Steven Godin's Reviews > Billiards at Half-Past Nine
Billiards at Half-Past Nine
by
Set in post-war Germany in the late 50's (although large parts of the narrative focuses on events from the past), Heinrich Böll has written a multi-layered and complex work of brilliance, that uses a free-form narrative, and, on a limited scale, a more structured recognizable one, which alternates around depending on whether in the past or present. And I have to say it's masterfully done. Böll starts out by giving nothing away, regarding names, where we are, or what's going on, landing the reader smack-bang in a scene that could have been plucked from the middle of a story rather than the beginning of one. Adept, and with a keen eye, he unravels the Faehmel family that lie at the heart of his novel. Covering three generations of the family, two world wars, thus spanning many decades. You might think a sweeping epic is on the cards, but it fact, it's quite the opposite. In real time, the novel plays out over only a single day.
One could believe the grass roots of the novel lies with father and son architects. Heinrich the elder, is selected post-WW1 to rebuild a local abbey suffering from neglect. The son, Robert (who plays billiards, with a cognac, without fail, from half-past nine to eleven), follows his father's footsteps into the building trade, but then averts away from development into demolition during WW2. And then we have Joseph, Robert's son, who likewise keeps with family tradition. But, actually the core theme of Böll's novel is that of the struggles of women, especially that of the mother, entrenched in the ideas of virtue, sacrifice, and honesty, and how greater the choices made can affect the wider scope. So, in essence, the manic confessions of Robert's mother, Joanna, really is the bread and butter of Böll's story. It is also, more importantly, a searing indictment of Nazi Germany.
The more I think about the level of depth Heinrich Böll depicts throughout the novel, the more passionate I will praise it. And I could write on and on about the many different underlying questions Böll has us locked into, but wouldn't want to serve everything up on a silver platter.
I simply found this immensely rewarding, more so, because it does require complete and utter attention. No, it's not one for the beach. It's a book I could have locked myself away with in a panic room. The key information to the novels interior is presented seemingly at random, and then given weight and context as the story slowly unfolds. For me, it was like wearing in a new pair of shoes that looked uncomfortable, expecting blisters, but then not getting any. How he approached the novel was intelligent, thought-provoking, tough when it needed to be, but also humane.
And it was great not to be spoon fed all the details, it made for a better read, and Böll absolutely knew this. It's in no way a book for the masses, but I couldn't care less. It's all the better for it.
by

Steven Godin's review
bookshelves: fiction, germany, nobel-laureates, classic-literature
Oct 19, 2018
bookshelves: fiction, germany, nobel-laureates, classic-literature
Set in post-war Germany in the late 50's (although large parts of the narrative focuses on events from the past), Heinrich Böll has written a multi-layered and complex work of brilliance, that uses a free-form narrative, and, on a limited scale, a more structured recognizable one, which alternates around depending on whether in the past or present. And I have to say it's masterfully done. Böll starts out by giving nothing away, regarding names, where we are, or what's going on, landing the reader smack-bang in a scene that could have been plucked from the middle of a story rather than the beginning of one. Adept, and with a keen eye, he unravels the Faehmel family that lie at the heart of his novel. Covering three generations of the family, two world wars, thus spanning many decades. You might think a sweeping epic is on the cards, but it fact, it's quite the opposite. In real time, the novel plays out over only a single day.
One could believe the grass roots of the novel lies with father and son architects. Heinrich the elder, is selected post-WW1 to rebuild a local abbey suffering from neglect. The son, Robert (who plays billiards, with a cognac, without fail, from half-past nine to eleven), follows his father's footsteps into the building trade, but then averts away from development into demolition during WW2. And then we have Joseph, Robert's son, who likewise keeps with family tradition. But, actually the core theme of Böll's novel is that of the struggles of women, especially that of the mother, entrenched in the ideas of virtue, sacrifice, and honesty, and how greater the choices made can affect the wider scope. So, in essence, the manic confessions of Robert's mother, Joanna, really is the bread and butter of Böll's story. It is also, more importantly, a searing indictment of Nazi Germany.
The more I think about the level of depth Heinrich Böll depicts throughout the novel, the more passionate I will praise it. And I could write on and on about the many different underlying questions Böll has us locked into, but wouldn't want to serve everything up on a silver platter.
I simply found this immensely rewarding, more so, because it does require complete and utter attention. No, it's not one for the beach. It's a book I could have locked myself away with in a panic room. The key information to the novels interior is presented seemingly at random, and then given weight and context as the story slowly unfolds. For me, it was like wearing in a new pair of shoes that looked uncomfortable, expecting blisters, but then not getting any. How he approached the novel was intelligent, thought-provoking, tough when it needed to be, but also humane.
And it was great not to be spoon fed all the details, it made for a better read, and Böll absolutely knew this. It's in no way a book for the masses, but I couldn't care less. It's all the better for it.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Billiards at Half-Past Nine.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 22, 2018
– Shelved
October 11, 2018
–
Started Reading
October 13, 2018
–
20.68%
"St. Severins's shadow had drawn near. Already it filled the left-hand billiard room window, and was closing in on the one to the right. Pushed forward by the sun, time drew closer like a threat, filling up the great clock which soon spew it out in terrible chimes. The billiard balls rolled on, white-green, red-green. Years were cut to pieces, seconds, seconds drawn out into eternities by the clock's calm voice."
page
61
October 17, 2018
–
39.32%
"trotting home through the desolate suburbs, taking with him his schoolboy honors, observing the smoking chimney stacks and blackened house fronts, he made up his his mind then and there to leave a mark behind on this earth. This he would do, a reddish mark, of brick facades growing ever sadder with the passage of the years, in their niches morose saints staring at the future with implacable dejection."
page
116
October 18, 2018
–
72.54%
"No feelings would come to him as he went rocking along in streetcar No. 11. Through the old town, the new town, past the allotments, the gravel pits, to Blessenfeld. The names of the stops he had heard four thousand times. They sounded like calls for help in a heavy fog. The almost empty car headed onwards in the afternoon summer sun to the end of the line."
page
214
October 19, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Jean-Marc
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Oct 19, 2018 12:03PM

reply
|
flag

This was definitely the best of the three I've read so far. And what's great, is I haven't even got to The Clown, or Group Portrait with Lady yet.


Sorry Diederick, my German isn't that great (had to translate!).
Thanks.

Thanks a lot Ilse. I have read quite a few Nobel recipients now, some of which have left me scratching my head (Jelinek for one), but certainly not Böll. Glad to see he runs strongly in your family.

This was definitely the best of the three I've read so far. And what's great, is..."
Both of those are truly outstanding works.

This was definitely the best of the three I've read so far. And w..."
Good to know, thanks.
Ilse I remember I loved Ansichhten eines Clown when I read it many years ago
I read Brot der frühen Jahre a couple of years ago
A small masterpiece
I read Brot der frühen Jahre a couple of years ago
A small masterpiece

You have written a very fine review. What I found particularly praiseworthy was your insistence that more attention should be paid to the female characters. You wrote: "But, actually the core theme of Böll's novel is that of the struggles of women, especially that of the mother, entrenched in the ideas of virtue, sacrifice, and honesty." You could have noted that none of the female characters "take oblation of the Beast". Some of the men become active Nazis. Most however do end giving in and collaborating on the project of the beast. Johanna is a unique character in that she actively fights back.
Again, I think you wrote a very good piece.