Jaline's Reviews > The Hush
The Hush (Johnny Merrimon, #2)
by
by

We did have a couple of glimpses into magical realism in The Last Child. Remember the tree? The eagle? Remember Levi and how the doctor could not make sense of the X-rays? Just tiny glimpses, but they were there.
In The Hush, there is no avoiding magical realism. The story also moves into supernatural elements that challenge the majority of the key characters in this book � and many other secondary characters. Suspicions lead to superstitions lead to unexplainable supernatural phenomena.
For some people such as law enforcement and professional trackers, the desire is for known reality to take the bite out of fear of the unknown. This leads to more conflict, hardships, and even deaths.
There is a crossover in this novel into fantasy that I recognized from the days when I read that genre a lot. Instead of slipping a ring on a finger and disappearing into another world, (The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant, the Unbeliever) in this book it is as simple as walking into a vast swampland known as The Hush.
Whether The Hush allows entry or instead confuses trails and pathways and direction and terrain depends on who is going there. Since Johnny Merrimon lives within The Hush and has used gunfire to scare off intruders before, suspicion falls heavily on him when people start showing up dead. Even though, or possibly especially because it is Johnny who finds them and reports their deaths.
I had a bit of a problem with Johnny in this book. In The Last Child, what was endearing and brave for a 13-year-old becomes a tad annoying and irksome in a 23 or 24 year old. A pee contest with a Sheriff trying to get information was not helpful - even though Johnny knew the consequences and knew he would not handle those consequences well. Also, at one point Johnny was having far too much fun watching from a distance and chuckling as people were floundering in the swamp � lost, terrified, being eaten alive by mosquitoes and not knowing how to get out of there. I also questioned why he put up barriers between himself and Jack when it was obvious that of anyone Johnny knew, Jack would be the one to understand. These are minor irritants but I was hoping for a bit more nobleness of character from Johnny.
I do confess that although I am not a huge fan of magical realism nor of fantasy any more, those elements � and even the supernatural ones � were well done. This book would not have existed without those features because it was based on the histories of the families who came before (Johnny’s ancestors and their slaves) and how certain incidents and influences of those times tracked through decades to converge in the present � and why.
There is a lot of darkness in this book, and even though their friendship is tested severely, Johnny and his best friend Jack Cross (now a lawyer) add some light and hope.
I didn’t love this book but I also didn’t hate it. It was well-written (other than Johnny’s behaviors fairly early on) and full of suspense. For those who want more involvement in Johnny Merrimon and Jack Cross� lives and adventures straight up, this is likely not the best choice. However, I can definitely recommend this to readers who enjoy magical realism mixed with fantasy and supernatural � I think it would definitely appeal.
In The Hush, there is no avoiding magical realism. The story also moves into supernatural elements that challenge the majority of the key characters in this book � and many other secondary characters. Suspicions lead to superstitions lead to unexplainable supernatural phenomena.
For some people such as law enforcement and professional trackers, the desire is for known reality to take the bite out of fear of the unknown. This leads to more conflict, hardships, and even deaths.
There is a crossover in this novel into fantasy that I recognized from the days when I read that genre a lot. Instead of slipping a ring on a finger and disappearing into another world, (The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant, the Unbeliever) in this book it is as simple as walking into a vast swampland known as The Hush.
Whether The Hush allows entry or instead confuses trails and pathways and direction and terrain depends on who is going there. Since Johnny Merrimon lives within The Hush and has used gunfire to scare off intruders before, suspicion falls heavily on him when people start showing up dead. Even though, or possibly especially because it is Johnny who finds them and reports their deaths.
I had a bit of a problem with Johnny in this book. In The Last Child, what was endearing and brave for a 13-year-old becomes a tad annoying and irksome in a 23 or 24 year old. A pee contest with a Sheriff trying to get information was not helpful - even though Johnny knew the consequences and knew he would not handle those consequences well. Also, at one point Johnny was having far too much fun watching from a distance and chuckling as people were floundering in the swamp � lost, terrified, being eaten alive by mosquitoes and not knowing how to get out of there. I also questioned why he put up barriers between himself and Jack when it was obvious that of anyone Johnny knew, Jack would be the one to understand. These are minor irritants but I was hoping for a bit more nobleness of character from Johnny.
I do confess that although I am not a huge fan of magical realism nor of fantasy any more, those elements � and even the supernatural ones � were well done. This book would not have existed without those features because it was based on the histories of the families who came before (Johnny’s ancestors and their slaves) and how certain incidents and influences of those times tracked through decades to converge in the present � and why.
There is a lot of darkness in this book, and even though their friendship is tested severely, Johnny and his best friend Jack Cross (now a lawyer) add some light and hope.
I didn’t love this book but I also didn’t hate it. It was well-written (other than Johnny’s behaviors fairly early on) and full of suspense. For those who want more involvement in Johnny Merrimon and Jack Cross� lives and adventures straight up, this is likely not the best choice. However, I can definitely recommend this to readers who enjoy magical realism mixed with fantasy and supernatural � I think it would definitely appeal.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Hush.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-50 of 51 (51 new)
message 1:
by
Melissa
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Jul 25, 2018 05:10PM

reply
|
flag

You did a marvelous job with your review, Melissa! This was definitely not what I envisioned, either, but - I had to give John Hart props for blending those "out there" genres together so well. I didn't particularly like it (the dropped star was for that and Johnny's behavior in the earlier parts), but it was done well so I didn't feel right about dropping more than the one star.
I also agree with you that this was a big risk to take for a sequel because the fact remains: some folks are solid, down-to-earth thriller and suspense fans while others are fans of magical realism, fantasy, and/or supernatural. I don't think we all appreciate being lumped together like this! hahaha



Thank you so much for taking time to comment, Lindsay! I am okay with some magical realism (Alice Hoffman is an example) but this one veered heavily into the mix with fantasy and supernatural so I'm still a bit boggled. 😊💕

Thank you for your comment, Meredith! I completely understand that it isn't for everyone. It wasn't the best fit for me, either, but I'm not a complete stranger to the various genres John Hart merged here. I think Johnny's antics bothered me more - hahaha


Thank you so much, Kimber! Do keep in mind, though, that it's not just magical realism - there is fantasy and supernatural involved, too. I'm not sure if the blend enhanced this book or detracted from it. :)




I hope you enjoy it if you get a chance to read it, Pear! It is definitely different! :)

That is definitely the wisest course, Julie. Maybe it will work out really well for you! Thank you for your kind comment! :)

Thank you so much, Kris! The two books are like day - and then night. Literally :)

Thank you, Mackenzie! It's okay because I have had a long run of very impressive reads. This one was impressive, too - it just wasn't the best fit for me. And the one I'm reading now is really good! :)

I wanted to love this one, too, Kendall but it definitely wasn't the best fit for me. I still appreciated John Hart's writing - except for making Johnny somewhat of a jerk in the earlier parts :)

Beautifully said, Jennifer - and your thoughts have my vote, for sure!! Thank you for your great comment! :)


Well, aren't you just awesome, Kristin! Thank you so much!! I can handle some magical realism (i.e., Himself; as well as most of Alice Hoffman's books), but this one stretched the boundaries with the blend of fantasy and ultra-supernatural in the mix. It was actually kind of close to the edge of horror. 😎

It works both ways, my friend! Your reviews have helped me with many selections, too! 😘


It works both ways, my friend! Your reviews have ..."
Yay! And yes it does :)


Thank you so much, Melissa, for your kind and generous comment! :)

Thank you so much, Jan - and I know exactly what you mean. To be honest, I'm not sure if I could have made up my mind to read this (knowing what I know now) had I not been so intent on finding out what happens with Johnny Merrimon after the first book. In an odd sort of way, I am glad I read it - sort of like diving into a pool without knowing if the water is freezing or not, being relieved that I survived the jump - and the temperature wasn't quite as bad as it might have been. 😉

Thank you so much, Norma! I really enjoyed your review of this, too - especially because it was a Traveling Sister review and discussion! :)


I know exactly what you mean, Antoinette! I have enjoyed certain books that have magical realism threaded through, but this was a pretty big helping! Still, it did enrich the story and I'm very glad I read it! :)


hahaha - "irksome Johnny", for sure. He does sort himself out later on, and maybe he didn't even bother anyone else. I was mostly disappointed that with all the maturity he displayed at 13, ten years later he acts like a child in spots. Thank you, Victoria, for reading my review and for your great comment. I hope I can borrow your pause button if/when I need it! ;)

Thank you, dear Cheri!! (Is that like saying, 'dear Dear'?? :)


Thank you for your kind and generous comment, Paula! Even though I don't read magic realism very much, I have definitely dipped my toes from time to time - and I have loved it: Himself and Tomorrow are two relatively recent examples. As you said in the Comments of your review for this one - it's wonderful when an author can lead us where we might not otherwise go. 😊

Thanks all for waving your feathers, and help me avoid a book with a bunch of crows hovering over my head.


Will have to give this book further consideration. Glad you and many others have enjoyed it.
