Kat Kennedy's Reviews > Storm Born
Storm Born (Dark Swan, #1)
by
by

Kat Kennedy's review
bookshelves: books-that-deserve-painful-death, just-plain-bad, kat-s-book-reviews, kat-s-rants
Nov 13, 2011
bookshelves: books-that-deserve-painful-death, just-plain-bad, kat-s-book-reviews, kat-s-rants
Did you hear that sound? That sound, right there? Okay, well, it's either the sound of my heart forsaking Mead for all eternity, or there's a murderer whose broken into your house and is SNEAKING UP BEHIND YOU!!!!!

Look over your shoulder just to check that I'm wrong. You know you want to do it!
Storm Born, the tragic tale of a woman forced by cruel fate to be hit on by ALL the men. Yes. That's what this story is about. Okay, there are fairies and she has to recover some damsel in distress but basically the novel is about Eugenie's love life.
I suppose my problem with Dark Born is that all of Mead's washed up, tried and not-so-true tropes are here. Again. Strong heroine (who will undoubtedly end the series as a complete moron), sexy hero who heroine loves, though nobody really knows why. Secondary sexy love interest who is way more awesome than sexy hero and who Mead spends far more time fleshing out a real relationship with the heroine, but who is apparently not the heroine's twue loff. For reasons completely unknown. I will inevitably like this love interest far more than the banal and boring love interest Mead champions.
The one thing I'll say about this novel is that Mead writes good sex. That's her one redeeming virtue. She writes gripping, interesting characters, a rich world and stories that hint at great possibilities, but Mead absolutely sucks at the follow through.
The difference with this novel is that I'm not interested in following through to watch her crash and burn yet another series. This novel reminded me of a quote by Dan Hemmens from Ferretbrain.
"Rape is not the occupational hazard of having a vagina."
Thank you.
Now I'll address the fictional critics in my head by saying that yes, Mead gave all these douches a reason to rape the protagonist that wasn't just about sex. But... well, it just doesn't count and I'll explain why.
I don't know about you, but *I* am personally sick of stories that tell me that because I have a vagina, I am a walking talking victim waiting to happen. Because novel after novel tells the same story. No matter how strong, powerful or kickarse you are as a heroine, you are still a victim and will need to be rescued by a man. Possibly several times.
I'm sick to death of it. Barely a page goes by in this book where rape isn't mentioned. Even if it's just to say, 'Eugenie, you're so beautiful I'd rape you and LIKE it!"
This book almost treats rape like a fucking compliment. "I've had five rape attempts today, what about you?" "Oh, I've had three." "Oh, I'm so sorry to hear that. Don't worry, maybe tomorrow will pick up!"
I have a problem with drilling into people's heads that women are victims. Always. Vulnerable, precious little petals. Don't let them out of the house or they'll trip over their puritanical vaginas and get raped. Or what about a message just as bad? Almost all men will rape if given the chance. It's the rare few who won't take the opportunity for a good ol' free for all on an unwilling woman.
Now hold on for an even bigger criticism. Of all the worst things, this was the WORST. POSSIBLE. THING!
[image error]
This book... is like Anita Blake.

It's got multiple love interests, fairies, bargains made, political sex, sexual awakening of formerly prudish, loner character, mystery, evil women bitches out to get you. It's all so very reminiscent.
You know what? Don't read this book. Just go watch Generation 4 My Little Pony instead. I promise there's no rape there and it's about a thousand times better and more entertaining.
And there is no rape.

Look over your shoulder just to check that I'm wrong. You know you want to do it!
Storm Born, the tragic tale of a woman forced by cruel fate to be hit on by ALL the men. Yes. That's what this story is about. Okay, there are fairies and she has to recover some damsel in distress but basically the novel is about Eugenie's love life.
I suppose my problem with Dark Born is that all of Mead's washed up, tried and not-so-true tropes are here. Again. Strong heroine (who will undoubtedly end the series as a complete moron), sexy hero who heroine loves, though nobody really knows why. Secondary sexy love interest who is way more awesome than sexy hero and who Mead spends far more time fleshing out a real relationship with the heroine, but who is apparently not the heroine's twue loff. For reasons completely unknown. I will inevitably like this love interest far more than the banal and boring love interest Mead champions.
The one thing I'll say about this novel is that Mead writes good sex. That's her one redeeming virtue. She writes gripping, interesting characters, a rich world and stories that hint at great possibilities, but Mead absolutely sucks at the follow through.
The difference with this novel is that I'm not interested in following through to watch her crash and burn yet another series. This novel reminded me of a quote by Dan Hemmens from Ferretbrain.
"Rape is not the occupational hazard of having a vagina."
Thank you.
Now I'll address the fictional critics in my head by saying that yes, Mead gave all these douches a reason to rape the protagonist that wasn't just about sex. But... well, it just doesn't count and I'll explain why.
I don't know about you, but *I* am personally sick of stories that tell me that because I have a vagina, I am a walking talking victim waiting to happen. Because novel after novel tells the same story. No matter how strong, powerful or kickarse you are as a heroine, you are still a victim and will need to be rescued by a man. Possibly several times.
I'm sick to death of it. Barely a page goes by in this book where rape isn't mentioned. Even if it's just to say, 'Eugenie, you're so beautiful I'd rape you and LIKE it!"
This book almost treats rape like a fucking compliment. "I've had five rape attempts today, what about you?" "Oh, I've had three." "Oh, I'm so sorry to hear that. Don't worry, maybe tomorrow will pick up!"
I have a problem with drilling into people's heads that women are victims. Always. Vulnerable, precious little petals. Don't let them out of the house or they'll trip over their puritanical vaginas and get raped. Or what about a message just as bad? Almost all men will rape if given the chance. It's the rare few who won't take the opportunity for a good ol' free for all on an unwilling woman.
Now hold on for an even bigger criticism. Of all the worst things, this was the WORST. POSSIBLE. THING!
[image error]
This book... is like Anita Blake.

It's got multiple love interests, fairies, bargains made, political sex, sexual awakening of formerly prudish, loner character, mystery, evil women bitches out to get you. It's all so very reminiscent.
You know what? Don't read this book. Just go watch Generation 4 My Little Pony instead. I promise there's no rape there and it's about a thousand times better and more entertaining.
And there is no rape.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Storm Born.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 13, 2011
–
Started Reading
November 13, 2011
– Shelved
Finished Reading
November 14, 2011
– Shelved as:
books-that-deserve-painful-death
November 14, 2011
– Shelved as:
just-plain-bad
November 14, 2011
– Shelved as:
kat-s-book-reviews
November 14, 2011
– Shelved as:
kat-s-rants
Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Vinaya
(new)
Nov 13, 2011 02:24AM

reply
|
flag

Just read your Succubus Revealed review and cracked up! Good job!




Is that it? :D
Well, I most often rate books at a 3 so I don't really anticipate enjoying any book too much. :)


Anyway, Kat, I'm anxious to read your review.


So which one is which in this series? Everybody else I know seems to love the fairy and hate the fox, so I'm assuming it's Dorian for a) and Kiyo for b). {Jeez, why do I even know these names???}


I think I only thought I loved this book at first is because of Dorian. willing him to be the hero that Seth wasn't. But now I really don't know why I thought it's better than Georgina. G.Kincaid at least gave me a hell of a ride over the years and it didn't disappoint at the end which this Dark Swan seems to be building up on..

Hmnn.. I just realized Mead never did disappointed me in her love interest. Like you, Kat I did like Roman and Christian better than the others but I never had doubts during the series that it'll be the others that they'll end up with. Now I like Dorian but I doubt she'll end up with Kiyo too. Is this a real thing or am I just making excuses to finish the series like I always do with Mead's book? :p



Thanks for the book rec. I *think* it is already in my to be considered shelf but if not, I'll add it in.

P.S. My girls and I watch the new My Little Pony together every day. It's pretty fun. I keep telling them I used to watch a My Little Pony cartoon when I was little. They seem oddly fascinated with that little tidbit of information.
P.P.S. Watching My Little Pony with my girls is WAY more entertaining then reading this series. Especially since the second book is extra rape-y.

On the one hand, if you like Dorian, book #2 is good for that. On the other hand... (major spoiler only for those who've read the book or know they will never read it) (view spoiler) I would have torn the book into little tiny pieces if it hadn't been a library copy.

Just so you know, I've had 6 rape attempts today and isn't even 10am LoL,, yep,, this is going to be a great day for a frail and weak girl with a vagina LoL

Not worth the aggravation.

And there is no rape.
Ummm. I hate to be the bringer of bad news, but...


Gah.
Though I will say Kiyo became a lot hotter to me once I started to picture him as Tyler Blackburn....
I loved the Vampire Academy series... Though watched the movie trailer the other day and was all "no... No no no no, what have you done!"

What is up with that? There is so much urban fantasy where the obvious main love interest bores me to death. (Because all of them are based on the same concept of super hot "alpha male" (hate that term but seemed the easiest way to describe the concept) and their relationship with the heroine is that they are both super attracted to each other but since he is a bossy asshole they can't interact in any interesting ways because everything between them is about "so hot must resist, but so hot. Oh no my brain is starting to shut down because of the overwhelming hotness") And it's not uncommon that some other guy is there who is just much more interesting. There might be actual banter or amusing flirting between them, he even might have a personality, they might actually spent time together where it's not either about resisting the great hotness of each other or work together for a bit to progress the plot while having no real chemistry.
Why is the main love interest the love interest instead of someone actually interesting for once. (Maybe I just don't understand because I'm not attracted to men and just read the books despite romance subplots that annoy me because I like urban fantasy.)



While good sex is a must in adult storytelling, it is NOT the only element! I don't know about you, but I want to see more magic, more fae tricks and word games. I want to see vampires with "teeth" who do not sparkle! I have to see shifters who actually act like human-animal hybrids, who are not just walking balls of rape and capture with shirtless photos!
I checked this book out because Shaman is not something I see every day. I was pissed! I wanted more bloody magic!
I hate to include rape in a story, though I have one in the works where the MC had a vision warning her of a possible future where she experienced such trauma... I feel like it is just become over abundant in the sorts of stories you see now! There are such forced pairings! "I should mace him, knee him in the balls and then run to the police" -He touches her arm-
The heroine suddenly turns to goo and insert five hundred justifications for her unwilling attraction. In my opinion, these bloody people who get off on this whole trashy clutter sub-genre of "real" genres of Fantasy need to be transported back to the stone age, where they can be drug into caves by their very own nearly naked cave men! (Or just ship them off to rural countrysides where there are an abundance of young single hillbillies!

