Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Cecily's Reviews > The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter

The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter by Carson McCullers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1199525
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favourites, miscellaneous-fiction, classics, usa-and-canada, historical-fict-20th-cent

Like most of McCullers stories, this is concerns lonely people living in the deep south. This one is set during WW2, told with strong musical currents (she had a place to study piano at the Julliard, and this shines through most of her work) and a radical passion against poverty and injustice.

The language is generally quite simple in terms of vocabulary and sentence length, yet the characters and events are all the more poetic and vivid for this apparent simplicity - a difficult literary trick to pull off.

The main character is John Singer, a deaf mute. Biff Brannon (café owner), Jake Kelly (migrant mechanic and social activist), Dr Copeland (black doctor and communist) and Mick Kelly (girl of 13-14) all attach themselves to Singer, who is of course, the perfect listener for their varied troubles and a blank canvas for them to create him as a god-like figure of whatever kind they each want. The main plot is Singer's relationships with the other four (they have almost none with each other). The subplot is a coming of age strand regarding Mick: moving from passionate and ambitious tomboy to frustrated young woman.

Each character who unburdens themselves to Singer thinks they know him and that he is something of a free spirit. None of them know that he is pining for the burden of caring for Antonapoulos, his former flat mate and fellow deaf mute, now in an asylum. In that relationship, Singer did all the talking and assumed that wisdom and empathy came from Antonapoulos, who largely listened. Now on his own, the tables are turned and he is cast in the role of wise listener. Singer's animated hands are redundant for communication - neglected and stuffed in his pockets.

We all need a Singer, but no one wants to be Singer.

All the closest relationships in this story, even amongst the minor characters, are compromised by literal or emotional distance or largely unreciprocated, though the characters themselves are not always aware of this.

As well as sadness, there is often an underlying sense of menace, though when bad things happen, they are often not what you had expected until a page or two before they happened, making them somehow more shocking.

Overall, a powerful and sad book, yet somehow not a depressing one. Despite much tragedy, there is always a glimmer of hope, arising from love and loyalty (even if it is one-sided).

NB "The Mortgaged Heart" (http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...) includes an author’s outline of this book, which sheds extra light on the story, though some of her preliminary ideas were not in the final book.
102 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 30, 2008 – Shelved
June 9, 2008 – Shelved as: favourites
April 5, 2009 – Shelved as: miscellaneous-fiction
Started Reading
May 23, 2009 – Shelved as: classics
May 23, 2009 – Finished Reading
August 9, 2009 – Shelved as: usa-and-canada
July 14, 2015 – Shelved as: historical-fict-20th-cent

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

doug bowman I really loved this book


message 2: by Mosca (last edited Mar 03, 2013 05:12PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mosca This book is so many, many things, and one of my very favorites.

I am, myself, a native product of the "Deep South". And I feel that very few "Southern" writers capture the thick stew of despair along with intimacy that is Southern life like Carson McCullers. No one matches her frightening insights and terrifying love. She is a tragic jewel.


Cecily McCullers always sounds authentic in my head, but being English, and not having been to the Deep South (let alone in the period she was writing about), I've taken that on trust. It's good to have confirmation.


Mosca I grew up in the small town Deep South of the 1950's. Carson McCullers writes mostly of the small town Deep South of the 1940's. There is not much difference between the very honestly portrayed world of her writings and the world I knew.

She does not exaggerate, nor does she stereotype. She loves the South as much as myself; and she fears it as much.

I'm incapable of selecting my favorite writer; so I have a Top Three. The names alter form and heirarchy over time. But she is always on the list.


Cecily Mosca wrote: "...I'm incapable of selecting my favorite writer; so I have a Top Three. The names alter form and heirarchy over time. But she is always on the list. "

I know what you mean. She probably rarely makes my top three, but she's probably been in my top dozen since I first read her when I was 17 or 18.


Dolors wow! I think I might discovered a good author! Thanks for that review!


Cecily It was the same for me - though I have reread it since, and keep meaning to reread McCullers again.


Cecily One can't read McCullers without being moved.

In a more literal sense, I hope you've recovered from surgery and are moving more easily yourself.


Laysee Great review, Cecily! You conveyed so well the mingling of loneliness, sadness and threat in the world of the lonely hunters. How true that even the closest relationships were marked by physical or emotional distance. Your review helped me to appreciate this book a bit more.


Cecily Thank you, Laysee. It's too long since I immersed myself in McCullers' words.


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

Cecily, I really enjoyed revisiting your excellent review. Seeing your summary helped to sum up my understanding of what McCullers was doing. I hold this book in high regard and your marvelous review makes me itch to re-read it, though I should probably first read some of her shorter works: "Member of the Wedding" and "Ballad of the Sad Cafe."
What a treat to relive the reading experience through your review.


message 12: by Cecily (last edited Dec 15, 2015 05:55AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cecily Thank you for popping by, Steve, and for sharing your love of McCullers. Member of the Wedding was the first of hers I read, when I was still at school, on the recommendation of a friend (still one of my best friends). I'm hard pressed to pick a favourite to reread (but probably not Clock Without Hands), but her name is nearing the top of my TBR pile, so I'll have to pick.

EDIT: Oops, I've realised that Member of the Wedding was my first - but it was on the recommendation of my friend.


message 13: by Greg (new) - rated it 4 stars

Greg Hi Cecily, great review! I just reread this book, and enjoyed it very much. I grew up in the American South and it does seem to me that McCullers gets the culture right for the 1940s. On the other hand, Harper Lee sets her "Go Set a Watchman" in the American South 1950s but it feels, culturally, like a much earlier time.


Cecily Thanks, Greg. I haven't read Go Set a Watchman (and am unlikely to), but it's good to know McCullers got this right.


Pearl I forgot how much the friendship between Antonapoulos and Singer touched me. Between this and Ballad of the Sad Café, Mcullers has such a gift for sifting out the helpless tenderness of human beings. Lovely review. Brought me right back to when I first read it.


Cecily LPG wrote: "...Between this and Ballad of the Sad Café, Mcullers has such a gift for sifting out the helpless tenderness of human beings..."

Indeed she does. Such a loss to the world that she died so young.


Arah-Lynda Great review Cecily. You have captured the loneliness and despair of the novel while still leaving room for the slim light of hope.


Cecily Arah-Lynda wrote: "Great review Cecily. You have captured the loneliness and despair of the novel while still leaving room for the slim light of hope."

Thanks, Arah-Lynda - as was yours. That painful combination of despair and hope is the ostinato of all her writing.


message 19: by Suzy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Suzy I'm so glad I stopped by to read your review of this, Cecily! You captured beautifully what is true about McCullers writing and about this story. I especially like your point early about the simplicity of the writing being what makes this brilliant

Have you seen the movie starring Alan Arkin? From 1968, I saw it when it first came out and have been meaning to view again. I thought it was great.


Cecily Suzy wrote: "I'm so glad I stopped by to read your review of this, Cecily! You captured beautifully what is true about McCullers writing and about this story...
Have you seen the movie starring Alan Arkin?"


You're very kind. Thank you, Suzy. I loved your review, too.

I haven't seen the film. One from that era don't always age well, but if you, as a fan of the book, recommend it, I presume it's worth the watch. Thank you.


message 21: by Suzy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Suzy Cecily wrote: "Suzy wrote: "I'm so glad I stopped by to read your review of this, Cecily! You captured beautifully what is true about McCullers writing and about this story...
Have you seen the movie starring Ala..."


I'm not sure how it will have aged since I haven't seen it in 48 years! But I'm going to see if my library has it and see if it lives up to my memories of it. I think it was Alan Arkin's big breakthrough.


Cecily Suzy wrote: "I'm not sure how it will have aged since I haven't seen it in 48 years!..."

But it's the sort of story that might work even better in a period film than a 21st century one.


Janet M Enjoyed your review. McCullers has been one of my favorite authors since I was a teenager. Will have to find The Mortgaged Heart: Selected Writings; sounds intriguing!


Cecily Janet M wrote: "Enjoyed your review. McCullers has been one of my favorite authors since I was a teenager...."

Ditto! I reread some of hers shorty after joining GR, but should really reread some.

I hope you enjoy The Mortgaged Heart.


Laura A good review, especially the comment - We all need a Singer, but no one wants to be Singer.
And also - All the closest... not always aware of this.
It struck me as a melancholic book, but at the same time as if a pose had been taken. A writer pursuing Her Art.


Cecily Laura wrote: "A good review, especially the comment - We all need a Singer, but no one wants to be Singer...."

Thanks, Laura.

Laura wrote: "It struck me as a melancholic book, but at the same time as if a pose had been taken. A writer pursuing Her Art."

Interesting comment. I certainly think of it as melancholic, and a writer pursuing her art, but as a pose (which sounds less genuine that I think she was).


message 27: by Asma (new) - rated it 4 stars

Asma Great review Cecily!
I haven't read it yet but will read very soon. I think I'll like the language here. Too complicated language is not my thing:)


message 28: by Cecily (last edited Jun 15, 2020 02:36AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cecily Asma wrote: "Great review Cecily!
I haven't read it yet but will read very soon. I think I'll like the language here. Too complicated language is not my thing:)"


Thanks, Asma. The language is fairly plain, but used to great emotive effect. A very book, and although the setting is a world away from Pakistan, I expect many of the underlying themes are universal.

Alternatively, the one of hers I love even more focuses on a girl approaching her teens, The Member of the Wedding, which I reviewed here: /review/show...


H (no longer expecting notifications) Balikov A powerful and troubling book. I appreciate your insights, Cecily.


Cecily HBalikov wrote: "A powerful and troubling book. I appreciate your insights, Cecily."

Troubling, but with hope and beauty too.


H (no longer expecting notifications) Balikov Cecily wrote: "HBalikov wrote: "A powerful and troubling book. I appreciate your insights, Cecily."

Troubling, but with hope and beauty too."


Yes, no doubt of that. Thanks


message 32: by Gogo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gogo Reminds me of the film "The Elephant Man". Most excellent! Rereading after 30 years


message 33: by Cecily (last edited Jan 03, 2021 09:23AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cecily Gogo wrote: "Reminds me of the film "The Elephant Man". Most excellent! Rereading after 30 years"

It's probably 20 years since I saw The Elephant Man, so I'm not sure about the comparison, but it's always interesting to have new connections between works.


message 34: by Gogo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gogo Mr. Singer


message 35: by Gogo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gogo I love this novel! Thank you for reminding me to reread.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Wow. Thanks SO much, Cecily!


Cecily Fergus wrote: "Wow. Thanks SO much, Cecily!"

And thank you, Fergus. I hope you read McCullers and come to love her work.


Kushagri Brilliant review, Cecily! I just finished this book today and it has become one of my all-time favourites. You have wonderfully captured the essence of the novel.
Also, this statement is so true, We all need a Singer, but no one wants to be Singer. . There is this universal longing for someone like Singer, an empathetic listener offering a compassionate and understanding presence in our lives. But there is an inherent reluctance to assume the role of Singer for other, as it comes with burdens of being someone's emotional anchor at the expense of thwarting their own needs and desires.
All the closest relationships in this story, even amongst the minor characters, are compromised by literal or emotional distance or largely unreciprocated, though the characters themselves are not always aware of this.. This is also so true, and it's wonderful how McCullers explores the theme of inherent asymmetry in the relationships.


Cecily Kushagri wrote: "Brilliant review, Cecily! I just finished this book today and it has become one of my all-time favourites. You have wonderfully captured the essence of the novel....
There is this universal longing for someone like Singer, an empathetic listener offering a compassionate and understanding presence in our lives..."


Nowadays, there's the option to pay for it, for those who can afford it, but that didn't occur to me when I wrote the review. A therapist isn't the same as a friend, of course, but that can have advantages: a different sort of asymmetry:
Kushagri wrote: "... it's wonderful how McCullers explores the theme of inherent asymmetry in the relationships"
Thanks, Kushagri.


back to top