Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Jola's Reviews > Austerlitz

Austerlitz by W.G. Sebald
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4785895
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: germany, world-war-ii, united-kingdom, london, belgium, czech-republic, prague

The beauty of Austerlitz (2001) is so intense that I had to take breaks while reading it. It was not difficult because almost all the suspense had been killed for me by the thorough summary of the plotline in the introduction by James Wood. Reading prefaces is risky, as it seems. I realize that the plot is not the core of this book but it felt awkward to know exactly what was going to happen. Besides, I would have preferred to compare my own interpretations to James Wood’s, not having his ideas imprinted in my mind from page one.

At first sight, Austerlitz is a story of a man who looks for traces of his lost family and struggles to reconstruct his past. I think it would be easier to enumerate the things this book is not than enlist what it is: a Holocaust testimony, a philosophical treaty on time, an essay on architecture, language, photography, nature and travelling, a fictional biography, a psychological study, a Bildungsroman, a historical fiction, an adoption story, to name just a few. The way the photos converse with the text is astonishing and the fact that they are fictional makes me admire W.G. Sebald’s creativity even more.

As for the protagonist’s surname, I agree with James Wood’s analysis (the battle of Austerlitz --> Auschwitz) but I also thought the fact that Jacques's family name begins with an A and ends with a Z might suggest that the character’s experiences are a summa of many, many others. Austerlitz is akin to Everyman.

When I was reading this novel, I could not stop thinking about the medieval legend of Jew the Eternal Wanderer. Jacques Austerlitz reminded me of the wandering Jew but contrary to Ahasver he was completely innocent. Never at home, always a lonely stranger and foreigner, constantly on the road... On the railroad, to be exact.

The book was so powerful that I expected a more impressive ending. Besides, the credibility of some events felt questionable � I mean the accidental meetings all over Europe. Notwithstanding, this book blew me away. As usual, there is some cost to it. Everything I am reading at the moment seems so bland, so lacklustre compared to Austerlitz.

For me, Austerlitz is the quintessence of my ideal book. An intellectual adventure and an emotional earthquake at the same time. I adore the author's sublime and unobtrusive use of symbols, especially water. The clarity and elegance of his writing style, particularly while discussing complex philosophical topics like the perception of time, were breathtaking also.

W.G. Sebald makes me like the things I usually hate, for instance, battle scenes. The reason why I detest them is not only violence but also my traumatic memories from Tolstoy's War and Peace: the military descriptions there were torturous. But the battle scene à la Sebald was riveting. And his nature descriptions, especially the ones starring light! Just an example: On bright summer days, in particular, so evenly disposed a lustre lay over the whole of Barmouth Bay that the separate surfaces of sand and water, sea and land, earth and sky could no longer be distinguished. All forms and colors were dissolved in a pearl-gray haze; there were no contrasts, no shading anymore, only flowing transitions with the light throbbing through them, a single blur from which only the most fleeting of visions emerged, and strangely—I remember this well—it was the very evanescence of those visions that gave me, at the time, something like a sense of eternity. How I wish I could seep into this landscape and dissolve in it. A lustre lay covers not only Barmouth Bay but Austerlitz too. Immersion in this glow, an iridescent veil of pale, cloudy milkiness, is one of the most stunning things that have happened to me lately.


Landscape with a Wanderer by Eugeniusz Żak, 1916.
74 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Austerlitz.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 23, 2017 – Shelved
May 23, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
January 15, 2023 – Started Reading
January 16, 2023 –
22.0% "I think how little we can hold in mind, how everything is constantly lapsing into oblivion with every extinguished life, how the world is, as it were, draining itself, in that the history of countless places and objects which themselves have no power of memory is never heard, never described or passed on."
January 18, 2023 –
36.0% "In my photographic work I was always especially entranced, said Austerlitz, by the moment when the shadows of reality, so to speak, emerge out of nothing on the exposed paper, as memories do in the middle of the night, darkening again if you try to cling to them, just like a photographic print left in the developing bath too long."
January 20, 2023 –
48.0% "Who knows, said Austerlitz, perhaps moths dream as well, perhaps a lettuce in the garden dreams as it looks up at the moon by night."
January 24, 2023 –
59.0% "When memories come back to you, you sometimes feel as if you were looking at the past through a glass mountain."
January 29, 2023 – Finished Reading
February 11, 2023 – Shelved as: germany
February 11, 2023 – Shelved as: world-war-ii
February 11, 2023 – Shelved as: united-kingdom
February 11, 2023 – Shelved as: london
February 11, 2023 – Shelved as: belgium
February 11, 2023 – Shelved as: czech-republic
February 11, 2023 – Shelved as: prague

Comments Showing 1-36 of 36 (36 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Orsodimondo Capolavoro!


Jola Caro Orso, hai ragione! Lo amo a tal punto che penso di razionarne la lettura, perché quando lo finirò, ci sarà un abisso. 😢 Molto probabilmente avrò problemi ad apprezzare altri scrittori per un po'. Succede sempre quando adoro un libro così tanto.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Sono d'accordo con voi. Un capolavoro.


Jola Sono felice di sapere che anche tu sei una fan, cara Adina.


message 5: by Lyn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lyn Elliott A wonderful review, Jola.


message 6: by Diane (new) - added it

Diane Barnes Fantastic review!


message 7: by Paula (new)

Paula Mota Thank you for this luminous review, dear Jola. This one has been on my TBR for 3 or 4 years but I always buckle when I'm about to grab it. It sounds a bit intimidating, I confess! Most prefaces should be afterwords and that's how I treat them. Perhaps I'll lose some context when I read them at the end, but I don't want somebody telling me the story or pointing me in a specific direction.


Emilio Berra Dalla tua bella recensione emerge il grande apprezzamento verso questo libro.
Ormai Sebald è entrato nella cerchia dei miei scrittori preferiti.


Jola Dear Lyn, so happy you liked it. I found the book absolutely amazing, one of the best I've ever read.


message 10: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Diane, thanks a lot for your kind words. I hope to explore other books by Sebald soon.


message 11: by Jola (last edited Feb 11, 2023 09:40AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Paula, my copy has been waiting to be read much longer than yours. I was scared of disappointment but it was a mistake: the book is much better than I expected. I'm so glad you are considering making acquaintance with Sebald! No reason to feel intimidated at all. The first book by him I read was The Emigrants and it was an excellent prelude to Austerlitz. If you happen to have the same edition of Austerlitz, please, not for all the world read James Wood's introduction before you finish the novel. I promised myself to never read prefaces first, even if they look totally innocent at first sight. 🙂


message 12: by David (new) - added it

David What serendipity, Jola. The name Austerlitz keeps coming up in Les Miserables. I am not that familiar with Napoleonic history and I kept thinking that there is a book with this title. I was going to look it up when I saw your review (and a very fine one). I too am not fond of battle scenes as there are about Waterloo in Les Miserables. This book sounds powerful. I love the image by Zak.


message 13: by Fran (new)

Fran Brilliant review, Jola!


Kalliope This is the only Sebald I have read. Interesting your comparing it with the Wandering Jew.


message 15: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Caro Emilio, grazie mille per il tuo generoso commento. Il primo libro di Sebald che ho letto è stato Gli emigrati e mi è piaciuto così tanto che è bastato per aggiungerlo al pantenone dei miei scrittori preferiti, esattamente come hai fatto tu. Austerlitz conferma che è stata la decisione giusta. Sono molto felice di sapere che tu condividi il mio entusiasmo per questo autore, veramente eccezionale.


message 16: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear David, I appreciate your kindness. Fingers crossed the battle scenes in Les Miserables are much more emotionally engaging than the ones in War and Peace which tested my patience brutally. I appreciate Tolstoy's knowledge of military issues but felt overwhelmed by all the details. I hope Hugo's take on this is much more impressive.


message 17: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Fran, thanks a lot. So glad you enjoyed it. I have the impression my words are just a pale shadow of what I really felt while reading this stunning book but I'm happy they resonated with you.


message 18: by Jola (last edited Feb 11, 2023 11:21PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Kalliope, I don't have much comparison because I read only Austerlitz and The Emigrants but found both outstanding and can't wait to embark on other books by Sebald. I already have a very good feeling about them. As for the Wandering Jew, the association was truly obtrusive. I read this legend when I was about 6-7 years old, it was one of the stories in a collection of tales from different parts of the world for children (which now I find quite strange because it's a very bleak and depressing legend) and I remember how heartbroken I felt after reading it. Not sure if it was Sebald's intention but Austerlitz's constant travels reminded me of Ahasver's loneliness, homelessness and neverending wanderings.


message 19: by Maryana (new) - added it

Maryana Brilliant review, dear Jola! Happy to hear that Austerlitz was such an immersive reading experience. After The Emigrants, I'm already dreaming about my next Sebald.

Ah, introductions - those impostors! I couldn't agree more with you, it's better to read them after finishing a book (sometimes I skip the blurbs for the same reason). Unless it's an Introduction written by the author and is an important part of the book, of course.

I didn't know about the legend of the Wandering Jew, your intriguing reminiscence seems to make so much sense in the context of this novel. I'll look it up, thank you!


Emilio Berra Jola wrote: "Caro Emilio, grazie mille per il tuo generoso commento. Il primo libro di Sebald che ho letto è stato Gli emigrati e mi è piaciuto così tanto che è bastato per aggiungerlo al panten..."

"Gli emigrati", dunque. Bella segnalazione.


message 21: by Marc (new) - rated it 5 stars

Marc Great review, Jola, of a truly great book! Indeed, it has a mesmerizing quality putting everything next to it in the shadow. I was struck by your reference to the Wandering Jew; it only supports the view that 'Austerlitz' has the quality of becoming an everlasting classic. Thanks for stressing this.


message 22: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi What a stunning review of a book I feel I must read, Jola! This sentence of yours sums up what I find to be the most sublime of reading experiences: "An intellectual adventure and an emotional earthquake at the same time." Yes, please! I'd like one of those :)


Violeta For me, Austerlitz is the quintessence of my ideal book. An intellectual adventure and an emotional earthquake at the same time.

I absolutely agree with your definition of the ideal book, Jola! This is a truly wonderful review, full of good points and astute observations. "Austerlitz" was a powerful reading experience for me too, and I sit here trying to remember why I gave it a 4, instead of a 5, when I was massively rating my library upon joining GR.
As you point out, the credibility of some events was questionable, but a historical account was not the scope of the book. Sebald asked of his readers to follow him on a journey through time and place with a certain amount of intellectual surrender and trust, not in the accuracy of the means, but in the nobleness of the end they served. He won my trust early on but when you raise the stakes it's very, very difficult to meet the expectations created in the process.

My copy of the Greek edition has the same cover as yours, but lacks the introduction. From what you say, it was better that way since I dived into the book, having absolutely no idea of its direction. I have his The Rings of Saturn waiting on the shelf for some years now, but I've been shying away from another dive/surrender into Sebalad's universe. Your thoughts have inspired me enough to start considering it, thank you!


message 24: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Maryana, thanks so much. When I was reading Austerlitz, I often wondered if you would enjoy it and I think it is highly probable. 🙂 I think The Emigrants we both read and loved is a wonderful preparation for this feast. You are so right about the immersive experience, the world sort of stopped existing when I was following Austerlitz's steps all over Europe guided by Sebald.

You are right about introductions. I'm aware James Wood's intentions were good, he tried to be helpful but got carried away. From now on, I will read the preface after finishing the book. The problem is I may forget to do it afterwards feeling relieved/unhappy/heartbroken about the finale. 😇

As for the legend, I remember it from my childhood. I had a strange collection of fairytales from different countries � as an adult, I'm surprised some of them were recommended for children then. Quite unsettling and depressing.


message 25: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Caro Emilio, spero che ti piacerà, se un giorno lo leggerai. È diverso da Austerlitz ma anche indimenticabile.


message 26: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Marc, your words made me very happy. Unfortunately, the shadow is affecting all the books I'm reading now, nothing compares to the beauty of Austerlitz. Being a huge admirer of your historical knowledge, I'm really happy you found my association with the Wandering Jew legend worthwhile. I hope to delve deeper on this trope. As for an everlasting classic, I couldn't agree more.


message 27: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Candi, thanks a bunch for your generous comment. I have an inkling you might be enchanted by Austerlitz also if you reach for it someday. For me the two elements of a perfect book I mentioned are inseparable. If only my brain is involved, the impact is not so big although I appreciate the author's intellect of course. Let's hope for many spellbinding combinations like this.


message 28: by Jola (last edited Feb 13, 2023 04:25AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Violeta, your comment means such a lot. Thank you. A great point that historical accuracy wasn't Sebald's priority in this book. Austerlitz has a parable vibe to it so time and place shifting was kind of justified, although felt odd sometimes. I also wondered about the financial aspect of Jacques and the narrator's constant travels and the amount of free time they had, being employed as academics, but it's nitpicking considering how breathtaking this novel is. So happy to know you were saved from the massive spoiler exposure in the introduction. I checked The Rings of Saturn and it definitely looks promising! I'm looking forward to meeting the lonely eccentrics mentioned in the blurb.


message 29: by Ilse (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ilse Dear Jola, thank you for writing such a marvellous, brilliant piece on a book that resonated so strongly with me it brought me to do something I had never done before: buying the book as soon as I had to bring the copy I read back to the library, keeping it on the nightstand for years just to savour a few sentences from it to close the day, as if it were a bible. I lost count how many times I revisited it but I see another time coming because of your review. I entirely understand how next reads simply pale with Austerlitz still on your mind. I also loved how your review echoes Sebald's poetry:

Glass in hand
They come and go
Stop still and expect
The metamorphosis of hawthorn
In the garden outside

Time measures
Nothing but itself.



message 30: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Ilse, I'm thrilled to know Austerlitz resonated with you significantly. So wonderful to know you share my enthusiasm. To be honest, I'm glad I'm not a writer � after finishing this novel I'd be too intimidated to write anything new, I guess. Austerlitz should have a warning label: not recommended for authors. 😀 And by the way, now I realize how many of them borrowed Sebald's ideas and used them in their works.

Thanks for sharing Sebald's absolutely beautiful poem! It left me speechless. Apropos his poetry, yesterday I had a look at his collection and this is the first poem I came across:

For how hard it is
to understand the landscape
as you pass in a train
from here to there
and mutely it
watches you vanish.


Feels a bit like Austerlitz in a pill.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Beautiful review. Just as the novel.


message 32: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Reading about your 'immersion' in this book is stunning in its own way, Jola. Isn't it in the hope of such immersion moments that we keep selecting new authors and more and more books? When one of us finds one, it's an event to be celebrated!
I had a little Sebald season before I joined goodreads and this was one of the titles I read. I haven't forgotten it but I just might revisit it one of these decades.


message 33: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Adina, thanks so much. It was a great pleasure to discover that you were enraptured by Sebald's novel also.


message 34: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear Fionnuala, you are so kind. It was full immersion indeed which resulted in problems with the ascent.🙂 I should probably read something completely, completely different for a while to avoid comparisons. I wish these immersion moments happened more often but on the other hand, maybe I wouldn't appreciate them as much as they deserve then. If you decide to revisit Sebaldia in the future, I have a hunch it won't be a regrettable decision.🙂


message 35: by lethe (new) - added it

lethe I've also learned the hard way that introductions should be read last. They should really be outroductions, or be preceded by a clear spoiler warning.

Great review, you've made me curious!


message 36: by Jola (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jola Dear lethe, sorry to hear you've had similar adventures with introductions. In my case, this is not the first time and I'm the one to blame because I could have already drawn some conclusions. 🙂

I'm so happy I piqued your interest! I hope you will satisfy your curiosity and give this bewitching novel a chance someday.


back to top