J's Reviews > Twilight
Twilight (Twilight, #1)
by
by

AFORE- Fine. Fine. Fine. I'll read it. I have two things to say first:
1) I am annoyed this woman can not spell her own name and have very low expectations based on that fact.
2) The vampires better be exciting.
AFTER- I could still feel warmth where his skin touched mine. The moisture of his lips was on my throat and the silken bristles of his hair brushed over my face as he drew his mouth down. The smell of him lingered in my nostrils. It was not like flowers.
I wanted him to bite me. Instead he pulled his head up and looked at me curiously. No question came, but I knew he was trying to understand. Trying to see what had brought me to this place. He looked like a cat with his head slightly cocked, as though listening for the words I couldn’t dare to utter. He was beautiful. Dark eyes aglitter, cunning written plainly on his face. Then the cat became a tiger.
“Get up.� The dream memory broke off and I opened my eyes. The tiger was alive and pacing. “Get up. NOW.� I scrambled to the other side of the wide bed, finally afraid. Two thoughts clicked into place simultaneously:
This is what he’d warned me of.
He’d been watching me sleep.
And there was no hope for me. No escape. I was alone with this beautiful man and this ravenous beast and the danger was of my own design. He’d tried to tell me but, headstrong and foolish, I didn’t believe. And now, when I believed it to the very core of my being, there was no escape. Not that I’d have wanted one anyway.
I am such a girl.
Yeah. So Twilight. I’m going to say something here that a few of you may hate me for. This book is not well written. It’s just not. Meyer’s a storyteller but this is not great literature. The typos I grumbled about? I wasn’t complaining so much about the typos themselves � okay, I kind of was - but what really bothered me was the type of typos. It’s clear someone has actually done some editing, but to improve the writing rather than to add a dropped period or correct a misspelling. It didn’t help.
And yet I enjoyed the book. I am such a girl. This is, I am convinced, where Meyer has struck the mother lode. Edward is handsome. Beautiful even. A marble statue of masculine beauty. I hesitate to say hot because the fact is he’s not. He’s cold to the touch, which makes him all the more attractive because he’s a challenge. Untouchable, so obviously all I can think of is touching him. Did I mention he’s handsome? And he likes me. Me! He spends pages and pages and pages fighting down his attraction to me but I’m so sweet smelling, so delicious, so special, he just can’t. I’m his own brand of heroin. More dreaminess: Edward’s beauteous and smart. Brains are sexy. Can I get an ‘Amen�? But so is brawn and Edward’s as agile and athletically gifted as he is beautiful. Did I already say he’s beautiful? Sorry. It’s just that he’s sooo beautiful. And rich. And he likes me. Me! And he’s bad. But he’s good. He’s fighting his bad side because he’s so good and he likes me. Me! I must really be special.
And there it is. Special. We girls like to be made to feel special. Like we’re the only one. The only one whose mind he can’t read and the only one whose mind he wants to read. The only girl he could spend all day talking to and still want to spend tomorrow with. The only girl he’s ever kissed. I’m so extraordinarily special that he’s fighting his very nature for me. Never forget Edward is a vampire. He’s dangerous. C’mon, you know you like it. And he likes me so much he’d like to feast on me. But I’m (almost, maybe, not quite) safe because he’ll protect me from himself. "And so the lion fell in love with the lamb. What a stupid lamb. What a sick, masochistic lion." Aww� He loves me�
* sigh *
Anyway. Points given for bringing my teenage daydreams to life. Points taken away for making my hero a vampire. Points given for writing a long book. Points taken for filling several pages of it with a girl googling and sending emails to her mother. Points given for not including sex in my teenage vampire love story. Points taken away for not including sex in my adult vampire love story. Points given for creativity. (Vampires sparkle in the sunlight??) Points taken for trying to undo hundreds of years worth of vampire lore in a mere 480 pages. (Several of which have been wasted on google searches for “vampire�.) What does that tally up to? I’d say three stars and two fang marks. Cause I really wanted him to bite.
1) I am annoyed this woman can not spell her own name and have very low expectations based on that fact.
2) The vampires better be exciting.
AFTER- I could still feel warmth where his skin touched mine. The moisture of his lips was on my throat and the silken bristles of his hair brushed over my face as he drew his mouth down. The smell of him lingered in my nostrils. It was not like flowers.
I wanted him to bite me. Instead he pulled his head up and looked at me curiously. No question came, but I knew he was trying to understand. Trying to see what had brought me to this place. He looked like a cat with his head slightly cocked, as though listening for the words I couldn’t dare to utter. He was beautiful. Dark eyes aglitter, cunning written plainly on his face. Then the cat became a tiger.
“Get up.� The dream memory broke off and I opened my eyes. The tiger was alive and pacing. “Get up. NOW.� I scrambled to the other side of the wide bed, finally afraid. Two thoughts clicked into place simultaneously:
This is what he’d warned me of.
He’d been watching me sleep.
And there was no hope for me. No escape. I was alone with this beautiful man and this ravenous beast and the danger was of my own design. He’d tried to tell me but, headstrong and foolish, I didn’t believe. And now, when I believed it to the very core of my being, there was no escape. Not that I’d have wanted one anyway.
I am such a girl.
Yeah. So Twilight. I’m going to say something here that a few of you may hate me for. This book is not well written. It’s just not. Meyer’s a storyteller but this is not great literature. The typos I grumbled about? I wasn’t complaining so much about the typos themselves � okay, I kind of was - but what really bothered me was the type of typos. It’s clear someone has actually done some editing, but to improve the writing rather than to add a dropped period or correct a misspelling. It didn’t help.
And yet I enjoyed the book. I am such a girl. This is, I am convinced, where Meyer has struck the mother lode. Edward is handsome. Beautiful even. A marble statue of masculine beauty. I hesitate to say hot because the fact is he’s not. He’s cold to the touch, which makes him all the more attractive because he’s a challenge. Untouchable, so obviously all I can think of is touching him. Did I mention he’s handsome? And he likes me. Me! He spends pages and pages and pages fighting down his attraction to me but I’m so sweet smelling, so delicious, so special, he just can’t. I’m his own brand of heroin. More dreaminess: Edward’s beauteous and smart. Brains are sexy. Can I get an ‘Amen�? But so is brawn and Edward’s as agile and athletically gifted as he is beautiful. Did I already say he’s beautiful? Sorry. It’s just that he’s sooo beautiful. And rich. And he likes me. Me! And he’s bad. But he’s good. He’s fighting his bad side because he’s so good and he likes me. Me! I must really be special.
And there it is. Special. We girls like to be made to feel special. Like we’re the only one. The only one whose mind he can’t read and the only one whose mind he wants to read. The only girl he could spend all day talking to and still want to spend tomorrow with. The only girl he’s ever kissed. I’m so extraordinarily special that he’s fighting his very nature for me. Never forget Edward is a vampire. He’s dangerous. C’mon, you know you like it. And he likes me so much he’d like to feast on me. But I’m (almost, maybe, not quite) safe because he’ll protect me from himself. "And so the lion fell in love with the lamb. What a stupid lamb. What a sick, masochistic lion." Aww� He loves me�
* sigh *
Anyway. Points given for bringing my teenage daydreams to life. Points taken away for making my hero a vampire. Points given for writing a long book. Points taken for filling several pages of it with a girl googling and sending emails to her mother. Points given for not including sex in my teenage vampire love story. Points taken away for not including sex in my adult vampire love story. Points given for creativity. (Vampires sparkle in the sunlight??) Points taken for trying to undo hundreds of years worth of vampire lore in a mere 480 pages. (Several of which have been wasted on google searches for “vampire�.) What does that tally up to? I’d say three stars and two fang marks. Cause I really wanted him to bite.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Twilight.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
August 27, 2008
– Shelved
Started Reading
April 1, 2009
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Ariella
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Aug 27, 2008 04:59PM

reply
|
flag

Ariella, you've captured perfectly how I felt about this series as I was reading it. I couldn't stop reading it either. It was like a compulsion. Fluffy page-turner is a good description.



I expect a 1000 word review by the end of the day. None of those indentations you're so fond of and no double spacing.

And it is my real name! Well, one of them, anyway. I get called a lot of things.

If you want to know the real story of how vampires are being introduced to modern society, see the corporate powerpoint presentation . (Longish, but brilliant.)

I have more to say here. I'll be back.
Very funny review, Poteet.
If I change my name to Cullen can you forgive me?
You're marrying Bill Cullen, former host of TV game show Joker's Wild?? Congrats! (Wait. I think he might be dead. Not undead, just dead.)
If I change my name to Cullen can you forgive me?
You're marrying Bill Cullen, former host of TV game show Joker's Wild?? Congrats! (Wait. I think he might be dead. Not undead, just dead.)


It figures, Michelle. Her father's probably (actually) dead and now I've offended her entire family.
I couldn't agree more. I'm pretty sure I reviewed that the editor should be flogged and that she wasn't really a very good writer, that the story itself was compelling. However, the writing and editing does get better as you move along in the series, by the 4th book (the best in my opinion, in every way), there is a vast improvement.





Turns out Stephen King, of all people, did a public smackdown of Stephenie. Caught some flack for it, since he didn't start out as a great prose stylist himself, but his key point (comparing Meyer to J.K. Rowling) is:
"...Both Rowling and Meyer, they’re speaking directly to young people. ... The real difference is that Jo Rowling is a terrific writer and Stephenie Meyer can’t write worth a darn. She’s not very good."But then he goes on to list a bunch of other famous authors that aren't very good writers and notes that storytelling isn't the same skill as writing, and some of these folks are magnificent storytellers. I think he also said her writing is getting better, but that might have been someone commenting on King's interview.
Anyway, apparently the story started a blog post for , and then spread like wildfire. A turned up 1,380,000 hits (but probably was overly broad).
Oh, and perhaps he also explained why J was so taken with the story:
"...in the case of Stephenie Meyer, it’s very clear that she’s writing to a whole generation of girls and opening up kind of a safe joining of love and sex in those books. It’s exciting and it’s thrilling and it's not particularly threatening because they’re not overtly sexual. A lot of the physical side of it is conveyed in things like the vampire will touch her forearm or run a hand over skin, and she just flushes all hot and cold. And for girls, that’s a shorthand for all the feelings that they’re not ready to deal with yet.":-)