Nenia � I yeet my books back and forth � Campbell's Reviews > The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
by
|| || || ||
When you're a shy, awkward child who doesn't have a lot of friends, you read. Or at least, I did. My favorite type of book was fantasy because the heroes and heroines of those books were always shy, awkward children who didn't have a lot of friends, and yet they triumphed in spite of that. In hindsight, that feels a bit exploitative, but child-me at that stuff up without questioning it too deeply. Since I've been in the mother of all book slumps, I figured what better way to get out than by picking up an old favorite, the Narnia series, and breezing through them all?
I'm doing this slightly differently and reading them in chronological order rather than publication order, so I actually kicked off this experiment with a book that I hadn't read yet, which was THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW. In publication order, I believe it is book #6, coming just before LAST BATTLE. However, in the chronology of the series, it is actually the "first."
THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW is a cool book because it explains the origin of both Narnia and the White Witch, as well as the Professor who agrees to take in the Pevensie children during the chaos of WWII. Reading it just before THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE was a real treat, because where THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW ENDS, THE LION begins, so depending on which series order you choose, it either brings the entire series full circle before ending it OR kicks of the story while treating you, the reader, with insider knowledge that will give you new perspective.
Rereading this was pretty great because my mom used to read me this book when I was a kid and still had what could be called a "nursery." I've also watched most of the film adaptations including the 1979 animated version, the 1988 TV movie version from BBC, and then the 2005 version that came out in theaters, hoping to ride on the coattails of the Post Harry Potter fantasy craze. I know my opinion isn't the popular one here, but I actually like the theatrically-released one the least. My favorite will always be the BBC one. It's cheesy and most of the animals are portrayed by people who are obviously wearing animal costumes and makeup, but it gives the movies a weird sort of charm. Plus, the opening music is kick-ass. Nothing like a French horn bugles, THIS IS FANTASY, BITCH.
I still liked the book upon rereading it but I definitely noticed a lot of stuff that flew over my head when I was a kid. There are elements of that Cold War paranoia in here (although more so in the prequel, THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW), many Christian allegories to the Bible and Original Sin, and there's also a shocking amount of sexism, with Susan and Lucy being excluded by all of the battles save for a "cry for help" or healing capacity, and Santa Claus himself even tells them that wars are uglier when women are involved, whatever that means. Also, Aslan's a judgy f*ck. Don't @ me.
This is a very short book and I was kind of surprised by how quickly it was over and how much of a movie they were able to make of it despite that. Some of the scenes have still stuck with me all these years, like Lucy's first tumbling through the Wardrobe, the flight through the cold and snowy forest, the night of the Stone Table, and the hall of the statues where they all come to life - relieving them as an adult is like seeing a double-exposed image; you experience it again as an adult while also remembering your childhood experiences of it with fond nostalgia. The ending always made me sad, because it felt like an allegory for growing up and having to leave fantasy behind.
I'm looking forward to reading the rest of the books in this series!
3.5 to 4 stars
by

Nenia � I yeet my books back and forth � Campbell's review
bookshelves: magic-and-sparkles-and-shit, ya-ya-land, you-can-watch-it-on-the-telly
Jul 07, 2018
bookshelves: magic-and-sparkles-and-shit, ya-ya-land, you-can-watch-it-on-the-telly
|| || || ||
When you're a shy, awkward child who doesn't have a lot of friends, you read. Or at least, I did. My favorite type of book was fantasy because the heroes and heroines of those books were always shy, awkward children who didn't have a lot of friends, and yet they triumphed in spite of that. In hindsight, that feels a bit exploitative, but child-me at that stuff up without questioning it too deeply. Since I've been in the mother of all book slumps, I figured what better way to get out than by picking up an old favorite, the Narnia series, and breezing through them all?
I'm doing this slightly differently and reading them in chronological order rather than publication order, so I actually kicked off this experiment with a book that I hadn't read yet, which was THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW. In publication order, I believe it is book #6, coming just before LAST BATTLE. However, in the chronology of the series, it is actually the "first."
THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW is a cool book because it explains the origin of both Narnia and the White Witch, as well as the Professor who agrees to take in the Pevensie children during the chaos of WWII. Reading it just before THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE was a real treat, because where THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW ENDS, THE LION begins, so depending on which series order you choose, it either brings the entire series full circle before ending it OR kicks of the story while treating you, the reader, with insider knowledge that will give you new perspective.
Rereading this was pretty great because my mom used to read me this book when I was a kid and still had what could be called a "nursery." I've also watched most of the film adaptations including the 1979 animated version, the 1988 TV movie version from BBC, and then the 2005 version that came out in theaters, hoping to ride on the coattails of the Post Harry Potter fantasy craze. I know my opinion isn't the popular one here, but I actually like the theatrically-released one the least. My favorite will always be the BBC one. It's cheesy and most of the animals are portrayed by people who are obviously wearing animal costumes and makeup, but it gives the movies a weird sort of charm. Plus, the opening music is kick-ass. Nothing like a French horn bugles, THIS IS FANTASY, BITCH.
I still liked the book upon rereading it but I definitely noticed a lot of stuff that flew over my head when I was a kid. There are elements of that Cold War paranoia in here (although more so in the prequel, THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW), many Christian allegories to the Bible and Original Sin, and there's also a shocking amount of sexism, with Susan and Lucy being excluded by all of the battles save for a "cry for help" or healing capacity, and Santa Claus himself even tells them that wars are uglier when women are involved, whatever that means. Also, Aslan's a judgy f*ck. Don't @ me.
This is a very short book and I was kind of surprised by how quickly it was over and how much of a movie they were able to make of it despite that. Some of the scenes have still stuck with me all these years, like Lucy's first tumbling through the Wardrobe, the flight through the cold and snowy forest, the night of the Stone Table, and the hall of the statues where they all come to life - relieving them as an adult is like seeing a double-exposed image; you experience it again as an adult while also remembering your childhood experiences of it with fond nostalgia. The ending always made me sad, because it felt like an allegory for growing up and having to leave fantasy behind.
I'm looking forward to reading the rest of the books in this series!
3.5 to 4 stars
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 7, 2018
–
Started Reading
July 7, 2018
– Shelved
July 7, 2018
– Shelved as:
magic-and-sparkles-and-shit
July 7, 2018
– Shelved as:
ya-ya-land
July 7, 2018
– Shelved as:
you-can-watch-it-on-the-telly
July 7, 2018
–
5.82%
"When you think about it, children have more chill than anyone. They're always wandering into these far-fetched situations that would drive a grown-up mad, but they just accept it completely instead of getting shook."
page
11
July 7, 2018
–
13.76%
"It always annoyed me how condescending Peter and Suan were to Lucy and Edmund. Honestly, it's a marvel that Lucy didn't decide to go rogue on their asses. They had it coming."
page
26
July 7, 2018
–
19.58%
"Did anyone else desperately want to try Turkish Delight after reading this book only to be crushed to find out that it was basically fruit-flavored gelatin?"
page
37
July 7, 2018
–
23.81%
"Edmund is such a shit in this book. I forgot what a shit he was in the beginning."
page
45
July 7, 2018
–
43.39%
""But in general, take my advice, when you meet anything that's going to be human and isn't yet, or used to be human once and isn't now, or ought to be human and isn't, you keep your eyes on it and feel for your hatchet."
This reminds me of that quote by Mr. Weasley in Harry Potter: "Never trust anything that can think for itself if you can't see where it keeps its brain�"
page
82
This reminds me of that quote by Mr. Weasley in Harry Potter: "Never trust anything that can think for itself if you can't see where it keeps its brain�"
July 7, 2018
–
57.67%
"Whoa, Santa is a sexist-ass motherfucker.
"Battles are ugly when women fight"? No, battles are ugly, period.
P.S. That doesn't explain why you gave Lucy a bottle of healing potion and Susan some Katniss arrows and a glorified rape whistle, while Peter gets a goddamn sword and shield."
page
109
"Battles are ugly when women fight"? No, battles are ugly, period.
P.S. That doesn't explain why you gave Lucy a bottle of healing potion and Susan some Katniss arrows and a glorified rape whistle, while Peter gets a goddamn sword and shield."
July 7, 2018
–
94.71%
""Daughter of Eve," said Aslan in a graver voice, "others are also at the point of death. Must MORE people die for Edmund?"
Wow, way to lay on the guilt trip thick, Ass-lan."
page
179
Wow, way to lay on the guilt trip thick, Ass-lan."
July 7, 2018
–
96.83%
"[T]hey libereated young dwarfs and young satyrs from being sent to school
WAT. Is Narnia anti-education???
"
page
183
WAT. Is Narnia anti-education???

July 7, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)
date
newest »


Aww, that's super cute. That's kind of how I feel about Eragon- bad movie, worse book, but I went to see it with my friends in high school, so it was "magical" at the time. :D


Omg I'm pretty sure this book is what got me obsessed with Turkish delight


Aww thank you ❤️🥰
How badly, you say? It scared 11 year old me so badly that I had to start sleeping with a nightlight again for the first time since I was four. I had nightmares about him for WEEKS and basically forced my parents to check my closets at night to make sure he wasn't there.
I do agree with you on the theatrical movie version though, in regard it trying to be the next Harry Potter (which is kind of a ridiculous thing to achieve cause let's be real: nothing can beat Potter). However, I have fond memories of it because when I was in the sixth grade we read the book and it also happened to be the year the movie came out. My class took a field trip down to Los Angeles to see the movie live in theaters and got to see some of the costumes that were worn in the film. 'Twas magical!