Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Lizzy's Reviews > Disgrace

Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
30575403
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: classics-literay-fiction, nobel-laureates, stars-5, read-2016, favorites-of-all-times

To begin with, let me make something clear: J.M. Coetzee's Disgrace left me intellectually fulfilled and severely shocked. Fulfilled at the simplicity and beauty of its narrative which resulted in a powerful drama; shocked at the impact it had on my innermost self. This is not a book for the faint-hearted. If you lack faith in your fortitude, do not even start, read something easier. But that would be a pity, for you would be deprived of an experience that will only enrich your understanding of the world. If you stay, Coetzee will grant you a masterpiece. And there have been some moments of genuine awe in my reading experiences, but I can without any trace of doubt testify that reading Coetzee is always one of them.

Disgrace follows David Lurie’s fall from grace, a professor of poetry and communications, that is unable to fit in a tormented post-apartheid South Africa. David clashes with the University’s politically correct environment as well as with the land dispute barbarism in the country’s interior, where his daughter lives.

With an immaculate prose, in which no word is wasted, the novel is a plunge into a society lacerated by poverty, criminality and a social conduct values deadlock. Disgrace is a work of art, rare nowadays: that that refuses simple explanations, which reinvents and enriches reality.
“But the truth, he knows, is otherwise. His pleasure in living has been snuffed out. Like a leaf on a stream, like a puffball on a breeze, he has begun to float towards his end. He sees it quite clearly, and it fills him with (the word will not go away) despair. The blood of life is leaving his body and despair is taking its place, despair that is like a gas, odourless, tasteless, without nourishment. You breathe it in, your limbs relax, you cease to care, even at the moment when the steel touches your throat.�
At 52, twice divorced, David is solitary, resigned, erudite and sarcastic. He does not care for the disinterest of his students show his poetry classes.
“He continues to teach because it provides him with a livelihood; also because it teaches him humility, brings it home to him who he is in the world. The irony does not escape him: that the one who comes to teach learns the keenest of lessons, while those who come to learn learn nothing.�
He contemplates writing an opera on Lord Byron, but always postpones the project. He believes to have “solved the problem of sex rather well�: on Thursdays afternoons he visits a prostitute that could be his daughter, pays what he owes her and has the right to the oasis of one and half hours of his continuous and dreary mundane existence.

(view spoiler)

In what is to come, he will face a brutal reality, made of vengeance, banditry, submission. Brutality against which occidental culture is simply worthless: “He speaks Italian, speaks French, but Italian and French are useless to him in Black Africa�.

J.M. Coetzee builds in Disgrace flesh and blood characters and, through them, weaves relationships between classes, between men and women, between parents and children, black and white, between a long exploration history and a present of explosive resentments.

Situated in nobody's land, where civilization and barbary mingle - a region well known by Brazilian readers, Coetzee slowly denudes realities and ultimately tells us that there are no just rewards, there are not even fairness.
�'How humiliating, ' he says finally. 'Such high hopes, and to end like this.'
'Yes, I agree, it is humiliating. But perhaps that is a good point to start from again. Perhaps that is what I must learn to accept. To start at ground level. With nothing. Not with nothing but... With nothing. No cards, no weapons, no property, no rights, no dignity.'
‘Like a dog.'
'Yes, like a dog.'"
____
302 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Disgrace.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 19, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
December 19, 2015 – Shelved
December 19, 2015 – Shelved as: classics-literay-fiction
Started Reading
June 18, 2016 – Shelved as: nobel-laureates
June 18, 2016 – Shelved as: stars-5
June 18, 2016 – Shelved as: read-2016
June 18, 2016 – Shelved as: favorites-of-all-times
June 18, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

withdrawn 'Disgrace' has just moved to the top of the 'To read' list. I shall have to go in search of it.

It is frightening to have the world suddenly slip, like an enormous earthquake in which the ground under one's feet, under one's home, under one's life is turned to liquid and everything starts to sink. I suppose this is something that we must all fear as we get older. We like to think that our values are strong, and more importantly, are the correct ones. Life has so much to throw our way. An excellent review Lizzy. Thanks.


message 2: by Lizzy (last edited Jan 26, 2017 04:15AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lizzy Indeed, RK-ique, to live is to be open to suffering and despair. And to have our values tested. Nobody better than Coetzee to make us see how dramatically that can happen. L.


message 3: by Katie (new) - added it

Katie Brilliant review, Lizzy. Really gets your enthusiasm across. Thanks.


Lizzy Glad you liked it, Katie!


message 5: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri Lovely, and very compelling review!


Lizzy Cheri wrote: "Lovely, and very compelling review!"

Thanks so much, Cheri!


message 7: by Roger (new)

Roger Brunyate I read this a long time ago, Lizzy, and reading your review I am impressed now all over again. I remember having a particular problem, though, that I don't know if I would have today. Not being at all tuned in to the cues in South Africa, I had trouble working out whether many of the characters were white or black. It shouldn't matter, but in that country at that time it does. R.


Lizzy Oh, I think it makes a difference, Roger. But since I read it some years back and merely revisited it superfically now, I wouldn't know either. But yours is a very important point. Thanks for your comment! L.


Kalliope Yes, a tough book to read, but excellently written. I think is the best of the (few) I have read by him.


message 10: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Excellent review, Lizzy!


message 11: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala I enjoyed revisiting this book through your experience of reading it, Lizzie - and I gained some new insights into Coetzee's intentions!


message 12: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita I will be honest, Lizzy. I didn't read your review after the first two paras. Because they were sufficient to know that you hold Coetzee in as much reference as I, and that I must come back after reading this book for myself. Until then, I take away those sparkling 5-stars in anticipation.


Lizzy Gaurav wrote: "Excellent review, Lizzy!"

Thanks a lot, Gaurav!


Lizzy Fionnuala wrote: "I enjoyed revisiting this book through your experience of reading it, Lizzie - and I gained some new insights into Coetzee's intentions!"

As you can easily see, I am a fan of Coetzee, Fionnuala! And Disgrace specially, despite its painful subject matter. I am glad you enjoyed my remarks. Thanks for your feedback.


Lizzy Seemita wrote: "I will be honest, Lizzy. I didn't read your review after the first two paras. Because they were sufficient to know that you hold Coetzee in as much reference as I, and that I must come back after r..."

I can understand you so well, Seemita. For I do the same thing, when reading reviews about books I plan to read. I thank you for liking my review just by the first two paras. I sincerely hope your anticipation is fully realized! L.


message 16: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue Excellent review Lizzy. I do need to read Coetzee and this book is on my list. Your words have certainly added impetus to my plan.


Lizzy I'm glad you appreciated it, Sue! Let me know when you read it. Enjoy! L.


message 18: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Hi Lizzy, your opening paragraph alone gives a foretaste of what to expect from this book. Such a compact, informative and impactful review! I would like to be brave enough to read it one day.


Lizzy Thanks for the nice words, Laysee! If you gather some courage, go ahead and enjoy.


Cheryl Beautiful review and alluring first paragraph, Lizzy. I was also moved by the grace of the writing structure in this novel.


Lizzy Thanks a lot, Cheryl! Really appreciate your feedback. L.


Sidharth Vardhan This is one of best books I have ever read and your review is the best one of this book I have read. Name 'Lurie' and 'Lucie' both have spellings that can be found in 'Lucifer'. Perhaps a hint to their fate!


Lizzy Sidharth wrote: "This is one of best books I have ever read and your review is the best one of this book I have read. Name 'Lurie' and 'Lucie' both have spellings that can be found in 'Lucifer'. Perhaps a hint to t..."

Thanks a lot for your kind words, Sidharth! I was probably in a good day, that occasionally happens. I like your idea that his name, so close to 'Lucifer', might be a hint to their fate. But would not the devil be able to escape it all, or even be the cause of all the disgrace? L.


message 24: by Trish (new)

Trish You "knocked it out of the park" with this one, Lizzy. Bravo!


Lizzy Lizzy wrote: "Sidharth wrote: "This is one of best books I have ever read and your review is the best one of this book I have read. Name 'Lurie' and 'Lucie' both have spellings that can be found in 'Lucifer'. Pe..."

I am so happy you liked it, Trish! A good incentive for me to keep writing my reviews. Thanks.


withdrawn I need to read this soon. Your review has given me a twinge of guilt at not having read Disgrace. One might say that I feel disgraced. (Sorry)


Lizzy RK-ique wrote: "I need to read this soon. Your review has given me a twinge of guilt at not having read Disgrace. One might say that I feel disgraced. (Sorry)"

So good that I could push you a little towards this great book, RK-ique! Thanks for the feedback. I liked your play with the word disgrace, very fitting. L.


Dolors Impacting closing para, Lizzy. You capture the brutality of this powerful novel very well. Fantastic review!


Pamela Mclaren I read this book years ago (can it really be 7?!) and it was my first experience with this author. I don't think I appreciated him as well as I should have. Thanks for your great review.


Lizzy Dolors wrote: "Impacting closing para, Lizzy. You capture the brutality of this powerful novel very well. Fantastic review!"

I am so glad you liked it, Dolors, for it was truly shocking and amazing to read. Thanks. L.


message 31: by Lizzy (last edited Nov 15, 2016 12:48PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lizzy Pamela wrote: "I read this book years ago (can it really be 7?!) and it was my first experience with this author. I don't think I appreciated him as well as I should have. Thanks for your great review."

You are very welcome, Pamela. I know how you feel, Disgrace is not an easy reading but so rewarding if you let yourself. For books like this, I think we need maturity. L.


Lizzy Elyse wrote: "This sounds good!"

It's great, Elyse. L.


Lizzy Elyse wrote: "Lizzy ---after I read your review --I went looking in every room of my house --I 'thought' I had a used copy..........
but no I don't---(I think the bookworms ate it) -- but I'll look for one next ..."


This book is indeed both shocking and amazing, Elyse, all in one...... I am certain you will find a copy, and you should read it!!! I will expect to see you post your own review soon. You have strong opinions about what you read and I like that. Thanks for your kind words, they nourish my new day... L.


Steve This is quite simply magnificent, Lizzy! You really got to the essence of this one, with your customary insight and flair for expression.


message 35: by Lizzy (last edited Feb 03, 2017 09:06AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lizzy Steve wrote: "This is quite simply magnificent, Lizzy! You really got to the essence of this one, with your customary insight and flair for expression."

Thanks so much for your kind words, Steve. It seems that the more a novel impacts me, the more it inspires me when I delve into writing my thoughts about it. I think that happened also with Crime and Punishment, The Lover, Atonement, To the Lighthouse, and a few others that I felt that I really was able to transmit my feelings into their respective reviews. So, when a friend likes them it's very rewarding. L.


Antoinette I love when I read someone's review and think wow she got it. That's exactly how I felt about this book. Thanks.


Lizzy Antoinette wrote: "I love when I read someone's review and think wow she got it. That's exactly how I felt about this book. Thanks."

You're welcome. Great that you liked Disgrace as I did, Antoinette. Sometimes I have the same feeling reading reviews about a book I loved, and indeed it's great. I'm very happy you felt this reading my thoughts. Thanks so much for your kind words, they are appreciated. L.


message 38: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Your review sums up my fulfilment and terror precisely. Excellent analysis, Lizzie!


message 39: by hamid (new)

hamid mazuji so, like i told j, i'm one third into it. should i just walk away then


Lizzy Lisa wrote: "Your review sums up my fulfilment and terror precisely. Excellent analysis, Lizzie!"

First, excuse me from taking so long to get back to you Lisa. I simply missed your comment. Anyway, I'm glad you enjoyed my thoughts on this terrific book. Your praise is specially appreciated in a moment in which I find myself struggling to find inspiration to write reviews. Thanks. L.


Jennifer Kloester What a great review of an extraordinary book. You nailed it exactly and prompted me to write my own review of Disgrace. It's an incredible book and I was in awe of Coetzee's use of language - it was as if he was writing and thinking at a whole different level. I'd never read anything like it. Thanks so much for this thoughtful, intelligent and perceptive review, I loved it.


Lizzy Jennifer wrote: "What a great review of an extraordinary book. You nailed it exactly and prompted me to write my own review of Disgrace. It's an incredible book and I was in awe of Coetzee's use of language - it wa..."

Jennifer, I'm glad you liked it. Disgrace touched me and I felt I had to write it. It's a pity I'm so busy now that I don't have enough time to write reviews anymore since I love doing it so much. But your comment inspires me. Thanks. L.


message 43: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review.


back to top