ŷ

William2's Reviews > Gilead

Gilead by Marilynne Robinson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4684009
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 21-ce, fiction, us

This novel reminds me—with its beautifully spare prose and the bleak stoicism of its characters—of three books: Per Petterson's Out Stealing Horses, Willa Cather's My Ántonia and Martin Amis's House of Meetings. This is not meant as a statement of influence, but simply one of kinship. The writing in all of these novels is conversational in tone and beautifully compressed, which is enormously hard to do, though it appears easy.

Gilead is the story of a Protestant pastor, the Reverend John Ames, who, in the midwestern town of Gilead of about 1950 or so, writes to his then seven-year-old son. The pastor is dying and the letter is intended to be read when his son has reached adulthood.

In it the pastor speaks of his grandfather and his father, and the long tradition of Christian ministry in the family, that, the writer assumes, will not continue with the recipient of the document which we, a little guiltily perhaps, hold in our hands. For the sense is very strong here of the reader as interloper, gazing at personal documents not meant for his eyes.

And just as we surely know that what we read can only resolve itself in death and dissolution, and we brace ourselves for that end--we've been given fair warning--yet despite this we find that there is no way to steel ourselves for the conclusion. We know vaguely the shape it may take, and yet it still moves us indescribably. This to my mind is great writing and no merely clever metafictional trickery can ever supplant it.

Christianity is not entirely the point of the story. Though the pastor has been driven by it the whole of his life and it's integral to his concern for family and flock, and the natural world, which he sees as pervaded by spirit at every level. Faith here is the means by which Marilynne Robinson shows us her characters' humanity, the tenuousness of their existence, their lives of suffering and loss, impermanence and fleetingness.

It has been wonderful for this agnostic to see how the old school, middle-American Christianity used to work in a good man. That is to say, how it drives him to ecstasis, to open-heartedness and love and an almost unbearable joy. It's pretty heady stuff. No doubt those so inclined will find the novel a powerful affirmation of faith, which is a fine thing. My point is that it would be a mistake to read it solely as a Christian novel. Masters like Naguib Mahfouz and Isaac Bashevis Singer have produced similarly powerful fictions using far different religious contexts. And Ms. Robinson's excellent work, like theirs, transcends its religiosity to bring us something deeply universal.

V.S Naipaul wrote in one of his books on Islam that the great gift of religious people is their confidence. How lovely, I've always felt, to be able to take solace in such belief. The Reverend Ames never wavers in his faith, but it is only by constant self-questioning that he's able to sustain it. Life is suffering. I have been wrong when I've thought of faith as an opiate. For the thinking person it is as challenging as any other form of mindful living.
484 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Gilead.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 16, 2011 – Shelved
July 16, 2011 – Shelved as: 21-ce
July 16, 2011 – Shelved as: fiction
July 16, 2011 – Shelved as: us
January 21, 2014 –
page 25
10.12%
January 22, 2014 – Started Reading
January 26, 2014 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 77 (77 new)


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) If you are going to read one Robinson, this is the one. Her style excels. Great summation William.


William2 Stephen wrote: "If you are going to read one Robinson, this is the one. Her style excels. Great summation William."

Thanks, Stephen! :-)


William2 Yes, it's quite the brilliant work! Thanks for your kind words. :-)


Douglas I agree. This novel is a brilliant example of how spirituality can live within the pages of literature without cajoling the reading into a belief system.

Even still, I nearly saw God in some of these passages:

"And this is something I remember very well. At first I thought I saw the sun setting in the east; I knew where east was, because the sun was just over the horizon when we got there that morning. Then I realized that what I saw was a full moon rising just as the sun was going down. Each of them was standing on its edge, with the most wonderful light between them. It seemed as if you could touch it, as if there were palpable currents of light passing back and forth, or as if there were great taut skeins of light suspended between them. I wanted my father to see it, but I knew I'd have to startle him out of his prayer and I wanted to do it the best way, so I took his hand and kissed it. And then I said, "Look at the moon."

I don't know why, but when I read this particular passage, it seemed otherworldly. Great review.


Michael You captured the grace and interior space of this gem so well. It almost turned my atheist self into a pantheist.


William2 I love the great confidence of religious people. One which one could share it but, alas...
:-)


Lynne King What a beautiful review William.


Kristen I agree with Lynne - lovely indeed. Thanks William!


Melanie Loved that book! I thought it was really arresting.


William2 Melanie wrote: "Loved that book! I thought it was really arresting."

Arresting is the perfect word. It slows you down and prompts a more reflective kind of reading. It's so rich emotionally. :-)


Melanie William wrote: "Melanie wrote: "Loved that book! I thought it was really arresting."

Arresting is the perfect word. It slows you down and prompts a more reflective kind of reading. It's so rich emotionally. :-)"


Absolutely. I thought it was the literary equivalent of a Terrence Malick film.


William2 Melanie wrote: "William wrote: "Melanie wrote: "Loved that book! I thought it was really arresting."

Arresting is the perfect word. It slows you down and prompts a more reflective kind of reading. It's so rich em..."


:-)


Lorraine Beautiful review William.
I found the book to be rich and full of love. I spent many hours with the book on my lap quietly and thankfully meditating on the nuanced meanings: this was John Ames' Gilead, his Gethsemane and ultimately he, as we all must, faces his demons alone. Moving and life changing. My desert island book. Perfect.


Miriam Bridenne Truly great review of a wonderful novel! I was wondering if you had also read Marilynne Robinson's debut novel, Housekeeping?

All best,

Miriam


William2 Thank you, lorrain


Steve Horton BB-
What a beautiful review...nicely done. I read it a few years ago with a similar perspective and was similarly impressed.

Best-
SH


William2 Thanks Steve!


message 18: by Karl (new) - added it

Karl Great review.


William2 Most welcome, Cheryl.


William2 Thank you, Karl.


message 21: by Elizabeth (new) - added it

Elizabeth Kral Good lord, you make too many books seem to worthwhile to ignore. You have caused me to again increase my already too long want to read list. Of course, you must continue. Thank you.


William2 Elizabeth wrote: "Good lord, you make too many books seem to worthwhile to ignore. You have caused me to again increase my already too long want to read list. Of course, you must continue. Thank you."

:-)


message 23: by Toni (new) - added it

Toni William; Oh my! Whew. Brilliant. Do you teach?


William2 Hi Toni. Thank you. It's funny you should ask about teaching. Only in the last few years have I decided that that would be something I could do well. Be well.


message 25: by Toni (new) - added it

Toni Yes, I sensed that you would be an excellent teacher. Cheers.


William2 Thanks friend.


message 27: by Bloodorange (last edited Jan 21, 2015 04:57AM) (new)

Bloodorange Thank you for the wise review.

I have just picked it up from the library today, and immediately read the first page. And then the last one. It will be a difficult pleasure, reading this.


William2 Bloodorange wrote: "Thank you for the wise review.

I have just picked it up from the library today, and immediately read the first page. And then the last one. It will be a difficult pleasure, reading this."


It was a heart-wrenching read for me. It's so hard to get that sort of sustained emotional intensity in prose. Very rare. Please let me know what you think. Thanks.


message 29: by Jean (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jean Hoefling Thank you William1 for discerning (correctly I think) that faith is not an opiate, but a challenge requiring great courage. Marilynne Robinson has made that point uncommonly well in Gilead. The Rev. Ames is as real as anyone I know who fights that battle to forgive, to not judge others, and not to despair over one's life, which is its own form of self-judgment. Great review.


William2 Jean Hoefling wrote: "Thank you William1 for discerning (correctly I think) that faith is not an opiate, but a challenge requiring great courage. Marilynne Robinson has made that point uncommonly well in Gilead. The Rev..."

Thanks, Jean!


Ellen I finally decided to read this book based on your comment that it is reminiscent of Out Stealing Horses in style; I enjoyed that book quite a bit and knew not to rush through it so as to appreciate the quality of the writing...Thanks :-)


William2 Youre welcome.


message 33: by Mona (new) - rated it 3 stars

Mona Wonderful review, William.


William2 Thanks, Mona.


Murf the Surf William...you've shown a very keen insight into the parameters of love. The physical, mental, and of course the little know spiritual aspect as well. Most religions claim they have all the answers and the only path. What hippocrits they become when forgetting it's all about the love you embrace and bestow on others. Peace.....Murf


message 36: by Fred Ahkner (new)

Fred Ahkner This is a great achievement By Robinson


message 37: by Fred Ahkner (new)

Fred Ahkner This is a good review


message 38: by noorlight. (new)

noorlight. nice rewievd William


message 39: by noorlight. (new)

noorlight. nice review William


Joseph This is the finest review of this novel I have read. Well done.


message 41: by Robert (new)

Robert McCaffrey Spectacular, insightful and beautifully written review. You might enjoy some of Flannery O'Connor's (often humorous) musings on the subject of her Christian (Catholic) writing which often appeals more to socialists and atheists than to sentimental Christians. Also, you made me nostalgic for the many decent Christians I grew up with. Oh, I'm sure they are still out there and just striving to be decent, but their voices have been drowned out by the noisy, rabid "Christians" whose religion is bizarrely and inextricably confounded with their un-Christian nationalism and their sense of Christianity as a white, homegrown American thing.


message 42: by Quo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Quo I enjoyed your commentary on Robinson's book. I don't think that the religious faith that guides so many of her characters is particularly "spiritual" but rather a quietly undefined merger of faith with hope--hope for an afterlife, hope for the future, hope that love will bring families & neighbors together & especially hope that a broadly unfolding Midwestern landscape will convey Balm of Gilead. Well done William!


William2 Thank you. Quo!


Joann Hnat Nice review. I just wanted to say that I also thought of "My Antonia" while reading this book. I even did a Google search for the two titles together, figuring I'd see lots of people talking about it, but no. Nice to see I'm not alone.


William2 Thanks, Joann. It's nice to know I wasn't alone in that perception. Be well


William2 Belated thanks for your kind words, Robert.


William2 Thank you Joseph!


message 48: by Abubakar (new)

Abubakar Mehdi What is good for the individual isn't necessarily good for the society too, and I can understand your point here, but again, the alchemy of this who experiment has done more harm then good. While a rationalist can't help but ridicule belief without evidence, a devotee takes great pride in his 'blind faith', and the ecstasies of mysticism, and it is a rather fascinating thing.


William2 Live and let live, Abubakar. Thank you for your comment.


William2 Catheter—I can’t tell you how that one made me laugh. Very good


« previous 1
back to top