ŷ

Kevin Ansbro's Reviews > The Dry

The Dry by Jane Harper
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
43579369
's review

liked it
bookshelves: doesn-t-live-up-to-the-hype, family-dynamics, thriller

I was drawn to this arid Australian crime thriller by a desert storm of five-star reviews, not to mention the fact that this was The Sunday Times Crime Book of the Year.
᳾�
*Folds his arms and sighs*
I'm not saying that this was a bad book � it was OK � though the storyline (for me) was flat, improbable, slow-paced and bereft of suspense.
Apart from that, it was fine!

Bland federal agent, Aaron Falk, returns to the small Outback town of his childhood for the funeral of his best friend (and also his best friend's immediate family) and is drawn into an unofficial investigation as to how they really met their deaths.

Here is a list of just some of the things that niggled me:

1) The book is titled The Dry. It's set in the swelter of the Outback in the middle of the worst drought to hit Australia in a century. Yet I didn't get any real sense of the suffocating heat, nor do I remember flies being swatted from any number of sweaty faces.

2) Aaron Falk is in town and just happens to be on the financial intelligence side of criminal investigation (how very convenient for the purpose of the story).

3) The dialogue was unconvincing. I mean, don't rough, tough, leather-necked Aussie men in the middle of the Outback ever use the f-word? I know Crocodile Dundee didn't, but come on!

4) I guessed who the killer was the moment he/she was introduced! As subterfuge goes, that's pretty average.

5) I found it difficult to connect with any of the characters; most were portrayed as small-minded and insular.

So, for me (and I seem to be swimming against the tide), this novel was several shrimps short of a barbie. But almost everyone else likes it, so please, please don't take a blind bit of notice of anything I've said!
450 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Dry.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 25, 2018 – Started Reading
January 27, 2018 – Shelved
January 27, 2018 – Shelved as: doesn-t-live-up-to-the-hype
January 27, 2018 – Shelved as: family-dynamics
January 27, 2018 – Shelved as: thriller
January 27, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 249 (249 new)


message 1: by Glenn (new)

Glenn Sumi LFMAO at “Apart from that it was fine.� Hilarious. No, seriously, great points, especially 1, 3 and 5. Which all seem pretty essential for good fiction. I will avoid this one. And I LOVE that you have a shelf called “doesn’t live up to the hype�!!! Good idea.


message 2: by Glenn (new)

Glenn Sumi Oops. That should me LMFAO of course.


Kevin Ansbro Glenn wrote: "LFMAO at “Apart from that it was fine.� Hilarious. No, seriously, great points, especially 1, 3 and 5. Which all seem pretty essential for good fiction. I will avoid this one. And I LOVE that you h..."

Glenn, your esteemed presence is always welcome in my ŷ drawing room (I'm like Elizabeth Bennet waiting for Mr Darcy to pop round).
And doesn't everyone have a 'doesn't live up to the hype' shelf?
; )


Kevin Ansbro Glenn wrote: "Oops. That should me LMFAO of course."

Ha! Yes, Glenn, I've just realised the ramifications of deciphering LFMAO!!
Seems to me to be a physical impossibility, but I'm sure someone's given it a go! : )


message 5: by Jo (new) - added it

Jo I rather cleverly gifted this to my crime buff sister at Christmas so that she can do the heavy lifting for me and I can make my decision off of hers. I don’t have high hopes from your review Kevin and thanks for going against the tide, overwhelming praise does get a bit claustrophobic!


Kevin Ansbro Jo wrote: "I rather cleverly gifted this to my crime buff sister at Christmas so that she can do the heavy lifting for me and I can make my decision off of hers. I don’t have high hopes from your review Kevin..."

Thanks, Jo!
This book is indeed overwhelmed by praise, but I just don't get it.
I'm beginning to wonder if I've somehow found myself in a parallel universe!


message 7: by Julie (new)

Julie G “Apart from that, it was fine!� Ha! As much as I like listening to most Australian men talk, I think I’ll take a pass on this crew.


Kevin Ansbro Julie wrote: "“Apart from that, it was fine!� Ha! As much as I like listening to most Australian men talk, I think I’ll take a pass on this crew."

G'day, Julie! ; D
As I said, my opinion seems to be antithetical. This is a very popular book, so what do I know?


message 9: by Adrian (new)

Adrian I listened to the (UK) Radio 4 production of this book last year, it was excellent


Kevin Ansbro Adrian wrote: "I listened to the (UK) Radio 4 production of this book last year, it was excellent"

Thanks, Adrian. I should've done that instead! : )


RM(Alwaysdaddygirl) Mahalo for your honest and in depth review! I do not understand how some folks see this as five stars. Each their own.


message 12: by Kevin (last edited Jan 27, 2018 10:26AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kevin Ansbro RM(Alwaysdaddygirl/Salemwitch) wrote: "Mahalo for your honest and in depth review! I do not understand how some folks see this as five stars. Each their own."

I just don’t get it either.
Thank you for reading my review!


Sarah I liked your review Kevin. It made me smile. Everyone can't agree on the same things always. Not even books. That's ok, the way I look at it. Kind of like when I wasn't impressed with The Atonement. Egads !! What is wrong with me ?


Kevin Ansbro Sarah wrote: "I liked your review Kevin. It made me smile. Everyone can't agree on the same things always. Not even books. That's ok, the way I look at it. Kind of like when I wasn't impressed with The Atonement..."

It’s all good, Sarah. : )
ŷ wouldn’t work as a concept if we all agreed.
That said, I was amazed by how many people have raved over this!


Cathrine ☯️ Kevin, I really don't appreciate your dry tone and the fact that you revealed the sex of the killer. Why are men always thinking about sex! Other than that, a really fine review. 🤪


Kevin Ansbro Cathrine ☯️ wrote: "Kevin, I really don't appreciate your dry tone and the fact that you revealed the sex of the killer. Why are men always thinking about sex! Other than that, a really fine review. 🤪"

Ha! You are so right, of course, Cathrine.
Me and my one-track mind! : D
I'll make the sex of the killer more ambiguous, changing it to he/she.


Melanie Love your review Kevin! I own this one so I hope I enjoy it more than you did. PS...I am going to add a " doesn't live up to the hype" shelf.


message 18: by Cecily (last edited Jan 27, 2018 01:30PM) (new)

Cecily The Sunday Times - that's your problem. A tabloid in all but paper size and a first cousin of Fox fake news.

(view spoiler)


Canadian Jen Lol I did enjoy this one more than you, Kevin - enough shrimps for me- but you make some valid points!


Cheri Terrific review, Kevin, I really loved this for the atmosphere, the setting, the mood it created 0 for me, anyway. Like most novels, not for everyone, but I'm sorry it wasn't a better one for you!


Carol I loved this candid (and entertaining) review, Kevin.


message 22: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline Awesome review, Kevin - insightful and incite-full. I haven't read this yet and will probably let it sit for a while longer. Maybe the flies will come out and the Aussie men will start f-bombing the flies! 😉


Vanessa I gave it a 5, but you’ve almost convinced me I’ve overrated it! Excellent review.


message 24: by Nat (new)

Nat K Maybe there were no flies being swatted due to a liberal dose of Aeroguard??? Enjoyed your review Kevin, keep swimming against the tide!


Kevin Ansbro Melanie wrote: "Love your review Kevin! I own this one so I hope I enjoy it more than you did. PS...I am going to add a " doesn't live up to the hype" shelf."

I'd be interested to see what you make of it, Melanie (could you nudge me when you've read it?).
Mine appears to be the minority view, so you may well love it!


message 26: by Kevin (last edited Jan 28, 2018 12:00AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kevin Ansbro Cecily wrote: "The Sunday Times - that's your problem. A tabloid in all but paper size and a first cousin of Fox fake news."

Ha! Thanks, Cecily!
I find myself shouting that whenever Trump appears on TV..
"Fake nooz, fake nooz!"
; D


message 27: by Kevin (last edited Jan 28, 2018 12:04AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kevin Ansbro Jen wrote: "Lol I did enjoy this one more than you, Kevin - enough shrimps for me- but you make some valid points!"

Thanks, Jen.
I was gobsmacked when I read it (after reading all the rave reviews). So many things niggled me, even down to a gravestone appearing on a recently-dug grave! That wouldn't happen, they would have had to allow the earth to settle first!
Grrrrr *much gnashing of teeth*


Kevin Ansbro Cheri wrote: "Terrific review, Kevin, I really loved this for the atmosphere, the setting, the mood it created 0 for me, anyway."

Thanks, Cheri.
I had high hopes, after a plethora of five-star reviews.
Still, my view is a minority one. : )


Kevin Ansbro Marita wrote: "Good review, Kevin. My feelings about this book were pretty much the same."

Thank you, Marita! The voice of reason! : )


Kevin Ansbro Carol wrote: "I loved this candid (and entertaining) review, Kevin."

Thank you so much, Carol!


Kevin Ansbro Kimber wrote: ""Apart from that, it was fine!" Ha! Love this line.
Your reviews are very entertaining! : )"


And you are always too kind. Thanks, Kimber! : )


Kevin Ansbro Jaline wrote: "Awesome review, Kevin - insightful and incite-full. I haven't read this yet and will probably let it sit for a while longer. Maybe the flies will come out and the Aussie men will start f-bombing th..."

I would love for you to read this, Jaline, to see it through your eyes.
I'm still baffled by all the rave reviews!


Kevin Ansbro Vanessa wrote: "I gave it a 5, but you’ve almost convinced me I’ve overrated it! Excellent review."

Thanks, Vanessa!
I'm saying nothing! ; )


Kevin Ansbro Nat wrote: "Maybe there were no flies being swatted due to a liberal dose of Aeroguard??? Enjoyed your review Kevin, keep swimming against the tide!"

I was swatting away a swarm of incredulity for much of this read, Nat. Thank you for your kind comment! : )


Bianca Sorry, it didn't work for you. Book of the year - definitely not. Not bad for a debut thriller. If you didn't care for this one, don't read the follow-up, as it's slower.


Kevin Ansbro Bianca wrote: "Sorry, it didn't work for you. Book of the year - definitely not. Not bad for a debut thriller. If you didn't care for this one, don't read the follow-up, as it's slower."

Oh, God, a follow-up?
Wake me up when it’s over.
Thanks, Bianca! : )


Bianca That's how it works: if something is popular, more often than not, there's a follow up, especially if it's a thriller, romance or fantasy.


message 38: by Angela M (new)

Angela M Kevin , I don’t read thrillers but I do read your reviews . Nice one as always!


Kevin Ansbro Bianca wrote: "That's how it works: if something is popular, more often than not, there's a follow up, especially if it's a thriller, romance or fantasy."

I knew there was a follow-up, Bianca. I was larking about as usual.
; )


Holly  B (slower pace!) I do agree with you Kevin...I thought it was just me.


message 41: by Robin (new)

Robin I find that it’s the very rare thriller that succeeds in thrilling me, unfortunately. Few stand up to critical analysis, as much as I wish it were otherwise! Great review. There are flies in the desert.


Kevin Ansbro Angela M wrote: "Kevin , I don’t read thrillers but I do read your reviews . Nice one as always!"

Thanks, Angela! The feeling's mutual, you know how much I love your empathetic reviews.


Kevin Ansbro Holly wrote: "I do agree with you Kevin...I thought it was just me."

Holly, your excellent review was spot-on.
You are not alone! : )


message 44: by Carol (new)

Carol Thanks for reassuring me that I can miss this one. Points 1 and 3 would have particularly irritated me, which is no way to spend one's reading time.


message 45: by Kevin (last edited Jan 28, 2018 05:49AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kevin Ansbro Robin wrote: "I find that it’s the very rare thriller that succeeds in thrilling me

Me also! And a crime thriller without a twist ... well, it's ... it's ... criminal!
Thanks, Robin.


message 46: by Kevin (last edited Jan 28, 2018 05:49AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kevin Ansbro Carol wrote: "Thanks for reassuring me that I can miss this one. Points 1 and 3 would have particularly irritated me, which is no way to spend one's reading time."

Thanks, Carol.
Point 3 was particularly annoying.
Here's an excerpt lifted straight from the book. An Outback barman talking to the main protagonist... try not to laugh.
"It's all right, mate. You can untwist your knickers. Your money is as good as the next man's and that's good enough for me."

Really? How stilted is that? I mean, what the heck?


PorshaJo Great review Kevin! I kept grabbing this one, thinking I must be missing something due to all the 5 star reviews. But i just wasn't ready to read it when I had it. Wasn't grabbing me. Your review was perfect as now I know I need to stop worrying about it and just skip it. Sorry it didn't work better for you. And Ha! Crocodile Dundee - crikey!


Kevin Ansbro PorshaJo wrote: "Great review Kevin! I kept grabbing this one, thinking I must be missing something due to all the 5 star reviews. But i just wasn't ready to read it when I had it. Wasn't grabbing me. Your review w..."

Thanks, PorshaJo!
Despite being underwhelmed, I still want others to read it because I'm intrigued as to why a book this lame can command such high praise! As with Lincoln in the Bardo, I'm baffled.


Marialyce I didn't like the first book and through your review, I have no interest in the second book.


Kevin Ansbro Marialyce wrote: "I didn't like the first book and through your review, I have no interest in the second book."

Can’t say I blame you, Marialyce. : )


« previous 1 3 4 5
back to top