Teresa's Reviews > Cannery Row
Cannery Row (Cannery Row, #1)
by
by

This book was very different from what I thought it would be. I envisioned mostly reading about the work in the canneries (it's mentioned but not a focus) and I thought it would be depressing (until I read a friend's review, which is, sadly, no longer on this site). Instead, it's a deceptively simple story (in terms of language) that evokes a range of emotions, humor and sadness all mixed up together, but it's never depressing.
At first I was reminded of Winesburg, Ohio in that its focus is on one community and the stories are more like vignettes (though they do end up connecting in many ways); but it's quite different from the Anderson. Anderson can be philosophical from what I remember, while Steinbeck, for the most part, lets his story speak for itself, which may seem surprising coming from the man who wrote The Grapes of Wrath. Anderson's characters can't, or won't, communicate with each other; the denizens of Cannery Row don't have that problem. They certainly don't always communicate in words -- they read each others' faces, vocal tones and mannerisms; they remember past history, but they know each other -- and ultimately themselves -- very well. Most of them would never say the actual words, but they love each other too.
The character of the young boy, Frankie, and the story of a gopher simply broke my heart. This slim book reinforces the idea that beauty and truth can be found in the unlikeliest of places, one of my favorite themes.
At first I was reminded of Winesburg, Ohio in that its focus is on one community and the stories are more like vignettes (though they do end up connecting in many ways); but it's quite different from the Anderson. Anderson can be philosophical from what I remember, while Steinbeck, for the most part, lets his story speak for itself, which may seem surprising coming from the man who wrote The Grapes of Wrath. Anderson's characters can't, or won't, communicate with each other; the denizens of Cannery Row don't have that problem. They certainly don't always communicate in words -- they read each others' faces, vocal tones and mannerisms; they remember past history, but they know each other -- and ultimately themselves -- very well. Most of them would never say the actual words, but they love each other too.
The character of the young boy, Frankie, and the story of a gopher simply broke my heart. This slim book reinforces the idea that beauty and truth can be found in the unlikeliest of places, one of my favorite themes.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Cannery Row.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 7, 2012
– Shelved
Started Reading
May 10, 2012
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)
date
newest »


I'm finding that to be the case for me as well. I read the gopher chapter this morning. It turns out to be so sad and telling -- of course about human nature too, not just that of gophers!

And I have never before found myself in the position Stei..."
Exactly! It was heartbreaking.
Same here. Only pages left, so I'll finish the book today.

"They certainly don't always communicate in words -- they read each others' faces, vocal tones and mannerisms; they remember past history -- but they know each other -- and ultimately themselves -- very well. Most of them would never say the actual words, but they love each other too."
Steinbeck is another of those great authors that knows people, so I can see that he would create this ability in his characters to "talk without speaking."

"Steinbeck is another of those great authors that knows people, so I can see that he would create this ability in his characters to "talk without speaking."
Thanks, Mikki. Though all I'd read of Steinbeck when I was younger was "Of Mice and Men" and I liked it, I don't know why for the longest time I thought Steinbeck wasn't for me ... and then I read "East of Eden" ...

Thanks for another really well-written review.

Thanks, Sue! And I in turn have another GR friend and her review to thank for my reading it. Nice how that works out.



I read somewhere that for Steinbeck Cannery Row was a work of nostalgia for a California that couldn't be recovered.


I plan on reading the sequel "Sweet Thursday" one of these days; maybe his motivation for that one was to extend the nostalgia.

Thanks, Judy. I've read those as well and a few more. Out of those few, East of Eden stands out.
I am enjoying it -- both funny and sad, one of my favorite things in writing.
Yes! I'm in the middle of their frog-hunting escapade right now.