Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

LA's Reviews > Milkman

Milkman by Anna Burns
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7862560
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorite-books, litmus-test

What a tremendous read! An 18 year old girl, the middle sister in her family, is guilty of a social crime that is considered by her entire community to be beyond the pale. I'm about to challenge you, fellow book lovers, to commit the same offense.

In the late 1970s, when women's opinions were still deemed to be of far lesser value than men's, a young lady who refuses to acknowledge bombings, shootings, and the sharp teeth of public opinion might be seen to bring on herself whatever rumors and ill will that pop up. She intentionally keeps her head in the sand, ostrich-like, digging for some modicum of peace in a place were death runs rampant. Her goal is to keep her head down and keep a low profile.

The irony is that her withdrawal sets her far apart from others, and her behavior comes under high scrutiny. An IRA terrorist (or freedom fighter, depending upon one's viewpoint) is highly placed in the ranks of local "renouncers" and is never crossed. This man, known as "Milkman," is accessorized with Semtex explosives, stacks of automatic weapons, black capsules full of poison, and a legion of thugs who follow him without question. Milkman is not one to refute. But as he takes notice of this pretty girl, a girl who goes out running in a time period when jogging seems irrational, the entire community notices too.

What follows, story-wise, is how his subtle but perseverative attention - his polite stalking - impacts not just this middle-sister in her family, but the fellow she has been dating for nearly a year. Her maybe-boyfriend (they're semi afraid to push the relationship forward) might just have his life at stake, considering that the murderous Milkman sees him as competition.

As you've likely noted, the 18 year old girl does not have a name, just a reference point. Middle-sister, Maybe-boyfriend, Wee-sisters (three adorably precocious little girls), Ma, Pa, Oldest-friend, Chef, Real milk man, 3rd Brother in Law, the International couple, and others are the appellations we learn. Because in a certain unnamed country (hello, Northern Ireland) there may be spies from Over the water (England) who are listening in and can come for you in the middle of the night. It is unwise to name names.

You don't need to read anymore about the plot - let's let you be surprised (there is a huge WOW at about the 85% mark). But the narrative style here will be something you adore or loathe. As in many stories, we have a first person point of view, but it is extremely conversational. Some have called it stream-of-consciousness, but I would not agree. The narration is FUNNY, with some half sentences and run-on sentences like you or I would have if we were just chatting. That said, the lengthy lines and probably grammatically incorrect punctuation might bother some readers. But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to the main thread, this was a dream to listen to!

So that's where I am, encouraging you to engage in the precise faux pas this middle sister committed and got the entire community gossiping. The offense is "reading while walking." While she would skip taking the bus so she could pull out an 18th century novel and read while walking home, I've merely turned on the audio book while out walking or driving. The audio narration is outstanding! My mom's parents were from Belfast, so of course, the accent flashed me back to my grandmother reading aloud to me.

The other thing that made this very real for me was that in 1979, I was on a trip to England with a high school group. My mom flew over the Atlantic with us but went to Belfast to look up her relatives and see where her parents were born. When her taxi pulled up to the hotel, there was nothing left but rubble and smoke. It had just been bombed that morning. She ended up staying in the private home of the hotels owners and sharing a bed with a servant girl. When it was time to leave Belfast, there were armed “soldiers� standing at some sort of gate. Another woman had several pieces of Waterford crystal in her luggage that she had just purchased. The soldiers told her they would not allow her to leave Belfast with them. The woman, incensed that they’d likely resell the crystal, removed each piece and shattered them on the street one by one. They were furious, raised their weapons but did not shoot. My mom was flipped out having seen her own tiny little slice of the Troubles.

As for the audio narration, beyond the brogue, the little semi sarcastic tones and witticisms brought the black humor alive. Brid Brennan is the award-winning actress who delivers this story so beautifully. As for the print version, I'm sticking in here a link to a book excerpt so you might judge for yourself how well you might love/tolerate the conversational style
For those who might not tolerate the long, irregular sentences in print format, the audio is free from the Hoopla app.

I’d say give it a go, no matter how old-farty you may regard audio books. Nobody will be watching or judging or gossiping, least of all anyone as scary as Milkman. Go ahead and shatter your crystal. There will be no witnesses.
49 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Milkman.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 11, 2018 – Started Reading
December 11, 2018 – Shelved
December 16, 2018 –
10.0% "This maybe-fan LOVES it so far. Clever charm to offset the serious, perhaps?"
December 17, 2018 –
15.0% "This audio narration hits the mark on irony and clever observation while the lines indirectly show the intelligence of, of all people, garage mechanics. Not your typical "bright professor" and "brilliant writer" dialogue. Fabulous!"
December 28, 2018 –
85.0% "Loving this!!!"
December 30, 2018 – Shelved as: favorite-books
December 30, 2018 – Finished Reading
December 31, 2018 – Shelved as: litmus-test

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Zoeytron (new)

Zoeytron So noted. Tasty review, LeAnne!


message 2: by Ken (new) - added it

Ken Your review does Anna Burns proud!


message 3: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Thanks, Z!
Ken - you are generous as always. Thank you!


Paula K Outstanding review, LeAnne! I’m sorry now that I purchased the kindle version. If it’s free on Hoopla, I’ll have to check out the audio also.

Fabulous review!

Happy New Year🎉


message 5: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to the main thread, this was a dream to listen to!

I very much agree, LeAnne. The narrator's conversational style and her choice of vocabulary were what made this book work so well. And you're right that it's not strictly stream of consciousness since the tangents always revert back to the main narrative, and the underlying framework of the story is never forgotten � not by the author, nor by the narrator nor even by the reader. We know that no matter what diversions happen, at the end we will be back at the beginning. So it's a really tightly constructed story and yet it roams really wide in terms of the issues it covers.
I enjoyed your anecdote about your mother's trip to Belfast on the day her hotel was bombed � I'm guesssing it was the Europa which was bombed 33 times during the Troubles! Is it any wonder the narrator stuck her nose in a book and ignored the world around her!


message 6: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Paula wrote: "Outstanding review, LeAnne! I’m sorry now that I purchased the kindle version. If it’s free on Hoopla, I’ll have to check out the audio also.

Fabulous review!
Happy New Year🎉"


Thank you, sweetheart! At least you'll have the book forever on Kindle and have the option of going from free audio to e-print. Sometimes a book translates better for me in one media versus another.

Regardless, Happy New Year! Wishing you joy, health, prosperity, and great reads.


Dianne Wonderful review! I am all about language, so really looking forward to this.


message 8: by LA (last edited Dec 31, 2018 10:19AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Fionnuala wrote: "But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to the main thread, this was a dream to listen to!

I very much ag..."


You encapsulate this style so much better than me, yes! It was odd noting that those who did not enjoy this - not because of content but because of technique - missed those repeated U-turns. I absolutely adored the repeated tie-backs to the main story.

The accompanying themes about how a small community judges others, the time-period of how women saw themselves, and the overarching attitudes born of war in their streets were fantastic. That nobody dared to marry his or her true love for fear of losing them seemed like something straight out of an old Russian novel - cleverly, the kind of thing Middle sister spent her time reading. Why take the leap for love when you foresee a fall into the abyss of loss?

As for my mom's hotel, you got me digging around on the internet! I believe it must have been the Marine Hotel (which was completely destroyed) or Wellington Park Hotel which had five bombs explode in June, 1979.

My mom and I met back up in Scotland after she'd spent time all over Northern Ireland and I'd been to Wales, the Lake District, and so forth. When I asked her about photos of my grandmother's place of birth - a stone cottage still standing and with a grassy sod roof - she said that nobody was permitted to take photos anywhere. She had seen cameras grabbed and smashed by armed men who were everywhere - outside shops, restaurants, entry ways into little towns, etc. Which side of the battle these men were on, I still don't know.

But really, the great thing about this book is that for the most part, we don't entirely know as readers who did what to who. That one could not go to the hospital for fear of interrogation or instead an accusation of collusion was just crazy.

As a US resident, I'm as ignorant as the next guy or gal as to what living in a war zone is like. This book, though, brought me there without depressing me. I was more interested in the life of Middle-sister and her loved ones than I was the political violence. Life goes on, no matter what. This author did justice to that in spades.


message 9: by Barbara (last edited Dec 31, 2018 10:49AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Barbara LeAnne wrote: "Fionnuala wrote: "But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to the main thread, this was a dream to listen t..."

What an astute review! I wondered also about the hotel, and thought perhaps it was the Europa which is adjacent to the bus station, and during the Troubles known as "the most bombed hotel in Europe". But seeing as you identified two other possibilities, I'd say they are the more likely places.

I had to look up the word "brogue" in reference to "the" Belfast accent or Northern Irish accent. I found that the BBC News NI also used the term "brogue" and "lilt" in reference to the accent in this article "Why do actors struggle with the Northern Irish accent?" from 2016.
Yet, I have never heard brogue or lilt ever used in Northern Ireland, but then again American southerners don't talk about Southern drawls. But I don't use these terms because they seem to lump together various "Irish" accents and as the BBC article points out the Northern Irish accent has much more in common with Scottish and Northern English accents: " These are from Scotland and from the English North and Midlands. This means that anyone trying to sound as if they are from Ulster needs first to move away from sounding generally "Irish", adopting some distinctly home-grown features instead."
I am from New England for 20 years and believe that the second most difficult accent to manage is the "Boston" accent, which is actually many different accents depending on the neighborhood or town.

I am editing to add, I am American but have traveled many times to Northern Ireland since the mid-1970's. I was in Omagh on the day in 1998 of the worst bombing in the history of the Troubles, missing the bombing by 10 minutes. My son wanted to stop and even though there was no sign of "trouble", I felt uncomfortable stopping. This was my 5th trip to Northern Ireland and rather than taking it as a sign to stay away, I interpreted as a sign that we are not in control of many things that will occur around us and to us, and I was meant to go back. I have returned four more times since 1998, participating in 2 summer schools, as well as a conference at Queens University.


message 10: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Dianne wrote: "Wonderful review! I am all about language, so really looking forward to this."

Dianne, if the long sentences in print don't bother you, I think you'll really love this. The speaker is casual but as a bright, well-read 18 year old expresses herself with words that seem to tie to old fashioned novels or perhaps with how natives of Northern Ireland speak. The narration did not read like that of an 18 year old out of 2018 Detroit. I found her voice addictive. Here's an excerpt:

"I was startled out of my reading. I had not heard this car drive up. Had not seen before either, this man at the wheel of it. He was leaning over, looking out at me, smiling and friendly by way of being obliging. But by now, by age eighteen, ‘smiling, friendly and obliging� always had me straight on the alert. It was not the lift itself. People who had cars here often would stop and offer lifts to others going into and out of the area. Cars were not in abundance then and public transport, because of bombscares and hijackings, was intermittently withdrawn. Kerb-crawling too, may have been a term recognised, but it was not recognised as a practice. Certainly I had never come across it. Anyway, I did not want a lift."


message 11: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Barbara wrote: "LeAnne wrote: "Fionnuala wrote: "But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to the main thread, this was a dr..."

Interesting point about the term "brogue." I wouldn't know the difference between Northern or Southern Irish pronunciation at all. Welsh, Northern England, and different parts of Scotland all have wonderful sounding expressions, but I'd be lucky to accurately distinguish them from one another. I barely can identify Aussie from Kiwi from South African.

Since both grandparents were from Northern Ireland and my step father was from Motherwell, Scotland, in our household, we just referred to their pronunciation as brogues. The grandparents were Scot-Irish, so maybe they picked up the term from their grandparents. They moved to the US right around WWI, so they missed the troubles.

As you say, though, as a southerner or specifically a New Orleanian, we rarely mention drawl or twang. There's a section or two of the city where the spoken language is often mistaken as something out of the Bronx! The "yat" accent is what you may hear during NFL Saints' playoff games: who dat? who dat? who dat sayin dey gonna beat dem Saints? Nobody who is a local speaks with a Cajun accent, but a big chunk of our population is originally from "down the bayou" so we hear it regularly.

As someone who has been to Ireland so many times and seen some of this violence, how did you find the book?


message 12: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Barbara wrote: "LeAnne wrote: "Fionnuala wrote: "But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to the main thread, this was a dr..."

OH! And I think it's funny that the link about actors attempting and failing at Irish brogues includes a mention of a movie about Ian Paisley. The link I stuck in which mentions two hotels that got bombed in June 1979 is of a quote by, you guessed it! Ian Paisley! Now I need to find that movie on Netflix :)


Barbara LeAnne wrote: "Barbara wrote: "LeAnne wrote: "Fionnuala wrote: "But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to the main threa..."

I loved it! 5 stars. My GR review was republished here:


So glad to learn something new about accents - I wasn't familiar with the term "yat accent" and can see why it is confused with Brooklynese. I had a friend who was Cajun but didn't speak with the accent (at least most of the time) but that could be the kind of codeswitching that is common in the Black Community - switching from "standard" English to Black English. I went to college in Pittsburgh and loved the Pittsburgh accent of the time (this was in the 70's and I am sure it has mostly disappeared). For the first couple of years I was there I'd hear locals referring to "the iron ear" as in "Yins jus go dawn the road to the iron ear...". Eventually I learned they meant the Eye and Ear Hospital. And in Boston, I talked a friend into relocating there from Portland Oregon and he kept hearing people refer to "going to the spa". He didn't realize that "spa" was a local term for the corner mom and pop grocer. In fact, there was one near my house in Boston and the sign actually said "Bob's Spa"

These are all examples of why I love language, and accents and regionalisms.


message 14: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Barbara wrote: "LeAnne wrote: "Barbara wrote: "LeAnne wrote: "Fionnuala wrote: "But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make a U turn back to..."

I'm pleased to introduce you to Yat - our happy conglomerate of sloppy diction and lousy grammar. "I'm at my mama and em's. Where y'at?"

Ha! But funny that you mention Pittsburgh - we lived there while I was a small child. My mom never had that accent - probably because of growing up with her parents' pronunciation, but I've got an older sister who is fabulous to listen to! The yuns or yinz, daaan taaan (down town), and worsh the laundry are just rich to listen to. The iron ear story is hilarious!!!!

BTW, I just poked around a bit on our common reads and enjoyed bumping into our likeminded reactions to various books. Your reviews are wonderful!


Barbara LeAnne wrote: "Barbara wrote: "LeAnne wrote: "Barbara wrote: "LeAnne wrote: "Fionnuala wrote: "But, oh - the language! Juicy and fat, colloquial, and loaded with thought tangents that recover themselves and make ..."

Thank you so much! I will take a look also at our common reads.

About Ian Paisley, apparently, late in life, he developed a friendship of sorts with the IRA leader Martin McGuinness. I have a friend from Carrickfergus who is a teacher at a boys school in Belfast. Schools in Northern Ireland are still very much segregated by religion. One of the pupils at his school was Paisley's grandson, and my friend said that he felt great sympathy for the boy when his grandfather died as he was clearly devastated as all children would be. He also said that the ability of some of the old figures entrenched in the Troubles to cross lines (enemy lines) was one of the great achievements of the 1998 Good Friday Agreement (the Peace Accords).


Vanessa Glad you loved it LeAnne and rated it full stars. I wish I could feel the same way about this book..


message 17: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Thanks, Vanessa. I just read your assessment and jotted a note. This thing did feel nearly dystopian. How lucky are we that we have been spared a judgemental, war torn life experience? Part of me felt like this book could have been set in North Korea!


message 18: by Fran (new)

Fran Excellent review, LeAnne!


message 19: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Thank you, Fran! Despite it’s award winning status, it was actually a surprise to end up loving it this much :)


message 20: by Kathleen (new)

Kathleen Fabulous review, LeAnne. Thanks for the link. It gave me a taste of the sentences.


message 21: by LA (new) - rated it 5 stars

LA Thanks, Kathleen!


David Great review, thanks. I'm really enjoying the audio version.


back to top