Yun's Reviews > Circe
Circe
by
Circe has always known that she does not belong. Though she is a goddess born to the almighty sun god Helios, she has never desired power nor indulged in vanity and cruelty the way her family does. They, in turn, have never ceased to remind her that she is the lesser daughter of greater sires. So when she displays an affinity for witchcraft and is exiled to a remote island, she jumps at the chance. Here finally is the opportunity to live life on her own terms.
Told in her trademark lyrical prose, Madeline Miller weaves a tale that is at once familiar and brand new. Circe has always been a minor goddess in Greek mythology, but in this book, she shines bright as the star of her own tale. It was fascinating to see so many familiar events—Scylla, Jason and Medea, and the infamous Odysseus—made fresh again through her eyes.
You would think a story like this might feel remote and otherworldly and be hard to relate to. After all, I'm not a goddess (well, only in my head). But what's amazing about this story is how utterly relatable it really is. Miller manages to portray Circe in sharp relief, and she is a compelling figure. Her search for purpose and belonging, her loneliness, her mistakes and sacrifices, and ultimately her redemption, all coalesce to drive home her humanity and fragility. It makes for a mesmerizing tale, one I could not look away from.
In comparison to The Song of Achilles, I found both to be wonderful in their own right. Which you will enjoy more will depend on personal preference. For me, The Song of Achilles has a better arc just based on source material, with the story relentlessly building up to the Trojan War. Circe does not have the luxury of a huge war at its end, so the story ebbs and flows depending on the current narrative. That isn't to knock Circe, but rather speaks to Miller's masterful skill that she was able to make this story just as riveting as its predecessor.
In just two books, Madeline Miller has become a favorite of mine. It must not be easy to take a classic that has been told again and again, and to infuse something thrilling and new into it. Yet she does just that, shaping these myths into tales appealing for the modern audience, while still retaining all of their old-world charms. I cannot wait to see what she comes up with next.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
See also, my thoughts on:
The Song of Achilles
~~~~~~~~~~~~
� Connect with me � �
by

"Next time you're going to defy the gods, do it for a better reason."
Circe has always known that she does not belong. Though she is a goddess born to the almighty sun god Helios, she has never desired power nor indulged in vanity and cruelty the way her family does. They, in turn, have never ceased to remind her that she is the lesser daughter of greater sires. So when she displays an affinity for witchcraft and is exiled to a remote island, she jumps at the chance. Here finally is the opportunity to live life on her own terms.
Told in her trademark lyrical prose, Madeline Miller weaves a tale that is at once familiar and brand new. Circe has always been a minor goddess in Greek mythology, but in this book, she shines bright as the star of her own tale. It was fascinating to see so many familiar events—Scylla, Jason and Medea, and the infamous Odysseus—made fresh again through her eyes.
You would think a story like this might feel remote and otherworldly and be hard to relate to. After all, I'm not a goddess (well, only in my head). But what's amazing about this story is how utterly relatable it really is. Miller manages to portray Circe in sharp relief, and she is a compelling figure. Her search for purpose and belonging, her loneliness, her mistakes and sacrifices, and ultimately her redemption, all coalesce to drive home her humanity and fragility. It makes for a mesmerizing tale, one I could not look away from.
In comparison to The Song of Achilles, I found both to be wonderful in their own right. Which you will enjoy more will depend on personal preference. For me, The Song of Achilles has a better arc just based on source material, with the story relentlessly building up to the Trojan War. Circe does not have the luxury of a huge war at its end, so the story ebbs and flows depending on the current narrative. That isn't to knock Circe, but rather speaks to Miller's masterful skill that she was able to make this story just as riveting as its predecessor.
In just two books, Madeline Miller has become a favorite of mine. It must not be easy to take a classic that has been told again and again, and to infuse something thrilling and new into it. Yet she does just that, shaping these myths into tales appealing for the modern audience, while still retaining all of their old-world charms. I cannot wait to see what she comes up with next.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
See also, my thoughts on:
The Song of Achilles
~~~~~~~~~~~~
� Connect with me � �
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Circe.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 8, 2018
–
Started Reading
May 8, 2018
– Shelved
May 13, 2018
–
Finished Reading
October 16, 2021
–
Started Reading
October 20, 2021
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 186 (186 new)
message 1:
by
Constantine
(new)
-
added it
Sep 11, 2019 02:41PM

reply
|
flag

Thank you, Constantine! I hope you love it! I look forward to seeing your thoughts. :)


Thanks so much, Carmen! I'm glad this was a winner for both of us! :)

Thanks, Darla! I'm just starting my reread. I read it years ago and have no recollection of it haha. I'm glad you loved it! :)


Thanks, Barbara! Ah, glad the audio was terrific too! Hope you enjoy Achilles! It seems a bit mixed which of the two people like more. Will be curious to see your thoughts! :)

Thanks, Ceecee! I totally get that, but this story is so special... I hope you get a chance to read it before too long! 💖

but you've created a comfortable opening for me -
Its also so very sweet to ..."
Thanks, Elyse! Miller is such a skilled writer, I think you'll find these very approachable and relatable, even if you didn't know anything about Greek mythology going in! :)


Thanks, Baba! I hope you get a chance to read her soon and you enjoy too! Will be most curious to see your thoughts! :)

Thanks, Maureen! Totally understand that haha. But hope you get a chance to read this one day! 💖

Thanks, Rosh! Feelings seem to be a bit mixed on which one people people love more, but for me, Achilles just had a more cohesive buildup that edged out Circe by just a bit. When you get to this, I hope you love it! Will be eager to see your thoughts! :)


Thanks, Jonathan! Yes, her style totally does! :)


Thanks so much, Elise! Hope you enjoy too! :)

Thanks, Lilly Luna! Hope you do too! Will be on the lookout for your thoughts! 🤗
Extraordinary review, Yun. Bravo!


Thanks so much, Bob! Appreciate you saying that! :)

Thanks so much, Anne! Appreciate your kind words! So glad you enjoyed this too! 💖


Haha I love that! Thanks so much, Kerrin! :)

Hahaha! Thanks a bunch, Mark! When you get to this, I hope you enjoy it too! Will be eager to see your thoughts! :)

Thanks, Rebecca! Glad this was a winner for both of us! 💖


Thanks, Jen! Haha, totally understand! Whenever you do get to it, I hope you enjoy it too! Will be most curious to see your thoughts! :)

Thanks, Kay! Oh, I hope you do and you love it too! 💖

Thanks, Beth Ann! Totally agree! I love how human her gods and heroes are! So glad you're a fan of Miller too! Yes, when is her next book coming out lol? It's been a few years since Circe, so hopefully we don't have to wait too long! :)