Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Kinga's Reviews > Freedom

Freedom by Jonathan Franzen
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
110812
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: pub-2010

UPDATED.

To keep in style of the book this review will be just a lot of rambling.

I mean, it was mostly a soap opera. And I just don’t do soap operas. I can just about manage about 10 minutes every 5th episode, but that’s about it. And Franzen submitted me to 570 bloody pages of a soap opera which I had to digest in a few sittings.
Like in all soap operas, everything ends well and love conquers all, of course some characters might have to be killed off along the way, but it seems like a small price to pay for a happy ending, non?

If it was well written, then maybe. But how can I take this sort of thing seriously:

"Patty said no, Walter insisted, she insisted no, he insisted yes. Then she realized he didn’t have a car and was offering to ride the bus with her, and she insisted no all over again, and he insisted yes"

Sorry, what is this? Is this the Great American Novel? Are you kidding me?

"She almost suggested to Walter that he had better kiss her first, if he was going to be asking her to live with him, but she was so offended that she didn’t feel like being kissed at that moment."

And if you are tired of this sugary girly revelations, you can get the more raw stuff when the perspective changes to Katz:

"His dick was saying yes to something now, and this something was certainly not the wideish ass of the retreating jogger. Had death, in fact, been his dick’s message in sending him to Washington? Had he simply misunderstood its prophecy?"

You get the idea.

And don’t even get me started on the fucked up chronology. It wasn’t done in eloquent, mysterious way, it was done in a blabbermouth with ADHD way. It is like my friend Maciek, who tells me a story and in the middle of it he remembers some other story that might or might not be related to the story he is telling me so he tells me that other story, and then some other story that somehow came from the second story, and then maybe he will return to the main story and you end up wondering if the second story actually happened in the middle of the first story or it was just his way of telling a story.

The final moral from this book is that we are all fucked up in our own special way but it will all be alright unless, of course, we become Republicans, in which case there will be no redemption.

It almost killed me. This book almost killed me. But as they say what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger, therefore this book made stronger, so for that alone I had to give it two stars.

I will admit that Patty and Walter were both interesting characters with all the supporting cast being all sorts of caricatures and serving as props to the main duo.

Now, I am off to read a book about people who do things and have real problems.

*UPDATE - oh yeah. And I also forgot to say that if this book was written by a woman, it would be deemed chick lit and stuck in a pastel colour cover with birds and flowers. No one would even look at it twice because there is so much better chick lit out there. But as Jonathan Franzen is lucky enough to be a man, this, all of a sudden, is the Great American Novel. DON'T MAKE ME LAUGH.
If anyone else claims there is no sexism in literary/publishing world, this here is my best demonstrative evidence that there is. Honest to God, who would take this book seriously if it was written by a woman and had something pink on the cover?
116 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Freedom.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 12, 2011 – Shelved
October 25, 2011 –
page 25
4.11% "He is chatty rambling that one isn't he"
October 26, 2011 –
page 42
6.91% "Why is the supposed AUTObiography written in the third person? This is some hot mess. This is Big Mac of literature"
November 1, 2011 –
page 288
47.37% "Soldier on, soldier on..."
November 2, 2011 –
page 312
51.32% "Is the insipidity of the bird story some sort of metaphor?"
November 5, 2011 –
page 401
65.95%
Started Reading
November 9, 2011 –
page 576
94.74% "Hallelujah!"
November 9, 2011 – Finished Reading
April 15, 2020 – Shelved as: pub-2010

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

David What almost kills a narative doesn't necessarily make it stronger - God what an unnecessary book


message 2: by Jaga (new) - added it

Jaga Gosh, you have just saved lots and lots of my precious time. Thanks


message 3: by MJ (new)

MJ Nicholls Haha. There's hope for us yet.


message 4: by KOMET (new)

KOMET I'll stay clear of this novel.


message 5: by K (new) - rated it 4 stars

K I liked this book, but you crack me up.


message 6: by Alan (new)

Alan umm, half my GR friends like this and the other half don't. I think, overall, it I'll go with the don'ts and not bother. Too many stories to read to waste on a long thing like this - if it's crap, or even not that good - you could fit a good fifty stories in it easy...


message 7: by Evan (new)

Evan I just added this book to my Amazon wish list last week. Thanks for saving me the trouble.


Kinga Don't believe the hype! :)


message 9: by Rita (new)

Rita I am wondering why you didn't just throw the book away after the first chapter?


Kinga Because I have this sort of OCD where I need to finish every book I start (I get rewarded by writing snarky reviews). This was also a book club book, so I wanted to finish to participate in the disucssion. :)


message 11: by Rita (new)

Rita Ah, it was chosen for your book club, yes that makes sense.
By the way, thanks for sending me the link [some months ago] to the website where you can hear pronunciation of Polish words. It's great!!


Kinga Ha. I spent a good part of Friday teaching my footbal fanatic friend how to pronounce Wojciech Szczęsny correctly. I am still not sure he is doing it right :D


message 13: by Tom (new)

Tom Never read the fella;never knew he existed. Your review was very entertaining.


Tom LA What do you mean by "soap opera book"? And why wouldn't any literary book like Anna Karenina, Pride & Prejudice or The Betrothed fall under that same nasty umbrella? The happy ending is not really happy, by the way. By reading your review I understand you hated this book, but I don't understand why.


Kinga Ok, I read this 2 years ago, so I can't really go very deeply into it now because I'd have to open it again and start rereading and this is something I'd rather not have to do,ever.

Basically the difference between a good book and Freedom is like the difference between a good drama film and a soap-opera. The latter being tacky, cheesy, overdramatic and never-ending.

I am aware of the bitter-sweet, supposedly ironic, taste of the 'happy ending' but I still don't rate it.


Tom LA Wow. I couldn't possibly disagree more! But thanks for your reply.


message 17: by Mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

Mark Robertson I'm not at all convinced that Patty and her husband, Saint Walter of Assisi, were interesting characters.


Cher 'N Books Excellent review! You put into words quite well, all the things that I disliked about this one.


Travis May I'm quite positive they are not Mark. :)


message 20: by Kristin (new)

Kristin Conner I like your point about if this had been written by a woman. I think I’m over it and I’m listening to the audiobook.


message 21: by Cat (new)

Cat Lundy Fun, accurate review! I don't need to write one now because you expressed my thoughts so well.


Nicholas Sierra "And don’t even get me started on the fucked up chronology. It wasn’t done in eloquent, mysterious way, it was done in a blabbermouth with ADHD way."
Freedom is not supposed to be a mysterious way its just out there for a reason. Franzen idea of Freedom is by how these characters are living. No regards to what they do or say because they have no sense of like cell. Its sets up all in the end by showing each characters perspective of Freedom. The drama that goes into it is how it sets up how they try and deal with it. Its set up by a description of the feelings or setting to then dialogue to characters. We also get a background of each character and why they are they act when it comes to certain things. I don’t know how you don’t get how each event leads to something its not all over the place its well placed with high school, college, adult life, kids, then back to adult life so I don’t know how you don’t know what’s going on.


message 23: by Colleen Chi-Girl (new)

Colleen Chi-Girl Fabulous review, Kinga. I guffawed at times. Thanks for saving me from it!


Kinga Colleen Chi-Girl wrote: "Fabulous review, Kinga. I guffawed at times. Thanks for saving me from it!"

my pleasure :D


Kinga Nicholas wrote: ""And don’t even get me started on the fucked up chronology. It wasn’t done in eloquent, mysterious way, it was done in a blabbermouth with ADHD way."
Freedom is not supposed to be a mysterious way ..."


Where did I say I didn't know what was going on??

I just said it was tedious. Not that it was difficult


message 26: by Erin (new) - rated it 2 stars

Erin Krajenke I am barely into this book and I 100% agree with you. Right off the bat, there are too many characters introduced and it is all just gossip. I was wondering, "How is this a great American novel? He must do something amazing with it." It is only considered fiction and not chick lit since it is written by a man. The audio book is also narrated by a man which seems odd since it is mostly women speaking (probably because they assume if a women narrated it, it would come across as chick lit).

I agree, I don't understand the sequencing either. This would be considered sub par chick lit but he obviously has a great marketing team.


message 27: by Lo (new)

Lo Loved this review, thanks!


back to top