Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Joe's Reviews > The Nix

The Nix by Nathan  Hill
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26876584
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: abandoned, 2016, fiction-general

My introduction to the fiction of Nathan Hill is his debut novel The Nix, a Great American Novel that at 620 pages, is a boat anchor. I came up for air and dropped it at 320 pages. Published in 2016, this literary epic is about a lot, mostly a reconciliation between a failed novelist named Samuel Andersen-Anderson and his mother Faye, who walked out on him and his father thirty years ago. Faye resurfaces during her fifteen minutes of fame chucking pebbles at a hardline governor running for president, which Samuel's publisher feels puts him in the unique position to crank out a tell-all memoir, if he can reconcile with his mother.

Oh, but this book is about so much more! Hill shares his opinion on the pitiful state of pop music, the ridiculous state of online gaming (a la World of Warcraft), the sad state of higher learning, the idiotic state of the 24 hour news cycle, the disgraceful state of publishing, etc. This all became very droll for me, not because I disagreed with Hill or didn't think he could write, but because I didn't want to read it. Elmore Leonard advised writers to cut out the parts of a novel that readers tend to skip. Leonard didn't mention anything specific about block paragraphs--that's more of a deal breaker for me.

Samuel always feels this way around his publisher: a little uneasy in comparison, a little derelict. Periwinkle looks about forty years old but he's actually the same age as Samuel's father: in his mid-sixties. He seems to be fighting time by being cooler than it. He carries himself in an erect and stiff and regal manner--it's like he thinks of himself as an expensive and tightly wrapped birthday present. His thin shoes are severe and Italian-looking and have little ski jumps at the tips. His waistline seems about eight inches smaller than that of any other adult male in the airport. The knot in his necktie is as tight and hard as an acorn. His lightly graying hair is shaved to what seems to be a perfect and uniform one-centimeter length. Samuel always feels, standing next to him, baggy and big. Clothes bought off the rack and ill-fitting, probably a size too large. Whereas Periwinkle's tight-fitting suit sculpts his body into clean angles and straight lines, Samuel's shape seems blobbier.

If you found that paragraph to be literary TNT, please don't let me dissuade you from reading The Nix. My eyes glazed over everything after the third sentence, which doesn't do what I want a good novel to do: tell me a compelling story. Hill expresses a lot of opinions but doesn't tell a story that I needed to read. A son doesn't need 620 pages to discover why his mother left him. He doesn't need 20 pages. Those who savor literary fiction might delight in the Writing here, but this book just wasn't for me. Point of view shifts from Samuel to an online gaming buddy to Faye put the novel in the "telling" mode rather than a "showing" mode. At this length, that's a lot of telling.

Length: 188,356 words
104 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Nix.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 3, 2019 – Shelved
May 3, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
June 11, 2019 – Started Reading
June 11, 2019 –
page 3
0.48% "If Samuel has known his mother was leaving, he might have paid more attention. He might have listened more carefully to her, observed her more closely, written certain crucial things down. Maybe he could have acted differently, spoken differently, been a different person.

Maybe he could have been a child worth sticking around for.
"
June 13, 2019 –
page 98
15.68% "Samuel’s mother told him about the Nix. Another of her father’s ghosts. The scariest one. The Nix, she said, was a spirit of the water who flew up and down the coastline looking for children, especially adventurous children out walking alone. When it found one, the Nix would appear to the child as a large white horse. Unsaddled, but friendly and tame."
June 13, 2019 –
page 148
23.68% "The first book Samuel ever wrote was a Choose Your Own Adventure story called The Castle of No Return. It was 12 pages long. He illustrated it himself. Its premise: You are a brave knight fighting your way through a haunted castle to save a beautiful princess. Pretty standard fare, he knew. He was sure he'd read something similar in one of the many Choose Your Own Adventure books that filled his shelves."
June 25, 2019 –
page 237
37.92% ""What is it?" Faye asked, and her father said it was a house spirit, a ghost that usually hid in basements, back in old Norway, in a time more enchanted that this one, it seemed to Faye, a time when everything in the world must have been paranormal: spirits of the air, sea, hills, wilderness, house. You had to look for ghosts everywhere back then."
June 26, 2019 – Shelved as: abandoned
June 26, 2019 – Finished Reading
December 23, 2022 – Shelved as: 2016
December 23, 2022 – Shelved as: fiction-general

Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Julie (new)

Julie Terrific review, Joe! I passed on this one and am glad now that I did. Hope your next book is much better! 😊


message 2: by Joe (last edited Jun 26, 2019 08:39PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Julie wrote: "Terrific review, Joe! I passed on this one and am glad now that I did. Hope your next book is much better! 😊"

Thank you! Some of my favorite reviewers on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ gave this five stars, Julie. If Writing moves you to turn the page, give it a try, you might find this amusing. I'm moving on to greener acres.


Nehrlisa Behrmann One star, ouch! Harsh. Lol. I agree that the book was somewhat unnecessarily long. But I did enjoy how much effort Hill put into developing each character. This book certainly isn’t for everyone. I enjoyed most of it until it grew tedious and sort of weird towards the end.


Stephanie ~~ Awww man, whaaaa? I loved this book. It's seriously one of my favorites. That being said, it's awesome that we can all have our own experiences with literature and express them honestly. I love that.


message 5: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Nehrlisa wrote: "One star, ouch! Harsh. Lol. I agree that the book was somewhat unnecessarily long. But I did enjoy how much effort Hill put into developing each character. This book certainly isn’t for everyone. I enjoyed most of it until it grew tedious and sort of weird towards the end."

I give one-star to any book I'm unable or unwilling to finish, Nehrlisa. Not fair to the author, maybe, but I try to filter stuff like Young Adult or romance or Man Booker Prize winners I know I'm not the demographic for. Sometimes, one slips by.


message 6: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Good honest review Joe, I hope your next read is better! :)


message 7: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Stephanie wrote: "Awww man, whaaaa? I loved this book. It's seriously one of my favorites. That being said, it's awesome that we can all have our own experiences with literature and express them honestly. I love that."

I found three friends on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ who didn't fall in love with this book, Stephanie, so I'm obviously in the minority. I have my genres I run for cover with but also need to branch out with something different, whether it be something obtusely literary or very silly or erotic. James Salter and Anais Nin are coming up. Thank you for your awesome comment!


message 8: by Debbie (new) - added it

Debbie I have a cat taking over my computer, so must be quick here....excellent review my friend. Sounds like an awful book. You know I'd have my red pencil out for this one!


message 9: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Sandra wrote: "Good honest review Joe, I hope your next read is better! :)"

Thank you, Sandra!


message 10: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Debbie wrote: "I have a cat taking over my computer, so must be quick here....excellent review my friend. Sounds like an awful book. You know I'd have my red pencil out for this one!"

I'd rather watch a cat try to get a human's attention than read a novel like this, Debbie, but I'm a real outlier on this. You have far more patience for literary digression and creative writing than I do. Then again, I think many of the characters here would have you drafting a letter to the Complaint Board.


Dianne LOL! Well said! I liked it more than you did, but what Debbie said - definitely needed an editor’s red pencil. Nice review, Joe.


message 12: by Julie (new)

Julie G Uh-oh. A boat anchor, eh? Good thing you didn't board ship with this one, Joseph.


message 13: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Dianne wrote: "LOL! Well said! I liked it more than you did, but what Debbie said - definitely needed an editor’s red pencil. Nice review, Joe."

Thank you, Dianne! I feel that what a character does is way more interesting than what that character thinks. A news anchor with opinions isn't very compelling to me. A news anchor who has a nervous breakdown on live TV and promises to commit suicide on tomorrow's broadcast has my attention. Few authors can approach the ability of Paddy Chayefsky but that's what I expect from satire.


message 14: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Julie wrote: "Uh-oh. A boat anchor, eh? Good thing you didn't board ship with this one, Joseph."

"One dog goes one way, the other dog goes the other way, and this guy's sayin', "Whadda ya want from me?'"




message 15: by Julie (new)

Julie G Somehow, I understand this.


Michelle Ah! I see you have attempted to get through this. I didn’t walk away with much after reading it. So meh.


message 17: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Julie wrote: "Somehow, I understand this."

GoodFellas has the greatest art critique in any movie. Your mention of being on a boat reminded me of it for no special reason.




message 18: by Julie (new)

Julie G Is that supposed to be you?


message 19: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Michelle wrote: "Ah! I see you have attempted to get through this. I didn’t walk away with much after reading it. So meh."

Readers who crave narrative velocity should definitely look elsewhere.


message 20: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Julie wrote: "Is that supposed to be you?"

I would someday love to be a guy who can take a motorboat on the estuary with his two dogs.


Bianca Sorry, it didn't work for you. I ended up liking it a lot, although it could have done with a good trim.


message 22: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Bianca wrote: "Sorry, it didn't work for you. I ended up liking it a lot, although it could have done with a good trim."

A shorter novel with a protagonist who was doing something other than mope would've been a good start for me, Bianca. Rob Fleming is operating a record store and tracking down his five all-time breakups while making droll observations in High Fidelity.


message 23: by Jason (new)

Jason Haha A Boat Anchor, at least this book is more useful than To The Lighthouse. :-)


Bianca Joe wrote: "Bianca wrote: "Sorry, it didn't work for you. I ended up liking it a lot, although it could have done with a good trim."

A shorter novel with a protagonist who was doing something other than mope ..."


I dare say the protagonist is not unlike many people of today who are moping, overanalysing, are paralysed by choices, addicted etc. - the modern man - not to generalise or anything like that ;-)


message 25: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Great review, Joseph! Sorry this was a dud.


message 26: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Jason wrote: "Haha A Boat Anchor, at least this book is more useful than To The Lighthouse. :-)"

Right!


message 27: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Carmen wrote: "Great review, Joseph! Sorry this was a dud."

Gracias, Carmen.


Robin Oh my lord! One star?
Well, I couldn't disagree more about that rating (and somehow I would have thought you'd have loved the video game aspect of the story, which I found sad/hilarious) BUT I do understand the notion that this book could have been edited down more. It was long, epic, 'Dickensian'. And that ain't for everyone. No book is!
Can't wait to see what you think of Salter... and Nin. :D


Hanneke Read it about two years ago and can't recall anything of the book except for the mother throwing pebbles at a political person. Thus, it made no big impression on me at all.


Katie One star and you didn't read the last part which was the worst part of the book for me! I agree with Robin that the video game shannigans was the best bit.


message 31: by Patricia (new) - added it

Patricia Williams I read that this book was being made into a movie. Very strange since it's getting such low ratings Have not read it yet but do own it.


message 32: by Kelly (new) - rated it 1 star

Kelly I detested it, too, Joe! You gave it a fairer chance than I did (think I stopped around page 250). We are in complete agreement that this book is an infuriating waste of time.


Richard (on hiatus) I love hearing how friends react to books in different ways and I genuinely enjoyed your review but ............... The Nix was probably my favourite book of last year. It would be a sad and boring world if we agreed on every book Joe :)


Stephanie ~~ Richard, I totally agree with you!


message 35: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Robin wrote: "Well, I couldn't disagree more about that rating (and somehow I would have thought you'd have loved the video game aspect of the story, which I found sad/hilarious) BUT I do understand the notion that this book could have been edited down more. It was long, epic, 'Dickensian'. And that ain't for everyone. No book is!"

I liked the way you described this novel, Robin. It was definitely a case of wrong book/ wrong time. Dickens requires a total shift in my awareness and also some comfortable clothes. Maybe even a nightcap. I've given one-star ratings to some very accomplished literary novels and question my taste at times. I'm really looking forward to Salter and Anais Nin, though!


message 36: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Hanneke wrote: "Read it about two years ago and can't recall anything of the book except for the mother throwing pebbles at a political person. Thus, it made no big impression on me at all."

I recall an over abundance of Nordic ghost stories and legends intended to have implications to the protagonist's dilemma. I wish I cared. Thanks for commenting, Hanneke!


message 37: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Katie wrote: "One star and you didn't read the last part which was the worst part of the book for me! I agree with Robin that the video game shannigans was the best bit."

I've enjoyed Douglas Coupland's tech silliness but I've never read a novel by him that couldn't fit through a mail slot!


message 38: by Joe (last edited Jun 27, 2019 05:32PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Patricia wrote: "I read that this book was being made into a movie. Very strange since it's getting such low ratings Have not read it yet but do own it."

There hasn't been any news since the J.J. Abrams-Meryl Streep mini-series was announced in September 2016. There used to be a market for bestselling literary work like The English Patient or The Wonder Boys to be adapted to film but now, most of those are being done for digital content providers like Netflix or Hulu. I can think of thousands of books that would be make better TV.


message 39: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Kelly wrote: "I detested it, too, Joe! You gave it a fairer chance than I did (think I stopped around page 250). We are in complete agreement that this book is an infuriating waste of time."

Your review was a beacon on a rocky coast, Kelly. I didn't hate this book, I was just bored by it. Cleverness isn't something I really covet in a novel. I want a good story.


message 40: by Joe (last edited Jun 27, 2019 05:36PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Richard wrote: "I love hearing how friends react to books in different ways and I genuinely enjoyed your review but ............... The Nix was probably my favourite book of last year. It would be a sad and boring..."

Thank you, Richard! I'm definitely the minority on this one. For what it's worth, I loved Middlesex by Jeffrey Eugenides. That was a character I was ready to follow on his journey to hell and back. I think the "journey" in this novel was very internal in comparison. I definitely value your perspective.


message 41: by Kelli (new)

Kelli And...off the list! Thank you for the insight. I wouldn’t last either:)


message 42: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Kelli wrote: "And...off the list! Thank you for the insight. I wouldn’t last either:)"

Thanks for making me grin, Kelli. I usually recommend everyone read a page or two and decide for themselves whether a book is for them. Who knows, this might really float your boat!


message 43: by Kelli (new)

Kelli Your review told me everything I needed to know!


message 44: by Christine (new)

Christine Boyer Brave 1 star for what looks like a popular book. The paragraph you included told me all I need to know. Pass.


message 45: by Joe (new) - rated it 1 star

Joe Christine wrote: "Brave 1 star for what looks like a popular book. The paragraph you included told me all I need to know. Pass."

It's popular because it's always more acceptable socially to endure the room temperature than take off any of your clothes. A book this thick needs to make me want to keep turning the pages to find out what happens next. This one did not. Thanks for commenting, Christine!


message 46: by Vanessa (new) - added it

Vanessa 1 star means I don’t need to rush to read this book! The length alone. So thanks!


Arlene I swear I thought I was the only one who just can’t even with this book. I fell asleep twice while listening to it-it was just SO BORING. I think this just isn’t going to be a book I can get though! Reading or listening to it.


message 48: by Peter (new)

Peter same for me. I tried to like this book. I rarely drop a book once started but this one was killing me after just an hour or so. I actually have been putting off reading this for quite a long time, but finally decided to give it a try. Should have trusted my first instinct.


message 49: by Suzanne Margaret (new)

Suzanne Margaret Dude, if you hated this, I can’t wait to see if you hate Wellness as much as I did. He outdid himself in his sophomore effort. Spoiler: it’s ABSOFUCKINGLUTELY sophomoric.


back to top