Ɗẳ� 2.�'s Reviews > Brother
Brother
by
by

★☆☆☆☆�
This book was disappointing for a multitude of reasons. Starting with the ŷ writeup that initially piqued my interest: “Deep in the heart of Appalachia stands a crooked farmhouse . . .� Yada yada yada. Something about missing girls, deeply disturbing traditions, buried secrets or treasure or . . . what exactly? I wasn’t sure, but I could only imagine some kind of crazy hillbilly story chock-full of madness and mayhem! Considering the string of luck I’d had with Hick Lit stories, and the book’s high rating among my friends, picking it up seemed like a no-brainer.
However, the first thing I noticed when I finally cracked open the spine was that this book wasn’t really Hick Lit at all. It started with more of a Texas Chainsaw Massacre vibe before it sank into a deep lull. Strike one!
The teen angst scenes of a burgeoning love-at-first-sight crush between the story’s timid protagonist, Michael, and a girl at the record store were downright painful to read. 🤦♂� Strike two! But thankfully the story moved along and things began to pick up with flashbacks that exposed a troubled family history.
Starting with the fact that Michael’s brother, Rebel, was a raging asshole who bullied Michael and treated him like a slave. Along with Momma getting her kicks from verbally abusing and slapping around his sister, Misty. All the while, their dad, Wade, just sat there . . . oblivious. Never acknowledging any abuse or wrongdoing, never lifting a finger to put a stop to it. So I couldn’t help but wonder if he was adlebrained or just indifferent because he did absolutely nothing throughout the entire story.
But, you know what? There weren’t any chains on Michael or Misty. No locked doors or guns to their heads. I know he was scared, but he was no longer a little kid. In fact, he was easily the most physically imposing person in the entire house. What bothered me most was that he claimed to love his sister fiercely and pledged to do whatever it took to protect her, but time and time again he did nothing when she was beaten black and blue.
I just didn’t get it. Not only was Michael a coward and a liar, but he was also an idiot, so it was really hard to pull for the guy when I was constantly yelling at him to, “WAKE THE FUCK UP!� But honestly, I couldn’t have cared less about any of these lowlifes and quickly began to lose interest in the story altogether. Strike three!
I should have stopped there—thrown in the towel at 30%—but when I glanced back at all those glowing reviews, I couldn’t help but wonder what I was missing, so I stuck with it. And that’s when the unthinkable happened.
All along the flashbacks had been hinting at something truly depraved, and when Rebel began to target an older woman who didn’t fit their profile things started to click. Then when they nabbed her and she cried out a single word, all the puzzle pieces fell into place for me to solve the mystery not even halfway through the book. Ugh. 🤦♂�
The rest of the story played out like a slow-motion train wreck. I couldn’t look away. Wishin� and hopin� and thinkin� and prayin� for a miracle that, sadly, just wasn’t in the cards.
However, despite its shortcomings and annoyances the story did manage to end on a perfect note, so kudos for that.
This book was disappointing for a multitude of reasons. Starting with the ŷ writeup that initially piqued my interest: “Deep in the heart of Appalachia stands a crooked farmhouse . . .� Yada yada yada. Something about missing girls, deeply disturbing traditions, buried secrets or treasure or . . . what exactly? I wasn’t sure, but I could only imagine some kind of crazy hillbilly story chock-full of madness and mayhem! Considering the string of luck I’d had with Hick Lit stories, and the book’s high rating among my friends, picking it up seemed like a no-brainer.
However, the first thing I noticed when I finally cracked open the spine was that this book wasn’t really Hick Lit at all. It started with more of a Texas Chainsaw Massacre vibe before it sank into a deep lull. Strike one!
The teen angst scenes of a burgeoning love-at-first-sight crush between the story’s timid protagonist, Michael, and a girl at the record store were downright painful to read. 🤦♂� Strike two! But thankfully the story moved along and things began to pick up with flashbacks that exposed a troubled family history.
Starting with the fact that Michael’s brother, Rebel, was a raging asshole who bullied Michael and treated him like a slave. Along with Momma getting her kicks from verbally abusing and slapping around his sister, Misty. All the while, their dad, Wade, just sat there . . . oblivious. Never acknowledging any abuse or wrongdoing, never lifting a finger to put a stop to it. So I couldn’t help but wonder if he was adlebrained or just indifferent because he did absolutely nothing throughout the entire story.
But, you know what? There weren’t any chains on Michael or Misty. No locked doors or guns to their heads. I know he was scared, but he was no longer a little kid. In fact, he was easily the most physically imposing person in the entire house. What bothered me most was that he claimed to love his sister fiercely and pledged to do whatever it took to protect her, but time and time again he did nothing when she was beaten black and blue.
I just didn’t get it. Not only was Michael a coward and a liar, but he was also an idiot, so it was really hard to pull for the guy when I was constantly yelling at him to, “WAKE THE FUCK UP!� But honestly, I couldn’t have cared less about any of these lowlifes and quickly began to lose interest in the story altogether. Strike three!
I should have stopped there—thrown in the towel at 30%—but when I glanced back at all those glowing reviews, I couldn’t help but wonder what I was missing, so I stuck with it. And that’s when the unthinkable happened.
All along the flashbacks had been hinting at something truly depraved, and when Rebel began to target an older woman who didn’t fit their profile things started to click. Then when they nabbed her and she cried out a single word, all the puzzle pieces fell into place for me to solve the mystery not even halfway through the book. Ugh. 🤦♂�
The rest of the story played out like a slow-motion train wreck. I couldn’t look away. Wishin� and hopin� and thinkin� and prayin� for a miracle that, sadly, just wasn’t in the cards.
However, despite its shortcomings and annoyances the story did manage to end on a perfect note, so kudos for that.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Brother.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 2, 2015
– Shelved
November 2, 2015
– Shelved as:
to-read
December 3, 2015
–
Started Reading
December 5, 2015
–
50.0%
"I don't get all the 5 star love for this one, maybe the second half will change my mind."
December 6, 2015
–
75.0%
"I seriously may lose my shit, if this story goes where I think it's headed. This is just so wrong, it makes my blood boil!"
December 7, 2015
–
Finished Reading
December 23, 2015
– Shelved as:
horror
Comments Showing 1-50 of 68 (68 new)
message 1:
by
carol.
(new)
Dec 07, 2015 10:02AM

reply
|
flag


It happens. I couldn't stand "Station Eleven" and many others that most people loved. Don't let peer pressure influence your review.


That's awesome Dan! :D



I will definitely pass on this one.

I will definitely pass on this one."
It must be all this Christmas joy, filling my cold, dark heart, and preventing a proper rant.
You may not want to scratch it off of your list just yet since everyone, except for me and Pamela here, seemed to have loved it.



Yeah, this story was too aggravating and disgusting for me to enjoy. I try, but seem unable to avoid some of these one star reads.
*Waits patiently for Shelby, Kelly, and Sh3lly to tell me how I read this wrong.*

Just kidding - I'm actually on here to point out I knew the whosits and whatsits the first time they pulled a stakeout on the "old lady" - but somehow I still ate this shit UP.

Yeah, this story was too aggravating and disgusting for me to enj..."
Nah, your review was entertaining and I did want to punch whiny boy in the face about fifty times. But I ate up the shit too.

Just kidding - I'm actually on here to point out I knew the whosits and whatsits the first time they pulled a stakeout on the "old lady" - but somehow I still ate th..."
I was very suspicious, when they stakeout the old lady, but I wasn't 100% sure, until they actually snatched her up.

Just kidding - I'm actually on here to point out I knew the whosits and whatsits the first time they pulled a stakeout on the "old lady" - but somehow I still ate th..."
You can handle disgusting and gross MUCH better than I can- it has to be a pretty special story for me to want to skim over the nasty bits..lol

You may not want to click this, if you have any plans on reading the book, but it's only a minor spoiler. (view spoiler) .

In simplistic terms-If a writer's main goal is to gross a reader out- I look for another writer.

He was so annoying. I think I could of tolerated his behavior, and maybe even ranked this story a little higher, if he was say 12 or 13 years old. But at 19, I refused to cut him any slack.

Don't encourage him debra ; )



: ) : ) Aaaaaaaaaah my work here is done
*instigating, little bitch smiles snidely and walks on*


FYI, she absolutely nails the ending. Such an odd conundrum, to have an awful story end perfectly.

FYI, she absolutely nails the ending. Such an odd conundrum, to have an awful story end perfectly."
Methinks that is my inclination (to side with you). Although, I barely listened to any of it. My reaction was so similar to yours-"WTF is this sh*t- teenage Texas Chainsaw??" Don't think a great ending is worth it -if you were ready to dnf at 30%.Wish I could listen in FF. Possibly- you were so happy the awful story ended that the ending seemed great-only kidding ;-)) Thanks, Dan!!


True that . . .


True that . . .
"
Oh dear, methinks I have just soiled myself!
PS Chocolate chip cookies???? xo


However, the scene with Misty and Michael set to The Cure's A Forest stuck with me a long time. Or maybe it was just the song...

Those early scenes with Misty and Michael were good, but even that relationship eventually became perverted. Ugh




Oh wow, your typo-ridden snarky comment has given me much food for thought. Thank you for pointing out my wrongheaded opinion. I'll try to do better in the future. 🍻

Stacie wrote: "Totally agree!"
Thanks for agreeing with my poor assessment, Salam and Stacie. It's lonely here on the wrong side of the argument!