ŷ

Dolors's Reviews > The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter

The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter by Carson McCullers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: read-in-2013

“Go, my songs, to the lonely and the unsatisfied,
Go also to the nerve-racked, go to the enslaved-by-convention,
Bear to them my contempt for their oppressors.
Go as a great wave of cool water,
Bear my contempt of oppressors.�


“G�, commands Ezra Pound in his poem “CdzDz� .
And so I obey, and I go.
I go and listen to the mute choir of the lonesome and the restless, of the disinherited and the excluded, of the alienated and the embittered.
Isolated voices withering in despair, wrestling in incomprehension, anguished voices that interweave with each other creating a desolate fugue where only the tuneless can sing.

A nameless mill town in the middle of the deep South during the thirties serves, not only as a background orchestra for these discordant voices, but also as the universal representative of the spiritual solitude that underlines the human condition. Four main characters struggle against different kinds of afflictions depending on race, class, age and sexuality.
Thirteen-year-old Mick Kelly nurtures her passion for music locked in her secret “inside-room�. Mr.Coperland, a colored doctor, tries to control his anger against the submissiveness of his race. Jake Blount, an alcoholic communist wanders from town to town spreading his inner contradictions. Biff Brannon, the owner of the Café, sits behind the booth and observes it all, especially boyish Mick, who seems frozen into eternal youth.
These disconnected individuals, eager to appease their escalating sense of alienation, pivot around John Singer, a deaf mute, whose grey eyes offer mute solace.

“Speak against unconscious oppression,
Speak against the tyranny of the unimaginative,
Speak against bonds.�


ٱ𲹰�, continues Pound’s song.
And speak is what these four rotating “satellites� do while hovering around their beaming sun, their self-created icon, like blind moths being drawn recklessly towards the scorching lightbulb. They all turn to Singer like starving souls, pouring all their turmoil into his opaque face, which looks back with a peaceful glance, a glance that swallows it all. Despair, anger, shame, pain, emptiness. All of them gone, diluted in the indefinite wells of easiness emanating from John Singer’s being, who becomes the so much coveted savior, the embodiment of goodness and empathy, the guardian angel who listens and understands.

“Mick Kelly and Jake Blount and Doctor Coperland would come and talk in the silent room � for they felt that the mute would always understand whatever they wanted to say to him. And maybe even more than that.� (87)

But does Mr. Singer really hear the uneasy songs of his faithful “disciples�? Can he fully grasp the implications of their vivid speech? Oh, the talking. Isn’t all the talking less about communicating rather than unburdening oneself? Isn’t the soul after all, as Virginia Woolf said, a “wedge-shaped core of darkness� ? Something invisible to others?
For what these lost souls don’t know is that Mr. Singer wanders the night as the most lonely of them all, imagining the face of his friend, his lover, the face of his only reason to keep on moving, his only reason to be.
Love, even when seemingly directed at another, is often a form of egoism.
What is then, the adored one?
Only a blank canvas on to which anything can be painted, only a shallow mirror reflecting whatever is wished. As in a chimerical fantasy, these off-balance voices, enraged by events, at once bruised and musing, fixate on the make-believe scene they create in their locked minds and think they live, cheating themselves.

“Oh how hideous it is
To see three generations of one house gathered together!
It is like an old tree with shoots,
And with some branches rotten and falling.�


As the trees in Ezra Pound’s poem, the condemned, the voiceless and the rejected stand staring at the abyss of their own incomprehension, in a world hovering on the edge of a Great War. Some will fight their loneliness with violence and depravity, some with sex or drink, and some � like Mick � with a quiet but fierce resolution to keep the beauty of Beethoven’s (also a deaf) “EǾ� engraved in the most recondite part of her soul.
But mostly, they will be suspended in uncertainty, swaying between radiance and darkness, between bitter irony and faith, between music and silence; eternally bend in a double-edged posture where empathy can be corrosive as well as liberating, where one can imagine the other as a melody of life, or as McCullers appears to be saying, as a melody of death.

“Wonderful music like this was the worst hurt there could be. The whole world was this symphony, and there was not enough of her to listen.� (107)


Note: I have had the pleasure to read this novel at the same time that my friend Tej and his criss- crossed comments and kind encouragement have made of this novel an even more intense reading experience. Thanks for sharing and building expectations along with me, Tej.
85 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter.
Sign In »

Quotes Dolors Liked

Carson McCullers
“Next to music, beer was best.”
Carson McCullers, The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter


Reading Progress

March 21, 2013 – Shelved
September 22, 2013 – Started Reading
September 22, 2013 –
page 41
11.42% ""In his face there came to be a brooding peace that is seen most often in the faces of the very sorrowful or the very wise.""
September 24, 2013 –
page 138
38.44% "Mick listening to Beethoven's Third Symphony:
"Wonderful music like this was the worst of hurt there could be. The whole world was this symphony, and there was not enough of her to listen." "
September 25, 2013 –
page 183
50.97% "" She wanted to kiss him and bite him because she loved him so much." Mick Kelly is killing me softly with her words...killing me softly...."
September 27, 2013 –
page 267
74.37% ""The way I need you is a loneliness I cannot bear""
September 27, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 57 (57 new)


message 1: by Traveller (last edited Sep 29, 2013 01:36PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Traveller What a lovely, eloquent, lyrical review, Dolors!

So glad to be your friend.


Garima Isolated voices withering in despair, wrestling in incomprehension, anguished voices that interweave with each other creating a desolate fugue where only the tuneless can sing.

These words are worthy of a place in the blurb of this book. I was about to say that you have outdone yourself but no! this is what Dolors is. A writer who is constantly and consistently recognizing her talent and obliging all of us to get a glimpse of her beautiful heart. It's pretty late here but I'm thankful to my insomniac tendencies to let me read this stunning piece of writing before surrendering to the world of dreams. Gorgeous review, Dolors dearest.


Paul Great review Dolors


Lela Wonderful review. Love that book!


message 5: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala “Go, my songs, to the lonely and the unsatisfied"

Great idea to build the review of this supremely lonely book around Ezra Pound's words, Dolors.


message 6: by Harry (new)

Harry Dolors wrote: "I have had the pleasure to read this novel at the same time that my friend Tej and his criss- crossed comments and kind encouragement have made of this novel an even more intense reading experience."

And so it is with novels, the more you know of their origins, as with historical art, so the greater is the enjoyment. Sublime, and such a lovely review, Dolors. I wonder were we to catapult your reviews into a time capsule, what future generations might think of us, living in our time. I would think they would say: "what have we missed and what have we lost!"


message 7: by Tej (new)

Tej hovering around their beaming sun, their self-created icon

Ain't we all need that beaming Sun, absorbing it all, basically us.... All the talk of big goals and huge ambitions strike bluntly into a big block of faith, that elicits trust... It might be more important than truth or knowledge, facts and understanding after all... good old ignorance? Don't know, maybe never will know, maybe its never knowable... and lastly, maybe it's better that way? Confusingly doubtful!!!

This book talks of each one of us, I guess...

Piercing in it's simplicity...

It was an emotionally tumultuous read, surely among the best ever, uniquely so... not just read but lived this book with you, Dolors... All I can do is, Thank you, from the core ... :)


Brian God, this is beautiful. Weaving Pound and Woolf into your review is brilliant.

Hats-off to you and Tej for a great tandem read of an amazing novel.


Moira What a great tandem review team!


message 10: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema I couldn't agree more with Garima! Your reviews are beautifully written, Dolors, mixing lyricism with a keen insight. This one is no exception. I also love how you opportunely integrate Ezra Pound's poem into your review.

What is then, the adored one? Only a blank canvas on to which anything can be painted, only a shallow mirror reflecting whatever is wished. Beautifully put and so insightful!

Despair, anger, shame, pain, emptiness. All of them gone, diluted in the indefinite wells of easiness emanating from John Singer’s being, who becomes the so much coveted savior, the embodiment of goodness and empathy, the guardian angel who listens and understands. I thoroughly agree, though I couldn't have said it so well as you did.


Declan I agree with Ema and all of the other people who have commented above: that is an outsanding review. I read this book, and all of McCullers' books - and then the biography The Lonely Hunter: A Biography of Carson McCullers - when I was a teenager and it was 'The Heart...' that I loved most of all. But I've never reread it; half-afraid that I would find that it wasn't as good as I had thought. But I now know, having read your review Dolors, that it is as good as I remember, and that I must read it again.


Samadrita This is a magnificent piece of writing, Dolors.
"A nameless mill town in the middle of the deep South during the thirties serves, not only as a background orchestra for these discordant voices, but also as the universal representative of the spiritual solitude that underlines the human condition." - Now that is a beautiful sentence among many others in this mesmerizing review.

And I love your way of adding sprinkles of poetic and philosophical ruminations by other writers into your reviews. Thanks for the dash of Woolf and Ezra Pound.
I really wish to read this sooner rather than later now.


message 13: by Matt (new) - added it

Matt Stunning. Really. I love how you weave the Ezra Pound in with the book I haven't read (yet) from a writer I'm really starting to appreciate. Kudos!


Kalliope Dolors, I really think your forte is in the lyrical.

I read this years ago, when a friend of mine was unexpectedly struck by a horrible tragedy. Reading this book helped me in trying to share her despair.


Dolors Traveller wrote: "What a lovely, eloquent, lyrical review, Dolors!

So glad to be your friend."


The feeling is more than reciprocated Trav, thank you so much for your comment. I love it when you make an "appearance" ! :)


Dolors Garima wrote: "Isolated voices withering in despair, wrestling in incomprehension, anguished voices that interweave with each other creating a desolate fugue where only the tuneless can sing.

These words are wor..."


Your comment goes straight to my heart, Garima, even more because I know you genuinely mean it. I don't know whether I deserve such praise, but I thank you for your constant and inspiring encouragement. Your comments AND reviews always manage to bring a smile on my face and to warm my heart! :)


Dolors @Paul: Thank you so much Paul, I also read and loved your review.

@Lela: Thanks for taking the time to read and to comment, Lela. Greatly appreciated.


Dolors Fionnuala wrote: "“Go, my songs, to the lonely and the unsatisfied"

Great idea to build the review of this supremely lonely book around Ezra Pound's words, Dolors."


Thanks Fionnuala, there's always a poem hovering around my head...


Dolors Harry wrote: "Dolors wrote: "I have had the pleasure to read this novel at the same time that my friend Tej and his criss- crossed comments and kind encouragement have made of this novel an even more intense rea..."

Thank you so much Harry, your comments are original, indeed they are! The idea of future generations getting to read my clumsy thoughts would have never crossed my mind. I have more than enough with the comments of just a few GR friends, like you, who never fail to encourage me to keep on reading, writing and.... dreaming, of course.


Dolors Tej wrote: "hovering around their beaming sun, their self-created icon

Ain't we all need that beaming Sun, absorbing it all, basically us.... All the talk of big goals and huge ambitions strike bluntly into a..."


Ah Tej, thank you. I see those 5 shinny stars and my heart leaps with joy.
Thank you for your comment and for having shared your own thoughts with me as you advanced reading.

"This book talks of each one of us, I guess..."

Your reflections are spot-on, as usual, my friend. I also thought this novel speaks about all of us and our incapability to understand what goes on in others, especially in those we most love.
One of the aspects that most moved me about the story is the way each character deals with isolation, and I could easily identify Mick's growing passion for music with my passion for literature, especially when I was a teenager.
There's so much packed here...we could speak ages about it, couldn't it?
I will wait now for your review, it'll be mind-blowingly good, I have no doubt. Thanks again, my friend.


Dolors Brian wrote: "God, this is beautiful. Weaving Pound and Woolf into your review is brilliant.

Hats-off to you and Tej for a great tandem read of an amazing novel."


Thank you so much Brian, this coming from you is extra bonus. You are an excellent writer and I have come to really look forward to reading all of your reviews. Thanks again.


Dolors Moira wrote: "What a great tandem review team!"

Thanks Moira, it's been an exciting experience.
I've loved sharing my reading thoughts with Tej. This is what I would most miss if my friends abandoned GR, for GR is the readers, and without them this site would have no soul. My stomach aches only to think of the possibility...


Dolors Ema wrote: "I couldn't agree more with Garima! Your reviews are beautifully written, Dolors, mixing lyricism with a keen insight. This one is no exception. I also love how you opportunely integrate Ezra Pound'..."

Thank you my dearest friend Ema. You are always infallibly kind to me. I can't wait to start that pending joint reading, I'm certain we'll find plenty to discuss about. Oh, the luxury of having literate friends! :)


Dolors Declan wrote: "I agree with Ema and all of the other people who have commented above: that is an outsanding review. I read this book, and all of McCullers' books - and then the biography The Lonely Hunter: A Biog..."

Thank you so much for such a generous comment Declan. This is my first McCullers and I now know it won't be my last. This woman has a gift in painting human landscapes in the most apparently simple colors, but giving them such depth that it's easy to get lost in reverie and wonder. And marvel while wondering.


Dolors Samadrita wrote: "This is a magnificent piece of writing, Dolors.
"A nameless mill town in the middle of the deep South during the thirties serves, not only as a background orchestra for these discordant voices, bu..."


Samadrita, you are the woman whose words burn and sting and move beyond expectations. Thank you so much.
I'm sure you'd love McCullers, there are so many undiscovered authors out there. I can only hope that we have much time to come to be able to discover some of them together! :)


Dolors matt wrote: "Stunning. Really. I love how you weave the Ezra Pound in with the book I haven't read (yet) from a writer I'm really starting to appreciate. Kudos!"

Thanks Matt! I think we have similar reading tastes and I'm sure you'd appreciate both the style and the way McCullers builds her stories. I'll be in the lookout and wait for your impressions if you ever decide to tackle any of her works.


Dolors Kalliope wrote: "Dolors, I really think your forte is in the lyrical.

I read this years ago, when a friend of mine was unexpectedly struck by a horrible tragedy. Reading this book helped me in trying to share her..."

Thanks for your encouragement Kalliope. I don't know if the "lyrical" is my forte, but I surely enjoy lyrical works.
And although this novel wasn't precisely poetic in style, I found there was plenty to inspire me in the story. I believe in the power of the arts, especially of literature and music, to express what's inexpressible. I am glad you were able to share some of your friend's despair through this novel. Yes, as one of my most loved friends said to me, that's the power of literature, to share in spite of time and distance.


message 28: by [deleted user] (new)

Dolors, I echo all the comments above and can only say that you have a true gift for lyrical and empathetic reviewing. I love the way you have mixed Pound with McCullers in a very effective manner. This review is a true blessing.


message 29: by Stephen (new) - added it

Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) "anguished voices that interweave with each other creating a desolate fugue where only the tuneless can sing." How beautiful Dolors and filled with the depth of many layered meanings. I chose this quote but it could truly be said of all parts of this fiercely eloquent review. I think this book provided a means of your expressing your understanding and deep feelings for others. Congrats! Great review!


Dolors Stephen wrote: ""anguished voices that interweave with each other creating a desolate fugue where only the tuneless can sing." How beautiful Dolors and filled with the depth of many layered meanings. I chose this ..."

Thank you so much, Stephen. Your balanced insight never fails to add substance to anything I write.


Dolors Steve aka Sckenda wrote: "Dolors, I echo all the comments above and can only say that you have a true gift for lyrical and empathetic reviewing. I love the way you have mixed Pound with McCullers in a very effective manner..."

"Empathetic" coming from you is the best compliment one could wish for, Steve.
I guess I found much to get inspiration from in the voice of this young but genial woman and I'm happy that something managed to show in my review. Thank you so much for your kind encouragement, it's much appreciated.


message 32: by Tej (new)

Tej Just dropped by to re-read your review, the wish to re-live everything associated with this book is so strong suddenly and it is sort of continuing to grow in my subconsciousness ever since I stopped thinking about it actively! I imagine that the shocking, heart-breaking numbness while finishing it the first time made for a slow percolation....


message 33: by Megha (new)

Megha I am only repeating what everyone has already said, but you have a lovely way with words, Dolors.


Dolors Tej wrote: "Just dropped by to re-read your review, the wish to re-live everything associated with this book is so strong suddenly and it is sort of continuing to grow in my subconsciousness ever since I stopp..."

I know what you mean Tej.
I've been giving the themes treated on this novel some deep thought during this week as well. I even feel like re-writing my review!


Dolors Megha wrote: "I am only repeating what everyone has already said, but you have a lovely way with words, Dolors."

Thank you so so much Megha, for your kind and encouraging comment.


message 36: by Tej (new)

Tej Dolors wrote: "Tej wrote: "Just dropped by to re-read your review, the wish to re-live everything associated with this book is so strong suddenly and it is sort of continuing to grow in my subconsciousness ever s..."

You wrote a beautiful piece already and that reflected your nascent and pure initial reaction... :)
Wonderful as this book was, as others which are, continue growing long after... So you can always add on to what you wrote already, why not?


Dolors Tej wrote: "Dolors wrote: "Tej wrote: "Just dropped by to re-read your review, the wish to re-live everything associated with this book is so strong suddenly and it is sort of continuing to grow in my subconsc..."

Yes, why not?
Although I'm afraid one could enter in a neverending editing circle, for each passing day adds new perspective to anything we read...


message 38: by Tej (new)

Tej Dolors wrote: "Tej wrote: "Dolors wrote: "Tej wrote: "Just dropped by to re-read your review, the wish to re-live everything associated with this book is so strong suddenly and it is sort of continuing to grow in..."

Ya... true, but both of them, old and the new should be kept separate, I don't think that is possible on GR !


Garima Dolors, I reread your review and can't help feeling elated at the wonderful precision and lyricism with which you depicted the gist of this masterful novel. I'm still reeling in the brilliance of Carson's writing and can't thank you enough for sharing your thoughtful views in such an incisive way.


message 40: by Dolors (last edited Dec 05, 2013 07:13AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Garima wrote: "Dolors, I reread your review and can't help feeling elated at the wonderful precision and lyricism with which you depicted the gist of this masterful novel. I'm still reeling in the brilliance of C..."

OH GARIMA! Have you finished already? Oh dear, I can't wait to read your thoughts. Thank you so much for having come back to re-read my attempt to transmit the complexity of humankind that Carson so masterfully portrayed at such a young age. Have you read her biography? Such a harrowing life... yet she managed to produce genial and unprecedented beauty and misery in her novels...Thanks once more for coming back, I don't deserve such good friends! :)


Garima A harrowing life indeed and reading about her makes the whole reading experience all the more sad. I finished it last night or early morning and you can very well imagine how it all conspired into a strangely vivid effect on me. And shh! you very well deserve all the lovely friends you have here.


message 42: by Tej (new)

Tej Garima wrote: "A harrowing life indeed and reading about her makes the whole reading experience all the more sad. I finished it last night or early morning and you can very well imagine how it all conspired into ..."

Vehemently and mmmm.... boisterously second Garima :))


Dolors Tej wrote: "Garima wrote: "A harrowing life indeed and reading about her makes the whole reading experience all the more sad. I finished it last night or early morning and you can very well imagine how it all ..."

And I boisterously second my assessment that you are a gift from heaven. Thank you Tej.


message 44: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King Excellent review Dolors. I've only just seen this as I was looking at Garima's and in so doing came across the reviews of Steve, Richard, Paul, Jennifer, Cecily and...

Obviously a very popular book by the look of things...


Dolors Lynne wrote: "Excellent review Dolors. I've only just seen this as I was looking at Garima's and in so doing came across the reviews of Steve, Richard, Paul, Jennifer, Cecily and...

Obviously a very popular bo..."


Thank you Lynne! This is a very special novel written by a very special writer, I think McCullers' life was even more racking than the ones of the fictional characters of her novels. I do hope you manage to read it some day, it adds new meanings to the word "loneliness".


message 46: by Dolors (last edited Apr 05, 2014 05:25AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Louisa wrote: "I have to say, this is hands down one of the best reviews I've read about this book. *applause*"
Wow Louisa, what a magnificent way to start my day. Thanks a lot, I am blushing with pleasure right now. Thanks for your generous comment! :)


Traveller Okay, wow! Your review shows such wonderful insight in the novel, Dolors! And yes, your Pound quotes are very fitting indeed! I really must read more Pound - I don't really know his poetry...

But yes, as I already said, I agree with your sentiments around Mick, (view spoiler) and you illustrated the ironic paradox at the center of the novel so well...


Dolors Traveller wrote: "Okay, wow! Your review shows such wonderful insight in the novel, Dolors! And yes, your Pound quotes are very fitting indeed! I really must read more Pound - I don't really know his poetry...

B..."


Pound wasn't much likeable as an individual, but his poetry was completely another matter... I will leave you with the intrigue hoping you'll further explore him! :)

Thanks for revisiting my review, which you propelled me to re-read and to discover that I actually used the word "fugue"! :O I even connected the dots with Mrs. Ramsay's "wedge-shaped core of darkness�, so I think our conclusions were pretty similar, don't you think? No good/bad cop this time! *clapping*


Cecily Dolors, this is a beautiful hymn to the musicality of McCullers' words, which in turn is a manifestation of her own musical passion and talent.


message 50: by Debbie "DJ" (new) - added it

Debbie "DJ" Wow Dolors, I know you read this awhile ago, but your review touched my heart. I haven't read this one, maybe it will be the first of the new year. :)


« previous 1
back to top