Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Paul Bryant's Reviews > Spin

Spin by Robert Charles Wilson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
416390
's review

liked it
bookshelves: sf-novels-aaargh

(note - satirical spoiler alerts ahoy)

Robert Charles Wilson appears to be paid by the word - how else to account for such passages, and they are legion, as this :

The day I left Perihelion the support staff summoned me into one of the now seldom-used boardrooms for a farewell party, where I was given the kind of gifts appropriate to yet another departure from a dwindling workforce : a miniature cactus in a terracotta pot, a coffee mug with my name on it, a pewter tie pin in the shape of a caduceus.

Yeah right so the world is about to end and there are millenial cults trashing the place which the woman he loves has married into one of them and his friend the genius has a grim disease and there's this stuff about a man from Mars but let's suspend all that and get the pot, the mug and the tiepin down, don't want to let that stuff go by unrecorded. Yeah they're little human touches amongst the catastrophes but let me tell you, Robert Charles Wilson, the pot, the mug and the tiepin are boring and if I may say so, so is your protagonist, a guy you'd rather jab needles into your sinuses than share a railway journey with, Doctor Humourless Dullard should be his name, not Tyler Dupree, which sounds like a guy who made two blues records for Paramount in 1928, but anyway, I'm straying from the point - what was the point? Oh yeah, a 450 page Hugo Award winning novel about the usual stuff - The End Of Life As we Know It. For most of the 450 pages the world's going to end, and by page 350 as I read I was thinking "come on, end! End now! End! Put us out of our misery!" but the world kept not ending and by page 390 this became distressing. Maybe I'm a bad person. So maybe if there has to be an Apocalypse we'd all vote for the kind where you have time to buy each other terracotta tie pins. It's just that it's more exciting reading about the other kind.

Sings with guitar accompaniment :

"I could've bought you a tiepin, didn't mean to be unkind
But tiepins were the last thing on my mind"


Two and a half stars.

*

Two bad tempered thoughts - the final Big Idea in Spin can also be found in Clifford Simak's lovely 1959 novella called the Big Front Yard. That one won the Hugo in 1959. And - there's a quote on the front cover of Spin which must be the worst marketing quote ever. It says "The best science fiction novel of the year so far" - Rocky Mountain News. So far? How do we know whether that review was in the February issue and they were expecting much better stuff next month?
107 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Spin.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 24, 2008 – Shelved
June 29, 2010 – Started Reading
July 11, 2010 – Shelved as: sf-novels-aaargh
July 11, 2010 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Paquita Maria (new)

Paquita Maria Sanchez Oh, Paul! You just refuse to give up on those genre mass market paperbacks. It's kinda charming.


Paul Bryant Well, I started out as a science fiction fan, way back when. Every now and then I get the idea there's life in the old dog yet. But.... doesn't always work out.


message 3: by Charles (new) - added it

Charles spoiler alert.


Paul Bryant thanks, added note


message 5: by Tom (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tom Hmmmmmmm... You spent an awful lot of words to complain about an author using to many words to say an awful lot of nothing. Sorry, couldn't resist...

I understand what you are saying, especially about the rather bland personality of the protagonist, but I found it a small price to pay for a great story. A good, old-fashioned (not really), space opera.


message 6: by Paul (last edited Feb 15, 2012 04:29AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant Well Tom - you want to see some of my other reviews! Actually I have three other modern space operish novels I want to read and when I'm done with those I'll know if a) I like modern space opera, just not Spin; or b) I thought I'd like modern space opera but actually I don't (which would be disappointing).


Marina Laven it's called Literature.


Marick I agree with most of what you say. Many parts could've been condensed, that is for certain.

What truly drove me nuts about this book—the one thing which made me scream in my head for it to END already—was the main character, Tyler. Without him, I would've liked this book a lot more, I think.

You wrote this review a while ago... so I'll ask, but I won't really expect a reply: Did the dialogue bother you a bit? (Especially Tyler's: "What is it, Jase?" or "Why, Jase?" or "What do you mean, Jase?" Stop saying his damn name!)

Anyway, nice review. Cheers.


Paul Bryant oh yes, that bugged me too... I have about 10 SF novels on my (physical) to-read shelf and this kind of experience has kind of put me off. Which is unfair on all the other authors.


Marick That is very unfair!


Clouds Haha - I'm trying to pull my thoughts together for my own review and this you've ticked a lot of the same boxes :-)


Kirkus Please spoil me, I give up with this one


Manosthehandsoffate Right on brother! Heck I gave it two stars.


Brian Lebovitz Loved the ideas in this book, but you were right on about the writing. If all the characters on Earth were as described in that book, Armageddon could happen without a single emotional interaction. Great plot. Needed a different writer.


Peter Couldn't agree more.


message 16: by Robert (new)

Robert Wolske Hey!I know a novel you might like - It has a couple of characters in it called Dick and Jane. Oh, and their dog, Spot, too!


message 17: by Paul (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant Oh I read that one. But I couldn't follow the plot. Maybe you could explain it to me?


Melanie Mascarenhas couldnt agree with you more. So. much. Rambling.


message 19: by G (new) - rated it 3 stars

G R I totally agree with your review, loved the idea, hated the autors writing and world building.


Hiranmayi I absolutely agree! Tyler was the most boring character I have ever read. And so much drag! The book was getting nowhere!


Graham This wasn't especially wordy, imo. Very readable and not heavy at all. Blimey, I've read some very wordy volumes that are considered classics. It was an enjoyable read covering some great (if not completely original) ideas.


message 22: by Paul (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant If you set it next to Buddenbrooks, then, yeah, Thomas Mann is way wordier. But this is science fiction!


Kaitlyn Crozier Good review! I liked the sci-fi aspect of this book but this main character is such a drab!! The struggle to complete this thing was real because lame leading character with even more lame friend characters.


message 24: by Paul (new) - rated it 3 stars

Paul Bryant yes, very true....


back to top