Ian "Marvin" Graye's Reviews > Homo Faber
Homo Faber
by
by

Ian "Marvin" Graye's review
bookshelves: reviews, read-2011, reviews-5-stars
Apr 01, 2011
bookshelves: reviews, read-2011, reviews-5-stars
Read 2 times. Last read April 20, 2011 to April 22, 2011.
April 20, 2011:
I bought this book in 1979 and read it sometime in the early 80's.
It's only a couple of hundred pages, so when Praj asked me to review it, I thought, hey, why not re-read it (even though I very rarely re-read books).
April 22, 2011:
Re-reading this novel has been a total revelation.
Firstly, I had previously rated it four stars from memory. Now I have upgraded it to five stars.
It's not just good, it's great, one of the best books I've read.
Secondly, I haven't seen the Volker Schlondorff film "Voyager", which is based on the novel.
If it is anywhere near as good as the book, I will seek out the film with a passion.
About the Right Length
I have read numerous books that were anywhere in length between 300 and 1,000 pages long.
However, there is something in me that feels that 200 pages is just the right length.
In the early days of the internet (when grazing seemed to have superseded dining), I thought everybody would head in this direction, and that the days of the epic were over.
I was clearly wrong, but I still feel that, if an author has a 600 page book in them, they should write three 200 page novels (or at most two 300 page novels).
Hit the ground running, say what you want to say, don't subject us to the risk of boredom, finish it and move onto the next novel.
It's ironic that I'm about to start "The Pale King".
But "Homo Faber" does just this.
Some Short, Sharp Examples
I have read a few novels that more or less live up to my prescription and are perfect as well.
Camus' "The Stranger" is one.
Thomas Mann's "Death in Venice" is another.
Joseph Conrad's "Heart of Darkness".
Nabokov's "Lolita".
"Tourmaline" by Randolph Stow.
To these great novels, I would now add "Homo Faber".
Towards Crystalline Perfection
Given the relatively small canvas, what matters to me is the crystalline perfection of the prose.
Not a word wasted, not a word that I would change.
Circumnavigating the Plot
I don't think it is fair to you to summarise or hint at the plot.
It is not a detailed or hyperactive plot.
The narrator (Walter Faber) finds himself in a number of related predicaments that conspire to reach a resolution, almost despite Faber's reluctance or inability to seize the initiative and direct or change the course of his life.
In retrospect, each predicament is an existentialist challenge to the certainty of his worldview and the way he (and we) live our lives.
Walter's Tanned and Toned
Part of the novel's appeal is the tone that derives from the unlikely character of Walter.
He is no hero, but neither is he an anti-hero.
He is a thin, wiry, 1950's Swiss engineer, a technologist, a believer in the reign of rationality over sentiment.
The Age of Aquarius isn't even on the horizon.
The tale is by him as well as about him.
His tone is dry and clinical, like an engineer's report.
Initially, he is world-weary, detached, disengaged, sarcastic, resigned.
You laugh at his interaction with the world, but it's not in your face comic farce per se, it's a serious farce scaling its way up to an immodest tragedy.
He's hanging on in quiet desperation (not just the English way, but the Swiss way as well).
Then things start to happen to him, some good, some bad.
Bit by bit, he becomes more engaged, more interactive, more hopeful.
Only to experience the greatest sadness I can conceive of.
Walter's Women
It's not giving anything away to say that Walter's plight revolves around the women in his life.
Given the relative absence of women friends, he is typical of many men in that he can only relate to a woman in one of three ways: in their capacity as mother, lover/wife or daughter.
This not only shapes the relationships in his life, it shapes him and the women as well.
The Feel, the Craft, the Finish
The novel starts dry, but builds quietly and confidently towards its end.
Max Frisch is a master of his craft.
An architect himself, Frisch's novel is immaculately conceived, flawlessly constructed and consummately delivered.
On time, on budget.
Ultimately, it defines the existentialist plight with both a rational and an emotional sensibility.
I realise that I haven't given you much to go on but my enthusiasm, but if you can find a copy, I guarantee that you will be hooked from the first sentence and you won't be able to stop.
Many thanks to Praj for prompting me to revisit the book and re-discover a classic of the second half of the last century.
P.S. Volker Schlöndorff Discusses His Film "Voyager [Homo Faber]" in 2011
I bought this book in 1979 and read it sometime in the early 80's.
It's only a couple of hundred pages, so when Praj asked me to review it, I thought, hey, why not re-read it (even though I very rarely re-read books).
April 22, 2011:
Re-reading this novel has been a total revelation.
Firstly, I had previously rated it four stars from memory. Now I have upgraded it to five stars.
It's not just good, it's great, one of the best books I've read.
Secondly, I haven't seen the Volker Schlondorff film "Voyager", which is based on the novel.
If it is anywhere near as good as the book, I will seek out the film with a passion.
About the Right Length
I have read numerous books that were anywhere in length between 300 and 1,000 pages long.
However, there is something in me that feels that 200 pages is just the right length.
In the early days of the internet (when grazing seemed to have superseded dining), I thought everybody would head in this direction, and that the days of the epic were over.
I was clearly wrong, but I still feel that, if an author has a 600 page book in them, they should write three 200 page novels (or at most two 300 page novels).
Hit the ground running, say what you want to say, don't subject us to the risk of boredom, finish it and move onto the next novel.
It's ironic that I'm about to start "The Pale King".
But "Homo Faber" does just this.
Some Short, Sharp Examples
I have read a few novels that more or less live up to my prescription and are perfect as well.
Camus' "The Stranger" is one.
Thomas Mann's "Death in Venice" is another.
Joseph Conrad's "Heart of Darkness".
Nabokov's "Lolita".
"Tourmaline" by Randolph Stow.
To these great novels, I would now add "Homo Faber".
Towards Crystalline Perfection
Given the relatively small canvas, what matters to me is the crystalline perfection of the prose.
Not a word wasted, not a word that I would change.
Circumnavigating the Plot
I don't think it is fair to you to summarise or hint at the plot.
It is not a detailed or hyperactive plot.
The narrator (Walter Faber) finds himself in a number of related predicaments that conspire to reach a resolution, almost despite Faber's reluctance or inability to seize the initiative and direct or change the course of his life.
In retrospect, each predicament is an existentialist challenge to the certainty of his worldview and the way he (and we) live our lives.
Walter's Tanned and Toned
Part of the novel's appeal is the tone that derives from the unlikely character of Walter.
He is no hero, but neither is he an anti-hero.
He is a thin, wiry, 1950's Swiss engineer, a technologist, a believer in the reign of rationality over sentiment.
The Age of Aquarius isn't even on the horizon.
The tale is by him as well as about him.
His tone is dry and clinical, like an engineer's report.
Initially, he is world-weary, detached, disengaged, sarcastic, resigned.
You laugh at his interaction with the world, but it's not in your face comic farce per se, it's a serious farce scaling its way up to an immodest tragedy.
He's hanging on in quiet desperation (not just the English way, but the Swiss way as well).
Then things start to happen to him, some good, some bad.
Bit by bit, he becomes more engaged, more interactive, more hopeful.
Only to experience the greatest sadness I can conceive of.
Walter's Women
It's not giving anything away to say that Walter's plight revolves around the women in his life.
Given the relative absence of women friends, he is typical of many men in that he can only relate to a woman in one of three ways: in their capacity as mother, lover/wife or daughter.
This not only shapes the relationships in his life, it shapes him and the women as well.
The Feel, the Craft, the Finish
The novel starts dry, but builds quietly and confidently towards its end.
Max Frisch is a master of his craft.
An architect himself, Frisch's novel is immaculately conceived, flawlessly constructed and consummately delivered.
On time, on budget.
Ultimately, it defines the existentialist plight with both a rational and an emotional sensibility.
I realise that I haven't given you much to go on but my enthusiasm, but if you can find a copy, I guarantee that you will be hooked from the first sentence and you won't be able to stop.
Many thanks to Praj for prompting me to revisit the book and re-discover a classic of the second half of the last century.
P.S. Volker Schlöndorff Discusses His Film "Voyager [Homo Faber]" in 2011
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Homo Faber.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
April 1, 2011
– Shelved
April 20, 2011
–
Started Reading
April 20, 2011
–
14.02%
"I bought this book in 1979 and read it sometime in the early 80's. It's only a couple of hundred pages, so when Praj asked me to review it, I thought, hey, why not re-read it (even though I very rarely re-read books). My recollection is it has an existentialist theme, but when I started reading it 20 minutes ago, it took off like a jet plane (which is ironic, because that's what the first chapter is about) and the pa"
page
30
April 20, 2011
–
14.02%
"My recollection is it has an existentialist theme, but when I started reading it 20 minutes ago, it took off like a jet plane (which is ironic, because that's what the first chapter is about) and the pace hasn't let up. So at this early stage, I'm thinking it's an existentialist thriller with a weird sarcastic Swiss sense of humour."
page
30
April 20, 2011
–
14.02%
"My recollection is that the novel has an existentialist theme, but when I started reading it 20 minutes ago, it took off like a jet plane (which is ironic, because that's what the first chapter is about) and the pace hasn't let up. So at this early stage, I'm thinking it's an existentialist thriller with a weird sarcastic Swiss sense of humour."
page
30
April 22, 2011
–
Finished Reading
June 28, 2011
– Shelved as:
reviews
September 29, 2011
– Shelved as:
read-2011
February 15, 2012
– Shelved as:
reviews-5-stars
Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Praj
(last edited Apr 19, 2011 02:19AM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Apr 19, 2011 02:18AM

reply
|
flag

This was a very long time ago.
I might try to whip something up over easter.
I have a favour to ask of you, but I will send you a message.

I think she set me up, she must have been holding her usual trump card in her hand.

Sigh. I've been giving him 5 stars for 20 years. Paul, it isn't a news flash, but do read him.

The word "Faber" derives from the Latin term for work or making things.
The blind Roman consul Appius Claudius Caecus originally said, “Homo faber suae quisque fortunae� ("Each man is maker/smith/artisan of his own fortune").
"Tuae ipsius fortunae faber es"[ “You are the maker of your own fate”].
The following is a discussion from this page:
In The Human Condition, Hannah Arendt (1958: 9) characterizes a “vita activa� comprising “three fundamental human activities: labor, work and action.�
For Arendt “animal laborans� is the activity which corresponds:
"to the biological process of the human body, whose spontaneous growth, metabolism, and eventual decay are bound to the vital necessities produced and fed into the life process by labor."
"Homo faber" is the work of our hands which corresponds
"to the unnaturalness of human existence, which is not imbedded in, and whose mortality is not compensated by, the species� ever-recurring life cycle. Work provides an “artificial� world of things, distinctly differently from all natural surroundings� Work and its product, the human artifact, bestow a measure of permanence and durability upon the futility of mortal life and the fleeting character of human time."
Hannah Arendt places the power to act at the core of the human condition.
She proposes (1958: 157) that a life without speech or action “is literally dead to the world, it has ceased to be a human life because it is no longer lived among men.�
For Arendt (1958: 9) action is:
"the only activity that goes on directly between men without the intermediary of things or matter, corresponds to the human condition of plurality, to the fact that men, not Man, live on the earth and inhabit the world."
Arendt, Hannah (1958) The Human Condition. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
Thanks to Kaworu for pointing me in this direction.

You're review makes clear to me the futility of reading a book or an author before you actually ready for it. But how can you know beforehand ?
I will check Prajs review too, and look forward to reading again bringing more to the table.



Sorry, Lottie, I just saw your comment. I've added an interview with Volker Schlondorrf about his film of the novel.

Thanks, Brian, you should re-read Praj's review. Where is she, by the way? I miss her, especially now that erotica is everywhere.

Coincidentally, I've just finished "Cosmopolis", 209 pages and also filmed.
I'm also ready for a few shorties, though I haven't decided on my next big project yet.

Ali, these books will wait patiently for you to be ready, like they waited for me and others before you.

well I sure wasn't looking for another title for the tbr ANS now #523
There is nothing to top the rush on finding quite serendipidously directed by no hype,a book that turns out to be a masterpiece. Those of us who haunted libraries in our formative years got to discover books outside the curriculum and form a special bond with them as "our" discovery (say have you heard of this guy Dostoevsky?) ;->
@Ali...you might enjoy short stories by
Michael Crummey, Greg Hollingsheadand Charles Johnson
RE message 24...good advice Ian,I'll take it myself!
