Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Matthias's Reviews > The Handmaid's Tale

The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
9889835
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: my-reviews

Don't let the bastards grind you down.

There's a lot of talk about women's rights these days. There were times where I thought: enough already. You girls got it good. I looked around me and saw women with strong voices and a million choices. If they wished to go for a career, they could go for it. If they didn't, no biggie. Their liberty seemed greater than men's in a lot of respects. The power they wield over men is magnificent and often described as the greatest humanity is capable of: a woman's love. They can choose to give it or withhold it. Men's political and physical powers look puny and artificial in contrast, as their strings are constantly pulled by forces they can't resist. Somewhere deep inside me I had a hard time believing things could really be so bad for women, with their majority in numbers and all this strenght at their disposal.

But then you turn on the news or you open a history book. You look outside your own country. You look at a presidential candidate talking about women as animals, as goods to be acquired, as territories to be conquered. You see people making excuses for it, making light of it, you see in their eyes they assume that it's normal. You see laws that tell women what to do with their own bodies, in the name of religion or the greater good. You hear of households where tiny kings use their physical power to terrorise their tiny kingdoms. And then you see all the machinations that have gone into trying to rob women of their mystical, almost holy, powers in greater kingdoms, machinations that often seem on the verge of systematising in the blink of an eye.

So, having accepted that the Woman's struggle is real, I was reading The Handmaid's Tale that paints a picture of how things would look like if circumstance and evil succeeded in stripping women of all the agency they have. When they have succesfully been ground down by the bastards. Bastards aren't Men, per se. Or all men. Or only men. This isn't so much a story about women versus men. It's a story of the artificial power against the real one, a story where the former won.

It's a bleak picture. Atwood uses the very claustrophobic perspective of Offred to great effect. Offred is the eponymous handmaid who find herself in a dystopia where her only societal value is also a curse: her fertility. Her world consists of her room, a stroll down the stairs, a garden, a walk to the butcher and her one and only societal mission: to get pregnant. She has to wear a cape that allows her to only look directly in front of her. She's isolated and stripped of her identity. Even her memories are slowly disappearing and losing relevance in a surrounding that offers nothing to link them to. Through this narrative Margaret Atwood succeeds in donning that same vision-confining cape on her readers' heads, immersing them in that same claustrophobic atmosphere.

This books does very well what it set out to do and that also explains why I didn't thoroughly enjoy it. I wanted more background. I wanted more explanations. I wanted more adventure. I wanted more action by the protagonist. I wanted her spirit, still apparent in the secretly hoarding of butter and the plotting of small thefts, to break free and wreak havoc among the bastards. Make them lose without losing herself. I wanted more direction. I wanted the flashes of hope to last. In short: the author succeeded in making me want what the protagonist wanted. She showed me what it is we should all strive to avoid actively.

An important book, and a good one to boot.

259 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Handmaid's Tale.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 26, 2016 – Started Reading
September 26, 2016 – Shelved
September 30, 2016 –
page 70
21.6% "Nothing much is happening so far, the setting is being created at a very leisurely pace."
October 6, 2016 –
page 70
21.6% "I got side-tracked completely. Picking this back up tonight."
October 11, 2016 –
page 246
75.93%
October 13, 2016 – Finished Reading
October 16, 2016 – Shelved as: my-reviews

Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lisa Fantastic review of this masterpiece, Matthias! I have felt unable to put into words what I felt when I read it, and I am pleased to find your review matching my (not articulated) thoughts perfectly. Being a woman, appreciating and celebrating that I can live a great, independent life, I found it to be one thing above all: scary!


Matt Quann Dude, what an excellent review! I love your introduction: a nice contrast that shows personal growth while also teeing up one of the big themes of this novel. I haven't read this one, but it is definitely my next Atwood!


Lizzy Amazing review, Matthias. Thanks for your deep understanding of us women's plight. I have this in my to-read list and just upgraded to read it sooner. L.


Lata I like your review.
I have yet to read this book, though it's received acclaim for years. As a woman and a feminist, I don't need a book to convince me of the power imbalances in cultures, having had many examples around me at home, growing up, and in my working life.
This book, however, keeps getting cited as an interesting extrapolation of many present situations, so I suppose I should give it a read.


Dolors Hey Matthias, you manage to articulate what I found impossible to do right after I finished this novel. I was as baffled as you were and in want of more background information, but the book certainly got me thinking, as it did to you. A great review of a book that doesn't leave indifferent!


Cecily I love the way you've brought this bang up to date.


Bionic Jean Great review, thanks Matthias. I once heard Margaret Attwood say that she never included anything in her novels which had not happened in the world in some form somewhere, some time. It makes you think :/


Matthias Lisa wrote: "Fantastic review of this masterpiece, Matthias! I have felt unable to put into words what I felt when I read it, and I am pleased to find your review matching my (not articulated) thoughts perfectl..."

Thank you Lisa! I had a difficult time writing a review for this one as well to be honest, but I'm glad it didn't show too much. It's a book that describes situations often talked about but seldomly truly acknowledged, and it's a paradox that's difficult to put your finger on. Atwood pokes the finger right in it and twists it around a bit.


Matthias Matthew wrote: "Dude, what an excellent review! I love your introduction: a nice contrast that shows personal growth while also teeing up one of the big themes of this novel. I haven't read this one, but it is def..."

Thanks Matthew! It was the first Atwood for me, but definitely not the last. I've got the Oryx and Crake series already on my shelves and got my eye on a certain blind assassin as well. Looking forward to read your thoughts on this one.


Matthias Kavita wrote: "Wow, this is a superb review, Matthias. Thanks. :)

This part really struck me: You hear of households where tiny kings use their phyical power to terrorise their tiny kingdoms.

And I was telling ..."


Thank you Kavita! I loved that quote as well. I wonder if this is the book where it came from originally, but even if it didn't, Atwood used it to very great effect. As you rightly said, there's a lot of strenght to be gotten out of it.


Justine Great review...I feel like it's time for me to reread this one.


Sidharth Vardhan Powerful review


Matthias Lizzy wrote: "Amazing review, Matthias. Thanks for your deep understanding of us women's plight. I have this in my to-read list and just upgraded to read it sooner. L."

Thanks Lizzy! Any understanding that I show in this review was greatly augmented by this book, so credit to Atwood for that for sure. I hope you'll enjoy the book.


Matthias Lata wrote: "This book, however, keeps getting cited as an interesting extrapolation of many present situations."

That's exactly what it is Lata! You won't be disappointed if you go in reading this book with that expectation in mind.


Matthias Dolors wrote: "Hey Matthias, you manage to articulate what I found impossible to do right after I finished this novel. I was as baffled as you were and in want of more background information, but the book certain..."

Thank you Dolors. I read your own review and think your own articulations prove it wasn't impossible after all ;-) The thought that the scenario is indeed a dangerous and very real possibility is what struck me about this book as well. I just hope that in describing it, Atwood helped make it more difficult for this dystopia to ever arise for real.


Matthias Cecily wrote: "I love the way you've brought this bang up to date."

It's scary how easy it is to show how relevant dystopias still are in relation to current affairs.


Matthias Jean wrote: "Great review, thanks Matthias. I once heard Margaret Attwood say that she never included anything in her novels which had not happened in the world in some form somewhere, some time. It makes you t..."

Thank you Jean! Yes, I wouldn't be surprised if that were true, the things described in this book never felt far fetched but were on the contrary quite familiar to me. It's like a condensed version of a particular branch of reality we prefer in watered down doses because it's easier to swallow in that form.


Matthias Justine wrote: "Great review...I feel like it's time for me to reread this one."

Thanks Justine! And enjoy the re-read, may it be an inspiration!


message 19: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita Your words hold respect and contempt, something not easy to achieve. And while I might be in a minority who is yet to read this tale, I know one thing: this story calls a spade, a spade. A powerful review, Matthias.


Matthias Seemita wrote: "Your words hold respect and contempt, something not easy to achieve. And while I might be in a minority who is yet to read this tale, I know one thing: this story calls a spade, a spade. A powerful..."

Even before reading the book you show great understanding of it Seemita! That is exactly what this story does with regards to spades. Your reviewing powers seem boundless! And so are your powers of leaving kind and encouraging comments. Thank you.


message 21: by Vessey (last edited Oct 18, 2016 01:56PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Vessey YAY! I'm so glad to see that you have upped your rating from 3 to 4 stars, Matthias! And a really powerful review as well. My favourite line:

Make them lose without losing herself.

I was glad to read this book along with you. I hope sometime we have a buddy reading that isn't coincidental. :)

Thank you!


Matthias Vessey wrote: "YAY! I'm so glad to see that you have upped your rating from 3 to 4 stars, Matthias! And a really powerful review as well. My favourite line:

Make them lose without losing herself.

I was glad to ..."


Haha, I remember when we started reading this book around the same time. Seems like such a long time ago. You finished it in a couple of days but for me it took weeks. That partially explains my initial 3-star rating, I kind of held it against this book that it didn't grip me in the way some pageturners do, but after letting it set in I decided for an additional star because I don't think that was what Atwood was aiming for. She was more into the creation of an atmosphere in which you would truly feel the desperation and isolation of the protagonist, and through that atmosphere make the central message hit home. And there she succeeded very well.
On to more buddy reads, buddy! I'll try to keep up the pace next time ;-)


message 23: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Hi Matthias. Very good to bump into one of your reviews again.

I enjoyed your take on one of my favorite books. I read this book when I was fifteen...the year after it was published and it had a profound effect on me in terms of burgeoning feminist consciousness. Thanks for this lovely reminder and I love the comments from our goodreads community !!


Matthias Jaidee wrote: "Hi Matthias. Very good to bump into one of your reviews again.

I enjoyed your take on one of my favorite books. I read this book when I was fifteen...the year after it was published and it had a p..."


Thank you Jaidee! Good to see you again indeed! :-)


message 25: by El (new) - rated it 5 stars

El Fitting I should see this review today. Last year on this day I got to meet Margaret Atwood and have her sign my beloved copy of The Handmaid's Tale. One of my favorite moments in life. Great review!


message 26: by Hanneke (last edited Oct 21, 2016 04:06PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hanneke Marvellous review, Matthias. I enjoyed how you seemed to get a bit annoyed about the lack of background on Offret, but wasn't that the reality of her life and how we should see her. I agree with you that this book wasn't perse about the power of men over women but about what a dominating ruling class could do to a society and especially to women who had to be controlled because its future depended on it. I hope you don't mind, but I would suggest you first read Alias Grace or The Blind Assassin before reading the trilogy Oryx and Crake. The Robber Bride is fantastic too. I don't want you to get a wrong impression about her writing only dystopian novels!


Matthias El wrote: "Fitting I should see this review today. Last year on this day I got to meet Margaret Atwood and have her sign my beloved copy of The Handmaid's Tale. One of my favorite moments in life. Great review!"

What a lucky meeting! Even though I have only met her through this book so far I'm already glad to have made her acquaintance. Continue to cherish your copy with all its annotations through time. Sounds like a fantastic way to look back on your own past all the while enjoying the book all over again.


Matthias Hanneke wrote: "Marvellous review, Matthias. I enjoyed how you seemed to get a bit annoyed about the lack of background on Offret, but wasn't that the reality of her life and how we should see her. I agree with yo..."
That's very good and sensible advice Hanneke, thank you very much. I'll start with her award-winning "The Blind Assassin" in that case! Consider "The Robber Bride" and "Alias Grace" also on my radar :-)


Ivana Books Are Magic great review of a fantastic book...when we talk about women's right, we do wrong to focus only the west (where things are not so bad for the women- we're basically facing the same problems as man, that is unemployment and well the collapse of the western economical system)...we forget about the other parts of the world, where women are tortured and killed, all in the name of religion. People prefer not to think about those things, because it would imply they need to do something about it. I think that Atwood's dystopian society picks well upon some trends in the West (anti-feminist ones) as well as warns us about the states in other parts of the world.


Matthias Ivana wrote: "great review of a fantastic book...when we talk about women's right, we do wrong to focus only the west (where things are not so bad for the women- we're basically facing the same problems as man, ..."

Thanks Ivana, those are some relevant observations you made there. It's true that also in the so-called West we've got a thing or two to learn from this book.


Ivana Books Are Magic Matthias wrote: "Ivana wrote: "great review of a fantastic book...when we talk about women's right, we do wrong to focus only the west (where things are not so bad for the women- we're basically facing the same pro..."

true...I feel a bit worried about all these new 'traditional' movements...I'm not anti-tradition and I can even understand why some people might be nostalgic about the past, but the truth is that there is no going back. It is not possible. We can all see that there are problems in Western societies but anti-feminism and overly traditional and fanatical religious movements won't change that.....If there was or there is a problem connected with feminism, it must be adressed, figured out and solved. I think this book is very brave in examing all of that, if you look at it closely, it is quite complex and it is not pro anything really...not pro- feminism certainly...

Basicially, I think that the main problem with feminism is that it tried to make women believe they had to be like men in order to have any value, in order to count at all...and that is just wrong. Having choice is what it should have been about, but somehow it turned out into endless complaints about men, followed by imitation of men....and I can see why men are annoyed with this kind of behaviour, but it is hard on woman as well...because being made to feel worthless because one choses to care or focus on one's child and family is not only morally wrong but it is catastrofic for the development of the sociey as well...if nobody wants to take care of children, what happens to them?

I don't know why as a society we always must pick the most extreme way to go....either we must hate the traditional family and the very idea of having kids and getting married...or we must create this rigid and unjust social structures to protect it...to kill and imprison everyone who wants to get a divorce and remarry (as in this novel). What is so wrong about admitting that different things work for different people?

I think that ultimately, we are all afraid of admitting to it because it would mean that we're all accountable for our actions. It would mean we have a responsibility for our own choices and happiness...and nobody seems to want that...or at least that is what the majority doesn't want, hence we always end up with extreme social movements and ideas that play on emotions and don't require an individual to use his head.


Strawbary Miller The connection you made between the idea of identity and the story’s lack of information was phenomenal. I had never put that together, and I hope that Atwood’s intentions were to do so,because it would be sheer genius. On another note, I like how you started off your review with a bit of personal perspective. I share your views as well. I do not think women are oppressed physically within the american society, however I think there is social oppression that we still face everyday from selective groups of men. I think that there are many normalities that we witness that are somehow justified by men when they should not be. Honestly, they shouldn’t even be normalities. I think the book touched on these ideas of ‘social� oppression more than the past inequalities that were experienced in hope to start a conversation for men to see women as a people, too.


back to top