ŷ

Vanessa's Reviews > Milkman

Milkman by Anna Burns
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
25545124
's review

it was ok

It took me way longer than usual to get into or warm to this book. I was initially open and excited, I knew this book had already won the man booker prize so going in my expectations were extremely high and it’s not that I don’t think this deserves the award, it certainly is a uniquely brilliant insight into the mind of ‘middle sister� an 18 year old girl living in Northern Ireland during the troubles a critical time of conflict and political unrest. You get right inside her head, in the stream of consciousness style her observations painfully accurate, the paranoid anxiety crippling. The style of writing deceptively simple yet dense and complex but overly repetitious and long winded causing my attention to drift. Anna Burns really displays her writing chops here whether you enjoy the style or not, she is a brilliant satirist, delving into the absurdity yet showing the complete seriousness of the times. It’s both comic and tragic. The violence and hidden shadowy figures and the sense of dread and danger lurking everywhere.

But for all it’s good and brilliant moments it got me zoning out pretty quickly. I lost steam, the stream of consciousness although witty and interesting with a refreshing spin ended up testing my patience. It bothered me that I was so bothered with it. The style grating on me more than endearing me to keep wanting to read it, it felt like an endurance test and I was so glad when I completed this book.
38 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Milkman.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 1, 2018 – Started Reading
November 2, 2018 – Shelved
December 1, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline I look forward to reading what you think about this one, Vanessa.


Bianca I see you're taking your time with it as well.


Vanessa Yes...I can’t seem to will myself to keep on reading :/ how is it for you?


Vanessa Don’t worry just saw your review pop up on my feed 😆


Bianca Vanessa wrote: "Yes...I can’t seem to will myself to keep on reading :/ how is it for you?"

I took my time as it's not a book to rush through. I loved it, as in it knocked my socks off.


C.  (Comment, never msg). Vanessa, you might notice my reviews often talking about how books are written or narrated. It is everything! It can be your favourite subject and grating or poor writing can make it unenjoyable. You perfectly describe what you appreciated and where the merits lost their lustre.


Bianca Fair enough. You gave it a go. At least you know your next read will be more enjoyable. Great review.


Vanessa Thank you C! Yes I have noticed that. This is when books are so subjective! It’s important that the writing gels for me, if it doesn’t then my mind tends to wander and I don’t get fully immersed in the book.


Vanessa Thanks Bianca. I know you gave this book high praise and it is deserved but unfortunately it just didn’t click with me. I almost left it unfinished but something kept me reading so it wasn’t a total fail.


message 10: by Brandice (new)

Brandice Sorry this was a letdown, Vanessa. I’m not 100% sure, but I don’t think I’ve read a book that won the man booker prize. Generally the reviews I’ve seen for books that won are very mixed - just an observation :) Hope your next read is better!


message 11: by Selena (new)

Selena Good and honest review Vanessa! Hope your next read is better.


Vanessa Thank you Brandice! Generally speaking I find them a little on the challenging side, so I tend to tread cautiously. Most have been a struggle and not my idea of enjoyment but I often get something a little more to sink my teeth into so I tend to appreciate them more than love them.


Vanessa Thank you Selena. I’ve already got a few books on the go that I’m enjoying 😊


message 14: by Brandice (new)

Brandice That makes sense, good to know! :)


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Wonderful review, Vanessa! I appreciate your thoughts on this one because I’d wondered about it.


Vanessa Thank you Jennifer. I think I’m in the minority here, plenty of 5 star reviews for this book..


message 17: by Vanessa (new) - added it

Vanessa I hate to say this, but "Booker Prize winner" instantly makes me think "not readable."


Debbie Excellent review, Vanessa! I'm glad to have company in the outlier club.

Loved this sentence of yours:
"The style of writing deceptively simple yet dense and complex but overly repetitious and long winded causing my attention to drift."

So true!!! And like you, I was bothered that I was bothered by it. Right after reading it, I read this super short epistolary novel, Holy Lands, and it was a 5-star read. Milkman is fading, lol. Luckily...


message 19: by Karen (new)

Karen Great review Vanessa! Sorry it didn’t live up to the hype for you.


Vanessa Your not wrong Vanessa 😏


Vanessa Thanks Debbie! It’s comforting to know you felt similar. I’m glad I’m in good outlier company ☺️


Vanessa Thank you Karen 🙏


message 23: by Greg (new) - rated it 3 stars

Greg Vanessa, yes, it was funny/odd that the 'wee sisters' reading material is "The Exorcist." But later, they want to watch "Whose Afraid of Virginia Woolf". So the joke isn't funny any more. I get that you write "I lost steam." Me too. 100 pages too long, at least.


back to top