Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Garima's Reviews > A Fine Balance

A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7915003
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: bharat, favorites, booker-prize, my-2-cents, miles-to-go-before-i

But rest assured: This tragedy is not a fiction. All is True.

Hence started my journey of a fine book, A Fine Balance. I have no sane excuse for my ignorance about Rohinton Mistry novels. I just didn’t have a single clue about him or his achievements till I joined Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ. Yes!! Though it’s not a big deal as one is not supposed to know everything but here’s a writer of Indian origin, writing unbelievably great books about Indians and is still remain unacknowledged by a common Indian reader is densely pitiable. His Facebook page has 7000+ odd likes where, as I gauged from the comments, majority is of non-Indians. But then he is no marketing guru but a writer who writes and writes well, so well that it can make you cringe at the comfortable life you’re having or at least makes you open your eyes to take a good look at the hardships of the hapless lots around you.

I don’t read about Politics because it disgusts me. I don’t have a deep understanding about the 1970’s Emergency period because fortunately nobody in my family or acquaintances got affected by it, so basically it’s the experience which tells a story, just watching, simply gives an indifferent shrug. On the surface I know that it happened under the PMship of Indira Gandhi. School mainly tells you: She was the First women PM of India. She was the daughter of honorable Pandit JawaharLal Nehru. She was the mother of one of the youngest PM of India, Rajiv Gandhi. She was the reason why India didn’t face another partition by launching Operation Blue Star, hence reduced the idea of Khalistan into ashes because of which she was later assassinated. Nothing more, nothing less always a glossy and martyred picture of Daughter of India, Ironically.

So how does it feel to read A Fine Balance? What does it promise to convey its readers? What makes a 600+ page novel readable or rather a page-turner? What’s different about the lives of Dina Dalal, Ishvar, Om and Maneck that you haven’t witness before especially being an Indian? Well the answer could be “May be nothing is different, all trite�, or; “It’s helluva great story, I haven’t read anything like this before�. But the answer remains somewhere in between and the secret is Rohinton’s great writing. His matter-of-factly narration, awesome character building and plot settings can give you the pleasure like watching ‘Hum Log� on high definition channel. He is not a man of big bulky words, dictionary is almost dispensable while reading him but the words are piercing enough to make you feel the subject. The story reflects through them in an unmatched finesse. There is no room left for any improvement as he has used every single component at his disposal in building this masterpiece, just like Dina’s quilt in the novel.

The story revolves around four main characters, Dina Dalal, a widow and a self-respected lady who treats her independence dearest than any of the relations left in her life. Ishwar, a darji (tailor) whose father sent him to get equipped with tailoring in order to earn him a life of repute which he wouldn’t have got under the fate-imposed Chamaar profession. Om, Ishvar’s nephew, again a darji, a young and aggressive lad and an orphan whose life is dedicated mainly to his uncle Ishvar and vice-versa. And, Maneck, a guy from Mountains, whose struggle to know and feel his worth in lives of others especially his parents and a college friend remained unending. The story is about how four of them got together in one flat not willingly but due to twists and turns life threw at them. It’s a journey of how reluctance was over-powered by compassion, how loneliness made room for companionship and how a house became home , how four of them amidst many doubts and objections became “there for each other� Kind, but it was a home of cards waiting for a gush of insensitive wind to tumble it and its housemates.

It’s a sad novel, heart wrenching in fact. It will make you cry (except in case of defective tear ducts) and it will make you very angry. It has its dose of humor but simultaneously it carries an air of apprehension around it like how a moment of happiness is short-lived and shall soon be replaced by gloominess and sorrow. It’s something I felt while watching Clint Eastwood’s Million Dollar Baby and Gran Torino, where as an audience one starts to feel that good days will be balanced out with bad days because Life, the bitch, usually gives us lemons, and to the unfortunate lot, it plants a lemon tree at the backyard of their wretched life. But throughout, this book echoes one universal law, that despair doesn’t have a favorite victim. It befalls upon everyone at some point of time, triggered by fate, destiny or power hungry human beings.

History is a witness to how Power breeds evil, breeds mainly on the blood of innocent lives who would have never imagined that their destiny would sacrifice them to such inexplicable atrocities. This book depicts the story revolving around such atrocities and enduring them, living through them, dying through them or merely surviving through them and resilience is the main key to such survival. Rohinton has captured life through his characters, has captured India through an unfortunate time, has captured ugliness of human face and has finally captured resplendence of human soul through his mesmerizing words.

READ IT !!!

Here's my audio review of this book:
335 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read A Fine Balance.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 1, 2012 – Shelved
July 15, 2012 – Started Reading
Finished Reading
August 3, 2012 – Shelved as: bharat
August 3, 2012 – Shelved as: favorites
September 11, 2012 – Shelved as: booker-prize
October 11, 2013 – Shelved as: my-2-cents
December 18, 2013 – Shelved as: miles-to-go-before-i

Comments Showing 1-50 of 72 (72 new)


Kris This is a beautiful review, Garima. It captures so much of what I experienced when reading A Fine Balance. It's a great novel - I hope others who read your review follow your orders and read it.


Garima Kris wrote: "This is a beautiful review, Garima. It captures so much of what I experienced when reading A Fine Balance. It's a great novel - I hope others who read your review follow your orders and read it."

Thanks a lot Kris! Have you read any other novel by him? I'll soon start with Such a Long Journey.


Kris I haven't yet, but I have Such a Long Journey and Family Matters here, just waiting to be read. :)


message 4: by Stephen M (new)

Stephen M Beautiful reading Garima. This sounds like a might fine novel.


Garima Thanks Stephen and this one surely is a great Novel. You should give it a try someday.


message 6: by Stephen M (new)

Stephen M I will!


message 7: by Kirstine (new)

Kirstine I have never heard of Rohinton Mistry in my life, but after this I believe I'll have to get acquainted.


Garima You surely do! Though his novels are mostly grim but writing is beautiful.


message 9: by Ian (new) - added it

Ian "Marvin" Graye You can listen to Garima's beautiful reading of her review here:

http://www.goodreads.com/story/show/2...


Jeffrey Keeten Ian wrote: "You can listen to Garima's beautiful reading of her review here:

http://www.goodreads.com/story/show/2..."


If only I could lay back in this hammock over here with my arm flung across my forehead, white curtains billowing into the room set in motion by an ocean breeze, and listen to Garima read this book to me. That would be splendid indeed. Excellent and charming Garima!


Garima Jeffrey wrote: "Ian wrote: "You can listen to Garima's beautiful reading of her review here:

http://www.goodreads.com/story/show/2..."

If only I could lay back in this hammock o..."


Wow Jeffrey! That's a lovely compliment. You certainly made my day and it would be great pleasure to read anything to you. You should read one of your great reviews too. They are a treat to read.


Garima Stanley wrote: "I like this review and loved your reading of it too. Have you done more such readings?"

Thank you Stanley. No, this is the only audio review I've done so far :)


message 13: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala ... the secret is Rohinton’s great writing. His matter-of-factly narration, awesome character building and plot settings..

That's it exactly, Garima. I read Mistry pre goodreads and loved his writing


Garima Fionnuala wrote: "... the secret is Rohinton’s great writing. His matter-of-factly narration, awesome character building and plot settings..

That's it exactly, Garima. I read Mistry pre goodreads and loved his writing"


After reading your review of The White tiger, I quickly went on to compare our books but didn't find Mistry among them and later noticed your 'about me' section.


Meena When I began to write a review for this book, I couldn't go beyond a few lines(Even though I've never written a review that's longer than a few lines.I just don't possess the talent).
I didn't know how to express my feelings about Mistry's 'balanced' situation and the 'unbalanced' one. But you just did that so beautifully.
Thoroughly enjoyed reading your review.


message 16: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Garima wrote: "After reading your review of The White tiger, I quickly went on to compare our books but didn't find Mistry among them and later noticed your 'about me' section."

I'm pleased to see that you, who can judge the work better than I can, also gave The White Tiger three stars.


Garima Meenakshi wrote: "When I began to write a review for this book, I couldn't go beyond a few lines(Even though I've never written a review that's longer than a few lines.I just don't possess the talent).
I didn't know..."


Thanks Meenakshi! I'm glad you enjoyed it and can certainly identify when we're not able to express how thoroughly a piece of writing moves us. Mistry's novel was a pleasant surprise for me and I felt a need to tell as to how much I loved his writing.


Garima Fionnuala wrote: "Garima wrote: "After reading your review of The White tiger, I quickly went on to compare our books but didn't find Mistry among them and later noticed your 'about me' section."

I'm pleased to see..."


I read that book much before I joined Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ and used to stay under the notion that hey! it won the booker so it must be good. Apparently it wasn't.


Meena Garima wrote: "Meenakshi wrote: "When I began to write a review for this book, I couldn't go beyond a few lines(Even though I've never written a review that's longer than a few lines.I just don't possess the tale..."

Oh yes. He has a very expressive style. I cried a river when I read this one.


message 20: by Mala (new) - added it

Mala Rohinton Mistry was always known to the glitterati & the literati of India but he is not a writer for the masses,if you get my drift.
A fine review!


Garima Mala wrote: "Rohinton Mistry was always known to the glitterati & the literati of India but he is not a writer for the masses,if you get my drift.
A fine review!"


Thanks Mala and I hear you!


message 22: by Dave (last edited Mar 14, 2013 09:15AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dave I don't often write reviews myself, but I do enjoy reading others reviews and finding one that really sum up my own feelings. Thank you Garima for taking the time to write and record, very well done.


Garima Dave wrote: "I don't often write reviews myself, but I do enjoy reading others reviews and finding one that really sums up my own feelings. Thank you Garima for taking the time to write and record, very well done."

Hey thanks Dave! I'm glad that you enjoyed reading this book.


Melanie What an extraordinary book , have just finished it , and am feeling that terrible sense of loss as the characters in this book have been my companions for the last week ......


Garima True Melanie! All the characters in this book is still vivid in my mind. It was a very humbling reading experience.


Madan Kanti good one garima...a lot of the scenes are depicted in hindi movies and even worse tragedies, but rohinton makes it so alive... all the characters are real. you even come to like the beggars, invalids and destitutes. and of course after reading this i am thankful for what i have got.. but gods grace and that's fine for me... thanks garima again


Garima Madan wrote: "good one garima...a lot of the scenes are depicted in hindi movies and even worse tragedies, but rohinton makes it so alive... all the characters are real. you even come to like the beggars, invali..."

Thanks Madan!


message 28: by Riku (new) - rated it 5 stars

Riku Sayuj Awesome as usual (...I read only the first line, but it looks finely balanced enough). Thanks for reminding me, I am picking this up on my way back today.


Garima Riku wrote: "Awesome as usual (...I read only the first line, but it looks finely balanced enough). Thanks for reminding me, I am picking this up on my way back today."

Thanks Riku! You'll love his writing or so I hope. Shall look forward to your thoughts.


Rowena I adored this book. It made my heart hurt but it was so worth the read.


Garima Rowena wrote: "I adored this book. It made my heart hurt but it was so worth the read."

Exactly! Mistry was uninhibited in his description of his characters and their ordeal.


Garima Thanks Shruti! Now that you got to know about him, read him asap, he's GOOD!


Dolors Tour-de-force review Garima, I'm standing up and clapping effusively.
Loved the way you link your own memories of the period with the plot in the book.
And I hadn't thought of it before, but you're right about the feeling of the story, awesomely similar to the Eastwood's films you mention (both fantastic films IMO). Fantastic review of an outstanding book.


Garima Dolors wrote: "Tour-de-force review Garima, I'm standing up and clapping effusively.
Loved the way you link your own memories of the period with the plot in the book.
And I hadn't thought of it before, but you'r..."


And here I am, thanking profusely to the generous praise you bestowed on this review, Dolors. I'm glad you liked the mention of Eastwood movies since I simply catered to my personal opinions and included here. Thank you once again.


message 35: by Darshana (new)

Darshana Unnikrishnan "Life, the bitch, usually gives us lemons, and to the unfortunate lot, it plants a lemon tree at the backyard of their wretched life"

i just love this line :-)


Garima Darshana wrote: ""Life, the bitch, usually gives us lemons, and to the unfortunate lot, it plants a lemon tree at the backyard of their wretched life"

i just love this line :-)"


Thanks Darshana! If I recall correctly then I wrote that line in a fit of anger. ;)


message 37: by Darshana (new)

Darshana Unnikrishnan Garima wrote: "Darshana wrote: ""Life, the bitch, usually gives us lemons, and to the unfortunate lot, it plants a lemon tree at the backyard of their wretched life"

i just love this line :-)"

Thanks Darshana! ..."


the emotion cant be felt from the line. aptly coined sentenced!!!!


Durham Wilton this is one of the finest books I've ever tead.Charles Dickens would have wept


Garima Durham wrote: "this is one of the finest books I've ever tead.Charles Dickens would have wept"

That's a nice line for a blurb :) It's a great book indeed.


message 40: by Kirk (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kirk I read this some years ago via audiobook, and loved it. Having recently finished "The White Tiger", it's sad that so little has changed in India since the 1970s. I've visited India several times, but as a white tourist I'd never get the insights these novels convey.


rahul Oh, what a compelling review Garima. Hats off! I will read this soon.


Garima Thank you, Rahul. :)


message 43: by Samadrita (new) - added it

Samadrita Ha I just listened to the audio version. You have a great voice. And obviously, gripping review.
Can't wait to read Rohinton Mistry.


Garima Hehe, thanks a lot, Samadrita. The audio review was the part of a project which included audio reviews by many of our beloved reviewers here. It was started by another goodreader who unfortunately deleted his account and the whole thing also got deleted. You could have listened some really wonderful reviews at one place but alas.

And yes, do read Mistry soon. I can't get enough of his writing.


message 45: by Samadrita (new) - added it

Samadrita Garima wrote: "Hehe, thanks a lot, Samadrita. The audio review was the part of a project which included audio reviews by many of our beloved reviewers here. It was started by another goodreader who unfortunately ..."

Damn that's regrettable. If only people would have kept the soundcloud links alive in their reviews. But at least I got to hear yours. So yay!


Garima If only people would have kept the soundcloud links alive in their reviews.

I think Kris, Ian, Nataliya (The Master and Margarita review) and probably most of us included the links in their respective reviews. You just have to do a little searching.


message 47: by Samadrita (new) - added it

Samadrita Garima wrote: "If only people would have kept the soundcloud links alive in their reviews.

I think Kris, Ian, Nataliya (The Master and Margarita review) and probably most of us included the links in their respe..."


Alrighty. I'll try and dig them out. Thanks for the tip.


Lit Bug Your short review aptly reveals the essence of the book - especially your opening statement. People who have lived through Emergency still dread it when they recount their stories to us - I am yet to meet a person who tells me s/he wasn't afraid of his/her life back then.

In case you wish to read an equally grim book on the Emergency, try Nirmal Verma's Raat Ka Reporter, translated into English as Dark Dispatches.


Garima Thank you, Lit. I would love to read your review of this book. Emergency was an unfortunate period and well, I wasn't even born during that time but such books brings alive the plight of the victims who suffered both in direct and indirect manner. Thanks for the recommendation too.


« previous 1
back to top