ŷ

Natalie Monroe's Reviews > A Court of Frost and Starlight

A Court of Frost and Starlight by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6688207
3.5 stars

“To the stars who listen, Feyre."

"To the dreams that are answered, Rhys.�


Honest to the twelve Olympians, the stakes in this novella is Feyre and Rhys finding time to bone.



Like seriously, Feyre and Rhy have got to stop having cosmic sex. They’re going to knock one of Saturn’s rings loose one day.

A Court of Frost and Starlight is basically the Christmas episode of every sitcom. Feyre wanders around Velaris, buying presents for everyone. There are snowball fights and drinking around a roaring fire and a decorating disaster (cue canny laugh track). (Why on earth did Maas turn the Solstice, a pagan festival, into a modern non-denominational Christmas anyway? In a high fantasy novel specifically.)

There are more serious and plot-relevant moments scattered throughout, pertaining to future books and how everyone is dealing with the aftermath of ACOWAR, but none of it really matters. It's all information that will be inevitably regurgitated in future full-length novels. (Btw, there's an excerpt of what I suspect is ACOTAR #4 at the end and it's Nesta's novel. My girl is gonna slaaaay.) ACOFAS has no value other than Christmas fluff.



I'm too lazy to organize the rest of my thoughts in coherent paragraphs, so here they are in their glorious messy form:

-Rhys is sickeningly perfect to the extent that he doesn't feel like a real person anymore. Yes, a decent guy would buy tampons for his partner and comfort her if she were undergoing the agonizing monthly shredding of her uterus lining, but to clean her off too? Just ew. Props for mentioning mensuration though when most YA/NA novels breeze past it.

-Um, why does the task of decorating their new house fall to Feyre? It's like Hilary Clinton saying she'd still plan the flower arrangements for state dinners after she became president. Yeah, High Lord and High Lady. We're fucking equals, y'all!!! But he shells out money for a house while his wife is in charge of the domestic aspect. I didn't realize the separate spheres mentality still held.

-It’s been, like what, how many centuries? When is Mor going to tell Az she’s not interested? It’s just cruel, what’s she’s doing. She doesn’t owe him anything, but he’s her friend. He deserves a straightforward no, instead of feigned ignorance.

-Feyre and Elaine are such bitches to Nesta. She very obviously has depression and PTSD. You can’t shit over Tamlin for not handling Feyre’s PTSD right, then have Feyre be this suffering martyr to her bitch sister who's still working through her trauma.

-Also, how many more times are we going to trash Tamlin? Yes, he was a shit for what he did to Feyre. I’m not excusing that. But does he deserve to have his ACOTAR character completely assassinated beyond redemption while Rhys and Feyre sneer from their lofty thrones? Don’t tell me they haven’t done worse. I still remember Rhys twisting Feyre’s broken arm until she screamed to get her to agree to their bargain. But none of that matters anymore, does it? Because now is her Rhys is her mate and every shit he ever did is either excused or swept under the rug.

-The writing is better than ACOWAR. Thank the old gods for small mercies.

-I just want to read about Mor, Elaine, Nesta, Lucien, Azriel, and Cassian. Feyre and Rhys and their mountain-shaking sex bore me.

-The worst part is I’m still trash for this series. I had fun reading about it. And you can bet when Nesta's book comes out in 2020, I'm going to be on Amazon, ready to fork over my hard-earned dough.



Me to me: why are you like this?

My review of A Court of Thorns & Roses
My review of A Court of Mist & Fury
My review of A Court of Wings & Ruin
My review of A Court of Silver Flames
118 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Court of Frost and Starlight.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 13, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
May 13, 2017 – Shelved
August 13, 2018 – Started Reading
August 14, 2018 –
47.0% "Oh my god, just LEAVE TAMLIN ALONE already! Hasn't his character been shredded enough from its ACOTAR incarnation?

"
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: cheesy-cheesy-cheesy
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: decimal-pieces
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: guilty-pleasures
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: he-s-so-bad-but-he-does-it-so-well
August 15, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mizuki (new)

Mizuki I don't want any guy to clean me off my mensurational blood or anything....it's just gross........well.....unless said guy and I are both in the mood of vampiric blood play.


message 2: by Victoria (new)

Victoria Robinson That much sex damn


♦Carlos_hoyos2707 Jotomei♦ AR My thoughts exactly.


Natalie Monroe Mizuki wrote: "I don't want any guy to clean me off my mensurational blood or anything....it's just gross........well.....unless said guy and I are both in the mood of vampiric blood play."

How very Satanic. XD


message 5: by Ella M (new)

Ella M I am so glad I decided not to read this book. It sounds terrible, and if I had to read about someone cleaning the blood off someone else... blech. Who the heck actually wants that?


message 6: by Mizuki (new)

Mizuki Natalie wrote: "How very Satanic. XD ."

blood play can be sexy too! but not when it is showed under the context of 'oh he is such a great guy he is willing to clean her off' BS.


message 7: by Natalie (last edited Aug 19, 2018 07:55AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Natalie Monroe Ella M wrote: "I am so glad I decided not to read this book. It sounds terrible, and if I had to read about someone cleaning the blood off someone else... blech. Who the heck actually wants that?"

I know, right?


message 8: by Z1 (new)

Z1 Yeesh. But as for holiday episodes in sitcoms, F.R.I.E.N.D.S had the best Thanksgiving ones.


Natalie Monroe Z1 wrote: "Yeesh. But as for holiday episodes in sitcoms, F.R.I.E.N.D.S had the best Thanksgiving ones."

My favorite is one where Ross and Monica play football.


message 10: by Z1 (new)

Z1 OMG YEEEESSSS. But mine would have to be where Chandler finds out that Monica cut his toe off (on accident people) because he called her fat.


message 11: by Hilda (new) - added it

Hilda The whole bashing on Tamlin got very old to me, very quick. It feels bad. They weren’t meant for each other. That’s it. Was he that bad, eh. All’s fair in love and war.


Samantha This review is every emotion and thought I just had in the last few hours. Thank you 🤣


Natalie Monroe Samantha wrote: "This review is every emotion and thought I just had in the last few hours. Thank you 🤣"

<3


message 14: by Caitlyn (new) - added it

Caitlyn Hamilton Me: Oh, now I don't need to worry I'm missing out if I don't buy it!
Me to Me: Read it even though Nat just saved you the trouble


Natalie Monroe Caitlyn wrote: "Me: Oh, now I don't need to worry I'm missing out if I don't buy it!
Me to Me: Read it even though Nat just saved you the trouble"


Hahaha A+ use of meme.


shifu I didn't know whether you would see my reply so here it is:

Honestly by now I am so confused. When I read the book i was astounded as to how she is treating everyone but then some people tell me that she is suffering through PTSD and then i think that her "behaviour" to everyone was okay and it was the result of her trauma.
I think the real mistake is that the author didn't portray her character as she should have. In ACOMAF Feyre was suffering from PTSD but her character still remained likable enough but in this book Nesta is portrayed so badly. I just couldn't like her :( .Even in ACOMAF when Feyre and Rhys go to their house her character reflected her personality and although she said all those things when they are eating but still she wasn't a bitch
But in ACOWAR and ACOFAS her character changed so dramatically from being a likable character to a completely awful person.
Like I said i think the author didn't portray her character as she should have. I honestly liked her but then this happened and now...I don't even know myself how i feel now XD


message 17: by shifu (last edited Jun 28, 2020 08:07AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

shifu And then there is Cassian. . .a reader told me that in ACOFAS he says that he slept with Mor while knowing Az had feelings for her and I am so confused about all of this now.
I don't even know what to believe now XD.
I just hope SJM redeems the perfect character (Nesta) that she created in ACOMAF and for me she utterly destroyed it in ACOFAS. Even though by now the only characters I am excited for are Mor, Lucien and Az.


Natalie Monroe theburqaavenger wrote: "And then there is Cassian. . .a reader told me that in ACOFAS he says that he slept with Mor while knowing Az had feelings for her and I am so confused about all of this now.
I don't even know what..."


Oh God, I'd completely forgotten Cassian slept with Mor. Honestly I think SJM is just so in love with her characters, she makes them perfect and irreproachable lol. I'm hoping Nesta's book does her character service too.


shifu I agree.


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Superb review Natalie �


Natalie Monroe Margaret M wrote: "Superb review Natalie �"

Thank you!


back to top