria, thank YOU so much for this comment. Even though I'm terrible and just now seeing it! But it truly warmed my heart, and made me even more excited for ACOFAS next week! 💖xx


Nikki i love this book and i love this review!


message 45: by Kayla (new)

Kayla can this be read as a stand-alone ?


Penny My body is READY eeeee! <3333


back to top