ŷ

Mikee (ReadWithMikee)'s Reviews > A Court of Mist and Fury

A Court of Mist and Fury by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
44137919
's review

it was amazing

❝I was not a pet, not a doll, not an animal. I was a survivor, and I was strong. I would not be weak, or helpless again. I would not, could not be broken. Tamed.�


A Court of Thorns and Roses was one of the first books I started reading that got me into Fantasy and reviewing books. Way back when this series, the Throne of Glass series, and Sarah J. Maas, herself, wasn't hyped up like there's no tomorrow. It was the first book I've read by Sarah J. Maas and the reason I picked up the Throne of Glass series because I just needed more SJM in my life.

I was satisfied with the way things ended in ACOTAR so when I heard that some "changes" were going to be made in A Court of Mist and Fury, I was a little disappointed. I was NOT a fan of the changes that were made in the Throne of Glass series which was why I haven't picked up Queen of Shadows yet even though the book has been sitting on my shelf since the day it's been released. That's just my opinion. I know some SJM fans are going to start pouncing because they sincerely believe that Sarah could absolutely do no wrong. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE SARAH J. MAAS. She is an outstanding author. I love her writing, her characters, and the world that she brings to life. It was her books that changed my perspective on Young Adult Fantasy, but I honestly wouldn't say that I agree with every direction that SJM takes with her books.

I suppose the questions to ask now are: what was my stance at the end of ACOTAR and how did I perceive the changes that were made after reading ACOMAF?

Let me address the most important aspect of Sarah J. Maas's books, this series, and probably the thing that majority of readers care about the most: THE ROMANCE. Since A Court of Thorns and Roses was a loose retelling of Beauty and the Beast, my ship of course was none other than Tamlin and Feyre. I loved them as individuals and I loved them even more as a couple. AND I loved Rhysand. Just not as a love interest. I felt like Feyre wasn't worthy of the enigma that was Rhysand. But knowing the trend that SJM follows in all of her books, I figured a change in love interests was inevitable. After all, a book isn't written by Sarah J. Maas if there isn't some character butchering and changes in love interests involved.

But after reading A Court of Mist and Fury, I actually found myself accepting the transition in love interests much to my surprise. As much as I wanted Tamlin and Feyre to stay together, I knew it wasn't going to happen. These two people that survived weren't the same people that were Under the Mountain. They're relationship became such a nightmare and so unhealthy. It was two damaged lovers waiting for a disaster to happen.

In the beginning of this series, I understood where Tamlin was coming from and why he was so protective of Feyre. It was for Feyre's own good and nobody wants to lose the people they love and/or care about. But he took it way too far. He became too overbearing to the point where he was holding Feyre back. We all understood the trials and suffering that Feyre had to go through but I feel like people don't acknowledge what Tamlin had to go through as well while they were Under the Mountain. It was nothing close to what Feyre had to go through but Tamlin had to watch the person he loved suffer and die. He couldn't protect her the way he wanted and he didn't fight for her as he knew he very well could have. He was helpless and a coward. I think he realized this, which was why he tried to make up for it afterwards by protecting her now to the point where she's being suffocated. It still doesn't excuse what Tamlin does in this book but he's just another damaged character like Feyre and Rhysand. He's just hurting in different ways and expressing that pain in a way the he views would make up for his shortcomings in the first book. Tamlin loves Feyre, that much is evident. He just loves her too much, and that is the tragedy.

As for Rhysand, all I can say is that I loved him in ACOTAR and I loved him even more in A Court of Mist and Fury. I loved that we finally get a good understanding of Rhys as a character, the secrets he's kept, and the sacrifices he's made for the good of his people and his court. He was everything that Tamlin was not and twice the man and High Lord that Tamlin will ever be. I'm not completely sure if I'm 100% on board with Feyre and Rhysand yet but I love their chemistry, friendship, and the way they just understand and respect one another. I think I would've been head over heels in love with Feyre and Rhys instantly as a couple if ACOTAR never happened and I didn't get so attached to Feyre and Tamlin. But I no longer ship Tamlin/Feyre and I'm slowly, but surely, beginning to fall in love with Rhysand and Feyre little by little.

With romance aside, everything about A Court of Mist and Fury turned out every bit as great as I anticipated a year ago. Sarah J. Maas did not disappoint. I was preparing myself for the worst but instead I got the best. Sarah really knows how to capture her audience with her writing, worldbuilding, and characters that she has created. Of all the new things that were introduced in this book, the new characters of the Night Court were definitely my favorite. I thought the Spring Court was great in ACOTAR with characters like Lucien and Alis but the Night Court was at a whole new level with Cassian, Azriel, Morrigan, and Amren. BADASS is literally an understatement describing these new characters.

Besides Rhysand and Feyre, ACOMAF introduced so many new ships and I can't handle all the perfectness that everyone is. I now ship Mor and Azriel with all of my being, just putting it out there. XD And Cassian and Nesta. And Lucian and Elain. None for you Tamlin.

Overall, I was glad I waited to read A Court of Mist and Fury because as a result, I was able to dive into the story with an open mind about the changes that were going to be made in terms of romance and the direction that Sarah J. Maas was taking the series. Love her or hate her, Sarah can write one hell of a story and is such an outstanding author. Although there were some parts of the book that went by a little slow, I think A Court of Mist and Fury was even better than ACOTAR in more ways than one. Sometimes I find that sequels may suffer "middle book syndrome" but ACOMAF amplifies that momentum knowing that Sarah is preparing to hurtle anticipation and suffering our way for the conclusion of the A Court of Thorns and Roses trilogy.
741 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Court of Mist and Fury.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 26, 2015 – Shelved
July 26, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
May 30, 2016 – Started Reading
May 30, 2016 –
page 0
0.0% "ACOTAR was one of the first books I've read when I started reviewing. Before SJM & her books blew up. I was dying thinking of having to wait a whole year but come release day, I was hesitant because some "CHANGES" were obviously going to be made. But I've put this off as long as I could to try and read this book with no opinions and no expectations to avoid disappointing myself. Fingers crossed."
May 30, 2016 –
page 33
5.29% "I've seen people saying that Tamlin is overbearing and controlling but so far it seems to me that he's just doing it for Feyre's own good. Nobody wants to lose someone they love and/or care for. I understand where Feyre is coming from, of course, but recovering from Amarantha's curse goes beyond even her. She may have suffered and lost the most, but she is not the only one."
May 30, 2016 –
page 45
7.21% "Okay but why can't Rhysand take me to the Night Court. :'("
May 30, 2016 –
page 88
14.1% "I loved Tamlin and Feyre in ACOTAR, both as individuals and as a pair. I was never really on board with Rhys and Feyre romantically but I loved Rhys as a character. But it's sad to actually see Tamlin hold Feyre back like that. I, myself, enjoy reading about the Night Court and wishing I didn't have to go back to reading about the Spring Court so soon."
May 30, 2016 –
page 158
25.32% ""But the second male, the more classically beautiful of the two... Even the light shied from the elegant planes of his face. With good reason. Beautiful, but near-unreadable." So basically long story short: Sarah J. Maas only writes about attractive characters."
June 1, 2016 –
page 233
37.34% "This book is NOT YA lol. Not even borderline NA. This book has had enough sex and nudity to satisfy a Game of Thrones episode and I'm not even halfway through. XD"
June 1, 2016 –
page 285
45.67% "I SHIP MOR AND AZRIEL SO HARD."
June 5, 2016 –
page 469
75.16% ""I would have torn apart the world to get you back." SWOON. Can Rhys be any more perfect? <3"
June 5, 2016 –
page 529
84.78% "Everyone keeps talking about CHAPTER 55 and I guess I'm about to find out why. (;"
June 5, 2016 –
page 603
96.63% "MOR AND AZRIEL ARE MY BABIES. IF ANYTHING HAPPENS TO EITHER OF THEM... NOBODY TOUCH ME. :'("
June 5, 2016 –
page 605
96.96% "OMG SO MANY OF MY SHIPS and couples I didn't even know I shipped are happening at once. I'm jumping for joy but at the same time I'm like nooooo, not under these circumstances. XD"
June 5, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 85 (85 new)


message 1: by Chelsea (new) - added it

Chelsea SWATCHSEA Totally agree! Love triangles are overdone, authors should be more original and stop including the same tropes in each book


Katerina  Kondrenko I'm so agree with you! Though I do care who will Feyre choose) But she has too choose, dammit. I see no bad in Celaena/Aelin men 'cause she was with them in different times. You can love twice, thrice and more but not at the same fucking time. So if Feyre will choose Rhys (oh, please). she has to break up with Tam for the start.


message 3: by Lekeisha (new)

Lekeisha I just don't see a love triangle with Feyre, Tam, and Rhys. I think something else is going on. That thing with Rhys was a distraction in my opinion. If it is a love fest happening, I'm stopping at this one. I can't deal. LOL


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Katerina wrote: "I'm so agree with you! Though I do care who will Feyre choose) But she has too choose, dammit. I see no bad in Celaena/Aelin men 'cause she was with them in different times. You can love twice, thr..."

Aha yeah, I do care as well! But I don't really want Sarah J. Maas to follow the Throne of Glass route and give her like 3 love interests. This was supposed to be a Beauty and the Beast retelling and then all of a sudden Rhys is in the picture. I like Rhys's character but not as a love interest. But the way Sarah J. Maas is, I'm pretty sure Rhysand and Feyra will happen.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Lekeisha wrote: "I just don't see a love triangle with Feyre, Tam, and Rhys. I think something else is going on. That thing with Rhys was a distraction in my opinion. If it is a love fest happening, I'm stopping at..."

I hope it's just a distraction. That's actually a pretty clever theory! Although, I won't be surprised if Rhysand and Feyre get together. As much as I love Sarah J. Maas, I feel like her books rely too much on romance. It seems like she gets bored with a couple halfway writing through a book, so she ends up writing a new male character in to be a potential love interest. Everyone has also been saying that if Feyre and Rhysand happens, the whole first book would've been irrelevant. But then again, I'm also not surprised because that's exactly what happened with Throne of Glass lol.


message 6: by Katerina (last edited Oct 15, 2015 06:20AM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Katerina  Kondrenko Mikee wrote: "Katerina wrote: "I'm so agree with you! Though I do care who will Feyre choose) But she has too choose, dammit. I see no bad in Celaena/Aelin men 'cause she was with them in different times. You ca..."

I thought the same and the I got that every book will be dedicate to another tale. The first one was, indeed, BatB. But who know what she has on mind about her sequels) Feyre might end up with... I don't know Lucien?!)


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Yeah! I guess the next book is going to be Hades and Persephone? Regarding Feyre and Rhys. Aha hey, I won't be surprised at all if she ends up with Lucien haha!


Katerina  Kondrenko Mikee wrote: "Yeah! I guess the next book is going to be Hades and Persephone? Regarding Feyre and Rhys. Aha hey, I won't be surprised at all if she ends up with Lucien haha!"

Uh-huh, Hades and Persephone as people (and me) guessed. Anyway, it would be steamy) Just remember the book #1! Hotness itself.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Katerina wrote: Uh-huh, Hades and Pe..."

I'm really looking forward to this book! ACOTAR is the very first book I read from Sarah J. Maas and it led me to the Throne of Glass series. :)


message 10: by Isabela (new) - added it

Isabela Severino YES. Although it makes sense to make Rhys fall in love with her if we follow the story of the Beauty and the Beast. Gaston loves her in the story. But yeah, i do agree, i'm sick of these stories with one guy in every book.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Isabela wrote: "YES. Although it makes sense to make Rhys fall in love with her if we follow the story of the Beauty and the Beast. Gaston loves her in the story. But yeah, i do agree, i'm sick of these stories wi..."

I can totally see Rhys falling in love with her since I figured he was the Gaston of ACOTAR, but even then I hoped nothing serious happens between them. But obviously the whole Rhys and Feyre relationship is here to stay at least for now. As much as I ship Tamlin/Feyre, I'm not setting my hopes high when it comes to their relationship. The challenges in ACOTAR has me second guessing how close Sarah J. Maas is sticking to the whole Beauty and the Beast concept haha.


Katerina  Kondrenko I thought Gaston was that boy Feyre slept with in her village)


Rachelann Lmfao I'm so sick of triangles. This book is gonna drive me mad with Rys and Tam. Mainly because I myself don't know who I want her to end up with... My heart will break for Tam into a million pieces if she leaves him... But Rhys... *gushes*


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Katerina wrote: "I thought Gaston was that boy Feyre slept with in her village)"

The boy from their village is named Isaac if I remember correctly. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's been awhile since I read the book lol. Gaston is from the original BATB story, and he's the antagonist who wanted to marry Belle. But reading ACOTAR, I just kept picturing Rhysand as the Gaston of the story lol.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Rachelann wrote: "Lmfao I'm so sick of triangles. This book is gonna drive me mad with Rys and Tam. Mainly because I myself don't know who I want her to end up with... My heart will break for Tam into a million piec..."

Haha honestly, who knows who she ends up with. For all we now, Sarah is going to introduce a new male character and Feyre might end up with him aha! Tamlin is... TAMLIN lol. He's the Beast of the story. Of course we'll root for him since he's supposed to be the traditional love interest. But Rhysand, he's the perfect image of dark, mysterious, but secretly good despite what everyone else believes him to be. And we all love a good bad boy. (;


Katerina  Kondrenko Mikee wrote: "Katerina wrote: "I thought Gaston was that boy Feyre slept with in her village)"

The boy from their village is named Isaac if I remember correctly. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's been awhile si..."


I know who is who))) But I though Isaak is ACOTAR's Gaston and maybe he'll go to Faeland to try to kill Tam.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) I thought that too at first but I had a feeling that we probably won't hear anything about Isaac's character that much or even at all after Feyre saw him when she returned to the village. So I just associated Gaston with Rhys more.


Katerina  Kondrenko For me Rhys was like someone who came from the other tale (and he is like that)), and as I remember I was falling for him since the moment he saved Feyre. There was a few sentences with him but that was enough for my poor hear aching for dangerous men.


message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

I'm wishing she doesn't chose anybody and just goes on to live her life. She's immortal now, why not have some fun!


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Mila wrote: "I'm wishing she doesn't chose anybody and just goes on to live her life. She's immortal now, why not have some fun!"

Aha I agree! Plenty of time to learn how to read lmao. xD


Katerina  Kondrenko She can make her own court - A Court of Bumpkins and Illiterates.


message 22: by Cass (last edited Oct 19, 2015 06:10PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cass What are the chances that Feyre and Rhysand will just end up as bros? 1/1000000? *crosses fingers* idk, I feel like I'd like them as besties or something, like Rowaelin in HoF.


message 23: by Di (new)

Di I pray to everyone up there that this isn't like Thorne of Glass. I can not deal with shipping and loving one person of like 3 damn books and then BAM new character swoops in and ruins everything. Throne of Glass series ruins my life ;(

But it would be so pointless if she doesn't end up with Tamlin when she did all this for him. STOP CALLING TAMLIN BORING AND TOO NICE!!! That's not a bad thing! Tamlin baby is beautiful and enticing and freaking badass!! He sliced the chick in like two and he's hot! I like Rhys but not as a love interest...please Sarah. Don't go all Throne of Glass on us! I hate love triangles.


nonexistentdecimal I love your review! Its basically all my feelings to the point.


Laurie –Read Between The Skylines– Wisdom just spoke. Amen.


message 26: by Sophie (new) - added it

Sophie Y. Um, hey, read Divergent (unless you have already)


Baelie Bales But in real life you have multiple loves, and in TOG Heir of Fire, she's not in a relationship with anyone.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) @Baelie we do have multiple loves but if a person is indecisive about who they want to be with or emotionally invested in another person while being in a relationship I'm sure it's frustrating for all parties involved both in literature and in real life. Celaena may not be in a relationship in HoF but it's pretty obvious who the new love interest is -- Rowan. Throne of Glass was Dorian with hints of Chaol. Crown of Midnight was Chaol with hints of Dorian. Heir of Fire had hints of both Chaol and Dorian but Rowan was introduced and later becomes a love interest in QoS. And as for ACOTAR, Tamlin is the love interest, and I'm pretty sure this sequel is going to paint Rhys as a love interest considering how Feyre will be spending more time with Rhysand. And considering Sarah J. Maas's romantic patterns in her books, I won't be surprised if we get another new love interest in the next book after this. Either way, it's still pretty irritating when a person can't make up their mind both in books and in real life. It's rather selfish to mess around with other people's feelings just because you're unsure of yours don't you think?


message 29: by selene (new)

selene YES! I'm so tired of love triangles, I feel like they just takeaway from the main plot. I loved the Throne of Glass series in the beginning and was able to take the love interest switching (though it did hurt a bit), but after she got another love interest I was like NOPE im out. #pleasenolovetriangle


message 30: by Blythe (new)

Blythe Thank you!!!! Yes, please stop the love triangles everywhere!


message 31: by Abi.A (new) - added it

Abi.A If you haven't you should try Quinn Loftis' books because her characters stay together and actually grow with each other. I found this to be good because too many YA books just throw in a triangle/rectangle and it's like... so you've wasted my time...? Its also why I've put off reading Heir of Fire and Queen of Shadows (although I've never liked Chaol anyways so... hahaha)


Shan( Shans_Shelves) &#x1f49c; Yes this is exactly how I felt about the TOG series, I thought I was the only one because I seem to see constant love for the series everywhere I look. I honestly haven't read HOF or QOS yet because I read spoilers of the new love interest and thought nope not reading it. These love triangles are getting old and very annoying.


Mia Signorita I really hope SJM doesn't pull a Chaol on Tamlin. If his character is destroyed so Feyre and Rhys can happen, I will not be happy.


Petra Špirhanzlová it's funny, I like the fact that in ToG she has new love interest every book, it's making it interesting for me. Ussualy I get bored at the moment they end up together, I guess I just enjoy the "will they, wont they" tension :)


Lalla Totally agree with you! Love your "rant".


message 36: by Samantha (new) - added it

Samantha well, not everyone just dates one person and stays with them their entire lives, people change and if the person that they are with doesn't make them as happy anymore, they have every right to leave them and move on. I find the fact that Celaena and Feyre are moving on and growing as people more realistic than falling for one person as a teenager and staying the exact same way they were for the rest of their lives.


message 37: by Katie (new)

Katie Honestly I was fine with Celaena moving on because she changed and Chaol only loved the human aspect of her NOT her true character... Feyre on the other hand did not truly change herself inside (true she went a physcial change) but she still remains the same character. I would be very annoyed if she ended up with Rhys bc that would make this entire book void in my opinion. She underwent all those hardships and challenges for her love of Tamlin. It's like her love would be cheapened if she switched... sadly I feel like it's a strong possibility from my history with this author :/
For people whose like it's more realistic to move on: so being tortured and killing is not true love?? Because that serious commitment in my book and it's cliche if she end up with Rhys because he's her mate (I thought I'm reading a book about fey not werewolves?) please please don't go there ._.


message 38: by Angel (new) - added it

Angel Ok try and only have one bf/gf in your whole life. If you decide to break up at any point because of changes, by all means, feel free to get judged like this. Dude ppl change all the time. After every single little problem people change at least that tiny bit. And wtf look at what feyre has been through! What celaena has been through! If they don't change then I'm a fricking potato.


message 39: by e (new) - rated it 5 stars

e MY THOUGHTS EXACTLY. I WILL CRY IF SHE CHANGES IT


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) Ahhhh, okay lol. I don't like the fact that Celaena has a new love interest in every book because the way Sarah handles the romance in her books makes me feel like she recycles love interests when she gets tired of them. She pairs them with Celaena and then come the next book, she gets tired of them as a character and just tosses them aside to the point where it doesn't even seem like Celaena is "moving on" but as a way for Sarah to discard characters when she finds no more use of them. At this point, I'm not even sure I want to continue on with the ToG series because of the romance because it ruins the whole series for me considering how romance does play a huge part in the series.

As for Feyre, she risked her life for Tamlin not once, not twice, but numerous times because of her love for him. The whole ACOTAR book would literally be void or pointless if Rhys becomes a love interest regardless if you ship Feyre with Tamlin or Rhys.

You can keep pushing the fact that nobody stays with just one person their whole life and that's true. I mean that's blatantly quite obvious. But this is YA fantasy. You can try to push reality into this but no matter what, this book, this series, is fantasy and isn't in the same world as reality or go by the pace of reality. That's why books, in general, don't introduce more than two main love interests (hence the whole "love triangle" ordeal) over a span of a whole series. And that, in itself, is evident in almost all YA fantasy, contemporary, or any genre.

I can understand if a main character doesn't end up with the first guy she meets in a book, and I actually prefer it. I prefer that she doesn't end up with the first guy that we get introduced to. In my opinion, that's how "nobody stays with one person their whole life" is handled. But honestly, I just find that a new love interest in every book is just overkill. The Assassin's Blade we have Sam. Throne of Glass we have Dorian. Crown of Midnight we have Chaol. Heir of Fire is the introduction of Rowan and Queen of Shadows seals the deal. That's FOUR different love interests. Three, not including Sam.

I'm not even judging Celeana or Feyre so I don't really know why that point is even brought up. I'm just criticizing the romance in Sarah J. Maas' books as a whole. I love her books, don't get me wrong, but Sarah J. Maas is not all perfect when it comes to her books. And at this point, we can just agree to disagree because we all have different opinions especially when it comes to romance in books. I believe that books shouldn't have more than two potential love interests over a span of a whole series. Any more than that is overwhelming. That's just me. And my opinion on how many love interests a heroine at most should have in a book reflects nothing on how I view relationships in real life. Fiction and reality are two different things. And if it were up to me, Sarah's books would be much better without the romance. And that's coming from a person who actually enjoys romance in books.


Aeron Trahaearn Hmmm I get your point but trust me This book is better. atleast thats what I think. Without giving you any spoilers, I can promise that she sticks to JUST one person and shell stick to him the whole series.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) @Aeron I don't really care who Feyre ends up with. To be honest, I don't care who any of Sarah's main characters end up with anymore. :/ But I'm glad she actually sticks to one person. I'm still going to read this book of course since I loved ACOTAR. It's actually the first book I read by SJM. I even already have the book on my shelf. I'm just waiting to finish my current reads before picking it up! :)


Aeron Trahaearn :P actually this is the only book i ever pre ordered (ACOMAF) and it was worth it!


JAIME LOUISE Oh man, I've read like a quarter of it and Rhys is all the nice guy and I hate Tamlin. WHAT?! TOG all over again :/


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) @Jaime I feel like in order to give a new love interest, you have to butchered the first one so you can force everyone to jump ship. Kinda like what happened with Chaol.


Mikee (ReadWithMikee) happened with Chaol!


Kyla (ourbookworlds) ugh I totally get what you mean especially for TOG it's driving me crazy rn


message 48: by Caira (new)

Caira Definitely how I feel! But I wonder if the way the relationships played out in the Throne of Glass series was for realistic purposes. In reality, people fall in and out of love all the time. But it did hurt my heart that Chaol and Celaena...or Aelin didn't work out. But the reasoning made sense: he just couldn't accept her past or her heritage. But I hope its not like that in this story...


elise | mochi I swear if she starts passing around Feyre like she did with Celaena I'm going to be so mad. I didn't even finish the Throne of Glass series because Celaena pissed me off enough as it is.


message 50: by Mphozana (new)

Mphozana Girl. I feel you. Only major disappointment with Sarah J Maas unfortunately otherwise I would totally be a #1 fan. Her stories are really gripping but my extreme hate of love shapes always prevents me from that "click" with the characters. Good review/ rant btw.


« previous 1
back to top