Yun's Reviews > Anna Karenina
Anna Karenina
by
by

As part of my reading challenge this year, I wanted to read at least one or two classics, and Anna Karenina was high on my list. It's considered by many to be one of the best novels ever written, and I've never read any Tolstoy. So even though it's a monster at more than 800 pages, I decided it's time I conquered it.
The story starts out so strong, with what seems to be an insightful treatise into the family and romantic life of several characters, including title character Anna. The domestic strife, misunderstandings, affairs, and life in general of the Russian elite, when boiled down to its essentials, are not so different from what occupy people's attentions today. I found the initial chapters to be interesting, and was drawn towards the circle of people who would make up the main cast of the book.
Then as the story progressed, things started to reach their natural conclusions, until about halfway through the book. At that point, I wish Tolstoy would have stopped because I found the second half to be more or less unnecessary. Everything had been resolved by then. But Tolstoy continued, and for me, the story just fell apart after that.
The main characters, in particular Anna, having gotten what they wished for, started acting loony, for lack of a better word. The more their wishes came true, the unhappier they became. A good portion of the second half was devoted to Anna lamenting how her partner does not love her. Every time he goes somewhere, she would pounce on him as soon as he comes home, saying crazy things about how he must be thinking of other women and no longer of her. He would reassure her constantly of his love and unending devotion. She wouldn't listen, so when he inevitably would get frustrated, she took that as confirmation that he doesn't love her. She would leave messages for him not to bother her, and when he doesn't, she would take that as a sign that she is right. This went on for like 200 pages. I wanted to stab myself every time Anna showed up in a scene. It's hard to tolerate a book when you dislike the main character that much.
I'm also a little uncomfortable that Tolstoy seems to portray women in his story as weak and mentally unstable, while the men are portrayed as high-thinking orators. The women would fly into tears and rages at the drop of a hat, stirring up domestic trouble while their men are out doing their jobs or hanging out with their buddies. The women also blushed uncontrollably when talking to any man who isn't their husband. Maybe this is just the way it was during Tolstoy's time and this book would have been seen as progressive, but as a modern woman reading it now, it makes me cringe so hard.
Tolstoy also seems to have treated this book as a vehicle to get out whatever he wanted to say on a variety of topics, including farming techniques, local governments and elections, the meaning of life, religion, snipe shooting, duty and rights of citizens, etc. This book is full of philosophical musings on these topics and more. I don't mind when authors want to present interesting and tangential thoughts, but Tolstoy did it constantly and without filter. His ramblings would go on for many chapters, and were so unedited that it's essentially a stream of consciousness. I'm sure there are some good points in there, but it's so buried under pages of unreadable and irrelevant prattle that I couldn't find them. While these technical and philosophical ruminations are all throughout the book, they were much worse in the second half, taking up a significant portion of it.
Reading this 800+ page tome has been an odyssey. I didn't find any of the characters to be particularly likable or charming. They were all rather silly, unstable, or full of themselves. To me, this is far from one of the best books I've ever read, though it's possible that back then, when there wasn't much to read or do for fun, this would have fulfilled that role. Now I can say I have read Anna Karenina, but that's about as much as I got out of it.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
� Connect with me � �
The story starts out so strong, with what seems to be an insightful treatise into the family and romantic life of several characters, including title character Anna. The domestic strife, misunderstandings, affairs, and life in general of the Russian elite, when boiled down to its essentials, are not so different from what occupy people's attentions today. I found the initial chapters to be interesting, and was drawn towards the circle of people who would make up the main cast of the book.
Then as the story progressed, things started to reach their natural conclusions, until about halfway through the book. At that point, I wish Tolstoy would have stopped because I found the second half to be more or less unnecessary. Everything had been resolved by then. But Tolstoy continued, and for me, the story just fell apart after that.
The main characters, in particular Anna, having gotten what they wished for, started acting loony, for lack of a better word. The more their wishes came true, the unhappier they became. A good portion of the second half was devoted to Anna lamenting how her partner does not love her. Every time he goes somewhere, she would pounce on him as soon as he comes home, saying crazy things about how he must be thinking of other women and no longer of her. He would reassure her constantly of his love and unending devotion. She wouldn't listen, so when he inevitably would get frustrated, she took that as confirmation that he doesn't love her. She would leave messages for him not to bother her, and when he doesn't, she would take that as a sign that she is right. This went on for like 200 pages. I wanted to stab myself every time Anna showed up in a scene. It's hard to tolerate a book when you dislike the main character that much.
I'm also a little uncomfortable that Tolstoy seems to portray women in his story as weak and mentally unstable, while the men are portrayed as high-thinking orators. The women would fly into tears and rages at the drop of a hat, stirring up domestic trouble while their men are out doing their jobs or hanging out with their buddies. The women also blushed uncontrollably when talking to any man who isn't their husband. Maybe this is just the way it was during Tolstoy's time and this book would have been seen as progressive, but as a modern woman reading it now, it makes me cringe so hard.
Tolstoy also seems to have treated this book as a vehicle to get out whatever he wanted to say on a variety of topics, including farming techniques, local governments and elections, the meaning of life, religion, snipe shooting, duty and rights of citizens, etc. This book is full of philosophical musings on these topics and more. I don't mind when authors want to present interesting and tangential thoughts, but Tolstoy did it constantly and without filter. His ramblings would go on for many chapters, and were so unedited that it's essentially a stream of consciousness. I'm sure there are some good points in there, but it's so buried under pages of unreadable and irrelevant prattle that I couldn't find them. While these technical and philosophical ruminations are all throughout the book, they were much worse in the second half, taking up a significant portion of it.
Reading this 800+ page tome has been an odyssey. I didn't find any of the characters to be particularly likable or charming. They were all rather silly, unstable, or full of themselves. To me, this is far from one of the best books I've ever read, though it's possible that back then, when there wasn't much to read or do for fun, this would have fulfilled that role. Now I can say I have read Anna Karenina, but that's about as much as I got out of it.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
� Connect with me � �
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Anna Karenina.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 27, 2019
–
Started Reading
July 27, 2019
– Shelved
August 3, 2019
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 170 (170 new)
message 1:
by
KAS
(new)
Aug 04, 2019 09:47AM

reply
|
flag

Thank you, KAS! It was extra disappointing because so many people loved this classic, and it was such an arduous journey to read this huge book haha. 💖

Reading the whole book, even don't liking it so much..
Respect my dear!!!
By the way..
Yun, great review!!!
Dean;)
Dang Girl, look at you all cultured and stuff!

Thank you, Nicola! Even though I didn't get much out of it, I'm still happy to have gotten through it. 🥰

Reading the whole book, even don't liking it so much..
Respect my dear!!!
By the way..
Yun, great review!!!
Dean;)"
Thank you, Dean! That's a good point! I'm still happy to have read it, and now it's one thing I can cross off of my bucket list. 😊

Haha thank you, Dita! Although I'm not cultured enough to have appreciated it lol. 😄
Yun wrote: "Dita wrote: "Dang Girl, look at you all cultured and stuff!"
Haha thank you, Dita! Although I'm not cultured enough to have appreciated it lol. 😄"
Bwahahahaha...love it.
Haha thank you, Dita! Although I'm not cultured enough to have appreciated it lol. 😄"
Bwahahahaha...love it.


Haha you never know! 😄 Still, it's a good feeling just to have finished this book, even if I didn't really like it.

Thank you, Meredith! In the end, it was a tough book to read and an even tougher one to enjoy, and I just wasn't able to do the latter. Ah, too bad.


Thank you, Christy! I think it's a good book to read, but not a good book to enjoy haha. 😊


Thank you Luffy! Haha that's probably a smart outlook! 😉

Kudos for finishing!

Thanks Jan! Kudos to you as well for finishing it (and also loving it). It's quite a behemoth of a book, and even though I didn't love it, I'm still happy to have read it. 🌞


Thank you, Federico! I totally get you... the page count and how dense the story is are total deterrents. Nonetheless, I hope you get to it one day, and you enjoy it more than I did! 😊


True, the characters are unlikable, for sure. That, plus all the other things I mentioned, makes this an unlikable story for me. I'm glad you enjoyed this much more than me, though!

True, the characters are unlika..."
I love historical novels. Tolstoy writes realistic characters, and he writes them well. Also, personaly I enjoyed his writing style. I commented on this review because I love to discuss books. It is good to get other people's opinions. Thanks for replying.

This is my first Tolstoy, and I hope to read more by him in the future. I'm glad he's a consistently great author for you. I love talking about books too! Thank you for dropping by. :)


Thank you for your comment, Richard! That's what I find most interesting about ŷ, is that there are so many different ways to interpret a book and it's fascinating to read other's thoughts. Even though this book wasn't for me, I'm glad it holds a very special place for you, and that you found so much to love in it! :)

Thanks, Ethan! Appreciate your kind words! Ah, sorry this was a letdown for you too.

I kept listening and listening and listening - 2 entire days of my life in total on audio book - to this purportedly great and classic novel just to be bored most of the time and thinking that the whole story could have been whittled down to 1/4 of its length and not lost anything.

I kept listening and listening and listening - 2 entire days of my life in total on audio book - to this purportedly great and classic novel just to be bor..."
Thank you, Lauren! Yes, there is so much extraneous information in here! It would have been nice if the author followed the sentiment "less is more". But back in the day when this story was written, I think people didn't has as much to do and therefore "more is more" is more welcomed lol. :)


Thanks so much, Alex! I know what you mean... I sat on this book for a long time too before I picked it up. I hope you get a chance to read it, and that you find it more worthwhile than I did lol! :)



You don't want to read about farming techniques? Well, you're missing out! ;) Haha, yea, I can't recommend this one. Lots of classics out there in the sea to choose from!

I'm glad I'm not the only one how had problems with this book. Maybe Anna was considered "strong" during Tolstoy's time? Hmm I haven't thought about Dolly, but maybe you're right.

Thanks, Beata! I've always wanted to read War and Peace, but I think I'll wait a year or ten before I try to tackle that. :)




Thanks, Richard! I'm not sure if I could ever be in the right mood for a long and rambling book like this, but I'm glad I powered through it. If you try this again, I wish you the best of luck! I hope you end up getting a bit more out of it than me! :)

Thanks, Kat! I'm glad this classic lived up to expectations for you! Ah yes, War and Peace. I want to get to that one day, but that day is probably very far off lol! :)

Thanks, Dorie! Yikes 4 times! If you end up trying the audiobook, I wish you the best of luck! :)


Thanks, Lyn! It was an accomplishment, if I may say so myself lol! Honestly, I'm not sure you're missing much by not getting through it, and you're probably saving yourself needless frustrations! 😅
