Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Candi's Reviews > Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy

Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy by John Le Carré
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: mystery-crime, thriller, favorites, espionage

"After a lifetime of living by his wits and his considerable memory, he had given himself full time to the profession of forgetting."

Over the past couple of months, George Smiley has earned the distinction of my favorite spy. Not because he is handsome, sexy, charismatic or daring but rather because he is all too human. He’s the real deal, and no one could write a genuine character like him as well as the master, John le Carré.

"Small, podgy, and at best middle-aged, he was by appearance one of London’s meek who do not inherit the earth. His legs were short, his gait anything but agile, his dress costly, ill-fitting, and extremely wet."

How on earth does a guy like this get saddled with the onerous task of uncovering a Russian-planted mole at the highest level of the British Secret Service? Because he is brilliant and honorable, that’s how! There are many layers to George Smiley, and I am thoroughly enjoying the unpeeling of each one as I delve more and more into these novels. Smiley teams up with Peter Guillam, a younger agent who is further removed from the upper echelon of the service, partly due to a botched operation and partly as a result of his prior association with Smiley. The guys at the top have been very deliberately remaking the organization to their own advantage. Anyone with a loyalty to the former chief, or those that hovered too close to the truth, have been quietly relocated to lesser positions or simply dismissed. The organization is being carefully refashioned to the mole’s purpose. I was further pleased to become further acquainted with the somewhat eccentric Mendel, a former police inspector whom was introduced to us in le Carré’s novel Call for the Dead.

Naturally, a huge theme in this novel is that of betrayal. George Smiley grapples with this not only in his professional life but also his private life. His sincere interior conflict further illuminates the real character of the man. I can’t help but feel sympathy for Smiley, and admire his courage to examine his own principles.

"It worried him that he felt so bankrupt; that whatever intellectual or philosophical precepts he clung to broke down entirely now that he was faced with the human situation."

One thing I have come to expect from le Carré is that I need to be a bit more savvy with my spy lingo. If there were a little glossary of the terms in the back of the book, I would be off and running with the story straight from the get-go. In reality, it takes me a little bit to settle in and really understand what is happening. It’s okay though, I get there eventually, and any earlier confusion is worth the payoff! I’m not very successful with my own personal psychological analysis of the characters, but I consider myself in good hands with the author who was once a secret service agent himself. I was once again fully invested with each character, and the plot took me down a twisty, furtive and thrilling path that I wouldn’t mind riding once more!

This book is the first in the Karla trilogy � Karla being the working-name counterpart to Smiley in the Russian Intelligence agency. If all goes as planned, I will be reading the second one next month. If you have any interest in reading an authentic espionage thriller, then I highly recommend this or any of le Carré’s books. They really do deliver. I can’t forget to mention the movie adaptation � expertly cast with Gary Oldman as Smiley and highly entertaining!

"Like an actor, he had a sense of approaching anti-climax before the curtain went up, a sense of great things dwindling to a small, mean end; as death itself seemed small and mean to him after the struggles of his life."
150 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 11, 2019 – Shelved
February 11, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
February 11, 2019 – Shelved as: mystery-crime
February 11, 2019 – Shelved as: thriller
February 25, 2019 – Started Reading
March 2, 2019 – Finished Reading
March 18, 2019 – Shelved as: favorites
April 25, 2019 – Shelved as: espionage

Comments Showing 1-50 of 53 (53 new)


Sara Looking forward to getting back to Smiley in April. Your review is perfect, he is the quintessential real spy.


message 2: by Tim (new)

Tim Terrific review, Candi. Recently saw and enjoyed the film of this.


message 3: by JanB (new)

JanB Candi, I can see from the quotes you included, the writing is excellent. I really need to find a spot in my toppling tbr for a le Carré novel. Wonderful review!


message 4: by Daniel (last edited Mar 18, 2019 11:56AM) (new)

Daniel Chaikin Not a thriller kind of reader, I haven't read le Carre. But I've wondered about him and Smiley. Great review and encouraging. Maybe I should try him, just to learn more about the meek who did not inherit the earth.


message 5: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Candi, you're on a Le Carre binge! Don't blame you. He's in a genre all his own.


message 6: by Julie (new)

Julie One the best spy classics ever! My hubby loves this one. Great review, Candi!! 😊


Zoeytron Oh, I love George Smiley, too. BBC did a mini-series back in the late 70's of this with Sir Alec Guinness as Smiley. He did such a fine job that I couldn't wrap my arms around the movie adaptation with Oldman. Well worth checking out if you have a chance. And super review here, Candi.


Candi Sara wrote: "Looking forward to getting back to Smiley in April. Your review is perfect, he is the quintessential real spy."

I have you to thank for the introduction to Smiley, Sara! I confess that I likely would not have picked these up if not for your encouragement. You are always right :) Can't wait for the next one.


Candi Tim wrote: "Terrific review, Candi. Recently saw and enjoyed the film of this."

Thank you, Tim! The film was quite good, but as is usually the case, the book is even better! It's much easier to get into the character's heads that way :)


Candi JanB wrote: "Candi, I can see from the quotes you included, the writing is excellent. I really need to find a spot in my toppling tbr for a le Carré novel. Wonderful review!"

Many thanks, Jan! Yes, the writing really is top-notch. I hope you can squeeze one in and let me know what you think!


Candi Daniel wrote: "Not a thriller kind of reader, I haven't read le Carre. But I've wondered about him and Smiley. Great review and encouraging. Maybe I should try him, just to learn more about the meek who did not i..."

Thanks, Daniel! Thrillers are not at all my usual fare, but I make an exception for these. Definitely worth a shot. Sara nailed it when she stated that Smiley is 'the quintessential real spy' :)


Candi Anne wrote: "Candi, you're on a Le Carre binge! Don't blame you. He's in a genre all his own."

Ha ha! Yes, I sure am, Anne! And I'm reading these along with some friends, so that makes it an extra special treat :)


message 13: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Candi wrote: "Anne wrote: "Candi, you're on a Le Carre binge! Don't blame you. He's in a genre all his own."

Ha ha! Yes, I sure am, Anne! And I'm reading these along with some friends, so that makes it an extra..."


Definitely. Enjoy!


Candi Julie wrote: "One the best spy classics ever! My hubby loves this one. Great review, Candi!! 😊"

Your hubby has great taste, Julie! Thanks so much :)


Candi Zoeytron wrote: "Oh, I love George Smiley, too. BBC did a mini-series back in the late 70's of this with Sir Alec Guinness as Smiley. He did such a fine job that I couldn't wrap my arms around the movie adaptation ..."

Thanks so much, Zoeytron! I think I'd really love to check out the BBC mini-series. Although I really enjoyed the movie, I felt that much was left out. I'm delighted to hear you're a Smiley fan too!


message 16: by Katie (new)

Katie Great review, Candi! One of my dad's favourite books.


Candi Katie wrote: "Great review, Candi! One of my dad's favourite books."

Thank you, Katie! I've added this one to my favorites' shelf, so I'm right there with your dad :)


message 18: by Angela M (new)

Angela M Fantastic review, Candi. I have to read him some day !


Candi Angela M wrote: "Fantastic review, Candi. I have to read him some day !"

Thank you, Angela! If you do pick up one of his books, I'd love to hear what you think :)


Jeffrey Keeten Few people know that after Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy comes Reader, (W)Riter. There is probably a security clearance issue on that, so if MI6 does manage to nab me, do delete this comment.

So wonderful to see that you enjoyed this book. It does confound some readers, but of course the trick is to just keep reading and let more nuances seep into your brain until some wonderful realizations start to occur. Great review Candi!


Nancy John le Carre was introduced to me by my dad. He is really the best! I have read quite a number of his books.


message 22: by Paula (new)

Paula K Excellent review, Candi! I saw the movie, but haven’t read the book yet. I did read a few others of Le Carre’s over the past two years that were terrific!


Lorna Candi, wonderful review. George Smiley has become one of my favorite spies as well. This book is next on my list.


Candi Jeffrey wrote: "Few people know that after Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy comes Reader, (W)Riter. There is probably a security clearance issue on that, so if MI6 does manage to nab me, do delete this comment.

So w..."


Ha ha, Jeffrey! I'm not very good at subterfuge, but I can keep a secret ;) It's a pleasure to find yet another fan! Thanks so much for reading and commenting on my review. I enjoyed reading your witty review!


Candi Nancy wrote: "John le Carre was introduced to me by my dad. He is really the best! I have read quite a number of his books."

Nancy, I'm starting to see a trend here with readers and their dads when it comes to le Carre's books! I did suggest this one to my own dad just the other day. Glad to hear you've enjoyed these books too :)


Candi Paula wrote: "Excellent review, Candi! I saw the movie, but haven’t read the book yet. I did read a few others of Le Carre’s over the past two years that were terrific!"

Thank you very much, Paula! I highly recommend the book to you then! You'll get even more out of it. I'm just glad I have several more of his books to look forward to!


Candi Lorna wrote: "Candi, wonderful review. George Smiley has become one of my favorite spies as well. This book is next on my list."

Thank you, Lorna! I'm so pleased to 'meet' another Smiley fan. This book should be wholly satisfying for you - I hope :)


message 28: by Bionic Jean (last edited Mar 19, 2019 04:13PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Bionic Jean Excellent review, thanks Candi! I really enjoyed this one.

(I mean your review of course, although I do like the book ;) )


message 29: by Felicia (new)

Felicia Wow FANTASTIC review, Candi 💖


Candi Bionic Jean wrote: "Excellent review, thanks Candi! I really enjoyed this one.

(I mean your review of course, although I do like the book ;) )"


Thanks very much, Jean! I'm pleased you enjoyed both, lol! :)


Candi Felicia wrote: "Wow FANTASTIC review, Candi 💖"

Many thanks, Felicia!! :)


message 32: by Melanie (new)

Melanie I enjoyed your review Candi. I have not read this but did watch the movie and I must admit, I was confused!


Barbara K It’s been many years since I read LeCarre, but I can remember that feeling of being somewhat in the dark about what was going on. He can be very subtle, very indirect, and he makes assumptions that you are familiar with nuances of the political climate at the time he is writing.


Barbara K Candi, I've realized that I own two print copies of "Legacy of Spies", a Smiley novel published just a couple of years ago. I'd be happy to mail one to you if you'd like.


Candi Melanie wrote: "I enjoyed your review Candi. I have not read this but did watch the movie and I must admit, I was confused!"

Thanks, Melanie! I'm pretty sure that if I hadn't read the book first, I would have been lost in the movie. The order of events was different, and it would have been difficult even to determine who was who!


Candi Barbara wrote: "It’s been many years since I read LeCarre, but I can remember that feeling of being somewhat in the dark about what was going on. He can be very subtle, very indirect, and he makes assumptions that..."

I agree with your comment, Barbara. I am sure that I don't quite 'get' everything going on, but given a bit of time I can usually grasp enough to understand the overall picture. I'm realizing, too, that the more of them I read, the easier it is to settle in and become absorbed in the story!

Regarding Legacy of Spies, that would be wonderful - thank you for the offer! It may be some time before I reach the point of reading that one (I haven't really looked to see how many books there actually are!), but I know I will read it eventually :) I will send you a message soon.


message 37: by Cheri (new)

Cheri Love your enthusiasm for le Carré, Candi, although I've never read any of his books, you make me want to.


Candi Thank you, Cheri! Sara is the one I have to credit with getting me hooked on le Carre. She's very convincing and always right :)


message 39: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Terrific review, Candi!!


Candi Deanna wrote: "Terrific review, Candi!!"

Thank you, Deanna! :)


Jaline Outstanding review, Candi! Although I have not forgotten this one, your review brought it all back - and I loved reading your perspective on it, too! :)


Candi Jaline wrote: "Outstanding review, Candi! Although I have not forgotten this one, your review brought it all back - and I loved reading your perspective on it, too! :)"

Thanks so much, Jaline! I'm pleased to join the ranks of Le Carre fans with friends like you! I have watched the movie adaptation now (which was quite good); and I have the BBC production sitting on my counter for when I have a good chunk of time to sit and watch it as well :)


message 43: by Christine (new)

Christine Candi, awesome review! A year or so ago I would have no interest in LeCarre’s work, but I am approaching the time to try one of his. Will keep in mind the possible confusion aspect and continue to push through that.


Candi Christine wrote: "Candi, awesome review! A year or so ago I would have no interest in LeCarre’s work, but I am approaching the time to try one of his. Will keep in mind the possible confusion aspect and continue to ..."

Thank you, Christine! There were some aspects of the spy world I never grasped right away, but it all eventually fell into place for me. I hope you enjoy le Carre's work if you happen to give it a try sometime :)


message 45: by Christine (new)

Christine I will try him, Candi. Thanks so much for the heads up on the intricacies of the spy world!


message 46: by Rajan (new)

Rajan Review seems better than book. Kudos.


Have u seen the movie? Which is better?


Candi Kshitij wrote: "Review seems better than book. Kudos.


Have u seen the movie? Which is better?"


Thanks, Kshitij! There really is so much more to the book, but you are very kind. I have seen the movie and I liked it, but prefer the book. I think the movie would have been more confusing without first having read the book.


message 48: by SLB (new) - rated it 4 stars

SLB Lovely review.


Candi Steven L. Bashwiner wrote: "Lovely review."

Thank you, Steven!


Left Coast Justin And Candi nails it. I loved this book, right from the first sentence: "The truth is, ..."

C'mon. Truth isn't what Le Carre books are about!


« previous 1
back to top