Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Dolors's Reviews > Hunger

Hunger by Knut Hamsun
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: read-in-2017
Read 2 times. Last read August 5, 2017.

What is it that differentiates dignity from stubbornness?
Moral rectitude from pride?
Attitude. Intention. Motivation.
Knut Hamsun’s autobiographical novella explores the tenuous line that separates the iron will from the almost obsession of an aspiring writer who refuses to give way to the silent pressure of a dehumanized society that insists on nullifying his efforts to earn his living through his writing.

The protagonist is a nameless narrator who seldom raises sympathy from an estranged reader because he seems to be the source of all his misery and keeps on refusing help that is not merited by what he considers honest means � in his standards, composing high quality articles.
Such apparently scrupulous moral values collide violently with the fastidious nature of this dubious individual. He is vengeful, arrogant and self-righteous; a narcissist, a masochist who grovels in self-pity one moment and is inexplicably ecstatic the next, spurred by his unappreciated worthiness as an artist of the word. Is it delusion or outstanding genius that rules his erratic actions?

Presented in four fragmented chapters, the dramatic spectrum of Knut’s setting contrasts with the acerbic humor displayed by the unattractive narrator, and there is a cyclical pattern in the manifestations of both shown always in the same order: jocularity that go hand in hand with relative economic stability at the beginning of each section and a galloping downfall towards uttermost penury that almost ends by the protagonist’s death from prolonged periods of starvation to close each part.
Kristiana, the Norwegian city, opens and closes the story and remains the impassible spectator of the tribulations of this individual and the silent prosecutor of his fate, echoing authors like Rodenbach, Camus or Kafka who depicted alienation amidst an indifferent society using the modernistic hues of symbolism, surrealism and existentialist doctrines.

At the end of the last chapter, the reader has followed the histrionic ups and downs of a man who has stopped being ashamed of his poverty, a man who has suffered a subtle but ongoing transformation and defeated his physical needs, his craving for acceptance and social recognition. He always arrives late, the clock mocks him, but he tries and tries and tries again, almost in Sisyphean effort. Extreme hunger hasn’t killed him, cold and permanent dampness hasn’t frozen his spirit, repeated rejection hasn’t diminished his self-esteem. Contrarily, the extremity of his degradation has given free rein to his creative drive, and the hunger to write, the lust to compose is what has kept him alive, what has finally set him free.

I stare at the cover illustration of my edition, Edvard Munch’s “Anxiety�, and ponder about the real horrors of existence. It might be better to embrace loneliness as one of the predominant states in human nature than to sell one’s soul for the superficial acceptance of the faceless multitude that silently marches off towards the comfortable palace of invisibility. But, is it?
150 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Hunger.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 29, 2017 – Started Reading
July 29, 2017 – Shelved
July 29, 2017 –
page 32
13.33% ""Autumn had arrived, that lovely, cool time of year when everything turns color and dies.""
August 1, 2017 –
page 145
60.42% ""Then a drowsy calm came over me, a pleasant fatigue which I did nothing to resist. The darkness had become thicker now, and a light breeze ruffled the mother-of-pearl of the sea.""
August 3, 2017 –
page 197
82.08% ""The hardships had got the better of me, they had been too gross; I was so strangely ruined, nothing but a shadow of what I once was.""
August 3, 2017 – Finished Reading
August 5, 2017 – Started Reading
August 5, 2017 –
page 240
100.0% "And off he goes...to other shores, forever hungry, but with his soul intact."
August 5, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Teresa Dolors, I am so glad you mentioned its "acerbic humor" and "jocularity". I found that too during my read, but have seen no one else mention it, so thought maybe something was 'wrong' with me. ;)


message 2: by Ed (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ed An excellent and thoughtful review, Dolors. You outline a number of intriguing themes. I am planning to read this book next year. I've noticed that tastes tend to be split on Hamsun's writing, so I'm glad you enjoyed it.


message 3: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl Ah, the thin line between delusion and artistic stubbornness. It's always the concoction of several components that makes the true renegade, isn't it? Society says no to outside-of-the-box thinking, distant-star dreaming, so of course I love when writers paint the visuals clearly through prose. Thanks for another fascinating and thought-provoking look at a unique book, Dolors.


Dolors Teresa wrote: "Dolors, I am so glad you mentioned its "acerbic humor" and "jocularity". I found that too during my read, but have seen no one else mention it, so thought maybe something was 'wrong' with me. ;)"

Oh Teresa, I am glad you also picked that humorous, self-deprecating vibe in this story. I did find many of the narrator's remarks rather funny, even though the situation was extreme. In a way, the casual tone of the narrative voice feeds Hamsun's disregard for mainstream thinking.


Dolors Edward wrote: "An excellent and thoughtful review, Dolors. You outline a number of intriguing themes. I am planning to read this book next year. I've noticed that tastes tend to be split on Hamsun's writing, so I..."

I have become quite a fan of Norwegian literature myself, Edward. Not sure it's an acquired taste, but there is certainly a mixture of dissafection, quirky humor and melancholy that speaks to me. I hope you will find as many things to ponder in this thought-provoking novella as I did, so I will be heedful of your next reading choices. Thanks for taking the time to read.


Dolors Cheryl wrote: "Ah, the thin line between delusion and artistic stubbornness. It's always the concoction of several components that makes the true renegade, isn't it? Society says no to outside-of-the-box thinking..."

You express it beautifully, Cheryl. This is exactly what Hamsun intends to denounce in this book, which is partly biographical (and all the more shocking!). That hazzy line between obsession and genius that in many cases defines the artistic drive. This was a challenging read, quite raw, but with plenty of food for thought about the many ways in which we can defy a society that annhiliates the uniqueness that we are born with.
Thanks for taking the time to read, it's always a pleasure to read your comments.


Violet wells I read this years and years ago and your review brought back memories. It's stayed with me more than most books but perhaps less than a handful of others.


message 8: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Such an intriguing and gorgeous write-up, Dolors - I have only read Pan and Victoria by Hamsun so far, which both enthralled me, so Hunger is one I really look forward to read too. Maybe odd, but your reflections on the protagonist bring Dostoesky's narrator from Notes from Underground, wandering the streets, to mind...


Dolors Violet wrote: "It's stayed with me more than most books but perhaps less than a handful of others. "

That's a very spot-on remark, with which I will probably identify some years from now, Violet.


message 10: by Dolors (last edited Oct 25, 2017 06:29AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Ilse wrote: "Such an intriguing and gorgeous write-up, Dolors - I have only read Pan and Victoria by Hamsun so far, which both enthralled me, so Hunger is one I really look forward to read too. Maybe odd, but y..."

That's is a fine connection, Ilse! Dostoevsky's underground man has much in common with this nameless protagonist, the main difference is that Hamsun's anti-hero focuses his obsessions over the creative process as some kind of manifesto against a society that marginalizes those who approach life differently.
How great that you mention other books by him, I had Mysteries and Victoria as possible candidates to continue exploring Hamsun's works. I just added Pan: From Lieutenant Thomas Glahn's Papers to the list.
Thanks for taking the time to read and to kindly comment, as you always do, Ilse.


Betsy Robinson I had this on my to read list already. Now I'm really curious. Thanks for a thought-provoker of a review, Dolors.


message 12: by Caterina (last edited Oct 25, 2017 07:53AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Caterina Thoughtful and discerning review, Dolors -- it sounds like a book that would create an intense tension in the reader because of the nature of the protagonist. He immediately brought to mind Dostoevsky's Notes from Underground (and I see that Ilse had the same thought!) and to some degree, Raskolnikov from Crime and Punishment, in his intellectual arrogance and extreme poverty. In my view this attitude creates a false "heroic artist against the world" dichotomy. He sees himself as a hero but perhaps he's just a jerk. I've come to believe that there is no such thing as a "faceless multitude." If he stopped regarding himself as better than others and started getting to know others and listening to them, he might see their dignity and humanity to which he is now blind, and they might mutually lift each other up. Like you I have doubts about this romanticized myth of the lone wolf starving artist.


Dolors Betsy wrote: "I had this on my to read list already. Now I'm really curious. Thanks for a thought-provoker of a review, Dolors."

Thanks to you for reading, Betsy. I feel like dissenters are trendy nowadays...they are more needed than ever, even if they are deeply flawed, as it's the case for this nameless narrator...


Dolors Caterina wrote: "Thoughtful and discerning review, Dolors -- it sounds like a book that would create an intense tension in the reader because of the nature of the protagonist. He immediately brought to mind Dostoev..."

Brava for that response, Caterina! You list many valid point and raise pertinent questions about the dilemmas presented in this controversial novella. The writer depicted in this story (supposedly a slightly altered version of Hamsun in his youth) believes himself above the mundanity of others, and in it's preciley this heighty attitude that brings him much misery and isolation. In fact, he bumps into a handful of people who treat him with kindness, but his pride prevents him from accepting what he describes as their "guilty charity".
On the other hand, the book is an honest account on the limits an artist might go to release their creative drive, and the obssessive tendencies of those who live in their minds rather than in the more material reality of their surroundings.
A good, if sometimes also exasperating, read... you draw finely connections, so I guess if you found some worth in Dostoevsky's dubious heros, you might also find something to like in Hamsun's novella.
Thanks for the stimulating comment, Caterina!


message 15: by Waqas (new) - added it

Waqas Jani I had this book on my radar since your reference in our recent discussion. This excellent review further consolidates the deal. Thanks for such stimulating and insightful impressions. Much to glean from your mastery over Scandinavian literature!


message 16: by Cecily (new)

Cecily Intriguing - the review and, evidently, the book.

"What is it that differentiates dignity from stubbornness?"
At the risk of sounding glib, perhaps it's whether or not you agree with the person?

Your final paragraph... I hope the horrors of existence march off to invisibility.


message 17: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala I find that I rely on the authors I read for pictures of the past rather than on history books. Oslo in those years will always be Hamsun’s version. Thanks for letting me revisit his Kristiania and the strange lives he creates around it in your elegant company, Dolores.


Dolors Waqas wrote: "I had this book on my radar since your reference in our recent discussion. This excellent review further consolidates the deal. Thanks for such stimulating and insightful impressions. Much to glean..."

Oh Waqas, I don't feel at all in command of the vast and thrilling world of Scandinavian literature, that's why I want to keep exploring more books and new authors. I recall our recent dicussion, indeed, which gave me a new angle to re-think this novella. Thanks for taking the time to read and to comment, as you always do, Waqas!


Dolors Cecily wrote: "Intriguing - the review and, evidently, the book.

"What is it that differentiates dignity from stubbornness?"
At the risk of sounding glib, perhaps it's whether or not you agree with the person?

..."


Heh, that is a fairly good response, but I am afraid it wouldn't suit this narrator, Cecily. He doesn't seek approval or to agree with anybody, he acts as he considers he has to, out of... dignity or stubbornness? Maybe he is trying to convince himself.
And I join you in your wish, Cecily... may we seem them gone never to disrupt the few years we have in this world...


Dolors Fionnuala wrote: "I find that I rely on the authors I read for pictures of the past rather than on history books. Oslo in those years will always be Hamsun’s version. Thanks for letting me revisit his Kristiania and..."

It's funny that sometimes the past mingles with the present, because there is still something of Hamsun's Kristiana in contemporary authors like Per Petterson. Literature is a marvelous (and rewarding) way to broaden our limited horizons, isn't it. Thanks for stopping by, Fio.


Steven Godin Splendid review Dolors. I must read this again as don't remember much the first time around.


Dolors Steven wrote: "Splendid review Dolors. I must read this again as don't remember much the first time around."

That's the dilemma, isn't it? Re-read great books or keep seeking greatest ones by authors we are unfamiliar with...
Thanks for checking this out, Steven.


message 23: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia Cachia This review is making me want to read this book, -and anything by the author, with more urgency.


message 24: by Silvia (new) - added it

Silvia Cachia I will be attentive, and see if I get that humorous vibe in the book. I don't know if I will "like" this book, according to how you describe the author and protagonist, but it is intriguing.


message 25: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Fabulous, Dolors! My experience is that the acceptance of the faceless multitude makes you feel more lonely than quiet solitude ever could.


Lostaccount Great book. Read it years ago and it's still with me. One day I'll read it again.


Dolors Silvia wrote: "I will be attentive, and see if I get that humorous vibe in the book. I don't know if I will "like" this book, according to how you describe the author and protagonist, but it is intriguing."

Thanks for taking the time to read, Silvia! If you have responded to authors Dostoyevsky or Kafka, I have the feeling you will also connect with Hamsun's anti-hero. I will look forward to your updates and wait to see if you detected that "humorous" vibe!


Dolors Lisa wrote: "Fabulous, Dolors! My experience is that the acceptance of the faceless multitude makes you feel more lonely than quiet solitude ever could."

Oh yes, Lisa, you are so right... My own experience too. Even though sometimes one craves company for the sake of avoiding repetitive patterns of thinking...


Dolors Lostaccount wrote: "Great book. Read it years ago and it's still with me. One day I'll read it again."

I might do the same, Lostaccount. Thanks for taking the time to read and to comment.


Seemita Stellar review, D. Absolutely smashing and enlightening at the same time. I sensed an urgency in your review, a voice too overwhelmed to narrate what she is narrating and in the course, telling us things unadulterated, unhindered. My reading of this book is still very fresh even though it has been a while since I closed the book and gave it a place in my treasured collection. Hunger colliding with existence, ambition with esteem, eccentricity with realization and masochism with creative freedom - all this made this work so compelling, so formidable. Thank you bringing back the pertinent questions of existence to the fore with your unwavering, incisive pen and dispatching me onto another journey of thoughts.


Dolors Manuel wrote: "Dolores, you perfectly captured the spirit of the novel. It's an immense
achievement to write about hunger from the psychological side (Orwell did it from the sociological side in Down and Out in P..."


Thanks for enlarging the picture and offering context to this unsettling piece of work, Manuel. You capture the ethos of this anti-hero and Hamsun's sharp-edged style with amazing precision, and link them to other artists, adding nuance to Hamsun's interpretation of the world.
I was shocked when I read the blurb of Hamsun's biography and discovered what you display in your comment, and as it often happens (quite recently with Ezra Pound), I tried to read the book disentangling any notion about the personality or political preferences of the writer to appreciate his oeuvre as it deserved.
Thanks again for another meaningful, rich comment that sends me off to the weekend with a satisfied smile.


Dolors Seemita wrote: "Stellar review, D. Absolutely smashing and enlightening at the same time. I sensed an urgency in your review, a voice too overwhelmed to narrate what she is narrating and in the course, telling us ..."

Oh Simi, reading your thoughts on any piece of writing is always sheer bliss. You expose the dichotomous nature of this novel so adroitly, highlighting the extremety of the situtions depicted in the story, while preserving their mysterious beauty, a beauty that sometimes borders a kind of crazed purity, a purity that calls out to the conflicted nature of this poor devil, Hamun's creature, his "underground man".
I recall your stupendous review as it served me to finally push the buy-button and get a copy of this book. So a double thanks, one for your steadfast support and invaluable presence, and another for having ensured that I finally got around to reading Hamsun!


message 33: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav A marvelous review, Dolors, filled with so many insights! The themes which you address in the review marks the real existence of a man- as you mentioned the difference between rectitude- pride and dignity- stubbornness. The paragraph about freedom is simply uplifting since you quite aptly mentioned that when a man comes out veneer of his consolations and accept his true existence, however absurd it my be, that is when he actually sets himself free. However, that could be a dangerous situation- as you mentioned in the concluding paragraph- as Kafka said in his famous quote (I am cage in search of bird) that when your soul gets free of all false references it may go insane merely due to anonymity as we also find it the short story- The Hunger Artist- by Kafka. Thanks for this truly enriching review :)


message 34: by Debbie (new)

Debbie Another thought-provoking and beauteous review. I am very curious. Thanks for making me want to look at this one.


message 35: by Dolors (last edited Oct 28, 2017 11:25AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Gaurav wrote: "A marvelous review, Dolors, filled with so many insights! The themes which you address in the review marks the real existence of a man- as you mentioned the difference between rectitude- pride and ..."

Thanks to you for this enriching comment, Gaurav. As you point out, Hamsun brings up the dilemmas of freedom vs ideals, creativity vs superficiality and solitude vs mainstream thinking by presenting a man who won't give in to the requirements of a society that he doesn't feel part of. Kafka is the perfect reference to put into context the delusory vibes of this man's journey into the pit of utter destitution. Nevertheless, according to Hamsun, it's when the body is at its limit that the mind is given free rein to soar cloud high in terms of artistic output; whereas in Kafka, art is a let-out to the insufferable greyness of reality... quite similar approaches but not completely in tune.


Dolors Gaurav wrote: "A marvelous review, Dolors, filled with so many insights! The themes which you address in the review marks the real existence of a man- as you mentioned the difference between rectitude- pride and ..."

Oh Debbie, thanks so much for taking the time to read, to understand my meandering thoughts and for taking an interest in this author! :)


Samra Yusuf tremendously beautiful,once again! the very first question you address till the last word,I am in awe of your erudition..You write with so much authority and calmness over such complex emotions,I can not say for sure that I would embrace loneliness,but I am certain of the fact that,acceptance holds peace!
you made my day,Dolors!
(wasn't able catching up soon to this beautiful write up,been superbusy in what seems endless chaotic lofe:(


message 38: by Deea (last edited Oct 29, 2017 10:23AM) (new)

Deea This novel seems quite depressing. I don't know why, but it gave me the feeling that it is so very depressing before I've even read anything about it at all. I remember that Henry Miller's main character from Sexus (a book that I considered quite brilliant) was obsessed with Hunger and this made me want to read Hamsun's novel at some point. You make a very good job of reviewing the novel and I particularly liked the conclusion which makes one ponder.


message 39: by flo (new) - added it

flo Ah, I've been putting this book off for quite some time and for different reasons. Naturally, finding out about the acerbic humor of the narrator - despite the extreme circumstances - is definitely one of the factors that would help me find the courage to tackle this short yet (I assume) incredibly powerful story. Your delicious prose encapsulates the reasons I should be reading this at some point; the analysis of different dualities, creativity as a means to freedom, etc. A big and profound "et cetera".
Thanks for another magnificent review. :)


message 40: by Ray (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ray Superb review, thought provoking and full of insight into what is a very powerful book.

Have you read any other Hamsun books? Wayfarers and The Wanderer are well worth a read, amongst others.


Dolors Samra wrote: "tremendously beautiful,once again! the very first question you address till the last word,I am in awe of your erudition..You write with so much authority and calmness over such complex emotions,I c..."

Oh Samra, you are such a generous friend, thanks so much for reading and for finding time to come back to my musings and post such an enthusiastic comment. I am not so sure about my erudition, I am as full of doubts as I have ever been, but writing them out on a page seems to ease my disquiet, and so I am so rewarded that some others might find them useful to some extent!
Thanks again for your beautiful friendship and for your constant, steadfast encouragement, they mean the world to me and I don't take them for granted.


Dolors Deea wrote: "This novel seems quite depressing. I don't know why, but it gave me the feeling that it is so very depressing before I've even read anything about it at all. I remember that Henry Miller's main cha..."

You caught the vibes perfectly, Deea. This is a disquieting, even depressing novella. So one needs to be in a specific frame of mind to approach it. The writing is not overly convoluted, so at least, it's easy to read, if not to digest.
I still have to read Henry Miller, he is one of those authors I have always kept in the periphery of the main nucleus of my to-read authors list, maybe I should put amends to that...
Thanks for stopping by and brightening up my afternoon, dear Deea!:)


Dolors Florencia wrote: "Ah, I've been putting this book off for quite some time and for different reasons. Naturally, finding out about the acerbic humor of the narrator - despite the extreme circumstances - is definitely..."

Thanks to you for taking the time to read, Flo. Oh well, I believe you would recognize that self-effacing humor and be reminded of Dostoyevsky, whom I know you are fond of. There are many parallels between this novella and his underground man. The Norwegian laureate brings up the most refined philosophical quandaries about the nature of creativity and the dividing line between body and mind. I would surely bask in your thoughts if you decided to write them after reading this one Flo... Maybe when things get calmer at your end! :)


Dolors Ray wrote: "Superb review, thought provoking and full of insight into what is a very powerful book.

Have you read any other Hamsun books? Wayfarers and The Wanderer are well worth a read, amongst others."


Many, many thanks for your kind words, Ray.
This was my first Haruf. I have "Mysteries", "Victoria" and "Pan" lined up as next reads, but I will hastily add the titles you suggest. Thanks a great deal.


Dolors Marita wrote: "Dolors, somehow your beautiful review didn’t make it into my updates. Just as well that I decided to visit your profile page."

Thanks so so much for taking the time to pay a visit to my profile, Marita!


s.penkevich Fantastic review! 'the extremity of his degradation has given free rein to his creative drive' SO well put! Yes. I think about this novel often, this has inspired me to probably read it again. Wonderful review as always!


back to top