ŷ

Jayakrishnan's Reviews > Half a Life

Half a Life by V.S. Naipaul
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5283293
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: indian-alienation, books-like-friends, terrible-honesty

VS Naipaul is out of fashion now. Who cares about him? Well, I do. Somehow, I always felt Naipaul spoke for things which I cared about. Look, I would not have invited the guy for lunch. He was always an openly grouchy person, who proudly displayed his cruelty. But I always felt like he spoke for people like me. Most people furiously stick up for their favorite political party. I loyally stick up for my favorite writers on ŷ.

I always thought of Naipaul as a brilliant but bitter teacher trying to pass on some messages to his audience. I think he was writing for Indians. Who read his novels? I think middle class Indians and other great writers. I do not know a famous writer who has not said something nice about Naipaul. Everyone from Hunter S Thompson to Marlon James adored him.

Let me sell Naipaul to you guys. He was this really grouchy Indian from the Caribbean (his ancestors were bonded laborers over there) who had a problem with nearly everyone in the world. He hated his own people (“Indians defecate everywhere. They defecate, mostly, beside the railway tracks. But they also defecate on the beaches; they defecate on the hills; they defecate on the river banks; they defecate on the streets; they never look for cover."). He hated the Caribbean. He once said the post-war British were proud of being stupid and quite gloriously shat on the sexual mores of white working class British women in the sequel to this novel. He did like rednecks. He sympathized, with a few conditions, with Hindu nationalists. He wrote three books about his travels across the Islamic world, which were like a warning. He used to beat up his Argentinian mistress, which he admitted to his biographer.

Half a Life is a bitter novel. It speaks the truth about a phony and debilitating Hindu upbringing full of false choices and grandstanding to hide ones own mediocrity. It underscores the inadequacy of the early Indian immigrants of the second half of the 20th century to fit into British society. Naipaul often talked quite honestly about his own sexual rage and this novel is filled with the sexual impotence and longings of Willie Chandran, an Indian immigrant who is utterly lost in post world war England. His relationship with an African lady which takes him to Africa seems to have pissed off many reviewers of this book. But if you are an Indian, you know what this man writes is the truth. The inadequacy, desolation and precariousness of our lives wherever we go, is perfectly described by Naipaul.

I sort of understand Indians and people from other parts of the world who hate Naipaul. Here is a writer who took more risks than Bruce Willis holding up that banner in Die Hard 3. It is almost as if Naipaul wanted to be hated. He was not even like Michel Houellebecq or someone who granted some solace with the sex scenes in his novels. Naipaul, simply wanted to write the truth which we all long to escape from but consume secretly :) Christopher Hitchens once described Naipaul as "unassailable". That is the perfect one word description of Naipaul's artistic intent. Yes, here is one writer who never played any games and wrote what he really felt. Nobody cares about him now. It is sad, but not surprising.
62 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Half a Life.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
April 18, 2011 – Shelved
May 20, 2011 – Shelved as: indian-alienation
July 3, 2012 – Shelved as: books-like-friends
July 3, 2012 – Shelved as: terrible-honesty

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ian (new)

Ian You write some damn good reviews Jayakrishnan!


Jayakrishnan Ian wrote: "You write some damn good reviews Jayakrishnan!"

Thank you for your kind words, Ian.


Old Man JP Excellent review Jayakrishnan . I've read most of his books but know very little about the man himself other than he was Indian and lived in the Caribbean. Your description explains a lot about his writing.


Jayakrishnan Jerry wrote: "Excellent review Jayakrishnan . I've read most of his books but know very little about the man himself other than he was Indian and lived in the Caribbean. Your description explains a lot about his..."

Cheers Jerry. He moved to Britain quite early in his life. He said he wanted to become a British writer and felt he never really got his due.


Tokoro I read this some years ago and have meant to pick up the author again. I'll be on the lookout for his work when I go out thrifting in the future.


Furciferous Quaintrelle Bex Wow! This review was an absolute rollercoaster and if the book itself is even half as entertaining, then I'm in! Great review Jayakrishnan. You have a really interesting taste in books. Thanks for the heads-up!


Jayakrishnan Furciferous Quaintrelle wrote: "Wow! This review was an absolute rollercoaster and if the book itself is even half as entertaining, then I'm in! Great review Jayakrishnan. You have a really interesting taste in books. Thanks for ..."

Cheers Furciferous Quaintrelle. I must warn you that it is a novel filled with bitterness and impotent rage. Not everyone enjoys Naipaul.


message 8: by [deleted user] (new)

Rollicking Romp? Yes or No?


Jayakrishnan Freddie wrote: "Rollicking Romp? Yes or No?"

No.


Dmitri Good one. I love Naipaul but I’m running out of the classics. This one is probably next on my list.


Jayakrishnan Dmitri wrote: "Good one. I love Naipaul but I’m running out of the classics. This one is probably next on my list."

It is a great novel, Dmitri. Not sure if it is a classic. I liked it.


message 12: by Adnamy (new)

Adnamy I have seen a documentary on this author & it was intriguing. Your review is both intriguing & entertaining - might hunt down a book - maybe not this one !
I love Somerset Maugham ( irrelevant note I know)


message 13: by Adnamy (new)

Adnamy PS I also tend to like people who are “out of fashion�


Jayakrishnan Adnamy wrote: "I have seen a documentary on this author & it was intriguing. Your review is both intriguing & entertaining - might hunt down a book - maybe not this one !
I love Somerset Maugham ( irrelevant not..."


This is among his most depressing, Adnamy. If you want to ease into Naipaul, I recommend some of his funnier books like The Mystic Masseur and Muriel Street.


Jayakrishnan Adnamy wrote: "PS I also tend to like people who are “out of fashion�"

That's cool.


back to top