Bianca's Reviews > Milkman
Milkman
by
by

Bianca's review
bookshelves: award-winner, feminist, first-person-narrator, irish, irish-author, literary-fiction, favorites, female-author, 2018
Nov 21, 2018
bookshelves: award-winner, feminist, first-person-narrator, irish, irish-author, literary-fiction, favorites, female-author, 2018
The day Somebody McSomebody put a gun to my breast and called me a cat and threatened to shoot me was the same day the milkman died. He had been shot by one of the state hit squads and I did not care about the shooting of this man.
And so it begins � one of the most extraordinary novels I’ve ever read. I got what I call “the giddiness� early on, but gave myself a talking down to not get ahead of myself, because really, can anyone sustain such a high level of interestingness for three hundred plus pages?
Written in the first person, through the eyes of an eighteen-year-old, who refers to herself as the middle sister, Milkman is very original. The setting is an unnamed place, somewhere in Northern Ireland during the 1970's Troubles.
The characters in this novel don’t have names, in the traditional way, but they are easily recognisable, I never got confused.
Speaking of characters, they're interesting, diverse and unusual. There’s Milkman who’s not really a milk man, he’s married, forty and he’s taken to stalking our protagonist. There’s also the real milkman who delivers milk and is also a friend of the family. There’s a maybe-boyfriend because they’re having a maybe-relationship. There’s ma who’s pious, hardened by life and who doesn’t trust our protagonist; pa, who had suffered from mental health issues, is dead now. The wee sisters are eight, nine and ten, they’re extremely intelligent and always together. There’s Somebody McSomebody who stalks her and can’t accept that she’s not interested. There’s the third brother in law, a man who’s in awe of women and who’s a compulsive runner, just like our protagonist. There’s even an issues women group aka the feminists. There’s the renouncers or those who take the republican side; there’s also a more vague category the beyond-the-pales those who society have deemed too different.
Our protagonist is apolitical, so much so, she takes refuge in reading mostly nineteen century literature. She’s trying her best to go unnoticed. She’s not pro or against anything. She doesn’t like to gossip, but that doesn’t stop others gossiping about her. People are put off by her walking and reading. Also, they think she’s the Milkman’s mistress. The absurdity of it all compels her to keep quiet, why have to explain herself and deny something that’s untrue? When she finally denies it, nobody believes her, not even her ma. Life becomes hell for the middle sister, as she joins the ranks of the beyond the pale.
Milkman is a dense novel, with some of the longest paragraphs I’ve ever read (with perfect punctuation, kudos to Ms Burns and/or editors). It’s both very readable and hard work. This was the closest I’ve ever come to completing/staying with a mindfulness exercise (in case you can’t tell from my all-over-the-place, unedited reviews, I have a very ADD brain). I didn’t mind taking my time with this novel, as I wanted to savour every line, turn of phrase, tangent and thought bubble. The writing is exquisite, playful, smart, insightful and all together bonkers, in a good way. The times were bonkers. The constant surveillance, suspicion, the imminence of death, affect everything and everyone. Everything is seen as a political statement. What you do and don’t do is labelled. There’s no escaping. The sense of self is easily eroded.
There’s so much to ponder and unpack. I am gobsmacked by this novel’s originality and complexity. I loved living in the eighteen-year old’s head. She may have come across as aloof and impenetrable, but she saw and understood more than anyone around. I even related to certain situations, despite having a different nationality. Somehow, in spite of the serious themes and undercurrents, this novel was quite amusing at times, not the slapstick kind of funny, but the kind derived from the absurdity of situations and people’s reactions.
This is where I gush about the importance of awards, especially for literary fiction, which seems to have become a niche genre. I read somewhere that each of the Man Booker short-listed novels sold less than six thousand copies in the UK. Had it not been for the Man Booker Prize, I, like many others, would have never come across this incredible novel. That would have been a shame.
Ms Burns, I take a bow and thank you for the words.
And so it begins � one of the most extraordinary novels I’ve ever read. I got what I call “the giddiness� early on, but gave myself a talking down to not get ahead of myself, because really, can anyone sustain such a high level of interestingness for three hundred plus pages?
Written in the first person, through the eyes of an eighteen-year-old, who refers to herself as the middle sister, Milkman is very original. The setting is an unnamed place, somewhere in Northern Ireland during the 1970's Troubles.
The characters in this novel don’t have names, in the traditional way, but they are easily recognisable, I never got confused.
Speaking of characters, they're interesting, diverse and unusual. There’s Milkman who’s not really a milk man, he’s married, forty and he’s taken to stalking our protagonist. There’s also the real milkman who delivers milk and is also a friend of the family. There’s a maybe-boyfriend because they’re having a maybe-relationship. There’s ma who’s pious, hardened by life and who doesn’t trust our protagonist; pa, who had suffered from mental health issues, is dead now. The wee sisters are eight, nine and ten, they’re extremely intelligent and always together. There’s Somebody McSomebody who stalks her and can’t accept that she’s not interested. There’s the third brother in law, a man who’s in awe of women and who’s a compulsive runner, just like our protagonist. There’s even an issues women group aka the feminists. There’s the renouncers or those who take the republican side; there’s also a more vague category the beyond-the-pales those who society have deemed too different.
Our protagonist is apolitical, so much so, she takes refuge in reading mostly nineteen century literature. She’s trying her best to go unnoticed. She’s not pro or against anything. She doesn’t like to gossip, but that doesn’t stop others gossiping about her. People are put off by her walking and reading. Also, they think she’s the Milkman’s mistress. The absurdity of it all compels her to keep quiet, why have to explain herself and deny something that’s untrue? When she finally denies it, nobody believes her, not even her ma. Life becomes hell for the middle sister, as she joins the ranks of the beyond the pale.
Milkman is a dense novel, with some of the longest paragraphs I’ve ever read (with perfect punctuation, kudos to Ms Burns and/or editors). It’s both very readable and hard work. This was the closest I’ve ever come to completing/staying with a mindfulness exercise (in case you can’t tell from my all-over-the-place, unedited reviews, I have a very ADD brain). I didn’t mind taking my time with this novel, as I wanted to savour every line, turn of phrase, tangent and thought bubble. The writing is exquisite, playful, smart, insightful and all together bonkers, in a good way. The times were bonkers. The constant surveillance, suspicion, the imminence of death, affect everything and everyone. Everything is seen as a political statement. What you do and don’t do is labelled. There’s no escaping. The sense of self is easily eroded.
There’s so much to ponder and unpack. I am gobsmacked by this novel’s originality and complexity. I loved living in the eighteen-year old’s head. She may have come across as aloof and impenetrable, but she saw and understood more than anyone around. I even related to certain situations, despite having a different nationality. Somehow, in spite of the serious themes and undercurrents, this novel was quite amusing at times, not the slapstick kind of funny, but the kind derived from the absurdity of situations and people’s reactions.
This is where I gush about the importance of awards, especially for literary fiction, which seems to have become a niche genre. I read somewhere that each of the Man Booker short-listed novels sold less than six thousand copies in the UK. Had it not been for the Man Booker Prize, I, like many others, would have never come across this incredible novel. That would have been a shame.
Ms Burns, I take a bow and thank you for the words.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Milkman.
Sign In »
Quotes Bianca Liked

“Cats are not adoring like dogs. They don’t care. They can never be relied upon to shore up a human ego. They go their way, do their thing, are not subservient and will never apologise. No one has ever come across a cat apologising and if a cat did, it would patently be obvious it was not being sincere.”
― Milkman
― Milkman

“According to the police, of course, our community was a rogue community. It was we who were the enemy, we who were the terrorists, the civilian terrorists, the associates of terrorists or simply individuals suspected of being but not yet discovered to be terrorists. That being the case, and understood by both parties to be the case, the only time you’d call the police in my area would be if you were going to shoot them, and naturally they would know this and so wouldn’t come.”
― Milkman
― Milkman

“As for the environment, that too, would object, backing up the pessimism of its people, which was what happened where I lived where the whole place always seemed to be in the dark. It was as if the electric lights were turned off, always turned off, even though dusk was over so they should have been turned on yet nobody was turning them on and nobody noticed either, they weren’t on.”
― Milkman
― Milkman
Reading Progress
July 26, 2018
– Shelved
July 26, 2018
– Shelved as:
to-read
November 13, 2018
–
Started Reading
November 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
award-winner
November 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
feminist
November 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
first-person-narrator
November 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
irish
November 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
irish-author
November 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
literary-fiction
November 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
favorites
November 21, 2018
–
Finished Reading
November 24, 2018
– Shelved as:
female-author
December 11, 2018
– Shelved as:
2018
Comments Showing 1-50 of 66 (66 new)
message 1:
by
Jaline
(new)
-
added it
Nov 20, 2018 06:00PM

reply
|
flag

I'm blown away by it. But I'm taking my time as it's quite dense.


This is definitely one of those books you either love or don't. True, the phrases are very long, but I thought they were playful. Many times I found myself exclaiming "this is incredible!"


Just accept that it's not going to be a quick read; honestly, I don't think I ever read more than 50 pages at a time, usually, it was about 20. I didn't want to skim or jump ahead. I do wish I had the hardcover or ebook, as I found paperback font was slightly too small and condensed and my eyes were getting tired easily (I'm at that age when I should get reading glasses).

Thanks, Karen. I had so many thoughts in my head ...




That's me, too. Interestingly enough, I've had glasses since I was 15 yo, but somehow, getting reading glasses annoys the hell out of me. It's just so much more annoying as you have to take them off put them on - I lose stuff that's not attached to me :-)

Sorry, it doesn't match your brilliant analysis.

Angela, I was a bit apprehensive as well, some called it dystopian, which in my view it's not, as it's about real people, real people, it's just told in an original way. You've got to read it, after all, it's a Man Booker winner. I'll try to read another one on the short-list, but we'll see how soon I can manage that.

Susanne, that's why awards are important. I also loved that a woman won it. It's been a while. Anna Burns seems to have had quite a few struggles in the past years, with health problems, house sitting, getting social benefits (she actually thanked the food bank and other organisations for helping her, how awesome is that!), so in this case, it warms my heart even more that she won it. I hope it allows her some security, the ability to deal with her health problems and obviously, write more. From what I've read about her, she dropped out of university, and only took some creative writing classes to accompany a friend; she must be a super smart cookie.

It's a special book, unique in every way. I hope you won't hate it, there are many 1 star reviews.

Candi, thank you. I can't wait to see what you make of it.

Thank you, Amanda. It knocked my socks off. I'm in awe of Anna Burns.

Thanks, Jen. Obviously, I can only encourage people to read it. It's one of a kind novel.

Thank you, Lucy. I hope you'll enjoy it.

Thank you, Paula. I hope you'll find as exhilarating as I did.


I encourage you to read this, it's quite different.

I can't wait to read your review.


Thank you kindly. I was thinking of you while reading - oh, Debbie would hate these overly long phrases. They are long, both dense and easy, I've never come across this kind of writing before. But it's so incredibly original, playful, eloquent - a literary accomplishment. Yes, it's impossible so breeze through it, but it's worth it, or it was to me.

Debbie, Bianca is right. There are def some long phrases, but they're intentionally written as humorous - not the content of the sentences but how they're presented.... kinda like shrimp stew, shrimp scampi, shrimp chowder, coconut shrimp, shrimp po boys, stir fry shrimp, etc. Some of it is also delivered dead-pan, like something out of Seinfeld.
The audio is on Hoopla and the narrator delivers it perfectly. I'm having fun listening but know that there is some scary stuff coming up amidst the griping about a middle aged mom eager to marry her daughter off to guys Ma *thinks* are lovely but are in fact awful. The backdrop of "the troubles" is not the focus - its just the setting. I hate to admit this, but I pretty much deplore most Irish books because of the wailing, woe are we, let's all be depressed theme I've bumped into before. This is pretty awful of me because my grandparents are from northern Ireland!
No woe. Just a great read.


It's in the same throughout. It doesn't let up, which was another thing I loved, how she managed to maintain such a high level and how when you least expect it, she comes up with another detail about someone, another morsel to chew on - you can't afford to skim.

We are like a three person book club but having read in the near past, the current, and the near future! Fun :)

Thank you, Jaline. It doesn't quite express how great this novel is.

Reminds me of a joke: The past, present, and future walked into a bar. It was tense : ) Except there’s no
tension in this club of course!