ŷ

Gerhard's Reviews > Milkman

Milkman by Anna Burns
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7416346
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2019, favorites, literary-fiction

How do you write convincingly about trauma, about its impact on daily life and its repercussions, in a way that gets a reader to empathise, without feeling repelled, or running the risk of being desensitised if the depiction is too relentless?

Anna Burns achieves this seemingly impossible balance with the exquisite Milkman, which is not only one of the funniest books I have read in a long time, but also one of the most harrowing. Two examples:

‘God, we’re plastered,� they said, and then they, including sister, fell over the ornamental hedge. Sister exploded into advanced asterisks, into percentage marks, crossword symbol signs, ampersands, circumflexes, hash keys, dollar signs, all that ‘If You See Kay� blue french language.



At last they considered they’d done so by coming up with the invention of rape with subsections � meaning that in our district there could now be full rape, three-quarter rape, half rape or one-quarter rape � which our renouncers said was better than rape divided by two � as in ‘rape� and ‘not rape� which, they added, were the acceptable categories in most fiefdoms as well as in the burlesque courts of the occupiers. ‘Streaks ahead therefore we are,� they maintained, and they meant in terms of modernity, of conflict resolution and of gender progressiveness.

This book also has one of the best opening lines I have ever read: “The day Somebody McSomebody put a gun to my breast and called me a cat and threatened to shoot me was the same day the milkman died.� It is an outrageous line that taunts the reader with its noirish improbability; yet it informs everything that goes forward.

A lot has been made about the nameless setting of this book � which by inference is the period of the Troubles in Northern Ireland � and the fact that, instead of names, the protagonists go by sobriquets such as Maybe-Boyfriend, Somebody McSomebody, or the titular Milkman (there is both a lower- and upper-case version of this character).

You’d think that such an obviously postmodern literary flourish would add a cartoonish quality to the writing; instead it plays perfectly into Burns’s strategy of interiorising the psychological trauma and PTSD that inflicts this little community.

Maybe Girlfriend � with her ‘beyond-the-pale� habit of reading while walking, and then only nineteenth-century novels at that because she detests the twentieth � is a beautifully-evoked character of such nuance and depth I was absolutely mesmerised by her.

Having evoked the ‘p� word, postmodernism, a lot has also been made about how ‘difficult� this novel is to read. Being an interior kind of monologue, the chapters are really long, with few paragraph breaks. I must confess to reading this in small chunks to prevent reader fatigue.

But the effort pays off handsomely. There is a striking plot twist at the end that is quite devastating in terms of its psychological impact on Maybe Girlfriend, and one that in hindsight Burns does foreshadow quite delicately. What I’m saying is: Give this book a chance.

Burns has an exquisite turn of phrase and sense of comedic timing. You will soon get used to her particular style of writing, and become immersed in the little community she brings to life in such an extraordinary fashion.
69 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Milkman.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 21, 2018 – Shelved
August 21, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
July 20, 2019 – Started Reading
July 20, 2019 –
13.0% "... This sister was standing in her drainpipes and flip-flops with every toenail painted a different colour. This was before the years when people except in Ancient Egypt painted toenails different colours. She had a glass of Bushmills in one hand and a glass of Bacardi in the other because she was still at that stage of working out what to have for her first drink."
July 20, 2019 –
25.0% "'It's not about being happy,' he said, which was, and still is, the saddest remark I've ever heard."
August 1, 2019 –
40.0% "Cats are not adoring like dogs. They don't care."
August 1, 2019 –
49.0% "The word 'feminist' was beyond-the-pale. The word 'woman' barely escaped beyond-the-pale. Put both together, or try unsuccessfully to soften things with another word, a general word, one in disguise such as 'issues' and basically you've had it."
August 8, 2019 –
57.0% "'Hold on a minute,' I said. 'Are you saying it's okay for him to go around with Semtex but not okay for me to read Jane Eyre in public?'"
August 8, 2019 –
69.0% "Third time I awoke it was from a dream of Proust, or rather, a nightmare of Proust, in which he turned out to be some reprehensible contemporary Nineteen-Seventies writer passing himself off as a turn-of-the-century writer."
August 9, 2019 –
86.0% "So God was great and all, according to ma, but imagine giving up real milkman for Him."
August 10, 2019 – Shelved as: 2019
August 10, 2019 – Shelved as: favorites
August 10, 2019 – Shelved as: literary-fiction
August 10, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Steve Did you abandon this one? Curious if I should bother to read it. The reviews are all over the place.


Gerhard Steve wrote: "Did you abandon this one? Curious if I should bother to read it. The reviews are all over the place."

Hi Steve, not at all! I got sidetracked by the Rosewater sequel, because the first one just won the Arthur C. Clarke Award. I swear I have the attention span of a squirrel. I am really enjoying Milkman. It is sublimely written, and extremely funny; also dark and, well, just overall an intense and engrossing reading experience. Yes, it is postmodern and stream-of-consciousness, but not in an overly taxing way. I do think genre readers have a distinct advantage when it comes to books like this, where the author demands both a commitment and an investment from the average reader. The payoff depends on how far you are willing to go in embracing the author's vision. The fact that the reviews are all over the place with this one is an indication of that. I definitely think this is a much easier read than 'Lincoln in the Bardo' by George Saunders, for example. So if you enjoy modern fiction that is experimental and timeless, then this is a must-read.


Steve I see now that you just recently updated your progress.. when I first looked at it I thought it said you started reading it in August 2018, which is why I asked if you had abandoned it. Anyway - I picked up a used copy for cheap yesterday, so it's on my TBR list. Who knows when I will finally get around to it.


Gerhard Steve wrote: "I see now that you just recently updated your progress.. when I first looked at it I thought it said you started reading it in August 2018, which is why I asked if you had abandoned it. Anyway - I ..."

Heh. The curse of the 'to read' pile. I added it in 2018, only got to it now by default, as a close friend of mine just finished reading it and reminded me of it. I usually read more than one book at once: Say science fiction, then something heavier or more literary, and intersperse the books according to my mood or energy levels. I know a lot of people don't like reading more than one book at once, but it's kind of my default reading mode.


Gerhard Dean the Bibliophage wrote: "Brilliant review."

Thanks for the kind words! A friend of mine, Deputy Head of English at the University of South Africa, who did her doctoral thesis on James Joyce, also recently read this, and commented to me on Burns's "Irish sense for discordant juxtapositions". So there are so many, many layers to this ... But, screw the theory, it is such a joyous, messy, humane novel!


PattyMacDotComma Love the review, Gerhard! I stumbled on it in a kind of round-a-bout way from another conversation on a review of American Dirt. I still smile when I think about this book and the language and the way she named the characters. Such a delight! (And she's from Belfast, so nobody can criticise her for cultural appropriation, or whatever restriction we're now supposed to consider.)


Gerhard PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Love the review, Gerhard! I stumbled on it in a kind of round-a-bout way from another conversation on a review of American Dirt. I still smile when I think about this book and the l..."

Thanks for the kind words! Given that this is a Booker winner, and hence a Serious Novel, kind of obscures the fact just how funny it really is. And I genuinely don't get how people can claim it is unreadable. You just have to find its unique voice, and let it talk to you.


PattyMacDotComma Gerhard wrote: "PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Love the review, Gerhard! I stumbled on it in a kind of round-a-bout way from another conversation on a review of American Dirt. I still smile when I think ..."

It was the Booker Winner part that scared me off! Some prize-winners are great and some are, well, you know. :)

I don't know if you've seen Fionnuala's review, but it was hers that pushed me over the line.
/review/show...


Gerhard PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Gerhard wrote: "PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Love the review, Gerhard! I stumbled on it in a kind of round-a-bout way from another conversation on a review of American Dirt. I still smi..."

Thanks, that is a great review! It is definitely the sort of book that sneaks up on you unexpectedly with its generosity and humour.


PattyMacDotComma Gerhard wrote: "PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Gerhard wrote: "PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Love the review, Gerhard! I stumbled on it in a kind of round-a-bout way from another conversation on a review of [book:American Di..."

:)


Lealea ❤️ I loved this too Gerhard. Fantastic review


back to top