ŷ

Cassy's Reviews > A Storm of Swords

A Storm of Swords by George R.R. Martin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2282938
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: physical-own, 2011, fiction-scifi-fantasy-paranormal, region-elsewhere

Martin outdid himself. And honestly, he didn’t have to try so hard. I was already going to give him five stars for this scene alone: (view spoiler)

Have you ever seen a car accident? Not the aftermath that messes up traffic, but the actual event itself? Having driven in both Atlanta and Houston’s rush hour, I’ve seen a handful. It’s horrible horrible horrible. There is that signature sound when thousands of pounds of metal crunch together. And it blows my mind. One side of my brain is in denial and keeps repeating, “That did not just happen.� The other half is moving forward. “Is anyone hurt? Don’t gawk � don’t want to be rear-ended myself. Do they have the insurance? Has someone called the police?� I get clammy and shaky, as well as teary-eyed thinking of all the emotions they’ll have to deal with. And even though I wasn’t directly involved, I have this on-edge feeling that lasts the whole day.

Reading THAT scene was akin to watching a multi-car pile-up. I freaked out. Literally slammed the book shut, stood up on the bed, and cussed for a bit. Next I curled up into a ball, hugged the book to my chest, and muttered “No no no!� on loop. I wailed to my concerned husband, “What is going to happen now?� Then I proceeded to mull over this development for days.

Looking back, I wonder why it shocked me so much. This series is full of twists, deaths, and reveals. What’s one more? And Martin certainly gave some clues leading up to the event.

I think it caught me off guard, because he had just devoted a fair amount of time to this part of the plot. Through books one and two, (view spoiler) Truth be told, I ignored my own advice after reading book two: if you see a bright light, don’t trust it. (view spoiler) I guess there is a new, supplemental lesson: never enter into a romantic relationship with Martin. He would jerk my emotions around mercilessly and leave me heartbroken on a bathroom floor.

Also, THE scene made me question where this entire series is headed. Imagine you’re reading a safe, mass-appeal book, you can rest assured that no how much hardship the author throws at the protagonist, they’ll survive, because (a) the author/publisher doesn’t have the guts to disappoint their legions of readers and (b) there’s a sequel! I thought the main goal here was to see the Stark family emerge victorious and save the Seven Kingdoms. Now I’m not as sure. And after reading roughly 3,000 pages and with 2,000+ pages to go, it shook me to feel so untethered.

Anyways, kudos to Martin for making me react that strongly. I read enough that I am becoming increasingly callous to authors� surprise attacks. And this series is so large that the plots from each book are already melting together. It is hard to remember during which book this or that character was introduced or where I learned a key piece of information. But THAT scene will always define book three for me.

I also love that when I felt confident the book was winding down (with only 200 pages to go), Martin threw in some more shockers. While they were not of the same caliber as THE scene, they nonetheless required me to reset my expectations for the next book. Of course I am referring to (view spoiler)

Martin, I am catching onto your wily ways. And I am begging for more.
100 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Storm of Swords.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 16, 2011 – Shelved
June 24, 2011 – Started Reading
June 28, 2011 –
page 213
21.13% "What a great twist with Catelyn & Robb's storyline. While Jon’s POV is headed down cliché lane."
July 5, 2011 –
page 704
69.84% "Holy moly! Sure, I smelled a trap, but not this level of butchery. I am shocked!"
July 7, 2011 –
page 833
82.64% "If you are ever invited to a wedding in the Seven Kingdoms, I recommend you decline with regrets."
July 10, 2011 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Ryan Five stars for the Red Wedding? That's not even an Arya chapter.


Cassy Kroms, if I had to pick a favorite, I agree. It would have to be book 3!


Cassy Ryan, I JUST saw your comment! Sigh, why does everyone love Arya so much?


Ryan Cassy wrote: "Ryan, I JUST saw your comment! Sigh, why does everyone love Arya so much?"

For me, it may be because she attracts the coolest mentors.


Ryan Kroms wrote: "She's just a great character. She doesn't take shit, and her arc is very fascinating. I love Arya."

Just so.


Ellen Goodlett I had the same reaction!! I thought the book was headed in one direction (although it was suspicious that Robb won EVERY dang battle so far, and that his wolf was all GRRRR DO NOT TRUST FREYS before the wedding). But I thought it'd just be more suckiness and he'd escape.
I guess it is all up to Dany and Arya now. Dany will have to save all of Westeros, and Arya will have to kill everyone who sucks?


Ellen Goodlett Also then Jon can hook up with Dany and R'hllor can make her fertile again so they can have loverly potentially-incestuous dragon babies. YEAH. I'll stop now...


Cassy Ellen, I'm glad to know I wasn't alone in my shock. It's up to the women to save the world. What's new, eh?

And there is merit to your Dany/Jon theory!


mark monday another great review. this book is my favorite of the series, for all the things you mention plus (view spoiler)


message 10: by Cassy (last edited Feb 17, 2012 09:56AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cassy Thanks, Mark!

Huh, I had forgotten about those men. Shame on me! I still don't see where (view spoiler) storyline is headed. I just have to trust that Martin has it all worked out...


Amanda Great review Cassy.


Cassy Thanks, Amanda! I hope you enjoy this one.


message 13: by Queen (last edited Jul 12, 2012 05:36PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Queen I just read that scene last night...and I'm still on edge. Just...wtf..I feel like curling into a ball and doing the same as you but I can't right now haha.
I guess I'll follow your wise advice "never enter into a romantic relationship with Martin" now I'm going to think that every character I like will eventually die...


Cassy Sigh. It is such a great scene.

And yeap, if you run across Martin's profile on an online dating site, move on!


Queen Must be, I guess I'll learn to appreciate it later XD. Right now I feel like I relieve it through the other characters when they get the news.


Cassy Thanks, Gerry!


Akina Luv your review Cassie. I agree with you wholeheartedly on every issue including comments about Arya. She seems like a useless character to me. I wonder what role she will play by the end of the series. Yes she has a little spunk but if she is killed off by the end of book 7 I will not shed one single tear.


Paula Savioli I also questioned where the whole series was headed after this point. It really struck me. I have absolutelly no idea what's gonna happen and that drives me mad!


message 19: by Trevor (new) - added it

Trevor I seriously couldn't help reading the spoiler and i like cried


message 20: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Johnson Your review is hilarious and its a definite favorite. You basically described me completely with the Red Wedding. I literally flipped a desk in disbelief that a character Martin spent so much time on was gone. Not only that fact but at a wedding,come on Martin. I felt the same way on the fact that Robb was dead.Why? Why would Martin write two books with a character still in it leaving traces of death,but not kill him. If Martin wanted us to build up a strong storyline he could have easily done so in the first two books and had him cut off. Not only did this catch you off guard it caught the world of guard. I was shocked,my mom was shocked,just everyone. Right when everyone starts to warm their fuzzy hearts up to Stark,he dies. I can never trust Martin again after what he has done. This will always put me on edge for the rest of his books knowing that no one is safe.


back to top