Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Praveen's Reviews > The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson

The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson by Emily Dickinson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
19760612
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: american, poetry

When I hoped, I feared
Since I hoped, I dared!


I realized for a moment with a great sense of sadness that from now on, whenever I decide to read a famous poet for the first time, I must keep myself free from any prejudice and presumption. I had heard that she was regarded as a transcendentalist as far as the major themes in her poems were concerned. I do not know, from where I got this notion, I probably learned it from some of the early articles, I read about her poems somewhere. How authentic was that source?
I never checked! And meanwhile, I never got time to read her, verifying such presuppositions.

I'm Nobody! Who are you?
Ar you--Nobody--Too?


Transcendentalism is certainly present there, but I also found commonplace innocence along with that profound sapience and susceptibility for Life, Love, and Death in her poetry. She has also written on various subjects like trains, shipwreck, surgeons, contract, lost jewel, etc. But she has filled those ordinary looking stuff around, with the fragrance of her craft and sensitivity.

Surgeons must be very careful
When they take the knife!
Underneath their fine incisions
stirs the culprit,- life!


She herself has claimed that she has her phrases for every thought, but she confessed her limitations as well.

I found the phrase to every thought
I ever had, but one;
And that defies me,- as a hand
did try to chalk the sun


While I was reading this bulky volume, I felt in the beginning as if I were getting acquainted with a young girl, who did not want to disclose her sentiments, and who felt irritated and looked sulky when someone read her and tried to empathize with her sensibility. I felt as if she wished to keep herself hidden. But at the very next moment, I felt as if she were daring me to explore too, proving my thoughts wrong about her hesitancy, telling me how audacious her approach was.

Who never climbed the weary league-
Can such a foot explore
The purple territories
On Pizarro's shore?


Her poems on nature, love, and life are extraordinarily beautiful and touching. Her sensibility in writing about hope and hunger, about life and death, about exploring and returning is just wonderful.

Tomorrow night will come again
Weary perhaps and sore
Ah, bugle, by my window
I pray you stroll once more!


She has scrutinized almost everything. Her subtle observation enlarged my common sense. There were four- liners giving a sound imprint to my sensibility and then there were beautiful longer poems taking me to her world of imagination giving an impression of her vision. She was humorous at times and expressed herself lightly as well, but she never looked futile. She maintained the depth and gravity every time.

I heard that though she lived a secluded life, she was never disappointed with life. I think she might have been an extremely sensitive introvert who invaginated her sentiments from the world and then from within her, came out such beautiful and impressive rhymes and verses, which made her readers feel instantly connected to her.

I am so pleased and joyous reading her and having filled myself with such unique and exotic poetry of this poetess that I am going to visit her poetic world again and again.
That’s a promise!

The soul unto itself
Is an imperial friend,-
Or the most agonizing spy
An enemy could send
111 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 28, 2017 – Shelved
May 29, 2017 – Started Reading
June 20, 2017 – Finished Reading
April 3, 2021 – Shelved as: american
April 3, 2021 – Shelved as: poetry

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ilse (new)

Ilse Lovely write-up, Praveen. There is a recent film about her life ().


Dolors Absolutely gorgeous write-up that makes justice to Emily's powers of observation. You've read her poetry with careful attention and it shows in every line of this fantastic review. Thanks for this refreshing glance into Emily's "fairer house than prose".


message 3: by Ivana (new)

Ivana Books Are Magic I do like Emily's poetry. It is not the most beautiful, complex or profound poetry I've ever read, but it is so unique...her poetry is (or seems to me) very individualist, and special in the sense that it is very peculiar....she does have a particular style...her poetry is a world in itself and I do like the originality of it all...Truth be told, I was never quite sure I understand the meaning of most of her poems but I like them nevertheless.


Praveen Ilse wrote: "Lovely write-up, Praveen. There is a recent film about her life ()."
Thanks Ilse :)
Its wonderful to know about that.. this would be interesting to watch.thanks for sharing!


Praveen Dolors wrote: "Absolutely gorgeous write-up that makes justice to Emily's powers of observation. You've read her poetry with careful attention and it shows in every line of this fantastic review. Thanks for this ..."

Thanks Dolors! For your kind comment..it was my first encounter with her and I was truly impressed. Great style !


message 6: by Arah-Lynda (new)

Arah-Lynda Simply beautiful Praveen. Thanks so much for sharing your experience as well as Emily's poetry.


Alan I don't get where you're quoting from--surely not Johnson, this edition. It's "I'm Nobody! Who are you?/ Ar you--Nobody--Too?" Very important to keep her idiosyncratic punctuation, especially dashes, which apparently signalled certain vocal usage. Her VOICE is improtant--see my teacher's , Archibald MacLeish's "The Private World." You might also enjoy Diorector James Wolpaw's "Loaded Gun" biopic for NPR, with me in it as a Poetry Villain.


message 8: by Josh (new)

Josh Anderson Any idea where one could watch that, Alan? PBS' site says the tape is unavailable :(


Alan Josh wrote: "Any idea where one could watch that, Alan? PBS' site says the tape is unavailable :("

It's out on CD, so some libraries must have it. Worldcat lists 117 libraries with it:



Praveen Ivana wrote: "I do like Emily's poetry. It is not the most beautiful, complex or profound poetry I've ever read, but it is so unique...her poetry is (or seems to me) very individualist, and special in the sense ..." Thanks for sharing your thoughts on her poetry Ivana!
I very much agree with what you say, she is unique and her style I also found very different. But one thing was sure that she touched me :)


Praveen Arah-Lynda wrote: "Simply beautiful Praveen. Thanks so much for sharing your experience as well as Emily's poetry."
My pleasure Arah-Lynda! Its always wonderful to have your comment!:)


Praveen Alan wrote: "I don't get where you're quoting from--surely not Johnson, this edition. It's "I'm Nobody! Who are you?/ Ar you--Nobody--Too?" Very important to keep her idiosyncratic punctuation, especially dashe..."
Only an expert like you can point out those technicalities Alan!
Thanks for reading and pointing out the important mistake I made! I know these idiosyncratic punctuation and dashes are undivided part of her style. Thanks again !


Praveen Alan wrote: "I don't get where you're quoting from--surely not Johnson, this edition. It's "I'm Nobody! Who are you?/ Ar you--Nobody--Too?" Very important to keep her idiosyncratic punctuation, especially dashe..."
But I cant imagine you as a poetry villain ! :) what is that ????


message 14: by B. P. (new) - added it

B. P. Rinehart One of my top poets, very underrated! I wish she wasn't taught in schools because it undermines the genius of her craft. Same with John Keats.


message 15: by Josh (new)

Josh Anderson Alan wrote: "Josh wrote: "Any idea where one could watch that, Alan? PBS' site says the tape is unavailable :("

It's out on CD, so some libraries must have it. Worldcat lists 117 libraries with it:
...."

Thanks Alan! I will put in a request! I love projects like this.


Praveen Ken wrote: "One of my top poets, very underrated! I wish she wasn't taught in schools because it undermines the genius of her craft. Same with John Keats."
Great Ken.. knowing that she comes on top rungs for you as well..I never read her in school.. I think you are right it requires a certain maturity level to feel essence of her verses !


Praveen Elyse wrote: "Beautiful Praveen.

I have a new interest in reading some of the poems now myself.

Paul and I have been watching a wonderful series called Dickinson�
It’s based on Emily Dickinson’s life.
Very..."

Great to know that Elyse, This review was written by me when I read her poems for the first time, last year I bought one of her small hardcover collections, and it felt really nice reading her poems on paper.
'series called Dickinson' must have been a treat.


back to top